PZ Myers, Seattle, 03-27-13

Evidence for this? I'm on my phone so find it hard to search, but IIRC, he hasn't published very much.

Mainly I added that so as to be somewhat balanced in my criticism; I was judging mostly from his writing on his blog on biological topics. He teaches 3 or 4 courses a semester in undergrad biology, he doesn't appear to have any real scholarly research going, though I could be wrong. I imagine he might be a good, thorough biology teacher. He seems to spend an inordinate amount of time away from the job; I wonder how that works for teaching prep and the like. Anyway, that's all I meant by it. If you want, given his vitae and his position, you might want to find evidence to argue against his attainments in biology if you really want a polemic.
 
Mainly I added that so as to be somewhat balanced in my criticism; I was judging mostly from his writing on his blog on biological topics. He teaches 3 or 4 courses a semester in undergrad biology, he doesn't appear to have any real scholarly research going, though I could be wrong. I imagine he might be a good, thorough biology teacher. He seems to spend an inordinate amount of time away from the job; I wonder how that works for teaching prep and the like. Anyway, that's all I meant by it.


That's my impression of PZ's academic career as well--he knows his stuff and he's a good communicator and probably a good teacher, though it wouldn't surprise me if he's pretty much on autopilot these days given how much time he spends outside the classroom, both literally and figuratively. I had understood your earlier statement to mean that beyond that he was a real standout among his biologist peers, which is what I was questioning.
 
So now a person has to be a leader in the field to be called "a very good biologist". :confused: Does the adjective "great" or "best" not apply to your continuum? "Very good" is at the far end?


Adman, you were claiming publishing is the measure of "a very good biologist". You may not have meant it to mean the only way, in which case all you needed was to merely tell us what are your other criteria. It would have been more helpful to simply clarify what you meant rather that go off on a rant about straw men. No one is trying to argue straw men with you.

Adman said:
Here, I'll help you: has he written biology textbooks that are widely used (or even highly-regarded popular books on the subject geared toward non-scientists)? Is he often invited to congresses or to other academic institutions to present his work? Is there evidence that he is highly respected among his peers?
Writing text books is a red herring. I used to get annoyed when my professors made every student in the class buy their $100+ textbooks.

I'd be surprised if he wasn't respected among his peers.

He's asked to speak all over the place, much of the time to refute Intelligent Design and address the anti-evolution theory fanatics.

He's cited often as an expert, for example in this blog, refuting the most recent claim of finding fossils in a meteorite.

Invited to present his work? We are back to your definition of "very good". He's on that speaking schedule he's belittled for in this thread because he's a knowledgeable speaker, not because he goes around ranting about Father Donahue's reaction to the 'Body of Christ' wafer PZ spit out. As far as I know, his blog and his talks are completely different things.


Adman said:
You seem to be highly defensive for some reason, when all I was asking for was evidence that PZ is "a very good biologist". Where is that evidence?
A fair number of people who consider themselves skeptics judge PZ Myer's quality as a biologist on the fact his politics and confrontational
atheist blog rubs them the wrong way. It would appear from the comments here that he supposedly has been too busy with other things, ergo he must not be up on his scientific field. I find people's inability to separate their personal feelings from the man's scientific qualifications to be rather telling.

"I don't like his religion and politics, therefore his science cred is suspect" is clearly a theme when you read comments about PZ around the web, including here.
 
Last edited:
So now a person has to be a leader in the field to be called "a very good biologist".
<snip>


Now that shadron has explained what he or she meant by using the phrase "a very good biologist", I've said I agree with that assessment of PZ, even if I wouldn't use that phrase. Let's move on.
 
Last edited:
As for what he's going to talk about, PZ writes:
I’m also working up my Seattle talk, which is slowly congealing. I’m going to talk about scientific and atheistic ethics there, and the message isn’t hopeful: I’m going to discuss our woeful failures, and suggest that morality ain’t gonna be found in a test tube. But there’ll also be some optimism for how broadening our foundations to encompass humanist values can compensate.

From http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2013/03/18/skeptech-help-me/
 
Ah, Kane Hall. Be nice to see it again.

Should be neat, just don't take 520. Those tolls suck.

;)
 
Myers and Plait both took to heart Watson's claim that women were being accosted everywhere. Plait has been close friends with Watson for as long as the JREF has existed. I don't know how close Myers is to her, but he is good friends with Plait.

Since the JREF has existed since 1996, I doubt that.
 
Since the JREF has existed since 1996, I doubt that.
OK, my bad. I stand corrected:

They've been friends since sometime between 2003 when Phil spoke at TAM 1 and 2005 when the Skepchick Blog started.

I've heard Phil speak very highly of Rebecca in person on more than one occasion.
 
Well Seattle Skeptics at the Pub had a very informative discussion last night about the whole FreeThoughtBlogs kerfuffle.

This web site Phawrongula has thorough coverage of the whole mess from beginning to present for anyone who wants to know what the issues are.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom