Preppers: What should we be worried about?

Wanna peek inside the mind of a gunnutter survivalist prepper?

For the LULz.

From your link, I was shocked at just how much blatant racism there is tied into the prepper movement.

http://www.glocktalk.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1202332

It ranges from the coded:

Did anyone else hear the clip played on one of the news shows about "Obama money"? This woman, of a certain lower socio-economic standpoint, is talking to a reporter about the "Obama money" she's getting. She's hootin and hollarin and celebrating about the free money. When asked where that money comes from she says "Obama...it's Obama money". When asked we Obama got the money from the woman goes "pshhh...his stash!".

To the overt:

What will happen? Remember the LA riots? Now imagine that on a nationwide scale, it'd be why we prep. Every urabn area in the country would burn, which isn't really a bad thing...

It seems that the actual fear of preppers is that "black people" will one day just explode in violence and take their land, property, and women.
 
Where do these guys get these ideas from?

Oh no?!?!? That is the road to ruin. Decrease public assistance to a bare subsistence level. You don't starve, you have shelter, but no phone, no tv, no game consoles, no high dollar SUV's with after market rims and a cool sound system, you get to live, that's it. A man working 20 hours a week at a part time job at minimum wage should have a better life than a welfare leach that is able to work.

If you give people the proper motivation to work they will work. That includes being very harsh to thieves.

Do they really think people on welfare make enough money to buy "high dollar SUVs"?

How much does welfare pay?

Answer: not much.

The two largest welfare programs -- by far -- are Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) and food stamps. In 1992, the average yearly AFDC family payment was $4,572, and food stamps for a family of three averaged $2,469, for a total of $7,041. So, to divide that up into 12 months would be about $586 a month.

So does a man on a 20 hour per week job make more?

Minimum wage is $7.25 an hour (that makes my heart ache to read that)
x 20=$145 per week, or $594 per month.

And this doesn't cover the second income from a spouse in that situation.

So to end this derail, it's safe to say that both people on welfare and the working poor are having an extremely tough time out there, but people on welfare cannot buy big screen TVs and high value SUVs and the latest gadgets. They are very, very poor.
 
Pretty well, actually. DC, Manhattan and LA would be a mess, and other areas would be without power. The state governments in Albany and Sacramento would continue to function, and federal continuity of government contingency plans would go into effect.

Disasters in the U.S., for the most part, tend to bring people together, not push them apart.

Pretty much. People in Seattle, St. Louis, Boston, and Miami will be sad, but they will go to work the next morning.
 
Emergency preparedness is keeping a few cases of bottled water stacked in the closet. Prepping is keeping a dozen 5-gallon jerry cans of water in the garage, along with several ceramic filters, chemical treatments, multiple rain-barrels and well-digging equipment.

CDC says:
http://emergency.cdc.gov/preparedness/kit/disasters/
"Water—one gallon per person, per day (3day supply for evacuation, 2week supply for home)"

If there's more than one person in that house, the nutballs are actually closer to the CDC recommendation. I don't know how many you call "a few", or what size bottles are in your "case", but you might be coming up short.



I think that ought to give the general idea.

Yes. The general idea is, whatever you would do is sane, anything more is crazy.

What I don't get is your motivation. OMG, that guy has more water than I do, he must be nuts? And you aren't the only one, of course. People are going so far as to suggest that anyone with a backup supply of food must be planning on kidnapping children. Insanity is definitely a problem here, but I don't think it is on the side you think it is.
 
Mrs. Agglerithm seems to be really worried about the possibility of food shortages. I tried to reassure her with a couple of facts:

1. We currently produce WAY TOO MUCH FOOD. We've got a long way to go before we're dealing with shortages.

You are making a very vague "too much food" into a verbal dogma and applying it without any reasonable limitation. That leads to two problems:

1. Most of that "too much food" in your grocery store is not very old. It's more than we need at any given time, but it is delivered and consumed quickly. It doesn't last long.

2. Most of our "too much food" isn't even in the store where you can get it. It has to be transported from the source to you. That's where the trouble comes in during a disaster. There was plenty of water all around the US, but there was no good way to distribute it to people in New Orleans.


2. During WWII, 40% of the vegetables produced in the US were from private "victory" gardens. When necessary, we can be very flexible with our food supply.

Yes, and that worked well enough when all of the violence was happening elsewhere. It says nothing about what would happen when bad things actually happen here. On the other hand, floods and hurricanes produced areas with much less-successful responses.
 
CDC says:
http://emergency.cdc.gov/preparedness/kit/disasters/
"Water—one gallon per person, per day (3day supply for evacuation, 2week supply for home)"

If there's more than one person in that house, the nutballs are actually closer to the CDC recommendation. I don't know how many you call "a few", or what size bottles are in your "case", but you might be coming up short.





Yes. The general idea is, whatever you would do is sane, anything more is crazy.

What I don't get is your motivation. OMG, that guy has more water than I do, he must be nuts? And you aren't the only one, of course. People are going so far as to suggest that anyone with a backup supply of food must be planning on kidnapping children. Insanity is definitely a problem here, but I don't think it is on the side you think it is.

The water is just one aspect of the bigger picture of the Prepper - even you realize it, because you singled that one aspect out from the whole post.

Perhaps the water was a bad example after all, but the rest of the post seems pretty accurate.

And you misunderstand. I don't think preppers are "crazy". Despite the thread title I don't have any "concern" about them. Some of them can at times be a little smarmy when discussing their "SHTF" fantasies with people who know better, and that can be a pain on occasion; but otherwise, like the aforementioned whackers, I consider them just mildly quirky.
 
You are making a very vague "too much food" into a verbal dogma and applying it without any reasonable limitation. That leads to two problems:

1. Most of that "too much food" in your grocery store is not very old. It's more than we need at any given time, but it is delivered and consumed quickly. It doesn't last long.

2. Most of our "too much food" isn't even in the store where you can get it. It has to be transported from the source to you. That's where the trouble comes in during a disaster. There was plenty of water all around the US, but there was no good way to distribute it to people in New Orleans.




Yes, and that worked well enough when all of the violence was happening elsewhere. It says nothing about what would happen when bad things actually happen here. On the other hand, floods and hurricanes produced areas with much less-successful responses.

Specifically, she was talking about food shortages happening as a result of things that are happening right now...rising fuel costs, drought, farmers getting out of the business. Certainly, there are a number of disasters that could result in food shortages, but she was talking about events that seemed likely based on the current state of affairs.
 
I'm not so sure. No country has ever lost a sizable percentage of its political and economic command structure in one day. Think of the knowledge that would evaporate in an instant. What would happen to the monetary and banking system? Would workers and retirees continue to get their checks? Would essential goods continue to reach their destinations? Would people who live in cities stay there and do their jobs, or would there be a mass exodus to the countryside?

I see the potential for massive disruption lasting years, and a short-term situation in which people with bunkers, guns and canned goods would be glad they had them.

We shut down trading for a while - we did that after Sept. 11. The monetary and banking system information rests on computers with data backed up all over, destruction in one place will not destroy all of the bankng and finance information.

The command structure would transition into contingency plans - we would have an acting president within a few hours, made permanent and sworn in after a day or two. State governments would replace legislators through methods already in place; it would be rare to replace to many at once, but the legal mechanisms exist.

IC Type 1 teams under a unified Military/Civilian command structure would be set up within 24 hours to manage the three nuke sites - they would deal with the medical issues, evacuation, containment, and everything else. The planning for this has evolved a great deal since 9/11 and Katrina.

Federal agencies have contingency plans - most of them have regional offices; many have offices in Denver that are at the same bureaucratic level as the Washington Office. Regional Directors, or Assistant Directors (some of whom are based in Denver) assume command. Less affected agencies can re-purpose some staff to fill in gaps created within other agencies by the hit on Washington.

In other words - for the most part, retirees get their checks, except for those who work in small, independent businesses in the nuked cities. Even then, many of those keep accounts with banks that keep records well backed up, in many cases the pensions will be handled by those banks. After Sept. 11, banks better understand the need for distributed record keeping.

Essential goods keep moving - there would be travel limitations in the radiated areas, but our system can handle enough re-routing to keep things going.

Exodus from the cities? That depends on your scenario. If more bombs are expected, maybe - but if we have any information to go on, our military and intelligence agencies, and those of our allies, would take the gloves off; they certainly would not lack for volunteers.
 
Specifically, she was talking about food shortages happening as a result of things that are happening right now...rising fuel costs, drought, farmers getting out of the business. Certainly, there are a number of disasters that could result in food shortages, but she was talking about events that seemed likely based on the current state of affairs.

I don't think anything that's happening now makes something like a food shortage likely. All of the things you mention will work to make certain foods more expensive; but this will tend to result in temporary food surpluses rather than shortages until the market balances.
 
Exodus from the cities? That depends on your scenario. If more bombs are expected, maybe - but if we have any information to go on, our military and intelligence agencies, and those of our allies, would take the gloves off; they certainly would not lack for volunteers.

More importantly: if there is an exodus, it will almost certainly be to already-existing but smaller urban centers; and those people who go elsewhere would be bringing infrastructure and urbanization with them wherever they go.

People will not be running for the forest to join Rambo Hood's Merry Men just because they don't think it's save to live in Atlanta anymore. They'll just drive to City of Smallerthanatlanta.
 
I'm not so sure. No country has ever lost a sizable percentage of its political and economic command structure in one day. Think of the knowledge that would evaporate in an instant. What would happen to the monetary and banking system? Would workers and retirees continue to get their checks? Would essential goods continue to reach their destinations? Would people who live in cities stay there and do their jobs, or would there be a mass exodus to the countryside?

I see the potential for massive disruption lasting years, and a short-term situation in which people with bunkers, guns and canned goods would be glad they had them.

My point is that even in your scenario there'd be virtually NO loss of political or economic structure. The vast responsibility of day to day running of a country lies in local structures, all of which would be untouched.
The loss of the president and congress is not going to mean that a local sheriff suddenly says "Oh well, the law doesn't apply anymore guys. Mad Max away!"

On the rest of the topic, one of the reasons this kind of prepping thinking might be more prominent in the US is that the country is far more prone to natural disasters then say europe. Those bits that aren't hit by hurricanes every year lie in areas with frequent tornado's, major faultlines or mad blizzard territory.
In europe on the other hand only the coastal area's get hit by atlantic storms from time to time and the south may occasionally get a few earthquakes. Off the top of my head I can think of only one city built right next to an active volcano (Naples).
 
On the rest of the topic, one of the reasons this kind of prepping thinking might be more prominent in the US is that the country is far more prone to natural disasters then say europe. Those bits that aren't hit by hurricanes every year lie in areas with frequent tornado's, major faultlines or mad blizzard territory.
In europe on the other hand only the coastal area's get hit by atlantic storms from time to time and the south may occasionally get a few earthquakes. Off the top of my head I can think of only one city built right next to an active volcano (Naples).

By that logic, Australia should be full of preppers. The place has fires, floods, and hurricanes. Also, every living non-human organism on that continent seems to have evolved specifically to murder humans. The main difference seems to be that they were not targeted with quite so many nukes as the U.S. was.
 
By that logic, Australia should be full of preppers. The place has fires, floods, and hurricanes. Also, every living non-human organism on that continent seems to have evolved specifically to murder humans. The main difference seems to be that they were not targeted with quite so many nukes as the U.S. was.

And Australia's is geographically close to three things that would make American preppers' eyes bug out so far they need their own bug-out bags:

A) the world's most populous majority-Muslim country
B) a tiny oil-rich sultanate
C) a communist superpower with nuclear weapons
 
I was only vaguely aware of what a "prepper" is until I stumbled into a conversation with one of my employees.

She and her husband are both retired military (sort of, Air Farce). They own several acres about 20 minutes outside our metro area. They own their home and two others that they've turned into rental propoerty. In other words, they are financially secure, and they seem to be reasonably normal folks.

They have a "strong room" in thei house, they own lots of guns, they stockpile food and water and have invested in a water pump/storage/purification system. They rehearse their retreat into their strong room should they get attacked (presumably for their food/water/guns).

I asked a few common sense questions - how do you plan to defend yourselves with only two of you, what do you see as the most likely cause of your retreat into Festung Edwards, etc. No logical answers at all. I got the impression they are actually hoping for a survivalist situation. I was taken by complete suprise.

About a day later, she came back not with answers but with questions of me - how would I survive the collapse of society. When I told her it wasn't something I gave any thought to, she gave the impression that I was a blind fool.
 
By that logic, Australia should be full of preppers. The place has fires, floods, and hurricanes. Also, every living non-human organism on that continent seems to have evolved specifically to murder humans. The main difference seems to be that they were not targeted with quite so many nukes as the U.S. was.

To be fair, in the US you can flee to the wilderness to hunt the wildlife. In Australia you can flee to the wilderness to be hunted by the wildlife ;)
 
I thought the TV series Jericho had a well thought-out version of what could happen to the USA should several cities come under nuclear attack.
 
I think both sides of this debate often suffer from irrationality:

- The doomers / preppers tend to evaluate the probability of a specific extreme ‘doom’ event as being high enough to be considered likely or even inevitable. This is a strong claim which would require strong evidence to back it up – which they typically don’t have. Therefore they are being irrational.

- However the non-doomers tend to evaluate the probability all extreme ‘doom’ events in aggregate as being so low as to be insignificant – e.g. less than 0.001%. They think it is almost inevitable that their current way of life will continue without interruption for many decades to come. There are many scenarios which could lead to a ‘doom’ event – which although not individually very likely – claiming the sum of those probabilities (including the ones we can’t foresee at all) is insignificant is a strong claim which would require strong evidence to back it up – which they don’t have. Therefore they are being irrational.

Note I am not claiming that I can estimate the probability of extreme ‘doom’ events taking place. Instead I’m claiming that the rational position to take in the face of an uncertain future is to be humble about our ability to predict it - and so avoid assigning extremely low (or high) probabilities to anything that we don’t have strong evidence for.
Human beings are often very bad at making rational decisions about low probability events. They tend to either grossly over or under estimate the probability. I think this is what happens when people consider the doom scenarios – they tend to polarize into those that think they are inevitable and those that think they are impossible.

I think the more rational evaluation is to say that the sum of these scenarios have a few percent of probability over the next few years. That’s not enough that it should dominate your life – but plenty enough that you should think about it and where sensible you should prepare – particularly in areas that have utility in the other ninety-something percent of the time (e.g. having some food and water stored in the house can be useful in situations far less dramatic than the apocalypse!).

If you agree with this evaluation of the probability – but disagree that a few percent is worth doing anything about – then fair enough that’s a rational position. However also don’t bother buying home insurance, and don’t worry about eating healthily either – both of those are examples where we tend to take actions to manage/prepare for similarly low (but not insignificant) probability risks.

Personally I find it hard to call myself a ‘prepper’ – because there is so much irrationality associated with that whole scene – and links to conspiracy theory nutters etc. However – I’m humble about how well I can predict the future – and I know from history that the world can be a scary place if you find yourself in the wrong place at the wrong time. Therefore yes – I have some water and food stored away and a few other things that would be considered at the minor end of ‘prepping’. I think it’s unlikely I will need them because of an apocalypse – but I also think it’s unlikely my house will burn to the ground and I’ve also bought insurance against that.

Finally it worries me that because of this polarization - its generally left to the ‘doomers’ to evaluate the risks associated with extreme events. As we know they aren’t typically the most rational bunch – and yet they tend to be the only ones thinking about these things. That is scary indeed.

- Drelda
 
Last edited:
I make reasonable preparations for house fires, tornadoes and hurricanes (I do live in Dallas), and have courses of action for rarer occasions like home invasion.

What does Dallas hurricane prep look like? A barricade on I-45 at the Trinity? A big sign: "No Houstonians welcome, go back to Centerville, they have good BBQ."

I think the Super Bowl Ice Storm was the must cut off I have seen the city. Three or four days of not much moving around, but not really isolated. We emptied our pantry and freezer, but we didn't need to. The grocery store was open the whole time, I just didn't want to get into a wreck with someone driving beyond their tires. I was on the verge of walking to the store one day, but the neighbor had some extra butter so I was spared the 3 mile walk.

Growing up closer to the coast we would fill up our bathtubs with water as the hurricane approached and we always had a week's worth of food in the pantry and freezer.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom