PZ Myers, Seattle, 03-27-13

Ginger -- that link only works for members of the MeetUp. Do you know what he's speaking on? -- MK
 
Rebecca W.? elevators (I understand from recent research I was doing for some others that he has taken great interest in that direction over the last year or so.:)

understatement of the century! yep, he certainly has gone off on a massive woo shaped tangent. its quits an interesting mental demise actually. there is a lesson in there for everyone. i would link but all you have to do is go to pharyngula and look at his posts.

he seems to have lost his critical thinking skills like superman around kryptonite.(although he was never a superman/woman/girl)

lxxx
 
Ginger -- that link only works for members of the MeetUp. Do you know what he's speaking on? -- MK
I didn't know that. Erika said it was open to all, including the public. Here's the blurb:
Wednesday, March 27, 2013
7:00 PM

University of Washington, Kane Hall Rm. 210
1510 NE Campus Parkway, Seattle, WA

PZ Myers is a biologist at the University of Minnesota Morris, with a special interest in developmental biology and evolution. He’s been battling creationists and bible-wallopers on the internet since 1993, and has gotten slightly curmudgeonly about it all. The blog Pharyngula is his outlet for venting his fury at faith, stupidity, and injustice, an occupation which somehow led to him being named American Humanist of the Year in 2009, and International Humanist of 2011 by the IHEU. He’s confident that science is the only tool we have for reaching new knowledge, regards faith and ignorance as vices, and finds happiness with his family.

$5 suggested donation for non-students.
I'm thinking it will be related to evolution and/or the lack of real gods in the Universe since this is the Atheists/Agnostics meetup.

I can't see him talking about feminism or elevatorgate. I doubt he's the least bit consumed by that topic. When he was here before he gave a great talk on the evolution of the eye. He also pointed out that the whole knowledge of 'Creation' of the Universe amounts to a page in the Bible while the amount of scientific knowledge we've accumulated is massive.
 
Last edited:
Rebecca W.? elevators (I understand from recent research I was doing for some others that he has taken great interest in that direction over the last year or so.:)
Myers and Plait both took to heart Watson's claim that women were being accosted everywhere. Plait has been close friends with Watson for as long as the JREF has existed. I don't know how close Myers is to her, but he is good friends with Plait.

Friendship can cause a great deal of confirmation bias.

I don't think it's more than that.
 
I would just mention that the confirmation bias probably also extends to the stable of people he has writing in the Freethought blog that he legally owns, exerts rather strict control over, and the money that that involves.

He is, though, a very good biologist.
 
Evidence for this? I'm on my phone so find it hard to search, but IIRC, he hasn't published very much.
I've heard his lecture on evolution of the eye and I can definitely attest to his full command of the science and his skill as an interesting speaker.
 
I've heard his lecture on evolution of the eye and I can definitely attest to his full command of the science and his skill as an interesting speaker.

I'm not saying he doesn't understand biology or isn't a good speaker. But claiming he's "a very good biologist" means a lot more than that in an academic/scientific setting.
 
I'm not saying he doesn't understand biology or isn't a good speaker. But claiming he's "a very good biologist" means a lot more than that in an academic/scientific setting.
Yet you're claiming publishing is the only measure of "a very good biologist"?
 
Yet you're claiming publishing is the only measure of "a very good biologist"?


That is a blatant strawman. I never said publishing is the only measure. I simply asked for evidence that he is "a very good biologist". One way to measure how "good" (or at least how prolific) a scientist is is by how much he or she has published (and the quality of the papers, of course, but that is difficult to evaluate by non-scientists like me), and I seem to recall reading that he hasn't published very much, at least in recent years.
 
Here's his credentials:
Paul Myers
Associate Professor

Ph.D., University of Oregon
B.S., University of Washington, Seattle

areas of expertise
Developmental Biology
Neurobiology

And he has published research:
JOURNAL ARTICLES
S.E. Stachel, D.J. Grunwald, and P.Z. Myers
Lithium perturbation and goosecoid expression identify a dorsal specification pathway in the pregastrula zebrafish
Development 1993 117:1261-1274


JOURNAL ARTICLES
W.K. Metcalfe, P.Z. Myers, B. Trevarrow, M.B. Bass, and C.B. Kimmel
Primary neurons that express the L2/HNK-1 carbohydrate during early development in the zebrafish
Development 1990 110:491-504

And I'm sure if you sorted through the 751 hits on Google Scholar for "PZ Myers" you'll find many more.
 
Probably the internet's best example of a whining jackass. He was the only person I ever unsubscribed to on RSS, way before any of this blathering babble about elevators, the guy is a shining example of how to be a self-important windbag.
 
Here's what he's published since 2007:

http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=author:"PZ+Myers"&hl=en&as_sdt=0,23&as_ylo=2007&as_yhi=2013

Seems thin to me. He published a lot more earlier in his career, which doesn't surprise me.
Are you backing down off your earlier complaint?

AdMan said:
shadron said:
He is, though, a very good biologist.
Evidence for this? I'm on my phone so find it hard to search, but IIRC, he hasn't published very much.
I'm not saying he doesn't understand biology or isn't a good speaker. But claiming he's "a very good biologist" means a lot more than that in an academic/scientific setting.
And now you say it's a straw man that I interpreted this to mean if you know your field and are a good science communicator, you still weren't "a very good biologist" unless you also published.

I fail to see the straw man charge. How else are you judging?

You're not a biologist if you only know the science and teach? I'm not sure I see 'researcher' as an absolute criteria for being a biologist. Nor do I see "must be doing current research" to continue to be a good biologist. PZ knows his stuff, people can accuse, but not liking his blog or his politics is not a criteria for doubting his academic credentials.

And FWIW, I'm definitely not in camp Rebecca.
 
Last edited:
Here's what he's published since 2007:

http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=author:"PZ+Myers"&hl=en&as_sdt=0,23&as_ylo=2007&as_yhi=2013

Seems thin to me. He published a lot more earlier in his career, which doesn't surprise me.
Are you backing down off your earlier complaint?
I'm not backing down from anything. My point was that he hasn't published that much (which I later qualified by saying in recent years--i.e., after he became well known primarily through his blog and he started spending time on stuff other than science and research).

AdMan said:
shadron said:
He is, though, a very good biologist.
Evidence for this? I'm on my phone so find it hard to search, but IIRC, he hasn't published very much.
I'm not saying he doesn't understand biology or isn't a good speaker. But claiming he's "a very good biologist" means a lot more than that in an academic/scientific setting.
And now you say it's a straw man that I interpreted this to mean if you know your field and are a good science communicator, you still weren't "a very good biologist" unless you also published.

I fail to see the straw man charge.


Here, I've highlighted your strawman for you to make it easy to spot:
Yet you're claiming publishing is the only measure of "a very good biologist"?

I never claimed that. Again, I asked for evidence because I'd heard he hadn't published much, which is not very impressive from an academic/scientific POV. It is one measure of academic achievement.

You're not a biologist if you only know the science and teach? I'm not sure I see 'researcher' as an absolute criteria for being a biologist. Nor do I see "must be doing current research" to continue to be a good biologist. PZ knows his stuff, people can accuse, but not liking his blog or his politics is not a criteria for doubting his academic credentials.

Yet more strawmen--you're putting words in my mouth. I never said that you're not a biologist if you only know the science and teach. I never said that "researcher" was an absolute criteria for being a good biologist. I never said that a good biologist "must be doing current research" (and why did you disingenuously put that phrase in quotes as if I had said it?).

You seem to be highly defensive for some reason, when all I was asking for was evidence that PZ is "a very good biologist". Where is that evidence?

Here, I'll help you: has he written biology textbooks that are widely used (or even highly-regarded popular books on the subject geared toward non-scientists)? Is he often invited to congresses or to other academic institutions to present his work? Is there evidence that he is highly respected among his peers?

That's the kind of evidence I was looking for (and I honestly don't know the answers). Do you have it?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom