• Quick note - the problem with Youtube videos not embedding on the forum appears to have been fixed, thanks to ZiprHead. If you do still see problems let me know.

Proof of reincarnation

gerg

Critical Thinker
G
Joined
Apr 3, 2010
Messages
407
youtube.com/watch?v=rkuwLZDxt6Y

Love thy neighbour folks we reincarnate!
 
It seems odd that we never hear that someone, in a past life, was a chinese peasant who lead a dull life cultivating rice. The statistical probabilities of such a previous life are enormous. But no, most past lives seem to be full of glamour and adventure, frequently at important moments in history. We hear narratives filled with Holywood style stereotypes.
 
yomero said:
It seems odd that we never hear that someone, in a past life, was a chinese peasant who lead a dull life cultivating rice. The statistical probabilities of such a previous life are enormous. But no, most past lives seem to be full of glamour and adventure, frequently at important moments in history. We hear narratives filled with Holywood style stereotypes.
Click to expand...

I asked a guy about this once, after a very glamorous list of his past life endeavours (emperor, princes, adventurer, hero, all with full Hollywood style disregard for historical fact). He thought about it for a few minutes then started insisting he'd had past lives where he just worked in paddy-fields his whole life.

Thing is, he'd also previously told me he was a new human, and used to be some superior white alien dude who ruled over other darker skinned aliens.

I've never met one of these people who could even keep their own story straight, much less other peoples. Plus he was racist, even though he claimed to be an advanced being in a puny human body.
 
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Definitely not “Proof of reincarnation” but definitely proof of gerg's gulibility and desperate attempt to validate his ludicrous beliefs. [/FONT]
 
Last edited:
It's one fact about little kids is that their brains are like sponges. We already know how easy it is for little kids to learn new languages, and I know from personal experiance how much I knew about dinosaurs before I was 10!

Also, it seems pretty clear that this kid has access to the internet. How easy would it be, if the parents were not moderating it, for him to get this information or watch documentaries on TV about WWII? Could he have seen this information about the person at an early age at a museum or somwhere, detailing certain battles or historical events? How common are little nicknames for children, and did this kid know of any such people before?

It's deffinatly not supernatural nor magical that there are children out there who are very imaginative and very smart. The human brain is a very powerfull thing, so I think that it should not be underestimated, even for a child, when dealing with recalling such acurate information.
 
[FONT=Verdana, sans-serif]Wouldn't be the first time parents set their child up with “amazing powers” to gain fame and fortune. The family has already had a free trip to Japan out of it.[/FONT]
 
yomero said:
It seems odd that we never hear that someone, in a past life, was a chinese peasant who lead a dull life cultivating rice. The statistical probabilities of such a previous life are enormous. But no, most past lives seem to be full of glamour and adventure, frequently at important moments in history. We hear narratives filled with Holywood style stereotypes.
Click to expand...
That's just the media for you.. Read any reincarnation book and you'll find the dull life stories you're looking for. Destiny of Souls by Dr. Michael Newton for example.
 
This story was discussed here a while ago and the background investigation showed that he had had ample opportunities since he was born to acquire the information. Exploitation of the story by parents from then on? Seems the obvious answer to me.
 
SusanB-M1 said:
This story was discussed here a while ago and the background investigation showed that he had had ample opportunities since he was born to acquire the information. Exploitation of the story by parents from then on? Seems the obvious answer to me.
Click to expand...

Not just the parents, did a little deeper and you come across this woman
http://www.childpastlives.org/

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
:rolleyes:

His fascination with carrier launched fighters also seems to coincide with the release of "Pearl Harbour" and hes a big fan of WW2 flight sims which he'd been watching his older brother play since before he could talk.

;)

There were two other threads on this already
 
yomero said:
It seems odd that we never hear that someone, in a past life, was a chinese peasant who lead a dull life cultivating rice. The statistical probabilities of such a previous life are enormous. But no, most past lives seem to be full of glamour and adventure, frequently at important moments in history. We hear narratives filled with Holywood style stereotypes.
Click to expand...
Crash Davis (in the movie Bull Durham asked the same question.)

***
Annie Savoy: I think probably with my love of four-legged creatures and hooves and everything, that in another lifetime I was probably Catherine the Great, or Francis of Assisi. I'm not sure which one. What do you think?

Crash Davis: How come in former lifetimes, everybody is someone famous? How come nobody ever says they were Joe Schmo?

Annie Savoy: laughing Because it doesn't work that way, you fool!
 
yomero said:
It seems odd that we never hear that someone, in a past life, was a chinese peasant who lead a dull life cultivating rice. The statistical probabilities of such a previous life are enormous. But no, most past lives seem to be full of glamour and adventure, frequently at important moments in history. We hear narratives filled with Holywood style stereotypes.
Click to expand...
There was this newspaper article once of a woman who was outraged that a "psychic" had told her she in an earlier life had been a German named "Hans", who worked in a concentration camp:D. At the time, I was outraged -- how can you tell that to someone? Today, however, I find the story hilarious, and it makes me wonder how warped the alternative beliefs really are. If this woman is a believer (and it's perfectly possible she wasn't, which would justify her outrage), how does she know she wasn't a concentration camp guard in an earlier life?

It's like psychics who tell people they are going to die -- if you believe in psychics, why is it bad to receive such news? If my doctor discovered I was gravely ill, I wouldn't appreciate it if he lied and said that everything was fine. Imagine a woman showing up at a psychic and asking not to be told bad news, because she hates it when psychics tell people that they or their loved ones are going to die or fall victims of other tragedies. The psychic looks at her tarot cards and see that the woman's sister will be killed in a car accident in the near future, but respects her wish and makes up some story about money and hot guys. Three months later, the girl loses her sister in a car accident and later asks the psychic how he didn't see it coming. "Oh, I did", says he, "but you said you didn't want any bad news". Somehow I believe she wouldn't be very pleased.
 
Reincarnation...ok. Someone please explain. There are lots, lots, lots (I mean lots) more people alive today than ever before. Assume reincarnation, where to all of the extra bodies/souls come from?
 
headscratcher4 said:
So, they just sort float around in there until a body opens up?
Click to expand...
That's one possibility; a second is that there could be other inhabited planets in the universe. So, for example, while the population of Earth is currently increasing, the population of the hypothetical planet Thetan in the Andromeda Galaxy may be currently decreasing. For all we know, there may be billions and billions (to borrow from Carl Sagan) of inhabited planets in the universe, and souls may be constantly shuttling among them and other planes of existence.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Orphia Nay
Tibet, China, and The Dalai Lama's reincarnation
Replies
11
Views
137
Gulliver Foyle
Gulliver Foyle
C
Alien Visitation Contact Proof
61 62 63 64 65
Replies
1K
Views
43K
xterra
xterra
Apathia
Afterlife: Proof!
2 3 4
Replies
66
Views
7K
Cosmic Yak
Cosmic Yak
B
skepticism, UK racism story, and burden of proof
2 3 4
Replies
66
Views
5K
BobTheCoward
B
A
Snow in Brazil in July!! End of times? Proof or debunking of climate change?
2
Replies
27
Views
3K
HansMustermann
HansMustermann

Back
Top Bottom