Roger Ebert on Sarah Palin

If any of you bothered to read the article, you will see that Ebert actually has a very valid point.

Quote:
I think I might be able to explain some of Barak Obam's appeal. He's the "American Idol" candidate. Consider. What defines an "American Idol" finalist? They're good-looking, work well on television, have a sunny personality, are fierce competitors, and so talented, why, they're darned near the real thing. There's a reason "American Idol" gets such high ratings. People identify with the contestants. They think, Hey, that could be me up there on that show!





It isn’t so much a political commentary as it is a cultural commentary, something that I thing he well qualified to give.

It's fluff.
 
Ebert writes thoughtful political articles sometimes. His explanation of school prayer issues was one of the best I have read for trying to explain it to a layman.

They are his opinions of course, but I think he's earned enough street cred for his articles to be taken seriously. Despite the whole Valley of the Dolls thing.
 
I wish to complain regarding the title of this thread. I came here expecting to see pr0n.

Dude, I need some industrial strength bleach and a steel wire brush to scrub that image out of my head.

You need professional help.
I believe this may be the first time I have ever agreed with Alferd_Packer.

Which just goes to prove what a disgusting, depraved, debauched piece of semi-humanity Shemp is.

Back to your goats, perv! :goat
 
It appears Ole Roger was in the lobby getting his oil drum of popcorn during the scene where Palin's travel itinerary was covered.

***..."And how can a politician her age have never have gone to Europe?"...*** R.E.

***..."What kind of a person (who has the money) arrives at the age of 44 and has only been out of the country once, on an official tour to Iraq?"...*** R.E.

She has been to Canada, Mexico and made a trip to Kuwait to visit Alaskan National Guard Troops serving there in July 2007 and to Landstuhl, Germany to visit wounded soldiers. Last I checked, Germany was still in Europe.
 
Last edited:
She has been to Canada, Mexico and made a trip to Kuwait to visit Alaskan National Guard Troops serving there in July 2007 and to Landstuhl, Germany to visit wounded soldiers. Last I checked, Germany was still in Europe.

If this is true (and I'm far too lazy to fact check right now) then you may win the argument, but purely on a technicality. The spirit of piece is that she's never experienced other cultures. Visiting US installations, whether they be in Europe or the Middle East doesn't really qualify. Going to Vancouver or Cancun for a week's holiday doesn't really qualify either.

Basically, has she ever had to say anything in a foreign tongue more than "Una Margarita, por favor"?
 
It appears Ole Roger was in the lobby getting his oil drum of popcorn during the scene where Palin's travel itinerary was covered.

***..."And how can a politician her age have never have gone to Europe?"...*** R.E.

***..."What kind of a person (who has the money) arrives at the age of 44 and has only been out of the country once, on an official tour to Iraq?"...*** R.E.

She has been to Canada, Mexico and made a trip to Kuwait to visit Alaskan National Guard Troops serving there in July 2007 and to Landstuhl, Germany to visit wounded soldiers. Last I checked, Germany was still in Europe.


So it only took 40 odd years to leave the Americas? Well, she is positively a globetrotter :)

when did she visit Mexico? Is the story that she had to apply for a passport to go to Kuwait not correct?
 
If this is true (and I'm far too lazy to fact check right now) then you may win the argument, but purely on a technicality. The spirit of piece is that she's never experienced other cultures. Visiting US installations, whether they be in Europe or the Middle East doesn't really qualify. Going to Vancouver or Cancun for a week's holiday doesn't really qualify either.

Basically, has she ever had to say anything in a foreign tongue more than "Una Margarita, por favor"?

Can you tell me all the exotic foreign locals Jimmy Carter visited before he became President? Other than his cruises in a submarine in the Pacific and Atlantic while in the Navy, where did he experience other cultures? If he ever had shore leave, say in the Philippines, were did he go? I wonder where most sailors go?
 
Can you tell me all the exotic foreign locals Jimmy Carter visited before he became President? Other than his cruises in a submarine in the Pacific and Atlantic while in the Navy, where did he experience other cultures? If he ever had shore leave, say in the Philippines, were did he go? I wonder where most sailors go?

And we all know what a fabulous presidency he had. I don't remember his foreign poliy getting rave reviews (I really don't, I was 2), but history doesn't look on his term kindly.

But I think you have found the only way to compare Palin to Carter.

Nice tu coque, by the way.
 
Last edited:
Can you tell me all the exotic foreign locals Jimmy Carter visited before he became President? Other than his cruises in a submarine in the Pacific and Atlantic while in the Navy, where did he experience other cultures? If he ever had shore leave, say in the Philippines, were did he go? I wonder where most sailors go?

And you were a fan of Jimmy Carter were you?
 
If this is true (and I'm far too lazy to fact check right now) then you may win the argument, but purely on a technicality. The spirit of piece is that she's never experienced other cultures. ....Basically, has she ever had to say anything in a foreign tongue more than "Una Margarita, por favor"?
Usted pegado en estupido, tal vez?

How much do you know about Inuit?
 
And you were a fan of Jimmy Carter were you?

Whom do you think Roger Ebert voted for in 1975, Ford, the guy who pardoned Nixon, or Carter? Since Carter was no globe trotter until the age of 52, his new standard for VP qualifications is mystifying.
 
I'd like to hear more critiques of the content rather than the speaker. I agree with what he says 100%

As to her "trip of a lifetime". It has now been established that she visited Alaska national guard troops in Kuwait, but did not cross over into Iraq as originally claimed. (It is unclear how much she commanded them while she was there).

It has also been established that her stop in Ireland was for refueling.

I have been unable to unearth any information about the German portion of her trip: how long she was there, who she met, where she went. I had the impression she was again visiting Alaska national guard troops, suggesting most of her time was probably spent at US military bases. Does anyone have any info?
 
I'd like to hear more critiques of the content rather than the speaker. I agree with what he says 100%

As to her "trip of a lifetime". It has now been established that she visited Alaska national guard troops in Kuwait, but did not cross over into Iraq as originally claimed. (It is unclear how much she commanded them while she was there).

It has also been established that her stop in Ireland was for refueling.

I have been unable to unearth any information about the German portion of her trip: how long she was there, who she met, where she went. I had the impression she was again visiting Alaska national guard troops, suggesting most of her time was probably spent at US military bases. Does anyone have any info?

The "content", that is riddled with errors and shows an inherent bias, was written by a die hard liberal. Whether Ebert offers opinions on politics or opinions on films, they are opinions. At least when he was on "At The Movies," Gene Siskel was there to challenge Ebert's opinions. In this article, nobody could call him on his contrived qualification of a VP candidate's travel history beyond the U.S.A., when the lack of said qualification never bothered him about Carter's credentials to be President.
 
The "content", that is riddled with errors and shows an inherent bias, was written by a die hard liberal. Whether Ebert offers opinions on politics or opinions on films, they are opinions. At least when he was on "At The Movies," Gene Siskel was there to challenge Ebert's opinions. In this article, nobody could call him on his contrived qualification of a VP candidate's travel history beyond the U.S.A., when the lack of said qualification never bothered him about Carter's credentials to be President.


"riddled with errors"? perhaps you would like to point these out. The best you have done is a claim that a stopover in Germany to visit wounded soldiers should be classified as a "trip to Europe".

Tell me, during this time did she go sightseeing, visit a museum, shop for souvenirs, eat in a restaurant? Did she actually talk to any German citizens? She may have. Or did she get off the plane, take a limo to a military base, shake some hands, have a meal or two with the troops, take a limo back to the airport, and then fly on to Kuwait. She may have spent a day, or a week. Don't know. Palin's campaign has not released the itinerary, to my knowledge. Draw your own conclusions.
 
Or did she get off the plane, take a limo to a military base, shake some hands, have a meal or two with the troops, take a limo back to the airport, and then fly on to Kuwait.

This was my point. I've been to Ramstein AFB when I was in Germany semi-long-term for business. Ramstein was like a little American oasis. Unless you turned on the radio or TV (or were familiar with European flora) you would have no idea you were in a foreign country. Hence my comment on winning on a technicality. Ramstien/Landstuhl may count as foreign soil, but it's as far from "foreign" as one can get. One gets more foreign cred going to Taco Bell.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom