Roger Ebert on Sarah Palin

That article is pretty poorly written. I'll admit that he can sometimes pick an alright movie, though.
 
Ebert wrote "Beyond the Valley of the Dolls," therefore disqualifying him for life from my giving a rat's patoot what he thinks about politics.

But man he's written some awesome reviews. The one for Hillary Duff's A Cinderella's Story springs to mind. :D
 
Well, he made a few good points. Five schools in six years (for a journalism degree), while sniveling at Ivy leaguers? ... Come on now.
 
While I find it bit silly that everyone and their mother, including Ebert and Matt Damon, thrust themselves into the pundit spotlight, I can understand it when they ask simple questions. I would be incredulous if some actor started to pick apart fiscal, energy, foreign (etc.) policies. But someone asking "Dinosaurs 4000 years ago? Seriously?" is fair game. I don't live in the US, so I don't know what kind of coverage she is getting there. All I get here is CNN International, but everyone certainly seems caught up in the style of Palin, without questioning her substance (this forum excepted, of course).

If it takes a celebrity to bring simple questions to the front, more power to them. Especially given the level of celebrity worship in the US.
 
What a snob. I'm especially offended by his interesting argument, which, if I believed it, would reduce my opinion of the good Mrs. Palin as second in line... so I'm just gonna dismiss him as a silly movie critic and even sillier screenwriter. Take that, Rog!

capt.c564a53e688e4e2f8fd9f0acb7ad28ad.people_ebert_ny310.jpg
 
Last edited:
Why should that matter? A taxi driver could give the most succinct, thoughtful reasons as to why Palin shouldn't be elected, and his profession shouldn't disqualify that.

You're right, why should Roger Ebert's opinion matter? You know the old saying. Opinions are like bumholes, everybody's got one.
 
If any of you bothered to read the article, you will see that Ebert actually has a very valid point.

I think I might be able to explain some of Sarah Palin's appeal. She's the "American Idol" candidate. Consider. What defines an "American Idol" finalist? They're good-looking, work well on television, have a sunny personality, are fierce competitors, and so talented, why, they're darned near the real thing. There's a reason "American Idol" gets such high ratings. People identify with the contestants. They think, Hey, that could be me up there on that show!


It isn’t so much a political commentary as it is a cultural commentary, something that I thing he well qualified to give.
 
Dude, I need some industrial strength bleach and a steel wire brush to scrub that image out of my head.

You need professional help.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom