Psychic Detectives on Television

I'm glad the Judicial System keeps a level head (contrary to popular belief :D). I am certain forever, no man is ever convicted of a crime because a lawyer brings in their witness, Psychic Steve, who says he saw the guy commit the crime with aid of tarot cards and remote viewing.
 
Of course none was ever convicted because of "Psychic Steve" but people have not been convicted because of doubts that "psychic Steve" has created to the Jury.
 
I saw TR night's show

and it was a sad, sad night for journalism.... f*cking pathetic actually. Even JE was there to support it... I have to wonder if he knew the context he would be portrayed in.... the show made it appear that JE was endorsing fuc*ing idiots.
 
Cleopatra said:
Of course none was ever convicted because of "Psychic Steve" but people have not been convicted because of doubts that "psychic Steve" has created to the Jury.

Really? Psychics giving persuasive evidence in court? Can you provide some examples for us?
 
Cleopatra said:
Of course none was ever convicted because of "Psychic Steve" but people have not been convicted because of doubts that "psychic Steve" has created to the Jury.
As far as people who have not been convicted, I'm reminded of this quote:

"That it is better 100 guilty persons should escape than that one innocent person should suffer, is a maxim that has been long and generally approved."
- Benjamin Franklin

And this one:

"It is better that ten guilty escape than one innocent suffer."
- Sir William Blackstone

In actuality, I was trying to figure out a way I could phrase "I deliberately neglected to mention people who have not been convicted" in my last post but I couldnt make it fit concisely with the rest of the post. Oh, and I deliberately chose Psychic Steve because I think he has an interestingly designed website.
 
RonSceptic said:


Really? Psychics giving persuasive evidence in court? Can you provide some examples for us?

Where did I say that psychics give persuasive evidence to courts?I am suggesting exactly the contrary. They can create doubts to Juries and it's not uncommon that someone is dismissed just because the Jury doubts that he is guilty. Sometimes we manage to show that a psychic is not in the position to show anything but one vote in the jury can be enough to change the outcome of a trial.
 
Yahweh said:

As far as people who have not been convicted, I'm reminded of this quote:


None can disagree with that Yahweh but I cannot accept doubts that are built on testimonies of people that when they do not want to mislead the jury on purpose they fantasize things. Can you base a decision or your doubts on a testimony of a psychic? This is what I am arguing.
 
Cleopatra said:


Where did I say that psychics give persuasive evidence to courts?I am suggesting exactly the contrary. They can create doubts to Juries and it's not uncommon that someone is dismissed just because the Jury doubts that he is guilty. Sometimes we manage to show that a psychic is not in the position to show anything but one vote in the jury can be enough to change the outcome of a trial.

You said "people have not been convicted because of doubts that "psychic Steve" has created to the Jury."

Do you have any evidence for this statement or is it simply an unsupported opinion?

For a psychic to have any influnce on a jury his evidence must have been presented to them in court. I'd be interested to see if any psychic ever gets past the courtroom door. I shudder to think what a good attourney would do to a psychic in the dock. Would be fun to watch though.
 
Unsupported opinion?

This is my job! I practice criminal Law in Greece and I have seen many psychics testifying. According to Greek legislation in murder cases any testimony that can shed light to a case is acceptable.

I hope that you don't believe that members of jury put aside their prejudices and judge only based on evidences or they ignore a testimony that is not based on evidence. I wish it was like that but it's not.

Most of the times it's not difficult to prove that the psychic is not in the position to know anything about the case but "that little lady in blue" ( sorry for the stereotype) that happens to be a member of the jury can make a difference with her vote if she believes in such things.

That's why after every trial that psychics have testified we sue them for purjury.

Also, in case you missed it in other threads that I have mentioned it. Mediums in Greece are recognized as professionals. They have licence to excercise their profession and they pay taxes.
 
Cleopatra said:
Unsupported opinion?

This is my job! I practice criminal Law in Greece and I have seen many psychics testifying. According to Greek legislation in murder cases any testimony that can shed light to a case is acceptable.

I hope that you don't believe that members of jury put aside their prejudices and judge only based on evidences or they ignore a testimony that is not based on evidence. I wish it was like that but it's not.

Most of the times it's not difficult to prove that the psychic is not in the position to know anything about the case but "that little lady in blue" ( sorry for the stereotype) that happens to be a member of the jury can make a difference with her vote if she believes in such things.

That's why after every trial that psychics have testified we sue them for purjury.

Also, in case you missed it in other threads that I have mentioned it. Mediums in Greece are recognized as professionals. They have licence to excercise their profession and they pay taxes.

Wow! I didn't know that. I am really amazed that these people are allowed to give evidence in court. I don't think that happens here in the UK. I imagine they must be given a pretty hard time by the defence counsel.

I am very pleased to hear that these creeps get sued afterwards. Have there been any succesful conviction for perjury?

And I hope my last post did not cause offence. I didn't realise what your background was.
 
No no Ron it's ok!! You are not obliged to know and I should have clarified this from start but you mentioned that other thread that I have participated in as well and I took for granted that you knew:)

Anyway.

So far we have managed to take out of business 6 of them out of 134 lawsuits.

I KNOW this doesn't seem impressive but have in mind that since our association has started this practice-- to sue psychics-- they are less willing to come and testify in murder cases because they know that regardless of the outcome of the trial we will put them in trouble.

I know that it sounds vindictive but believe me that those people cause a lot of harm and many problems. They destroy the trust between us and our clients and they waste the time of the Police.

I have mentioned before that when I started practicing Law I used to laugh at those things and I didn't give them much credit. I used to say : " Psychics! Ha! Who believes in those things, certainly juries will ignore them" . I was like that until I lost a case because I wasn't well prepared to confront a psychic in court and I am not the only one that has had such an experience.

Now in our association we try to find if there is any connection between cases psychics "offer" to help ( that's why I asked in a previous post) . Interestingly we have found that in 4/10 cases of murder that the relatives of the victims have pushed the Police to accept the help of a psychic turned out that the murderer was a member of the family...I find it extremely interesting.
 
Cleopatra said:

So far we have managed to take out of business 6 of them out of 134 lawsuits.

I KNOW this doesn't seem impressive but have in mind that since our association has started this practice-- to sue psychics-- they are less willing to come and testify in murder cases because they know that regardless of the outcome of the trial we will put them in trouble.

Well done ! :roll:

I wish the crooks that prey on bereaved families and waste precious police ressources in France and Switzerland (missing children cases, principally) would be sued and convicted too. I expect only 1 successful case would be enough to make quite a number of them reconsider their involvement in judicial matters ..
 
Cleopatra said:
This is my job! I practice criminal Law in Greece and I have seen many psychics testifying. According to Greek legislation in murder cases any testimony that can shed light to a case is acceptable.
From what I know of American Law, we dont see psychics as a witness, they cannot and will not testify in court with "I saw them in a dream" or any of the crap they like to smear. First, obviously, because they can falsely influence a jury (hey, people really believe JE is talking to their dead grandma, people might actually fall for an "expert psychic"). Second because its a waste of time for the Judicial system to handle Purjury charges from psychics bearing false witness. Quick question, how do these psychics try to defend themselves against these purjury charges? (Of course, if they had any real powers they'd just win the JREF challenge, play the lottery, find missing persons, predict disastors, etc.... but theyre not so either they aren't psychics or they are disgusting selfish individuals...)

Other non-admissable forms of evidence in American Law include: Polygraph tests, claiming God spoke to you, staring contest, throwing darts at a dartboard, tarot cards, arm wrestling match, monkeys on a typewriter etc. etc. etc.
 
Flo said:


Well done ! :roll:

I wish the crooks that prey on bereaved families and waste precious police ressources in France and Switzerland (missing children cases, principally) would be sued and convicted too. I expect only 1 successful case would be enough to make quite a number of them reconsider their involvement in judicial matters ..

The reason that it's possible to do it here is because they are professionals and they have licences, so they cannot really suggest that they didn't know that they couldn't provide evidence... BUT people are strange. There are people that think that " the reason lawyers are after psychics is because they are afraid that they will lose their clientele..." Right!

Some others go as far as accussing us for witch hunting and this makes me really mad.
 
Problem is, those "misstatements" you keep claiming exist....don't. You can repeat that they do, again and again, but that doesn't make you right.

:D They don't? Than what is this CFLarsen?

Posted by CFLarsen - We have two believers, who merely register what happens - and then sit back, going "Ooh!" and "Ahh!".

This is a misrepresentation of what Clancie and Neo did. Show me where these two in any way, shape, or form presented anything on this thread that resembled and OHH or AHH reaction.

You like to present these believers as gullible dishonest idiots, something that they are not. You try to misrepresent who they are on a continual basis. Wonder what you fear from them that causes you to find this necessary? How insecure do you have to be to go that far?

CFLarsen, I will be to you what you are to Clancie and the other believers, only I will be honest about it! ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom