I do not think it is really fair to characterize the "prepper" mentality as primarily a matter of "probably not, but just in case" prudent planning. That's not representative of my experience at all of even mild-flavored survivalists. The mythical and ever-referenced "SHTF" is something these individuals are fully convinced is impending and are anticipating, not just some worst-case hypothetical scenario they feel it's practical to be ready for "because who knows?". A visit to ANY survivalist-oriented web forum makes this quite painfully obvious; and it's why conspiracy theorizing is so hand-in-hand with doomsday prepping. It's the "evidence" of the all those conspiracies that "proves" to them that society is headed inevitably toward collapse, and prompts them to engage in the "prepping". To them, the Grand "SHTF" is most definitely not something that has only a few-tiny-percent-chance of coming to pass.
I'm not trying to characterize the "prepper" mentality as reasonable at all - as you say a lot of them are completely irrational. My point is that there is another kind of irrationality at the other extreme - where people discount the possibility of any 'doom' scenarios - without good evidence. Of course - partly this is a natural reaction to the fact that the doomers are not super rational - and tend to believe in conspiracy theories etc. Therefore people tend to categorize all possible doom scenarios as another form of woo - to be discounted as nonsense. I think this is an error.
As far as comparing the motivation behind prepping with the motivation behind buying insurance, and your talk of percentages - it really doesn't wash upon close consideration. Yes, it is true that the possibility of one's home being burned down or flooded is really miniscule, and buying home insurance is a hedge against something that has only a couple-percent chance of coming about. But the important thing to realize here is, that chance is real, and meaningful. Houses actually do burn down; houses actually do flood. They really are burglarized. These are rare things, and the chance they'll happen to any individual house is incredibly small; but we KNOW exactly how small because they've actually happened, and we can directly measure their rate of occurrence (and therefore deduce risk).
On the other hand, the "doomsday" scenario isn't something that happens - ever. There isn't so much as a single isolated case of it in all of recorded history.
I disagree with this - but we are probably just disagreeing about what constitutes a 'doomsday' scenario. Your definition seems to involve the end of human civilization - which I agree would be unprecedented and seems so unlikely in the short term as to be insignificant.
Instead lets define a doom scenario as a situation which :
- involves a breakdown in essential services - ie lack of food, water or electricity
- and / or a breakdown in law and order - such that your families safety is directly threatened
- which lasts for extended period of time (say more than a month)
- which you can't escape by traveling a few miles down the road (ie its not just a purely local disaster - which as crescent points out - the govt may have adequate plans in place for already)
i.e. a scenario where you might be really glad if you had put a small amount of resources into preparing in advance. When defined in those terms can we really argue that any such scenario is vanishingly unlikely for anyone in western civilization over the next decade or so?
I ask that specific to western civilization because of course there are plenty of other places in the world where people are struggling with those situations right now (Syria for example). Looking back into history there are many examples where people were living a nice civilized life which they probably imagined would never be interrupted - and things fell apart around them :
- cultural revolution in china in the 60s - tens of millions starved to death
- second world war - tens of millions killed, many more put in 'doom' scenario
- spanish flu pandemic of 1918 - killed about 5% of global population. In some cases things fell apart locally to the extent that people died of malnutrition.
- hyperinflation - heres 40 examples from recent history (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation) - in lots of those things got very tough for people caught in the middle of it
- etc etc - obviously I could go on - sadly its not hard to find situations in recent history where people had a really hard time because things fell apart - at least for a while.
Again my point is not to defend the doomers position which would maintain that these scenarios are likely or inevitable - instead I claim that it is rational to assume there is a small but significant chance of such a 'doom' scenario happening over the next decade or so - maybe a couple of percent chance.
Its true that the USA has avoided the worst of these problems in recent generations. I guess the civil war was the last time things really fell apart in the US. However that doesn't give it immunity from future issues I fear.
I would be willing to assign a much smaller probability to the doom scenarios if I felt that our civilization was taking the risks seriously and taking appropriate measures to manage those risks. However instead I mostly see politicians dismissing risks without evidence - or worse using evidence that is little more than woo to justify their lack of action. Examples of this kind of thing :
- The current economic argument that zero interest rates and printing money can maintain exponential growth in the economy forever. This is backed up by economists - who think they understand how the economy works - but are actually little more than astrologers. I don't claim to be able to predict the outcome - but its scary to me that people are doing these things when I don't believe they know what the outcome will be either.
- The fact that we don't have a plausible energy strategy for the next few decades - despite the fact that oil is likely to get more expensive as it gets harder to extract. Politicians like to waffle about renewable energy sources or nuclear fusion - but current plans are not very plausible.
- The fact that our civilization seems to be based on exponentially increasing about of debt - with little serious consideration of how that is going to end. The most you can hope for from politicians is talk of slowing the rate of increase in govt debt.
- etc etc - too often our leaders are just fire fighting the PR - trying to get through the next few months rather than having a long term plan.
Again - I'm not predicting that any of these issues is going to lead to impending doom. However given I don't have good answers to those issues its hard for me to conclude that bad situations are vanishingly unlikely. And lets not forget the wide range of bad things that can happen that we have no chance of anticipating.
You may disagree with me that those issues are anything to worry about - any maybe you are right. But I would still claim that it is rational to store some food and water - and other basic 'preps' - on the assumption that a 'doom' scenario as defined above is unlikely but definitely possible.
- Drelda