Radar Sort Boxes in the area of American Airlines Flight 77’s Turnaround/Disappearanc

BCR

Master Poster
Joined
Dec 6, 2008
Messages
2,278
My colleague Tom Lusch has completed a presentation explaining the disappearance of AAL77 in the ZID airspace. It is a little technical, but not so bad that the layperson should not be able to digest it. I suspect even CPT'N Bob could grasp it.

Here is a summary which suggests a few revisions to the Commission Report which more accurately reflect the issues.

tom1.jpg
 
Not at all. I think it is Tom's intent to get as much exposure as he can for a problem he had been working and warning about even before 9/11.

By the way, Tom is monitoring this thread and can answer any specific questions you guys may have.
 
Last edited:
A question;

Were people actually aware that the QRI Lynch radar site was set as the "preferred" for search radar over that area? And were they also aware this site was "broken"?

If I'm to understand this correctly, once a site is detected as not functioning correctly, the supplemental search station takes over, in this case, QWO London, and becomes the "preferred" site. And, as you stated, QWO detected AA77 the moment its transponder dropped, so is an error that the system did not automatically make QWO "preferred"? Or does the correction have to me made manually?
 
Last edited:
I think Tom is waiting for his registration at JREF to be approved so that he can answer questions directly. In the meantime,

Q:
Were people actually aware that the QRI Lynch radar site was set as the "preferred" for search radar over that area?

A:
Lusch said:
Air traffic controllers were probably not concerned as to what was "preferred" or otherwise. Controllers typically don't get into the "nuts and bolts" as to how radar, and/or radar data processing, works. They were obviously very aware that Higby (QHY) was a beacon-only site. Thus, they likely "logically" attributed the poor SEARCH coverage in that area (the "radar gap") to QHY. It is clear that the 9/11 Commission made that "logical" assumption as well.

As for the support staff in automation, and especially Stephen Snyder, the FAA official who created the "Details of Indianapolis ARTCC" presentation, they certainly should have been aware that QRI was "preferred" for SEARCH coverage in that area. But the "Details of Indianapolis ARTCC" presentation certainly didn't bring that fact to light.

Q:
And were they also aware this site was "broken"?

A:
Lusch said:
As for the maintenance folks who cared for the Lynch, KY (QRI) ARSR, I don't know what to think about that. How it was considered "certified" is beyond me.

Q:
If I'm to understand this correctly, once a site is detected as not functioning correctly, the supplemental search station takes over, in this case, QWO London, and becomes the "preferred" site. And, as you stated, QWO detected AA77 the moment its transponder dropped, so is an error that the system did not automatically make QWO "preferred"? Or does the correction have to me made manually?

A:
Lusch said:
The software would've used QWO data if it had begun "tracking" AAL77 as a SEARCH target. But the controller never had the option to initiate that. See the "Timing is everything" slides. All would've been okay if QRI SEARCH had been deemed, by maintenance personnel, as unacceptable.

The best I can do here is think of an analogy. If you're company has a 6-cyclinder automobile that everyone may use, and its been firing on 5 cylinders for the past few years, and yet it still gets you around town okay, is it working "okay"? And if you think something is wrong, but the company mechanic doesn't do anything about it, what do you do? If everyone accepts its lackluster acceleration...even the big boss, what do you do? You probably simply come to accept its lackluster performance as well.
 
I see.

Thanks for the answers Lusch, and the relay BCR. A very easy to follow document, a little bit to get the head around but not too bad at all.

I've added it to my blog under the Radar section.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Tom has updated his presentation with some nice graphics and actual radar data for illustration.

http://tomlusch.com/tomlusch/tomlusch/AAL77_files/TomLusch.com%20analysis%20AAL77%20RSB%20adaptation%20v2.0.pdf

I see.

Thanks for the answers Lusch, and the relay BCR. A very easy to follow document, a little bit to get the head around but not too bad at all.

I've added it to my blog under the Radar section.

Cheers.

A note from Tom:

The first thing I noticed when I looked at your blog is that I managed to have two "(1 of 1)" in my "Revised Language suggestions..." slides! I went in to correct that error, and here I am, emerging after nearly two weeks worth of editing, with a much improved version.

The most important portion of my update is of AAL77 SEARCH returns just after it began being displayed. The Commission's statement "...American 77 reemerged as a primary target..." doesn't give any idea as to just how incredibly poorly AAL77 was depicted for the controllers.

My updated presentation of July 29 is available at the bottom of my AAL77 page...

http://tomlusch.com/tomlusch/tomlusch/AAL77.html
 
Last edited:
Cheers Lusch/BCR, yes, I did too notice that error, but figured it was just one of those minor typo things :)

Edit; just have a look through, some very nice changes. I've updated the link on the blog.
 
Last edited:
John, about a year ago I remember you mentioning something about the tower at Yeager Airport picking up AA77 as it flew over, do you have a reference to that?
 
I'd love to have an official reference for the KCRW controllers evacuating as well.

I understand KPIT controllers evacuated as UAL93 flew overhead.

I just read Lynn Spencer's "Touching History," and on page 242 it discusses how Boston Center (ZBW) folks evacuated. However, after reading "Real Heroes, Fake Stories" (New York Times Op Ed of Sep 13, 2008), I'm wondering about any "facts" I may have read in her book.

So, does anyone recall if any other ATC facilities evacuated?

Tom (1st post here...let's see if it works this time)
 
Hi Tom, welcome to JREF, and thanks for the work you've put into your presentation.

I am not aware of any others, but too would in interesting in hearing if there were. KPIT's evacuation is on the ATC records, and I've also spoken to Mal Fuller (the watch supervisor) about it. As for the Boston Center evac, I've only heard of it through word of mouth. Colin Scoggins participates on these boards from time to time, so he's probably who I would have heard it from.

I'll see if I can track down the thread where Yeager was bought up... I have a feeling it was one of my own..

Edit; found it,

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8679055#post8679055

Edit 2; A link to a more informative thread.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=5646255&highlight=yeager#post5646255
 
Last edited:
Welcome sir!
I'd love to have an official reference for the KCRW controllers evacuating as well.

I understand KPIT controllers evacuated as UAL93 flew overhead.

I just read Lynn Spencer's "Touching History," and on page 242 it discusses how Boston Center (ZBW) folks evacuated. However, after reading "Real Heroes, Fake Stories" (New York Times Op Ed of Sep 13, 2008), I'm wondering about any "facts" I may have read in her book.

So, does anyone recall if any other ATC facilities evacuated?

Tom (1st post here...let's see if it works this time)

I'm sorry, but I do not; Colin Scoggins's ("Cheap Shot" is his forum handle here) reference to Boston Center is the only one I'm aware of.

Edit: I probably should've read cjnewson88's post before adding unproductive noise to the thread. At any rate, thanks for joining. And as an aside: Thanks for your site; it was very informative when I first was directed towards it several years ago.
 
Last edited:
John, about a year ago I remember you mentioning something about the tower at Yeager Airport picking up AA77 as it flew over, do you have a reference to that?

Looks like you already covered it. I learned of it during my field trip to Yeager a few years back. The FAA had no comment and the controllers would not speak with me w/o clearance from DC. So all I have is the AP manager's account. However, since the AP was closed due to fog at the time, it is easier to fathom a tower evacuation than the one at PIT.

Was never able to obtain radar data from the Yeager ASR, so it is unknown what aircraft would have led to an evacuation. I know they were back up and running shortly after the Pentagon event when the fog lifted, so it was a window of around 30-45 minutes (after the notification to the AP manager by the local police chief of the WTC event and before reopening).
 
That is the FDR INS positional data from the Stutt RO.
 
I just read Lynn Spencer's "Touching History," and on page 242 it discusses how Boston Center (ZBW) folks evacuated. However, after reading "Real Heroes, Fake Stories" (New York Times Op Ed of Sep 13, 2008), I'm wondering about any "facts" I may have read in her book.

ZBW was ready to evacuate around 10:30 EDT.
ZBW: I need — I needed to speak to someone at battle staff, a senior director, we’ve had an airborne threat on the building, and we’re ready to evacuate Boston Center. So I need to speak to someone quick and — just to let them know.
(NEADSTapes, Position ID2 Op, 10:32:23 EDT)

So, does anyone recall if any other ATC facilities evacuated?

ZOB was evacuated around 11:00 EDT.
ZOB: Command Center, you know, we have a report of a small aircraft from the local police into the city or the Center, so we’re now evacuating all, but basically skeleton proof [?].
(FAA ZOB Tapes, Position 70 ESP EAST, 10:58:50 EDT)
ZOB OMIC: We’re evacuating the building here in Cleveland, so there will be nobody here for a while. We’ll call if we get back, there is an aircraft over the building.
(FAA ZOB Tapes, Position 84, OMIC, 11:00:00 EDT)
NEADS: Command Center, this is Northeast Air Defense.
ATCSCC: Northeast, go ahed.
NEADS: We just got a report from Cleveland Center that they’re evacuating. DO you have any information on that?
ATCSCC: Stand by.
ZID: This is Indy. We got a [inaudible] report from Cleveland that there is a suspicious aircraft over the Center. There evacuating the facility.
(FAA ATCSCC Herndon Tapes, Position 1941, Ops phone, 11:02:22 EDT)
 
Last edited:
Thanks to all for posting info about the FAA radar facilities that evacuated that day.

Chris...earlier you asked whether air traffic personnel were aware that QRI was "broken." I did some additional research, and found a NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System report that mentions QRI's substandard performance. You can find a link to that in my July 31, 2013 update on my AAL77 page of Tom Lusch Dot Com. (Sorry for no clickable link...I haven't been on this forum long enough to have that privilege.)

I can't help but wonder when (if?) QRI got updated with improved SEARCH capability.

I really appreciate your blog, and all the evidence that you collected so as to counter those that think there was a grand conspiracy. And I really appreciate you adding a link to my presentation.

I wish to make one comment though, and that is the title you gave it... "Understanding why AA77 "disappeared" from Air Traffic Control RADAR over Indianapolis:" That title could be confusing or misleading, as the CITY OF Indianapolis, where Indianapolis Center is located, is 177 nautical miles from where AAL77 was located when it dropped off their screens. A suggested rewording of your title could be ""Understanding why AA77 "disappeared" from Air Traffic Control RADAR displays at Indianapolis Center."
 
Thanks to all for posting info about the FAA radar facilities that evacuated that day.

Chris...earlier you asked whether air traffic personnel were aware that QRI was "broken." I did some additional research, and found a NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System report that mentions QRI's substandard performance. You can find a link to that in my July 31, 2013 update on my AAL77 page of my site. (Sorry for no clickable link...I haven't been on this forum long enough to have that privilege.)

I can't help but wonder when (if?) QRI got updated with improved SEARCH capability.

I really appreciate your blog, and all the evidence that you collected so as to counter those that think there was a grand conspiracy. And I really appreciate you adding a link to my presentation.

I wish to make one comment though, and that is the title you gave it... "Understanding why AA77 "disappeared" from Air Traffic Control RADAR over Indianapolis:" That title could be confusing or misleading, as the CITY OF Indianapolis, where Indianapolis Center is located, is 177 nautical miles from where AAL77 was located when it dropped off their screens. A suggested rewording of your title could be ""Understanding why AA77 "disappeared" from Air Traffic Control RADAR displays at Indianapolis Center."


Welcome, made link clickable. :)
 
Thanks to all for posting info about the FAA radar facilities that evacuated that day.

Chris...earlier you asked whether air traffic personnel were aware that QRI was "broken." I did some additional research, and found a NASA Aviation Safety Reporting System report that mentions QRI's substandard performance. You can find a link to that in my July 31, 2013 update on my AAL77 page of Tom Lusch Dot Com. (Sorry for no clickable link...I haven't been on this forum long enough to have that privilege.)

I can't help but wonder when (if?) QRI got updated with improved SEARCH capability.

I really appreciate your blog, and all the evidence that you collected so as to counter those that think there was a grand conspiracy. And I really appreciate you adding a link to my presentation.

I wish to make one comment though, and that is the title you gave it... "Understanding why AA77 "disappeared" from Air Traffic Control RADAR over Indianapolis:" That title could be confusing or misleading, as the CITY OF Indianapolis, where Indianapolis Center is located, is 177 nautical miles from where AAL77 was located when it dropped off their screens. A suggested rewording of your title could be ""Understanding why AA77 "disappeared" from Air Traffic Control RADAR displays at Indianapolis Center."

Good point, title changed. I followed your link, quite frustrating to see that people actively knew of the problems with that site. Would be interesting to see if it ever got updated or whether to this day it's still broken :boggled:

Looks like you've put in quite a lot of work towards this, I'm gonna have a good read through some of your links.

Thanks.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom