Nevertheless a fireman needs to show aptitude and complete training before embarking on the career. Are you implying that all academics would automatically be able to do this? Why are you implying that an academic skill-set necessarily leads to higher ethical standards than a practical one? Are you saying that people with degrees are better than people without degrees?
Why are you building a strawman?
I never claimed academics could automatically trump the blue collar worker in anything he turned his hand to, I never said anything of that nature. What I did say is that I believe blue collar workers are more likely to or are quicker to betray than white collar and the reasons I think that are that the white collar will have more understanding of the principles of such action, have invested more time into his career than one who has 'walked into' his job, and is rewarded more handsomely.
Please back up assertions with evidence
Especially, please provide evidence that blue-collar workers are worse at keeping secrets than white collar ones.
Some examples of academically qualified people who have not kept secrets:
>links removed as I cannot post them<
also, the idea the politicians are good at keeping secrets is laughable.
Well, I see lots of instances where as an example, disgruntled call centre employees deride and betray their employers on forums. I don't see middle management doing this type of thing too often. I could round them up and see if I can get more links than you, though I really don't see that would aide this discussion or benefit the topic at all. To be honest it seems like silly nonsense for you to demand evidence of
my opinion when the reasons given for my thinking are not being disputed, only my conclusion.
With regard to politicians, if I extend that and say that if you find their idea of them keeping secrets amusing, then would you say that they are honest all the time? Of course not - so what went wrong with that logical extension? Well, for a start I should point out that trying to keep a secret and slipping up is not the same thing as deciding to reveal one.
Moving back on topic, if you had to guess, which one of two groups would be most likely to leak information about their organization that could endanger that organization to the media first, out of a group of lawyers and another of cleaners, which would you bet on?