Purging voter registration roles as a way to cheat in an election

Caging is illegal when it clearly targets only voters likely to vote for one party or candidate. If you sent letters to the entire state to clean up out dated voter registration roles, it wouldn't be illegal

I don't believe that. Show me the law
 
Pomer, you are just sticking your foot further and further in your mouth. If you would care to explain why Wildcat got that letter and his girlfriend didn't we are all anxious to hear. If you are aware of Cook County, Illinois' election board updating voter registration roles independent of any Republican challenges, that would support your case. If Cook County had a majority Republican voter history that would support your case. If you were familiar with the specific Illinois State law which describes who and how a voter's registration might be challenged and it did not allow anyone but election officials to challenge registrations, that would help your case.

As it turns out, political parties can purchase the voter registration data base in Illinois. I sent a PM to Wildcat asking

That is one possibility. I don't know at this point why he got that letter. And from what you've posted, neither do you. I hope he looks into it and lets us know. In the meantime, the issues I posted about in this thread are not dependent upon Wildcat's letter being among one of the caging schemes. The schemes are well documented as noted in the very thorough document I linked to in the OP.


I'm the one with a foot in his mouth? Now, that's funny! You swallow the liar Greg Palast's recycled claptrap hook, line, and sinker and then you tell me I don't understand what's going on?

Here's what's going on: the Dems are trying to cheat--again. They are, as always, pretending that attempts to clean up voting rolls are racist efforts to disenfranchise minority voters. Nobody ever actually produces any voters who have been disenfranchised in this manner, but, hey, why spoil a good scam?

WildCat, if he's interested, can call his local election board and ask why he recieved a notice. It's not difficult.

Remember: You register; you vote. Anyone who claims the process is more complicated than that is up to no good.
 
You send out letters to people in the districts which are likely to vote against your party or candidate. The letters require people to prove they are the person registered to vote on the voter registration roles. Anyone who doesn't reply, you then take the returned mail to the voter registration office and protest that registered voter's legality. The voter is then removed from the voter registration role and they don't find out about it until they go to vote and cannot.


Variations on this depend on state laws regarding challenging the legality of a voter.

In FL in 2000, letters sent out had the fact you had to reply buried in fine print.

In the more recent Tim Griffin scandal, the letters went out to an area where lots of black military personnel lived who were in Iraq. The letters could not be signed for by anyone but the recipient and could not be forwarded. Those soldiers identified in the Excel list of names and addresses (which Greg Palast of the BBC news obtained and the Republican Party admitted was their list and which Monica Goodling testified to its use in a caging scheme under oath in the Attorney General Gonzales hearings over the suspiciously fired federal attorneys, one of whom was replaced by Tim Griffin who subsequently resigned since the caging scheme was illegal) which might favor Democratic candidates were sent letters the Republican Party knew the soldiers could not reply to since they were in Iraq. Did you follow that?

Caging is illegal when it clearly targets only voters likely to vote for one party or candidate. If you sent letters to the entire state to clean up out dated voter registration roles, it wouldn't be illegal.

Thanks for that.

There's a very simple solution: Voter registration should be completely independent of any party affiliations whatsoever. Why not just have a partisanship-free national register of people who have proven their qualifications to vote and who have actually bother to enroll. And on any polling day, the list can be consulted when you appear to vote, and your name ticked off by some means as having voted.

Then caging and any related voting misdemeanors simply cannot happen.

To be honest, I've never understood why the need in the USA to register as a voter for party X. To me, that sounds like you have to at least give notice of your voting intentions just to get in the polling booth! I would have thought that would have been anathema!
 
There's a very simple solution: Voter registration should be completely independent of any party affiliations whatsoever.
It is.
Why not just have a partisanship-free national register of people who have proven their qualifications to vote and who have actually bother to enroll.
The individual states conduct elections, not the Federal government. Your solution would require a Constitutiona; Amendment, not likely to happen.
To be honest, I've never understood why the need in the USA to register as a voter for party X.
You only need to register as "party x" if you're voting in that party's primary election - not the general election. Many states (mine included) don't even do that, you just ask for party x's ballot at the polling place.
 
OK.

The individual states conduct elections, not the Federal government. Your solution would require a Constitutional Amendment, not likely to happen.
The federal government doesn't conduct federal elections?? OK... :confused:

You only need to register as "party x" if you're voting in that party's primary election - not the general election. Many states (mine included) don't even do that, you just ask for party x's ballot at the polling place.
I have to say that I don't understand what you have said at all. Remember, I'm not from around here, so let's just step through the definitions and my best guesses:

1) "party's primary election" = Selecting candidates for a party?

2) "general election" = Federal election? And does that include state elections?

3) "party x's ballot" = How-to-vote guide?? Or perhaps a proforma ballot?

See why I'm confused?
 
OK.

The federal government doesn't conduct federal elections?? OK... :confused:

In reality there are no Federal elections. All elections are controlled and run by individual state laws.

Article 1 section 4

The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Place of Chusing Senators.

Heres my favorite...

Article 2 section 1

Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress: but no Senator or Representative, or Person holding an Office of Trust or Profit under the United States, shall be appointed an Elector.


Meaning, the only reason that there are elections for president is because the individual states decided that is how they would decide electoral college votes. They could go back to having the state legislature decide who gets what electoral college votes or they could even flip a coin for it if they wanted to.
 
You send out letters to people in the districts which are likely to vote against your party or candidate.

Who sends out letters? Anybody? A political party? A local elections board? And are there no rules requiring everyone in a particular district or several districts of a city to be sent letters, not just a hand-chosen subset*?

And at my polling place, they allow you to swear ("or affirm") that you are, in fact, eligible for voting, anyway, so doesn't that trump being taken off?



* Of course, even if entire districts or whole cities/counties were required to be 100% sent such mails, given the larger picture is about swaying Congressional or presidential elections, hand-chosen counties to send letters would have the desired effect, yet fall within this rule, if'n it even is a rule.
 
Thanks for that.

There's a very simple solution: Voter registration should be completely independent of any party affiliations whatsoever. Why not just have a partisanship-free national register of people who have proven their qualifications to vote and who have actually bother to enroll. And on any polling day, the list can be consulted when you appear to vote, and your name ticked off by some means as having voted.

Then caging and any related voting misdemeanors simply cannot happen.

To be honest, I've never understood why the need in the USA to register as a voter for party X. To me, that sounds like you have to at least give notice of your voting intentions just to get in the polling booth! I would have thought that would have been anathema!
You don't register by party in WA State. And you only need to disclose your party if you want to vote for party candidates in the primaries.

I suspect other states are the same.

You don't send out caging letters by party. You send them out by other identifiers such as living in a county which votes heavily in one predictable direction. One could collect party affiliation from other records and match them to voter registration rolls.
 
Let me ask one question here: If a letter is sent to a voter at an address and it is returned by the post office as "Return to Sender: Address Unknown" or "Not known at this address" should they remain on the voter registration rolls? Is it the targeted nature that skeptigirl and others object to, or is it purging the rolls of voters who have moved?
 
Who sends out letters? Anybody? A political party? A local elections board? And are there no rules requiring everyone in a particular district or several districts of a city to be sent letters, not just a hand-chosen subset*?
The Republican Party sent out the letters in FL then challenged voter registrations based on returned letters.

In WA State, the Republicans challenged King County absentee ballots by looking at the signatures and matching them to the voter registration signature.

And at my polling place, they allow you to swear ("or affirm") that you are, in fact, eligible for voting, anyway, so doesn't that trump being taken off?
You mean without registering to vote at all? And if you are not registered are you talking about a provisional ballot? Those are held until it is confirmed you were a legal voter.

* Of course, even if entire districts or whole cities/counties were required to be 100% sent such mails, given the larger picture is about swaying Congressional or presidential elections, hand-chosen counties to send letters would have the desired effect, yet fall within this rule, if'n it even is a rule.
In an election for President and/or Senator, you would need to send letters to everyone in the state. If it was only a year for a Congressional seat you would need to send the letters to whole districts to be legal.
 
Let me ask one question here: If a letter is sent to a voter at an address and it is returned by the post office as "Return to Sender: Address Unknown" or "Not known at this address" should they remain on the voter registration rolls? Is it the targeted nature that skeptigirl and others object to, or is it purging the rolls of voters who have moved?
There is no issue updating voter registration rolls as long as one doesn't only update selected voters with the intent of eliminating legal voters in the process.

Some of the letters were deceitful, for example. In FL in 2000, one of the letters sent to thousands of people had the part about, "you must return this", hidden at the end of a long letter and it looked like junk mail. In the Griffin caging incident, a number of the targeted voters were military and known to be in Iraq. No one else could sign for the recipient.
 
Last edited:
For those of you who skipped the link which described everything this thread is about, here's another link from wiki, Caging listWP. I know the OP link was a long document but board rules prohibit me from posting much more than a paragraph. I urge you all to just open the link and skim the report for the key points yourselves. From the posts here, this information is new to many of you. Yet it literally is being used to affect election outcomes.

For the legal actions see "Caging litigation" page 26. A number of cases and the legal grounds are described in detail including:
2004 New Jersey Caging Case
In response to Republican caging operations in Ohio in the weeks before the 2004 presidential election, Ebony Malone, an Ohio African American voter, and Irving Agosto, an Ohio Hispanic voter, filed a motion to intervene in the New Jersey District Court case of DNC v. RNC . The Ohio voters charged that the RN C had violated the court’s 1987 consent decree. The factual grounds for the complaint were that the Ohio Republican Party had mailed out non-forwardable letters to all newly registered voters, then compiled a caging list from the returned letters. The state GOP proposed to use caging list to challenge the eligibility of all 35,000 voters. The intervenors charged, and provided evidence that, the RN C coordinated and assisted in the Ohio caging operation....
and
2004 Ohio Litigation
There are two prongs in the litigation against the Ohio Republican Party’s 2004 caging operation. The Southern prong was a decision by the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, enjoining the GOP caging operation,101 and the Northern prong was a similar decision by the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio.102....
There are many more cases described.
 
I don't believe that. Show me the law
Why would you think it was legal to remove legal voters from voter registration rolls? If anything it is a civil violation. Each case is based on state law so pick a state and I'll look up the rules for you. In the meantime, the link in the OP to the report on caging lists a number of cases and how courts ruled and why. This one on page 30 mentions Constitutional issues in the court's ruling. You can't get much more against the law than being unconstitutional.

Spencer v. Blackwell, S.D. Ohio
On October 27, 2004, two Ohio registered voters filed a complaint against Secretary of State J. Kenneth Blackwell, other state officials, and the Chairman of the Hamilton County Republican Party.103 The complaint, based upon 42 U.S.C § 1983, alleged that defendants, “acting under color of state law,” violated rights secured to the plaintiffs by the First and Fourteenth Amendments, including, inter alia, the right to vote, the right to due process, and the right to equal protection under the law. The Ohio Republican Party and the RN C had revealed the direct mail caging operation, or ballot security plan, at a press conference a few days earlier. The plaintiffs in the action were an African American couple who were registered voters living in a pre-dominantly African American Cincinnati precinct...

...[snip]...

...Based on this reasoning the judge found that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on the merits, “on the ground that the application of Ohio’s statute allowing challengers at polling places is unconstitutional” and that the plaintiffs would suffer irreparable harm if the mass challenges were to take place....
 
I'm the one with a foot in his mouth? Now, that's funny! You swallow the liar Greg Palast's recycled claptrap hook, line, and sinker and then you tell me I don't understand what's going on?

Here's what's going on: the Dems are trying to cheat--again. They are, as always, pretending that attempts to clean up voting rolls are racist efforts to disenfranchise minority voters. Nobody ever actually produces any voters who have been disenfranchised in this manner, but, hey, why spoil a good scam?

WildCat, if he's interested, can call his local election board and ask why he recieved a notice. It's not difficult.

Remember: You register; you vote. Anyone who claims the process is more complicated than that is up to no good.
For anyone wondering what this side discussion is all about, see the other thread in the CT forum linked in the OP.

In short, Fund is a right wing character who wrote a book about voter fraud. All of the examples Pomer brought up from the book were discredited by sources which I and others cited in the thread. Pomer ignores that fact and just keeps repeating we haven't bothered to read the book.

Bring up more examples, pomer. I'll be happy to take them on. But so far, you've brought up a number of examples from Fund's book and not a single one has been credible. That just isn't a book review which screams, "buy me and read me". I ask only that you please keep that discussion in the other thread unless the examples relate to caging activities, thank you.

Greg Palast is a left wing reporter known to exaggerate who claimed to have received over 500 emails from Republican leaders sent to other party members but which were misaddressed to GeorgeWBush.org instead of GeorgeWBush.com and went to a web site set up as a GWB parody site.

Caging listWP
The list [Excel address file] came to light because of numerous e-mails accidentally addressed by, among others, Republican campaigners to the georgewbush.org anti-Bush site instead of the georgewbush.com Bush campaign site. Two of these e-mails had the subject line "Re: Caging" and contained Microsoft Excel spreadsheet file attachments called "Caging.xls" and "Caging-1.xls".[14][15].

Investigative reporter Greg Palast initially received the emails from the owner of georgewbush.org, and in a recent interview has drawn a link to the scandal surrounding the Alberto Gonzales U.S. Attorney firings, claiming that the firings are part of a wider effort by Republicans to use caging to "steal the 2008 election."[16]
While none of us in the thread relied on Palast's claim of 500 emails, at least a few of the misaddressed emails and the Excel caging address list mentioned here have been documented. The RNC admitted the list was theirs while trying to cover it up by claiming it was a simple list of voters targeted for campaign material. Of course, the RNC couldn't explain why the list was mostly of Democrats and not people they had actually sent any campaign material to.
 
Yes, if the letters were deceitful. In FL in 2000, one of the letters sent to thousands of people had the part about, "you must return this", hidden at the end of a long letter and it looked like junk mail. In the Griffin caging incident, a number of the targeted voters were military and known to be in Iraq. No one else could sign for the recipient.

I'm slogging through the Project Vote PDF right now and not seeing any mention of the "you must return this" anywhere in the document. Indeed, the only occurrences of "2000" in the document were the Project Vote Zip Code (20003), and a quote by a Republican that "We learned our lesson in 2000 that you've got to be prepared."

Are you conflating caging with the Florida purge of the voter rolls that was required by the Florida government after the Miami mayoral election fiasco?
 
No, but I gotta do something else right now. I'll find you the link on the misleading you must return this letter incident in a bit. On page 29 of the Caging report there are some very specific descriptions of some of the caging actions which have been tried in the past.
 
You know, for all their talk, the only party that ever challenged my voter registration was

(... wait for it ...)

the Democrats.

The notice I received in the mail literally stated that the local Democratic party machine "challenged my voter registration."

But it's O.K. Since I'm a white male, I understand the "count every vote" thing doesn't really apply to me.
 
Last edited:
No, but I gotta do something else right now. I'll find you the link on the misleading you must return this letter incident in a bit. On page 29 of the Caging report there are some very specific descriptions of some of the caging actions which have been tried in the past.

So in a document that purports to be a 50-year history of caging in America, they somehow left out this particular incident, which occurred in the most controversial election of our lifetimes?

:rolleyes:
 
Thanks for that.



To be honest, I've never understood why the need in the USA to register as a voter for party X.
You don't.

I have registered to vote, and re registered, numerous times since 1978. I have never had to, nor have I ever, registered as a member of any party. My choice to remain independent has never once had an impact on my registration, nor on my ability to cast my ballot.

What are you talking about?

DR
 
You know, for all their talk, the only party that ever challenged my voter registration was

(... wait for it ...)

the Democrats.

The notice I received in the mail literally stated that the local Democratic party machine "challenged my voter registration."

But it's O.K. Since I'm a white male, I understand the "count every vote" thing doesn't really apply to me.
If you were a convicted felon, the Dems would have your back. So, go kill someone, and get your voting rights protected by the party who cares. Then, speak in Spanish when you go to register, and watch in amusement as the Republicans fall all over themselves to help you fill out the forms.

Then, vote Green. :) Just to piss them off.

Nader in 2008: why the hell not?

DR
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom