Purging voter registration roles as a way to cheat in an election

Both sides do crappy things all the time. In the 2004 election, my wife participated as a polling station watcher, whose job was to wait for people coming out who had been challenged (and stopped) from voting by a Republican inside, then she was to call one of 200 "roving lawyers" who would zip over.

The goal was to build up evidence to start screaming, "fraud!" When it became apparent that the Democrats were going to sweep the state, the leaders of the movement announced they found the election fair, and told everyone to go home. This is disingenuous in the extreme because the real setup was to come up with things to scream about rather than actually watch anything.
 
To be honest, I've never understood why the need in the USA to register as a voter for party X.
You don't.

This is true. You only need to register for a particular party if you want to participate in that party's primary process, where they select someone to nominate for various positions in the general election. For the general election, you don't.

And in many states, you don't even need to do that, as they have "open" primaries where anyone can vote in any particular party's primary vote. Many states that do this have reconsidered it in recent years, however, given opposing parties have made significant efforts to deliberately target the other party's primaries to try to force them to select as their candidate someone who is more likely to lose the general election than who is likely to win that primary.
 
I get the impression of trying to fix the current problems rather than eliminate them.

What would be the issues, if any, in having a non-partisan central federal registry of qualified voters? Such a registry would be used at government election times (at polling booths?) to ensure that a person was indeed a citizen qualified to vote, and was a resident of that state or county if such was relevant.

Whereas for party elections, why not have the party management keep their own registries of "paid-up party members" to qualify those doing candidate elections. This would eliminate non-party voters attempting to influence candidatures and their selection.

Wouldn't such measures eliminate caging and other nefarious election rigging tactics?
 
I get the impression of trying to fix the current problems rather than eliminate them.

What would be the issues, if any, in having a non-partisan central federal registry of qualified voters? Such a registry would be used at government election times (at polling booths?) to ensure that a person was indeed a citizen qualified to vote, and was a resident of that state or county if such was relevant.
You have already been told the answer to that, which is in the Constitution.
Wouldn't such measures eliminate caging and other nefarious election rigging tactics?
No. Another loophole would be found, and gerrymandering is a long and distinguished practice in American political circles.

So also is getting the dead to vote for you: Lyndon Johnson for fifty, Alex. :p

DR
 
You have already been told the answer to that, which is in the Constitution.
No, that was the actual scope of powers and conducting of elections. My special subject today, Alex, is the qualifying of voters.

No. Another loophole would be found, and gerrymandering is a long and distinguished practice in American political circles.

So also is getting the dead to vote for you: Lyndon Johnson for fifty, Alex. :p

DR
Of course loopholes will be found. I'm asking why my suggestion would be any worse than the current system with clear and major problems.

And I'm well aware that LBJ got himself into Congress via a handful of bogus votes, thanks.
 
Both sides do crappy things all the time. In the 2004 election, my wife participated as a polling station watcher, whose job was to wait for people coming out who had been challenged (and stopped) from voting by a Republican inside, then she was to call one of 200 "roving lawyers" who would zip over.

The goal was to build up evidence to start screaming, "fraud!" When it became apparent that the Democrats were going to sweep the state, the leaders of the movement announced they found the election fair, and told everyone to go home. This is disingenuous in the extreme because the real setup was to come up with things to scream about rather than actually watch anything.


Your anecdote demonstrates that you understand perfectly the cynical game played by the Dems.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom