planning a more formal debate internet radio show

Keep in mind that the papers that are written would not be read in the actual debate (as I understand it), they are simply there as a means of allowing both sides to fact check and so on before the actual debate, and to better focus on the most contentious and important issues.

The papers could then also be available as 'extra' material on the show's website.

Correct; the precognition (sorry for the formal title) would not be read out as part of the debate (how dull would that be) but could be referred to in the course of the discussion itself as would the reference works.

I would suggest that each "side" kicks off the debate with a summary of the key issues of their case, iunasmuch as these are likely to be relevant to the debate itself, a little like a lawyer's opening remarks.

Then we have the debate.

Then each side gets a brief (no more than 2 or 3 minute) summing up of what they feel the debate showed (or otherwise) as regards the points under discussion.
 
You know, when I do a public inquiry (most recently in Sefton, of all places) I usually get paid a whack for this kind of stuff!

Consider it my donation to the cause!!
 
If you wish to have moderators in a debate, you need to understand their role and function. A moderator should be able to withold personal opinion, and ensure fairness in the debate. A moderator therefore should not contribute to the debate, nor should they stand for either side.

The moderator should be in the middle, ensuring that each side gets equal time and attention, and that rules are agreed to and abided by.

I would normally expect any host to assume this position, and provide a good framework for a debate. If there are any biases the host feels they cannot suppress (being human), then they should be announced up front, and an independant moderator called in for that particular debate.

Your format has 2 people in each team debating each other, but seems to have no middle man retaining order and decorum.
 
Good point; I think OP envisaged two moderators, one from each side, but one wonders how that would work in practice.
 
Good point; I think OP envisaged two moderators, one from each side, but one wonders how that would work in practice.

It won't.

A moderator is by definition moderate in opinion, and therefore not leaning toward either side in a debate. To facilitate this, they should not participate, rather oversee the running of the debate.

A moderator should be a background role, unless action is required to be taken to return the debate to topic, or issue the agreed penalties for any rule breaches.
 
In that case the simple solution for the two parties to agree on a willing neutral moderator. Frankly I've no idea who that might be, but there you go. I'm sure that we could come up with suggestions.
 
I had actually assumed that was implicit in Architect's setup.

Agreed - one moderator is required, who may not interfere any more than their position requires. They are there to moderate, not participate.
 
You really need an independant third party to do the planning and provide the moderator. For example the League of Women Voters usually handles the Presidential and many other debates around election time. They would then not only moderate the debate, they would handle the negotiations about the ground rules. Formal rules of debate are not what you usually see on TV, try to attend one at a high school or college to get an idea of how they work. There are strict guidelines that most people, from all sides, will have great difficulty adhering to. Also familiarize yourself with the ways a person wins a formal debate. There was actually an episode of "Charm School" on VH1 where the ladies were asked to have a formal debate, it is a good example of how restricting the rules are and how a novice reacts to them and may think they've made there case, but didn't.

I would suggest going to a local college and approach one of the speech professors, they usually also handle the debate team. A fee may be charged by him/her, as it involves a great deal of time on his/her part. To save money, you could propose it as a project for a student to get credit for. As school is out for the year in many areas, you could also see if there is a local debating society who could perform the same duties.

Hopefully this will get you started.
 
Do you have debating societies in America, like the Senior Lit over in the UK? That may be a sensible place to start.
 
phantomwolf : the format yuo are describing is a form of lincoln-douglas debate. i'd agree to that form of debate, just not for the show i am proposing. they, while useful, don't make for good radio. i also find them to lend themselves to be limited in thier scope. i also tend to prefer debating in a one to one format under lincoln-douglas rules as i often have very little confidence in those that are on my team. anytime you want to engage in a debate of this type, i'm willing.

Actually it's a variation of the Australia-Asia Style with the teams extended to 4 rather then the standard 3 members. As to doing such a debate, I'm sure that if someone was willing to pay my travel costs, I'm love to gather a team and do it. The main trouble I'd have would be determining the other three team members.
 
Actually it's a variation of the Australia-Asia Style with the teams extended to 4 rather then the standard 3 members. As to doing such a debate, I'm sure that if someone was willing to pay my travel costs, I'm love to gather a team and do it. The main trouble I'd have would be determining the other three team members.

Hey - if there are travel costs covered, count me in! :D

I don't see that happening though...
 
What is with Conspiracy Theorists redefining words like "fact" to suit their own weird view of the world?

First we had the "a fact is something that is believed" and now we have "a fact is something that can be proven true or false".

For f-sake people, get a frikken dictionary!

-Gumboot
 
What is with Conspiracy Theorists redefining words like "fact" to suit their own weird view of the world?

First we had the "a fact is something that is believed" and now we have "a fact is something that can be proven true or false".

For f-sake people, get a frikken dictionary!

-Gumboot

They're using the Tinhat Dictionary of 9/11 Troof, gumboot. Apparently, it does not require any semblance of adherence to the real world; it eschews facts and evidence; and living in reality is optional for its adherents.
 
Goes nice with their definition of truth.

Truth - n tooth: What I want to believe.
 
there's one thing that so many people seem to forget. facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts.

And.............we're done. Well, I am, anyway. When facts are false and up is down, it's Miller Time.
 
Bump


So, Water-Bender, how are your proposals and thoughts on this shaping up?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom