Pyramids in the bible

Where was the Red Sea/Yam Suf in the days of Moses? Dead Sea Scroll, 1Q20, Genesis Apocryphon 21:15-19, said, “I proceeded by the Red Sea until I reached the extension of the Reed Sea which goes out from the Red Sea, and then I turned southward, until I reached the Gihon River....” The person in this account was already on the “Red Sea” and goes to the “extension” of it, which he calls the “Reed Sea" (Delta), and then to the Nile or “Gihon”. He is telling us in his day that the Red Sea was connected to the Nile by the “Reed Sea". The location of the “Gihon” River is a matter of debate, but Josephus (and many other Jewish writers) has it as the Nile River, “Geon runs through Egypt.” (Josephus, Antiquities, I, 3) The Targums, Pseudo-Jonathan and Jerusalem, both connect the Nile to the Red Sea/Yam Suph, “and the Gihon [Nile] had carried into the sea of Suph, and the sea of Suph bad cast upon its bank. But all the chariot horses of Pharaoh, and his horsemen, and his hosts (were coming) towards the Mouths of Hiratha, which are before the idol Zephon.” This Hebrew word "suf" (suph) is the same word translated "flags" of the river (Exodus 2:3, & 5), where the ark that held Moses as a baby was placed in the reeds of the Nile River. It is also the same word translated "Red" from Red Sea in the Hebrew Old Testament. In the Qur'an they also call the crossing place the “Red Sea”: however, one of Islam’s prophets explains that this was the Nile River! His name is Prophet Shu’ayb, a descendant of Abraham and a contemporary of Moses. This is found in Hay Al Qulub Vol. I, Stories of the prophets, Section 13, “An Account of Musa and Harun” (Moses and Aaron). The pertinent parts are, “Musa and the Israelites came to the bank of the river Nile. The water of river split and made a way to cross the river…and the last man of the Pharaoh entered into the river. Allah ordered the wind to move the water and the mountain of water fell on them.” (See also Akhlaq-e-Aaimma, by Sayyed Zafar Hasan Amrohi, r-d). Legends of the Jews, when speaking of the ark of the baby Moses which Miriam put in the Nile, called it the Yam Suf (Red Sea), “And then she [Miriam] abandoned the ark on the shores of the Red Sea.” (Volume II, Moses Rescued from the Water.) Author and highly respected Jewish Priest Eleazar (4th century AD), also believed the placement of Moses’ ark was in the Yam Suf (Babylonian Talmud Sotah 12a).
 
Where was the Red Sea/Yam Suf in the days of Moses? Dead Sea Scroll, 1Q20, Genesis Apocryphon 21:15-19, said, “I proceeded by the Red Sea until I reached the extension of the Reed Sea which goes out from the Red Sea, and then I turned southward, until I reached the Gihon River....” The person in this account was already on the “Red Sea” and goes to the “extension” of it, which he calls the “Reed Sea" (Delta), and then to the Nile or “Gihon”. He is telling us in his day that the Red Sea was connected to the Nile by the “Reed Sea". The location of the “Gihon” River is a matter of debate, but Josephus (and many other Jewish writers) has it as the Nile River, “Geon runs through Egypt.” (Josephus, Antiquities, I, 3) The Targums, Pseudo-Jonathan and Jerusalem, both connect the Nile to the Red Sea/Yam Suph, “and the Gihon [Nile] had carried into the sea of Suph, and the sea of Suph bad cast upon its bank. But all the chariot horses of Pharaoh, and his horsemen, and his hosts (were coming) towards the Mouths of Hiratha, which are before the idol Zephon.” This Hebrew word "suf" (suph) is the same word translated "flags" of the river (Exodus 2:3, & 5), where the ark that held Moses as a baby was placed in the reeds of the Nile River. It is also the same word translated "Red" from Red Sea in the Hebrew Old Testament. In the Qur'an they also call the crossing place the “Red Sea”: however, one of Islam’s prophets explains that this was the Nile River! His name is Prophet Shu’ayb, a descendant of Abraham and a contemporary of Moses. This is found in Hay Al Qulub Vol. I, Stories of the prophets, Section 13, “An Account of Musa and Harun” (Moses and Aaron). The pertinent parts are, “Musa and the Israelites came to the bank of the river Nile. The water of river split and made a way to cross the river…and the last man of the Pharaoh entered into the river. Allah ordered the wind to move the water and the mountain of water fell on them.” (See also Akhlaq-e-Aaimma, by Sayyed Zafar Hasan Amrohi, r-d). Legends of the Jews, when speaking of the ark of the baby Moses which Miriam put in the Nile, called it the Yam Suf (Red Sea), “And then she [Miriam] abandoned the ark on the shores of the Red Sea.” (Volume II, Moses Rescued from the Water.) Author and highly respected Jewish Priest Eleazar (4th century AD), also believed the placement of Moses’ ark was in the Yam Suf (Babylonian Talmud Sotah 12a).
Remember, paragraphs are your friend.
 
Last edited:
I found some pyramids:

1 Maccabees 13:28-29: 28 He (Simon) also erected seven pyramids, opposite one another, for his father and mother and four brothers. 29 For the pyramids he devised an elaborate setting, erecting about them great columns, and on the columns he put suits of armor for a permanent memorial, and beside the suits of armor he carved ships, so that they could be seen by all who sail the sea.

That was from the New Revised Standard Version Catholic Edition at Biblegateway. (As opposed to the Revised New Standard Edition Catholic Version, I suppose).

So there's one off-the-cuff mention of giants in Genesis, and a couple of mentions of pyramids in Maccabees, which, in my Catholic Bible Personal Study Edition is only separated by about 550 pages.

I'm sure it's an honest error.
 
Where was the Red Sea/Yam Suf in the days of Moses?


Unless this Moses fellow was wandering about the place more than 30 million years ago, right where it is now.


Dead Sea Scroll, 1Q20, Genesis Apocryphon 21:15-19, said, “I proceeded by the Red Sea until I reached the extension of the Reed Sea which goes out from the Red Sea, and then I turned southward, until I reached the Gihon River....” The person in this account was already on the “Red Sea” and goes to the “extension” of it, which he calls the “Reed Sea" (Delta), and then to the Nile or “Gihon”.


Even if some of these rather vague and in some cases guessed-at directions are correct they do not imply a direct connection between the Nile and the Red Sea. If one "proceeds by the Red Sea" to its most northerly extent in the Gulf of Suez and then turns south one will still, to this very day, eventually encounter the Nile.


He is telling us in his day that the Red Sea was connected to the Nile by the “Reed Sea".


No, he isn't.


The location of the “Gihon” River is a matter of debate, but Josephus (and many other Jewish writers) has it as the Nile River, “Geon runs through Egypt.” (Josephus, Antiquities, I, 3).


This says nothing to help make a case for the Nile flowing into the Red Sea.


The Targums, Pseudo-Jonathan and Jerusalem, both connect the Nile to the Red Sea/Yam Suph, “and the Gihon [Nile] had carried into the sea of Suph, and the sea of Suph bad cast upon its bank. But all the chariot horses of Pharaoh, and his horsemen, and his hosts (were coming) towards the Mouths of Hiratha, which are before the idol Zephon.” This Hebrew word "suf" (suph) is the same word translated "flags" of the river (Exodus 2:3, & 5), where the ark that held Moses as a baby was placed in the reeds of the Nile River. It is also the same word translated "Red" from Red Sea in the Hebrew Old Testament. In the Qur'an they also call the crossing place the “Red Sea”: however, one of Islam’s prophets explains that this was the Nile River! His name is Prophet Shu’ayb, a descendant of Abraham and a contemporary of Moses. This is found in Hay Al Qulub Vol. I, Stories of the prophets, Section 13, “An Account of Musa and Harun” (Moses and Aaron). The pertinent parts are, “Musa and the Israelites came to the bank of the river Nile. The water of river split and made a way to cross the river…and the last man of the Pharaoh entered into the river. Allah ordered the wind to move the water and the mountain of water fell on them.” (See also Akhlaq-e-Aaimma, by Sayyed Zafar Hasan Amrohi, r-d). Legends of the Jews, when speaking of the ark of the baby Moses which Miriam put in the Nile, called it the Yam Suf (Red Sea), “And then she [Miriam] abandoned the ark on the shores of the Red Sea.” (Volume II, Moses Rescued from the Water.) Author and highly respected Jewish Priest Eleazar (4th century AD), also believed the placement of Moses’ ark was in the Yam Suf (Babylonian Talmud Sotah 12a).


I'm not even going to try to sort out what that mess is trying to say, other than to point out that I can't see any mention of Pyramids in there.
 
I found some pyramids:

1 Maccabees 13:28-29: 28 He (Simon) also erected seven pyramids, opposite one another, for his father and mother and four brothers. 29 For the pyramids he devised an elaborate setting, erecting about them great columns, and on the columns he put suits of armor for a permanent memorial, and beside the suits of armor he carved ships, so that they could be seen by all who sail the sea.


Yep, that's definitely a description of the Pyramids built by the Egyptians on the western side of the Nile.

Or not.


That was from the New Revised Standard Version Catholic Edition at Biblegateway. (As opposed to the Revised New Standard Edition Catholic Version, I suppose).

So there's one off-the-cuff mention of giants in Genesis, and a couple of mentions of pyramids in Maccabees, which, in my Catholic Bible Personal Study Edition is only separated by about 550 pages.

I'm sure it's an honest error.


Just like the bats = birds thingy.
 
Aren't Maccabees describing events somewhat later than the time of the supposed Exodus?
 
The pyramids in Maccabees are interesting. There's some really fascinating Jewish archaeology from the Hellenistic period which shows the Jews of the time mixing in all sorts of different architechtural traditions, including Doric and Corinthian columns, pyramids, Roman temple architecture, and so on, for tombs, houses and sacred buildings. Google 'Hasmonean tombs' to see lots of tombs of Jewish dignitaries with columns and pyramids. Eg this site has pics:

http://thejudeochristiantradition.blogspot.co.uk/2011/01/hammer-of-god-part-iv-maccabee-tombs.html

This architecture is used a lot in debates about the nature of Judaism during the Hellenistic period. Were the Jews holding out for a pure culture, uncontaminated by Greek and other influences? This architecture, with other evidence, suggests not.
 
“Wouldn't the mountain range between them be a bit of an obstacle to the Nile flowing into the Red Sea?” The land is flat between the Gulf of Suez and the Mediterranean Sea, that is why they made the Suez Canal there. Actually the Pharaohs themselves had built an ancient canal from the Delta to the Gulf of Suez. Herodotus (440 BC) said that at one time the Nile Delta was always under water not just during the yearly flood. “And they [the priest] told me that the first man who ruled over Egypt was Min, and that in his time all Egypt, except the baic canton, was a marsh, none of the land below Lake Moeris then showing itself above the surface of the water.” (The History of Herodotus, II) The Delta has slowly filled in from the silt of the Nile, but at the time of the first king of Egypt, the Delta would have been underwater all year long, not just during the yearly flood. And if so then it would have been extended to the Gulf of Suez. There is no way to know how long the Red Sea and the Nile were connected; however, it is recorded that they were connected in the Dead Sea Scroll Genesis Apocryphon which I gave already, and which was copied out from early texts.

“one ‘proceeds by the Red Sea’ to its most northerly extent in the Gulf of Suez and then turns south one will still, to this very day, eventually encounter the Nile.”

Today the Suez and the Nile are not connected, at least not to my knowledge, unless you are talking about a small canal branching off of the Suez canal.



“I can't see any mention of Pyramids in there.” I was bringing out that the body of water in front of the Great Pyramid and the Sphinx was at times called the Yam Suf.
The name that the Egyptians gave the Delta was “Ta-mehu” (Land of the Papyrus/reeds). In the Old Testament the name that is translated “Red Sea” is taken from the Hebrew Yam Suf/Suph and means "sea of reeds" (see Strong's Concordance, online), and it is true that there was more than one place named this as the Gulf of Aqaba.

If we already have a “land of reeds", and we “add water" (the average annual flood was 24 feet above the Nile), we should have a “sea of reeds”. That is why the Egyptians called the flooded Delta the “Lake of Rushes”. Would not this be translated by the Hebrew words Yam Suf? (“sea of reeds”/Red Sea). How else could they have translated it?

The word translated “sea” (yam) in the Hebrew can refer to a small fresh water lake such as the “Sea” of Galilee, or, according to Strong's Concordance, a “mighty river". Diodorus, who lived during the first century BC, said the Egyptians called the Nile an “ocean” (Diodorus, book I, 12, 96). The Nile is the longest river in the world, and modern Egyptians commonly call the Nile River El-Bahr = "The Sea".
 
When do we get to the bit where the Pyramids are in the Bible?

Also, please learn to use the quote function.


ETA: Just to answer one point:

No matter what irrelevant translations you use (including the ones you just make up as you go) the Nile River near Giza is not now, never has been and in all reasonable likelihood never will be known as the Red Sea or even the Reed Sea.
 
Last edited:
In an earlier post I said that at the time of the Exodus the Hebrew Bible would not use the Greek Name “Pyramid”, any more than the ancient Egyptians would to describe them. As Pliny the elder (Roman author, first century AD) also called them “towers”, so during the time of Moses it was “Migdol” (tower).

What about the Sphinx? Again we cannot expect the Hebrew Bible to use the Greek name “Sphinx” for this Egyptian Idol. And it was worshiped by the Egyptians with sacrifice given up to it. The Dream Stele which was found between the paws of the Sphinx talks of Pharaoh Thutmose IV offering up scarifies to it. One of the other place names found at the sea crossing was Baal-zephon Exodus 14:2, and Jewish sources say that Baal-zephon was an idol. “efore the idol Zephon,” (Targum Pseudo-Jonathan, Exodus 14:2), “dol of Zephon,” (Targum Jerusalem, Exodus 14:2).

Ancient Jewish sources make an interesting comment about this idol. “Of set purpose God had left Baal-zephon uninjured, alone of all the Egyptian idols. He wanted the Egyptian people to think that this idol was possessed of exceeding might, which it exercised to prevent the Israelites from journeying on.” (The Legends of the Jews, III Pharaoh Pursues the Hebrews, also Targum Pseudo-Jonathan, Exodus 14) The Bible declares that on the night of the Passover, besides smiting all the firstborn, God “executes judgment” on all the gods of Egypt. (Exodus 12:12, also Numbers 33:4). This was believed to be when God destroyed the idols of Egypt. But as quoted above the reason Baal-zephon was still standing was to give Pharaoh a false hope in this idol. This would mean that the Sphinx would be the only possibility for Baal-zephon, for all believe it was standing when the children of Israel left Egypt! What other idol could it have been? These Jewish sources just quoted said Baal-zephon was the only one left, it was and is still there. It could not have been some carry-around idol that was set back up, but of necessity it would have to have been very large, for it is used as a landmark for a nation.

Baal-zephon is a Hebrew or Canaanite word and means “lord of the north” (Strong’s Concordance). One would expect the Jews to use a name they were familiar with from their time in Canaan before they came to Egypt. Just as the Egyptian god Amun was called by the Greeks, Zeus and by the Romans, Jupiter, so the Sphinx was called Baal-zephon by the Jews.

But why would the Jews pick this particular Canaanite deity to identify with the Sphinx and not one of the other gods of the Canaanites? There would have to be some reason to identify the Sphinx with Baal-zephon. The Egyptians, by 1500 BC, were calling the Sphinx “Horus in the Horizon”. Horus was associated with the north or Lower Egypt (“lower” Egypt is north, and “upper” Egypt is south). There is a stele called the Shabaka Stone in which one of their gods named Geb, calls a council and divides the rule of Egypt between two gods named Seth and Horus. “Geb made Horus King of Lower [northern] Egypt.” Horus later wins out and becomes god of Upper and Lower Egypt, but he had already been known as “King of the north.”

The Uraeus, or cobra, was the symbol of northern Egypt. Pharaohs that ruled both northern and southern Egypt wore both the vulture and the cobra on their headdress to show they were the rulers of the two lands, as found on King Tutankhamun’s grave mask. But the Sphinx does not have the emblem of the south (vulture) on it, however it does have engraved on its upper forehead the Uraeus or cobra, and it is made from the stone of the Sphinx itself. The head of the cobra, though defaced, is still seen on the forehead of the Sphinx. A two foot limestone piece of the Sphinx’s cobra was broken off, just as the nose of the Sphinx was, but it has been found and it is now in the British Museum #1204. Being that the Sphinx only had the cobra (Uraeus), as a permanent part of it, and therefore a symbol of northern Egypt, it was a clear sign to all that the Great Sphinx was “Lord of the north”, and to the Hebrews, this was Baal-zephon!
 
Last edited:
Are there any other sources for all but one of the Egyptian idols being destroyed? It sounds like a significant event.
 
I only know of these two (The Legends of the Jews, III Pharaoh Pursues the Hebrews, also Targum Pseudo-Jonathan, Exodus 14), and it is possible that Legends of the Jews copied form the Targum.
 
I only know of these two sources and Legends of the Jews may have copied form the Targum.
 
These are the only two i know of, and it is possible that Legends of the Jews copied this from the Targum.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom