beachnut & cjnewson88...thank you very much for the excellent references, which allow me to better respond to folks when they bring up things like this.
beachnut...the lack of a transponder for legal traffic could most certainly be a major problem (for the aircraft itself, as well as others it may endanger). At the speeds they are flying up there, SEE AND AVOID simply doesn't work worth a crap. (IMO, the BIG SKY THEORY is what worked.) That's why everyone is required to have a transponder and follow ATC clearances at those altitudes.
Also, as a "thought experiment," take away 9/11, and presume AAL77 simply had a major electrical failure that day, and turned around like it did. Rendering it (a "legal" aircraft) invisible, is simply not acceptable, especially when at least 8 other FAA SEARCH radars had AAL77 within their sight. FAA multiple radar data processing failed miserably that day. The problem we have is not radar, but rather the processing of the abundant and available radar data. We deserve much better.
77 on a normal day would follow what pilots do in emergencies, and would appear as a primary target in the sector where this problem is not. But you are right, things should work the same all over as needed. But see and avoid is valid, and pilots in that sector would be alerted to look for 77, lost come, lost transponder.
I agree it would be nice for them to see primary stuff, but see avoid does work. I have flown up there since 1975, and in clear weather I am looking out, and center does point out traffic if they see it. It is the pilots responsibility to avoid stuff in the air, like airspeed on final, it is another most important basic skill near the ground or above 18,000 feet. See and avoid is still important, at 550 KTAS and 29,000, the same from zero to FL490.
77 with electrical failure would show up in the next sector, and the pilot would follow procedures. Is the transponder on the battery bus, the emergency bus? Radios?
See and avoid does work, I have flown up there since 1975, and see and avoid is what we do. Seeing a small C-150 (low level) when we are going 300 or 500 mph is a problem, but seeing an airliner who is transponder free is against the law, and can't happen up there unless is is a crime, or an emergency, and this is why we look out and scan for traffic. Is your pilot on your next flight reading the news paper, or scanning for possible traffic; what is he being paid to do? An aircraft which drops off transponder and radio, would be know to all aircraft near him, they would be asked to look for him - is there a lot of traffic in the "dead zone"?
See and avoid does work. I have seen balloons at FL 290, and I avoided them. I am looking for birds too. In the WX I can't see, at night we look for lights. The copilot was tracking mars all flight long thinking it was traffic. Why do I avoid party balloons? What are the party balloons carrying? Any object hit at 500 mph will do what to my window, or engine, or wing? I flew large jets up there, and I was looking for traffic, be it geese or balloons, or UFOs, I did not want to hit something at 500 mph.
I agree, having primary is good, but on 911 the system was not made to intercept and stop aircraft used as weapons. It did not make a difference on 911. If there had been 10 more planes, then being in the dead zone would be a problem if you wanted to run an intercept.
There is a lot to learn about the system. I don't see anything wrong with making it work over the entire country so traffic can be called out that has no transponder as it would be (if it is) in area where it is working correctly. I don't see what difference it made on 911; 77 was picked up going 300 knots near DC, the controllers might think it was a military flight due to the speed, and their normal traffic is 200 to 170 knots.
ATC failed to paint the balloons, sometimes they can paint large flocks of birds. I don't think I have ever had traffic up there as unknown. During decent and landing or takeoff and climb-out, in the past we have had traffic unknown, but now it is usually VFR traffic with transponder, which is not up there. Up there is all under control.
For an emergency which the transponder is off and you need to land now (total electrical failure might be one), you pick the nearest suitable field and land based on your emergency. ATC would in a normal world contact everyone on the track to explain the problem.
Yes, all the sectors should work the same. I wonder if the low traffic volume in that sector was an excuse for not fixing it.