RNC Spent $150,000 to "Spruce" up Palin

Status
Not open for further replies.
Since your are the incredulous type, the kind that surely demanded proof that Trig was Bristol's baby before buying into the story, Jackie's affair with Gilpatric is recounted in Sally Bedell Smith's "Grace & Power," Thomas Reeves "A Question of Character."

Actually I never bought into that whole thing with Trig and Bristol. Unlike some I am not willing to believe every negative thing about a person just because they have different politcal beliefs. I have not read either of the books that you mention in this post but I did find an excerpt from a book saying that Jackie Kennedy did indeed have a relationship with Roswell Gilpatric. But the thing is it puts the date at about 1967. Now I don't know about you but I don't call it an affair if the woman was a widow.

http://stories.the-times.co.uk/jackiekennedy/extract3.html

ETA: Gilpatrics wiki bio is a stub but it doesn't mention him ever marrying. Strangly enough he has a listing on imdb which says he was married in 1958 and later divorced but doesn't give his divorce date. If he was indeed married at the time he was having a relationship with Kennedy I cede the point Cicero.
 
Last edited:
... If he was indeed married at the time he was having a relationship with Kennedy I cede the point Cicero.

I went through the same process. I found a book on line that mentioned the affair. I thought, jeez that's no affair. She wasn't married but then, at least according to the book, Gilpatrick was. The book seemed to be credible. It talked about them going away together which seems like something that might have been a verifiable data point.

It is amazing segue from Palin's 150K clothing budget and an affair by Jackie forty years ago.

ETA: And since we're sequeing, here's a link to a NY Times article on the nature of Palin's crowds and her fan base:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/19/us/politics/19palin.html?_r=2&oref=slogin&oref=slogin
 
Last edited:
It is amazing segue from Palin's 150K clothing budget and an affair by Jackie forty years ago.

Yeah it is like I mentioned earlier in the thread. It glaringly points out that the closest thing to a tu quoque that Cicero can manage is someone using their family money to wardrobe themselves nearly half a century ago. And it continues his strange obsession with besmirching the Kennedys. And really whether you think he was a good President or a terrible one, he was a war hero and was assassinated whilst in the service of his country. Just bad form really.
 
Yeah it is like I mentioned earlier in the thread. It glaringly points out that the closest thing to a tu quoque that Cicero can manage is someone using their family money to wardrobe themselves nearly half a century ago. And it continues his strange obsession with besmirching the Kennedys. And really whether you think he was a good President or a terrible one, he was a war hero and was assassinated whilst in the service of his country. Just bad form really.

JFK's assassination was a tragedy, but no more so than Garfield or McKinley and less so than Lincoln. JFK's actions in the South Pacific are well documented.

***.."Despite being declared unfit for duty in April 1942, the US Navy agreed in June 1942 to his request for transfer to sea duty and after attending midshipman school, when his father again intervened to ensure that his son won a posting to his desired motor torpedo boat command.

This was the only occasion in the entire war when a PT boat managed to get itself rammed by an enemy vessel. "He wasn't a particularly good boat commander" was how his commanding officer explained the incident, whilst General Douglas MacArthur wanted him court-martialled for incompetence."..***


JFK's 1000 days in office were a disaster. His personal life was a disaster. The professional Kennedy apologists Sorenson and Schlesinger act as if it is still 1964 and the world isn't hip to the long ago shattered Camelot propaganda that Jackie desperately tried to sell to the public after his death..
 
Despite being declared unfit for duty in April 1942, the US Navy agreed in June 1942 to his request for transfer to sea duty and after attending midshipman school, when his father again intervened to ensure that his son won a posting to his desired motor torpedo boat command.

This was the only occasion in the entire war when a PT boat managed to get itself rammed by an enemy vessel. "He wasn't a particularly good boat commander" was how his commanding officer explained the incident, whilst General Douglas MacArthur wanted him court-martialled for incompetence
Shameful

Kennedy was later awarded the Navy and Marine Corps Medal for his heroics in the rescue of the crew of PT 109, as well as the Purple Heart Medal for injuries sustained in the accident on the night of 1 August 1943.

Cicero, how do you feel about those who criticize Bush for using family connections to get into the National Guard? How do you feel about those who criticize McCain for being a lousy pilot? Have you ever heard Obama say anything about McCain other than that he is a war hero who served honorably and deserves our gratitude and respect? Does not Kennedy deserve the same courtesy relative to his war record?

Shameful.
 
JFK's assassination was a tragedy, but no more so than Garfield or McKinley and less so than Lincoln. JFK's actions in the South Pacific are well documented.

***.."Despite being declared unfit for duty in April 1942, the US Navy agreed in June 1942 to his request for transfer to sea duty and after attending midshipman school, when his father again intervened to ensure that his son won a posting to his desired motor torpedo boat command.

This was the only occasion in the entire war when a PT boat managed to get itself rammed by an enemy vessel. "He wasn't a particularly good boat commander" was how his commanding officer explained the incident, whilst General Douglas MacArthur wanted him court-martialled for incompetence."..***

JFK's 1000 days in office were a disaster. His personal life was a disaster. The professional Kennedy apologists Sorenson and Schlesinger act as if it is still 1964 and the world isn't hip to the long ago shattered Camelot propaganda that Jackie desperately tried to sell to the public after his death..
I think I found the link which you failed to include.

And how is this piece of unbiased journalism described?
"A contrarian view of the life of John F. Kennedy"

That's the nice thing about the internet. No matter how radical and unsupportable your point of view, you can always find somebody out there who agrees with you.
 
JFK's assassination was a tragedy, but no more so than Garfield or McKinley and less so than Lincoln. JFK's actions in the South Pacific are well documented.

***.."Despite being declared unfit for duty in April 1942, the US Navy agreed in June 1942 to his request for transfer to sea duty and after attending midshipman school, when his father again intervened to ensure that his son won a posting to his desired motor torpedo boat command.

This was the only occasion in the entire war when a PT boat managed to get itself rammed by an enemy vessel. "He wasn't a particularly good boat commander" was how his commanding officer explained the incident, whilst General Douglas MacArthur wanted him court-martialled for incompetence."..***


JFK's 1000 days in office were a disaster. His personal life was a disaster. The professional Kennedy apologists Sorenson and Schlesinger act as if it is still 1964 and the world isn't hip to the long ago shattered Camelot propaganda that Jackie desperately tried to sell to the public after his death..

This entire post of yours changes nothing that I wrote. JFK served his country in war. Your country BTW, not mine.
He risked his life, again for your country, not mine.
He was assassinated while in office serving your country, not mine.
And yet I, a foreigner, show more respect for him than you, a citizen of the country he served.
And that is what I am talking about, respect. It doesn't matter if you like or hate the man. It doesn't matter if you thought he was the greatest leader your nation ever had or the worst. You could at least have the respect not to smear his and his familys name every chance you get on an internet message board. It shows very little class.
 
Shameful.
Worse than that, based on Tricky's discovery. Not only is Cicero smearing JFK. His copy/paste was written by some anonymous bozo posting to a lame website where anyone can post anything. No wonder a link wasn't provided.

(We need a higher caliber of zealotry around here. Mormons, that's the ticket. Industrious, and civil to boot.)
 
JFK's assassination was a tragedy, but no more so than Garfield or McKinley and less so than Lincoln. JFK's actions in the South Pacific are well documented.

***.."Despite being declared unfit for duty in April 1942, the US Navy agreed in June 1942 to his request for transfer to sea duty and after attending midshipman school, when his father again intervened to ensure that his son won a posting to his desired motor torpedo boat command.

This was the only occasion in the entire war when a PT boat managed to get itself rammed by an enemy vessel. "He wasn't a particularly good boat commander" was how his commanding officer explained the incident, whilst General Douglas MacArthur wanted him court-martialled for incompetence."..***


JFK's 1000 days in office were a disaster. His personal life was a disaster. The professional Kennedy apologists Sorenson and Schlesinger act as if it is still 1964 and the world isn't hip to the long ago shattered Camelot propaganda that Jackie desperately tried to sell to the public after his death..

Great!

Now I get to dredge up the equally-true war crimes of GHW Bush.

You know, the utterly spurious story of how he machine-gunned Japanese sailors in lifeboats after the sinking of their merchant vessel?
 
***.."Despite being declared unfit for duty in April 1942, the US Navy agreed in June 1942 to his request for transfer to sea duty and after attending midshipman school, when his father again intervened to ensure that his son won a posting to his desired motor torpedo boat command.


I keep thinking more about this passage. Unfit for duty: what does that mean? In this case it means that he had a disability (a bad back) that qualified him for a medical discharge. Instead, he had his father intervene so he could get into combat. And as a result, he aggravated his back injury, which remained a chronic problem throughout his life. And you find this a reason for criticism? :rolleyes:
 
McGovern's running mate Eagleton springs to mind. He was of course certifiable crazy when his own team threw him under the Greyhound.

But Palin's coolest attribute is that she drives liberals like yourself apoplectic just by her existence.
Do you ever tell the truth?
 
I think I found the link which you failed to include.

And how is this piece of unbiased journalism described?
"A contrarian view of the life of John F. Kennedy"

That's the nice thing about the internet. No matter how radical and unsupportable your point of view, you can always find somebody out there who agrees with you.

Unsupportable POV? Thomas Reeves, Richard Reeves, and even Noam Chomsky in his "Rethinking Camelot" not only support this POV, but supply the facts to back them up. On the other hand, you have not said anything that contradicts these facts other than express an obdurate admiration for JFK.
 
Worse than that, based on Tricky's discovery. Not only is Cicero smearing JFK. His copy/paste was written by some anonymous bozo posting to a lame website where anyone can post anything. No wonder a link wasn't provided.

(We need a higher caliber of zealotry around here. Mormons, that's the ticket. Industrious, and civil to boot.)

Obviously you have never read any non fiction book on JFK. Sally Bedell Smith, Noam Chomsky, Thomas Reeves, Richard Reeves have all covered this material and have documented the truth about JFK's time in the Navy.

It is amazing how JFK idolatry makes his fans blind to reality.
 
This entire post of yours changes nothing that I wrote. JFK served his country in war. Your country BTW, not mine.
He risked his life, again for your country, not mine.
He was assassinated while in office serving your country, not mine.
And yet I, a foreigner, show more respect for him than you, a citizen of the country he served.
And that is what I am talking about, respect. It doesn't matter if you like or hate the man. It doesn't matter if you thought he was the greatest leader your nation ever had or the worst. You could at least have the respect not to smear his and his familys name every chance you get on an internet message board. It shows very little class.

What country are you posting from. Do they have an extradition treaty with the U.S.?

I have zero respect for JFK. So all the historians who write truthful, but unflattering, books about JFK are "smearing his name and are classless?" Does your country have any 1st Amendment rights?
 
What country are you posting from. Do they have an extradition treaty with the U.S.?

I have zero respect for JFK. So all the historians who write truthful, but unflattering, books about JFK are "smearing his name and are classless?" Does your country have any 1st Amendment rights?

If you compare people compiling history books to someone smearing someones name on a message board by continually bringing the person up in threads that have nothing to do with them you are so out of touch with reality you barely rate a response.
Just out of curiosity though why would you ask about extradition treaties between the U.S and where i am writing from?
 
Shameful



Cicero, how do you feel about those who criticize Bush for using family connections to get into the National Guard? How do you feel about those who criticize McCain for being a lousy pilot? Have you ever heard Obama say anything about McCain other than that he is a war hero who served honorably and deserves our gratitude and respect? Does not Kennedy deserve the same courtesy relative to his war record?

Shameful.

You mean JFK's incompetence as a boat commander was shameful?

McCain was a horrible pilot. He graduated at the bottom of his class. Of all the jobs he could have been assigned to in the Navy, he never would have been an aviator without his dad the Admrial's connections.

That is a fact Bush 43 used Bush 41's connections to get into the NG.

There were 16 million men and women in uniform during WWII. It was a common situation at that time. JFK's record as a boat commander is not a good one. He was responsible for his boat being hit by a Japanese Destroyer, which caused the death of one of his crew. This did not advance the war effort for the allies. Of all the jobs he could have been assigned to in the Navy, he never would have been a PT Boat commander without his father Joe's connections. JFK could have served on a Destroyer, Battleship, Carrier, but he never should have been assigned to the rigorous duty of the PT Boats, and certainly never in command of one of them.
 
There were 16 million men and women in uniform during WWII. It was a common situation at that time. JFK's record as a boat commander is not a good one. He was responsible for his boat being hit by a Japanese Destroyer, which caused the death of one of his crew. This did not advance the war effort for the allies. Of all the jobs he could have been assigned to in the Navy, he never would have been a PT Boat commander without his father Joe's connections. JFK could have served on a Destroyer, Battleship, Carrier, but he never should have been assigned to the rigorous duty of the PT Boats, and certainly never in command of one of them.

If your sources are accurate, then Kennedy used his family connections to place himself in harm's way despite a disability that qualified him for a medical waiver. Do you not find that behavior admirable, worthy of respect?

I repeat my previous statement.

Cicero, how do you feel about those who criticize Bush for using family connections to get into the National Guard? How do you feel about those who criticize McCain for being a lousy pilot? Have you ever heard Obama say anything about McCain other than that he is a war hero who served honorably and deserves our gratitude and respect? Does not Kennedy deserve the same courtesy relative to his war record?

Shameful.
 
Unsupportable POV? Thomas Reeves, Richard Reeves, and even Noam Chomsky in his "Rethinking Camelot" not only support this POV, but supply the facts to back them up. On the other hand, you have not said anything that contradicts these facts other than express an obdurate admiration for JFK.
You must have mistaken me for someone else. I don't even argue that JFK was a good president. Not the worst, but certainly not that good. But your obsessive hatred of him, well, really all Democratic presidents and their wives, doesn't inspire me with any confidence that your assessments of his military career are particularly accurate. Let's just say I find you to be a biased source. The National Review is more objective than you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom