Psychic Detectives on Television

Clancie

Illuminator
Joined
May 19, 2002
Messages
3,021
Thursday through Sunday

COURT TV: Psychic Detectives
60 min.
"The role psychics play in solving crimes is illustrated by focusing on four cases in which seers have provided important information to the police. One spotlighted case involves a missing Penn State student; psychic Carla Baron is helping with the investigation.

The other cases are a 1980 murder; a 1999 double homicide; and the abduction-murder of an 8-year-old girl. All three found the police turning to psychic Kay Rhea for help.

Lending insight into the police-psychic process: John Edward; and parapsychologist Stephen Schwartz.
 
Hi, Clancie. Well, this is a subject that always generates a lot of interest. I'll be away when most of these shows air, but I think I'll program my VCR.

I see I missed JE on Court TV with Catherine Crier today at 5:00 pm. Perhaps you can still catch it, Clancie and RC.

And Thursday in the wee hours of the morning here, (1:35 am) on LAST CALL with Carson Daly. I actually got an e-mail invitation to call for tickets, but I couldn't get there. Instig8R said she couldn't make it either, but I forwarded the e-mail to Jeff Cory and he called and was waiting for a call back. I hope he gets on. I'd love for him to get a great reading, wouldn't you? ;)

Thanks for the info, Clancie. :) .....neo
 
Yeah, yeah...Stephan Schwartz is quite famous in woowoo-circles:

Solely directed by remote viewing, Schwartz led many research expeditions to locate many spectacular finds: Mark Antony's palace in Alexandria, the Ptolemaic Palace Complex of Cleopatra, and the remains of the Lighthouse of Pharos, one of the seven wonders of the ancient world.
The Field

Let's take a closer look at just one of these claims, shall we?

The Lighthouse of Pharos
In 1994, an Egyptian film-maker noticed hieroglyphic-covered shapes in the sea near Fort Qaitbey. It seemed that, thanks to earthquakes, tidal waves and erosion, the shoreline of Alexandria had been pushed back by up to 100 yards. Much of the ancient city lay beneath the waves.

Soon, archeologists from France were raising boatloads of artefacts from the splendid, though prodigiously polluted, Eastern Harbour. The site off Fort Qaitbey turned out to contain the ruins of the Pharos, along with hundreds of marble columns and fragments of giant statues made of pink Aswan granite. The most famous image of Alexandria was now a marine archeologist face to face with an underwater sphinx — Indiana Jones with a waterproof note pad.
Source: TimesOnline

Schwartz did not "locate" the Lighthouse of Pharos. I haven't looked into the other two claims (it's early morning here), but I don't need to be a Remote Viewer to know what I will "locate".

Read Schwartz' own account:

Archeology & R.V. Eastern Harbour, Alexandria, Egypt
A PRELIMINARY SURVEY OF THE EASTERN HARBOR,ALEXANDRIA, EGYPT INCLUDING A COMPARISON OF SIDE SCAN SONAR AND REMOTE VIEWING
Stephan A. Schwartz - The Mobius Group
Link


Some "expert"....:rolleyes:
 
Interesting they don't give details in the blurb.

A quick internet search about the Penn State student and Carla Baron indicates:

-The student is Cindy Song who went missing in November 2001.

-The Paranormal Research Society at Penn State contacted Carla Baron to help the police; Baron began phone conversations in, I think, May 2002.

-The founder and director of PRS (Ryan Buell) is quoted as saying "Our job is to - naturally - document the investigation concerning Carla's involvement."

-The last online reference to the actual investigation is dated August 2002. The detective (Brian Sprinkle, Ferguson Township) is apparently an ardent believer in psychics. But the best he can say is (paraphrased as I forgot to copy it and don't want to search again): "Carla Baron has given us a lot of information; unfortunately, it hasn't helped us further the case. It will probably take months and maybe years."

-As of right now, the case is STILL unsolved, 15 months after Baron began "helping." Very impressive addition to the psychic resume, eh?

There are more indicators about the BS this psychic is foisting on the police, if you dig just a little.

I have e-mailed the PRS requesting a copy of their documentation. We will see if they respond.

-----

About Kay Rhea and the other cases, far less information is available. I have e-mailed the Fresno PD for information.

What is available is intriguing. First, Rhea allegedly worked with a Detective Tim McFadden, and has done so for many years.

Second, no Tim McFadden shows up in any searches I could work in relation to Fresno.

Third, a Mark McFadden on the Fresno PD did show up.

---

twill be interesting to see if I get responses.

These things, like so many others, tend to crumble when scrutinized.
 
Garrette said:
Interesting they don't give details in the blurb.

As one would expect... :)

Garrette said:
These things, like so many others, tend to crumble when scrutinized.

These things, like so many others, tend to not be scrutinized by believers. As one would expect... :)

Seriously, what we've seen here pretty much defines the difference between skeptical thinking and believer-thinking. We have two believers, who merely register what happens - and then sit back, going "Ooh!" and "Ahh!".

Then, we have two skeptics, who begin investigating immediately, coming up with some hard data.

Fascinating difference, isn't it?
 
Posted by CFLarsen - Seriously, what we've seen here pretty much defines the difference between skeptical thinking and believer-thinking. We have two believers, who merely register what happens - and then sit back, going "Ooh!" and "Ahh!".


Perhaps you could spare us your personal insults and instead try focusing on the issues.

I read the two believers posts, and nothing in them indicated to me that they were in "Ooh, or Ahh. I find your statement misleading and insulting toward believers - and that kind of thing gives other skeptics, such as myself, a bad image.
 
Leroy said:
I find your statement misleading and insulting toward believers
It's insulting, true. But it's not misleading.

Have you ever considered that skeptics like you give the rest of us a bad name? It's long past time we indulged these people, with their cries of open-mindedness which always turn out to be smoke-screens until they can retreat and find someone more guillible.
 
Posted by CFLarsen - Seriously, what we've seen here pretty much defines the difference between skeptical thinking and believer-thinking. We have two believers, who merely register what happens - and then sit back, going "Ooh!" and "Ahh!".

Originally posted by Leroy - I find your statement misleading and insulting toward believers

Posted by Yahzi - It's insulting, true. But it's not misleading.

It's misleading, Nowhere in the post from the two believers, do they Ohh, or Ahh over the topic, therefore, CFLarsens post is misleading.

Have you ever considered that skeptics like you give the rest of us a bad name?

If you mean the rest of you as in skeptics like CFLarsen, and BillHoyt, and Thai, than I certainly hope so.

It's long past time we indulged these people, with their cries of open-mindedness which always turn out to be smoke-screens until they can retreat and find someone more guillible.

[ALWAYS]? [THESE PEOPLE]? I have met many a believer who cried open minded but were not, just as I have met many a skeptic who cried open minded who were not.

I have met just a many believers who were open minded, some who even changed their mind about their beliefs after many discussions with me. I have many skeptics who were sincerely open minded.

Unlike you I don't label all believers as being alike. I have no prejudices against believers, can you say the same?
 
You're welcome, Dingler 44.

(I'm glad to see that at least you and Leroy understood the point of this thread).
 
Leroy said:



Perhaps you could spare us your personal insults and instead try focusing on the issues.

I read the two believers posts, and nothing in them indicated to me that they were in "Ooh, or Ahh. I find your statement misleading and insulting toward believers - and that kind of thing gives other skeptics, such as myself, a bad image.

Thank you, Leroy! I really do appreciate your walking around after Claus and cleaning up his inaccuracies. That saves Clancie and I the trouble of doing it ourselves. ;) ......neo
 
Yahzi said:

It's insulting, true. But it's not misleading.

Have you ever considered that skeptics like you give the rest of us a bad name? It's long past time we indulged these people, with their cries of open-mindedness which always turn out to be smoke-screens until they can retreat and find someone more guillible.

Yahzi, you, Claus and other "skeptics" like you, have only yourselves to blame for any bad name that you may have. For you to get on Leroy's case for correcting a misstatement made by Claus, is neither very skeptical of you, nor very admirable. :rolleyes: ......neo
 
neofight said:
Yahzi, you, Claus and other "skeptics" like you, have only yourselves to blame for any bad name that you may have. For you to get on Leroy's case for correcting a misstatement made by Claus, is neither very skeptical of you, nor very admirable. :rolleyes: ......neo

Problem is, those "misstatements" you keep claiming exist....don't. You can repeat that they do, again and again, but that doesn't make you right.
 
Can anybody point to me a site about the "psychic detectives" ?

psychic + detective is a fallacious expression of course but anyway.

I searched some sources of Interpol and I didn't come up with anything regarding those cases.

Do we have any statistics? How many cases those detectives have help to be solved.

I am interested in seeing what the cases that those detectives have provided evidence for have in common.
 
Cleopatra said:
Can anybody point to me a site about the "psychic detectives" ?

psychic + detective is a fallacious expression of course but anyway.

I searched some sources of Interpol and I didn't come up with anything regarding those cases.

Do we have any statistics? How many cases those detectives have help to be solved.

I am interested in seeing what the cases that those detectives have provided evidence for have in common.

In all the numerous threads devoted to this topic I don't recall anyone claiming that any case has actually been solved by a psychic. Not even the most strident believers have yet identified such a case. Check out the 'Police and Pychics' threads for detailed discussion.

I think it's fair to say that the last case which resulted in a conviction based on paranormal evidence was the Salem Which Trial.:)
 
RonSceptic said:
I think it's fair to say that the last case which resulted in a conviction based on paranormal evidence was the Salem Which Trial.:)
Which...one was that? :D
 
Here is the reply, in its entirety, from Herman Silva of the Fresno Police Department:

Sgt. Tim Mcfadden was employed here for over thirty years, and retired several years ago. As far as the issue of using psychics for police investigations, there is not a policy that requires or prohibits their assistance. I don't believe that we would pay for this assistance, but I'm not certain. Also, I'm not aware of any noteworthy cases where a pyschic's assistance was the determining factor or impetus needed to solve a case. As with most law enforcement agencies, I believe you will find differing opinions within our organization on the effectiveness and legitimacy of pychics.

So Tim McFadden did work there, but he was a Sergeant, not a Detective, which is what the websites I found called him. There is a difference, but I think that's attributable to simple and common sloppy reporting.

Note that I have not received a response from the PRS at Penn State which is the organization that brought Carla Baron into the first case (still unsolved) and promised to document her involvement.
 
RonSceptic said:


In all the numerous threads devoted to this topic I don't recall anyone claiming that any case has actually been solved by a psychic. Not even the most strident believers have yet identified such a case. Check out the 'Police and Pychics' threads for detailed discussion.

I think it's fair to say that the last case which resulted in a conviction based on paranormal evidence was the Salem Which Trial.:)

My point was that in legal terms "important information" is called only the clues that lead either to suspects or to proofs. "Psychic detectives" cannot suggest that they have provided the Police with important info since no case has ever been solved based on info provided by them.

Everytime I hear that a psychic detective has provided " important information" I will ask which is the case that he has helped to be resolved :)

Words do matter in Law.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom