Pyramids in the bible

Are there any other sources for all but one of the Egyptian idols being destroyed? It sounds like a significant event.


I only know of these two (The Legends of the Jews, III Pharaoh Pursues the Hebrews, also Targum Pseudo-Jonathan, Exodus 14), and it is possible that Legends of the Jews copied form the Targum.


So the Egyptians themselves made no mention of this alleged destruction of their cultural and religious heritage, as well as forgetting to mention the loss of Pharaoh and the entire army?

Just shrugged their shoulders and went on with other projects, did they?


Also . . .


AvenueOfSphinxes.jpg

It appears that the Hebrew god missed a few



Hathor3.jpg

Hathor is not amused



Horus.jpg

Horus looks a bit snippy as well​
 
Last edited:
This would mean that the Sphinx would be the only possibility for Baal-zephon, for all believe it was standing when the children of Israel left Egypt!


In what way do you consider crossing the Nile from Giza to the outskirts of the ancient city of Heliopolis to be leaving Egypt? Why does the name of Beth-shemesh (the Hebrew name for Heliopolis) not appear in your storyl?

And if Exodus 14 is describing a crossing of the Nile River, where then is the description of the Israelites crossing the actual Red Sea to be found?
 
Last edited:
Are there any other sources for all but one of the Egyptian idols being destroyed? It sounds like a significant event.


The destruction of various bits of Egypt appears to have been a fantasy of the Hebrews throughout most of their history.

For example, Jeremiah 43:13 foretells (of the Babylonian king, Nebuchadnezzar) that:


"He shall break the obelisks of Heliopolis, which is in the land of Egypt, and the temples of the gods of Egypt he shall burn with fire."​


However . . .


ObeliskHeliopolis.jpg

Guess where?​
 
Where was the Red Sea/Yam Suf in the days of Moses? Dead Sea Scroll, 1Q20, Genesis Apocryphon 21:15-19, said, “I proceeded by the Red Sea until I reached the extension of the Reed Sea which goes out from the Red Sea, and then I turned southward, until I reached the Gihon River....” The person in this account was already on the “Red Sea” and goes to the “extension” of it, which he calls the “Reed Sea" (Delta), and then to the Nile or “Gihon”. He is telling us in his day that the Red Sea was connected to the Nile by the “Reed Sea".

I think you should read a few more of the lines: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genesis_Apocryphon

I began my journey at the river Gihon and traveled along the coast of the sea until I came to the Mountain of the Bull [Taurus]. Then I traveled from the coast of the Great Salt Sea and journeyed towards the east by the Mountain of the Bull, across the breadth of the land, until I came to the river Euphrates. I journeyed along the Euphrates until I came to the Red Sea in the east, and I traveled along the coast of the Red Sea until I came to the tongue of the Sea of Reeds [the modern Red Sea] which flows out from the Red Sea. Then I pursued my way in the south until I came to the river Gihon, and returning, I came to my house in peace and found all things prosperous there.

Abram's journey as described here takes him from the river Gihon [the Nile] to the Mountain of the Bull, across the breadth of the land, then down the river Euphrates to the Red Sea. This tells us "the Red Sea" in this account was what we now refer to as the Persian Gulf.

Abram then followed the coast of the Persian Gulf until he came to "the tongue of the Sea of Reeds [the modern Red Sea]". He pursued his way IN THE SOUTH (not "towards the south", simply "in the south") until he came to the river Gihon (the Nile) again.

Summary: The "Gihon" is the Nile, the "Red Sea" is the Persian Gulf, and the "Reed Sea" is the Red Sea.
 
In what way do you consider crossing the Nile from Giza to the outskirts of the ancient city of Heliopolis to be leaving Egypt?"

Egypt controlled other lands out-side of its borders, but these were not considered the country of Egypt. The Delta and the Nile valley are where all the Egyptians lived; to leave these was to leave the country of Egypt (Herodotus, Book II and Strabo, Geography, Book XVII, 30) This is why the Bible said Israel left Egypt on the first day of their Exodus. "And it came to pass the selfsame day, that the LORD did bring the children of Israel out of the land of Egypt...." (Exodus 12:51, also verses 17 & 41) Once Israel left the Nile Valley it left Egypt, they did not have to cross the Sinai Peninsula before they left Egypt.

Israel left from where Josephus said, the second Nome, and then they went out on the desert to two locations (Succoth and Etham), and it was at the second encampment that the Bible says they were to return to where they had been, “And they removed from Etham, and turned again unto Pi-hahiroth…” (Numbers 33:7). The Bible, all three Targums, the Torah, and Jewish legends have Israel going back to where she started! “Moses…gave the signal to turn back to Pi-hahiroth. Those of little faith among the Israelites tore their hair and their garments in desperation, though Moses assured them that by the Word of God they were free men, and no longer slaves to Pharaoh. Accordingly, they retraced their steps to Pi-hahiroth, where....the great sanctuary of Baal-zephon was situated” (Legends of the Jews). Israel was to “turn back” to Pi-hahiroth, even saying they “retraced their steps to Pi-hahiroth”, ending up where they started! Notice the children of Israel were not happy with this news, “tore their hair and their garments in desperation”. They thought they were going to become slaves again. “For Pharaoh will say of the children of Israel, They are entangled in the land, the wilderness hath shut them in. And I will harden Pharaoh's heart, that he shall follow after them; and I will be honoured upon Pharaoh, and upon all his host; that the Egyptians may know that I am the LORD.” (Exodus 14:3-4) In Pharaoh’s mind, all they had done was just go in a big circle.

I believe Israel left from the “land” of Rameses. The children of Israel left from Rameses, but the Bible does not say if it was the city or the land of Rameses. (Numbers 33:3) But the “land of Goshen” and the “land of Rameses” are one and the same. The children of Israel are said to live in both, and both are said to be “the best of the land” of Egypt (Genesis 47:4-6, 11).






Why does the name of Beth-shemesh (the Hebrew name for Heliopolis) not appear in your storyl?"

Because they did not go there. Heliopolis was not far, but there was a place that was even closer. Besides the place names Migdol, Baalzephon and “the sea”, there was also Pihahiroth (Exodus 14:2, not Beth-shemesh), Pihahiroth is pronounced “pē hah khērōth'” (Strong’s Concordance). And most would translate “pe-ha” as “the mouth of” (a canal/river?). It is disputed if this name “Kheroth” is Egyptian, though some strongly believe that it is, “t is doubtless to be regarded as Egyptian…” (Gesenius Lexicon, online). And the Septuagint for Exodus 14:2 said it was a “village”, not a monument, making the name “Kheroth” more likely to be an Egyptian name of that town. Josephus said the Exodus started at “Letopolis” (Antiq. II, 15, 1, the second nome, on the west side of the Nile), and at the southern end of it “where Babylon was built afterwards…” This fortress named “Babylon” was directly across the Nile from the Sphinx in the area of Old Cairo. The area where Fort Babylon was built, was originally an ancient Egyptian town called Kher-aha or Kher-ahau (vowels are conjecture). The Dream Stela, Papyrus of Sanehat (Sinuhit), Victory Stelea of King Piye and the Papyrus of Ani (all on line) all mention the town of Kherahau and its location being in the area of Old Fort Babylon.

And if Exodus 14 is describing a crossing of the Nile River, where then is the description of the Israelites crossing the actual Red Sea to be found?

The name “Red Sea” in the Old Testament was Yam Suf, and ancient Jewish sources say that that was the Nile. Legends of the Jews, when speaking of the ark of the baby Moses which Miriam put in the Nile, called it the Yam Suf (Red Sea), “And then she [Miriam] abandoned the ark on the shores of the Red Sea.” (Volume II, Moses Rescued from the Water, also the Babylonian Talmud Sotah 12a). The annual Nile flood would fill the area between the Great Sphinx and Old Cairo with water, and it was a full six miles across.


Summary: The "Gihon" is the Nile, the "Red Sea" is the Persian Gulf, and the "Reed Sea" is the Red Sea.

Regardless of where the “Reed Sea” turned into the “Red Sea”, or started and stopped we both have the account end up at the Nile. By the way nice picture!


And still the point remains: No Pyramids."

Very good Akhenaten, you finale got it, that the Hebrew Bible would not have used a Greek word to describe them.
 
In what way do you consider crossing the Nile from Giza to the outskirts of the ancient city of Heliopolis to be leaving Egypt?"


Egypt controlled other lands out-side of its borders, but these were not considered the country of Egypt.


You don't say.

I think if you look closely you'll see that my post is talking about Heliopolis, capital of the 13th Nome of Lower Egypt, and well within the country's borders.



The Delta and the Nile valley are where all the Egyptians lived; to leave these was to leave the country of Egypt (Herodotus, Book II and Strabo, Geography, Book XVII, 30) This is why the Bible said Israel left Egypt on the first day of their Exodus. "And it came to pass the selfsame day, that the LORD did bring the children of Israel out of the land of Egypt...." (Exodus 12:51, also verses 17 & 41) Once Israel left the Nile Valley it left Egypt, they did not have to cross the Sinai Peninsula before they left Egypt.


Cross the Sinai? Your silly scenario hasn't even gotten them across the Eastern Desert.

I still want you to explain how crossing the Nile between Giza and Heliopolis could be described, as it is in your Big Book of Fairytales, as "leaving Egypt".



Israel left from where Josephus said, the second Nome . . .


Where the Pyramids are, you mean?

In any case, your version of the story still only has them moving from the 2nd Nome across the river and into the 13th Nome. This, quite clearly, is not "leaving the Land of Egypt".

Furthermore, where did Josephus come by this knowledge and how well is his claim supported by the archæological record?



. . . and then they went out on the desert to two locations (Succoth and Etham), and it was at the second encampment that the Bible says they were to return to where they had been, “And they removed from Etham, and turned again unto Pi-hahiroth…” (Numbers 33:7). The Bible, all three Targums, the Torah, and Jewish legends have Israel going back to where she started! “Moses…gave the signal to turn back to Pi-hahiroth. Those of little faith among the Israelites tore their hair and their garments in desperation, though Moses assured them that by the Word of God they were free men, and no longer slaves to Pharaoh. Accordingly, they retraced their steps to Pi-hahiroth, where....the great sanctuary of Baal-zephon was situated” (Legends of the Jews). Israel was to “turn back” to Pi-hahiroth, even saying they “retraced their steps to Pi-hahiroth”, ending up where they started! Notice the children of Israel were not happy with this news, “tore their hair and their garments in desperation”. They thought they were going to become slaves again. “For Pharaoh will say of the children of Israel, They are entangled in the land, the wilderness hath shut them in. And I will harden Pharaoh's heart, that he shall follow after them; and I will be honoured upon Pharaoh, and upon all his host; that the Egyptians may know that I am the LORD.” (Exodus 14:3-4) In Pharaoh’s mind, all they had done was just go in a big circle.


I assume that mess is trying to tell me that the biblical account is true because it's in the Bible.

Where have I heard that before?



I believe Israel left from the “land” of Rameses. The children of Israel left from Rameses, but the Bible does not say if it was the city or the land of Rameses. (Numbers 33:3) But the “land of Goshen” and the “land of Rameses” are one and the same. The children of Israel are said to live in both, and both are said to be “the best of the land” of Egypt (Genesis 47:4-6, 11).


What you believe is irrelevent, no matter what translations you make up to support that belief.



Why does the name of Beth-shemesh (the Hebrew name for Heliopolis) not appear in your story?"


Because they did not go there.


No, they didn't. Except in the fairytale.



Heliopolis was not far, but there was a place that was even closer. Besides the place names Migdol, Baalzephon and “the sea”, there was also Pihahiroth (Exodus 14:2, not Beth-shemesh), Pihahiroth is pronounced “pē hah khērōth'” (Strong’s Concordance). And most would translate “pe-ha” as “the mouth of” (a canal/river?). It is disputed if this name “Kheroth” is Egyptian, though some strongly believe that it is, “t is doubtless to be regarded as Egyptian…” (Gesenius Lexicon, online). And the Septuagint for Exodus 14:2 said it was a “village”, not a monument, making the name “Kheroth” more likely to be an Egyptian name of that town. Josephus said the Exodus started at “Letopolis” (Antiq. II, 15, 1, the second nome, on the west side of the Nile), and at the southern end of it “where Babylon was built afterwards…” This fortress named “Babylon” was directly across the Nile from the Sphinx in the area of Old Cairo. The area where Fort Babylon was built, was originally an ancient Egyptian town called Kher-aha or Kher-ahau (vowels are conjecture). The Dream Stela, Papyrus of Sanehat (Sinuhit), Victory Stelea of King Piye and the Papyrus of Ani (all on line) all mention the town of Kherahau and its location being in the area of Old Fort Babylon.





All you're doing here is making fanciful connections between (possibly) actual places and places that only appear in the fairytale and force fitting those connections back into the fairytale.

In doing so, you're trying to make it appear that the story of these mythical escapees contains a wealth of precise details about the places they travelled to/from and yet it omits even a single mention of the biggest things in the whole bloody world at that time and which, according to you, were right in the middle of where they were milling around waiting for Moses to do the big scene with his magic staff.



And if Exodus 14 is describing a crossing of the Nile River, where then is the description of the Israelites crossing the actual Red Sea to be found?


The name “Red Sea” in the Old Testament was Yam Suf, and ancient Jewish sources say that that was the Nile. Legends of the Jews, when speaking of the ark of the baby Moses which Miriam put in the Nile, called it the Yam Suf (Red Sea), “And then she [Miriam] abandoned the ark on the shores of the Red Sea.” (Volume II, Moses Rescued from the Water, also the Babylonian Talmud Sotah 12a). The annual Nile flood would fill the area between the Great Sphinx and Old Cairo with water, and it was a full six miles across.


That's not even a poor attempt to answer the question that I asked.

I'm not talking about your made-up Nile River/Red Sea - I'm talking about the really, truly Red Sea that lies between the Eastern Desert and the Sinai Peninsula.



Summary: The "Gihon" is the Nile, the "Red Sea" is the Persian Gulf, and the "Reed Sea" is the Red Sea.


Regardless of where the “Reed Sea” turned into the “Red Sea”, or started and stopped we both have the account end up at the Nile. By the way nice picture!


What in the name of Isis are you talking about? Where do you believe the Red Sea turns into the Persian Gulf?

What picture?



And still the point remains: No Pyramids."


Very good Akhenaten, you finale got it, that the Hebrew Bible would not have used a Greek word to describe them.


So, what word does it use for them?
 
I think you should read a few more of the lines: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genesis_Apocryphon



Abram's journey as described here takes him from the river Gihon [the Nile] to the Mountain of the Bull, across the breadth of the land, then down the river Euphrates to the Red Sea. This tells us "the Red Sea" in this account was what we now refer to as the Persian Gulf.

Abram then followed the coast of the Persian Gulf until he came to "the tongue of the Sea of Reeds [the modern Red Sea]". He pursued his way IN THE SOUTH (not "towards the south", simply "in the south") until he came to the river Gihon (the Nile) again.

Summary: The "Gihon" is the Nile, the "Red Sea" is the Persian Gulf, and the "Reed Sea" is the Red Sea.

Thanks for the link; the Apocryphon is new to me.
I don't really get an idea of why it's being brought up as proof of pyramids in the bible, though.
 
Aah, the famous Shower Curtain of Transcona. I've heard that C14 dating has placed its origins somwhere between 6:15 and 8:45 pm, putting its authenticity beyond all reasonable doubt.
 
In the uncropped version of that image, the clock beside "my" head might verify that. But I'm from Transcona, and we're too lazy to go check.

I'm not sure why the clock managed to also leave an image. One must have faith.

Also, that's not a beard. I was eating a cat.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom