planning a more formal debate internet radio show

I didn't say that I wasn't suspicious about his motives or suggestions, merely that we should see if there is an acceptable, even handed way in wish his proposed debate might work.

As I said before, the advantage of the precognition system is that each time has to lay its cards on the table; there is very little scope for ambush. If the CT side of the table bases its entire evidence on facts that are blatantly no such thing (concrete cores spring to mind) then everyone knows about it well in advance.
 
simply put a fact is a fact. if you need me to link you to a dictionary definition i can, but i would hope that you are beyond that. is innuendo a fact? no. is speculation a fact? only if that speculation has an outcome that can be rendered true or false. there's one thing that so many people seem to forget. facts can be false or wrong, it doesnt change that they are still facts.

Could you give us an example of a "fact" that is false or wrong?
 
Last edited:
Could you give us an example of a "fact" that is false or wrong?

He uses them all the time at lcf.

He'll begin a conversation on, say, WTC7 with something along the lines of, "It's a fact that WTC7 was a controlled demolition..."

Once he believes in something, it becomes a fact to him. Even if later proven wrong, it's still a fact.
 
Steve, Conspi; lads.

Any problems with my suggested UK PLI format? There are no unfair ambushes, particular areas of concern (eg disputed "facts") are flagged up in advance, and so on.

I don't see the point.

The 'truthers' are entrenched in their beliefs

So-called 'fencesitters' are unlikely to bother with another lame internet 'radio' broadcast

So why indulge the 'truther' debate fantasy?
If the 'truth' movement has evidence which hasn't been shown to be totally baseless then it's time they tested it in law.
Of course some will argue that it won't matter because the judiciary and political establishment is against them (boo hoo) but, short of a revolution which installs a 'truther' as dictator in the US, they have to work with what they've got.

Internet 'radio' debates aint gonna bring down the government, so one can only conclude that this is just another 'truther' all talk and no action ploy.

I say, if they have the goods they should get off their lazy arses and do something.

But they won't because they don't
 
Well, for a start refusing to debate the issues demeans us. And secondly, and with due respect to the OP, I have considerable doubts as to whether the CT brigade would sign up to a regime wich ensured fairness and openness.
 
Well, for a start refusing to debate the issues demeans us. And secondly, and with due respect to the OP, I have considerable doubts as to whether the CT brigade would sign up to a regime wich ensured fairness and openness.

True. But I do understand why the scientific community declined to address the intelligent design fantasy for so long.

My tolerance for the 'truther' bs is wearing thin.

But I concede that, whilst no one is actually working towards having 911 ct fantasies taught in schools, to ignore the fantasy completely would allow them free reign.

I just can't imagine that they have anything new to bring to the table. It will be the same old crap that's bee proven to be wrong time and time again on these pages.

They'll refuse to accept the truth, just like any good religious fanatic.

Critical thinkers will get a headache trying to understand and then counter the 'truther's convoluted claims.

No 'undecided' will be listening anyway

So it will end with 'truthers' talking about common sense and complaining about semantics, and rational people complaining about the lack of 'truther' comprehension and we'll be precisely where we are now
 
Well, for a start refusing to debate the issues demeans us. And secondly, and with due respect to the OP, I have considerable doubts as to whether the CT brigade would sign up to a regime wich ensured fairness and openness.
It could only "work", for what that's worth, if conducted like we do debating here. A person gets their say, fully. No interruptions, time limit on answer, same exact time allotted to each of the debaters. The moderator offers no opinion at all. Just presents the questions, in an impartial fashion.

And in fact this could be done in stages, production-wise. The two sides never even have to see or hear each other. You get their timed statements and edit it together.

That takes the spectacle out of the debate, the bias, the hijacking of it, the interruptions, the insults.
 
Now your thinking!

I still think it has to be a PLI type forum, personally, but I'm open to more suggestions.

Where has our OP disappeared to, btw?
 
It could only "work", for what that's worth, if conducted like we do debating here. A person gets their say, fully. No interruptions, time limit on answer, same exact time allotted to each of the debaters. The moderator offers no opinion at all. Just presents the questions, in an impartial fashion.

And in fact this could be done in stages, production-wise. The two sides never even have to see or hear each other. You get their timed statements and edit it together.

That takes the spectacle out of the debate, the bias, the hijacking of it, the interruptions, the insults.

I quite like that idea, aye!
 
I'd love to see a real debate done. 4 members a side. 5min intros, then 10 minutes each, plus 10 minutes summing up by the "captains" at the end.

Basically you have an Affirmative and a Negitive team based on the proposition that "The WTC Towers were destroyed by a Controlled Demolition."

The team captain of the Affirmative would open his side's argument and has five minutes to present an outline or overview of what their their case will be. The Negative team's captain then opens their case using his/her five minutes to outline their case. The debate then starts with the Affirmative Captain speaking for 10 minutes on his/her topic, adreesing the points they want to get across. Once they have had their 10 minutes, the Captain of the Negitive team starts their address, first rebuting anything the Affirmative Captain has said that they wish to deal with, then putting over their side of the argument as to why the proposition is wrong. The debate would then progress with each speaker alternating between Affirmative and Negative till all four have spoken. The two Captains then get an extra 10 minutes each to sum up their case and reinforce any points their teams have already made.

The Moderator basically is only there to introduce each speaker, tell interjectors to shut up and keep the time for each speaker.

I seriously doubt that any Truthers would be willing to submit to that sort of format however since they'd get their butts well and truely kicked about the room.
 
"Fact in investigations

In investigations a fact is an item of information that can be verified as either true or falsehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False. For example, the statement "the President is standing in the back of the classroom" is a fact because it can be verified as true or false by turning around and looking. In this context, "fact" does not imply truthfulness - only objectivity. If it is subjective (" The President is a snappy dresser") then it is either an opinion or a conclusion and cannot be verified."

this is the definition of fact by which this process will be operating. first an item is determined to be fact or opinion. if it is opinion it is thrown out. if it is factual then its validity is investigated. are we clear now? if you can't grasp this concept then your participation is not welcome. if you can't adhere to the proposed rules, then your participation is not welcome. if the extent of your involvement is limited to the remarks 80% of you have been making then your participation is not welcome. how hard is it to be objective?
harder than i thought if i'm to form my opinion based on most of the responses.




i agree that most of what cters say is utter trash. conversely so is most of what the skeptics say. i'm putting forth an idea that satisfies fairness to both sides of the debate. if i was doing anything other than that then i wouldn't bother asking a skeptic to co-moderate. i wouldn't have the desire to have the whole process to be live. i wouldn't bother, period.




phantomwolf : the format yuo are describing is a form of lincoln-douglas debate. i'd agree to that form of debate, just not for the show i am proposing. they, while useful, don't make for good radio. i also find them to lend themselves to be limited in thier scope. i also tend to prefer debating in a one to one format under lincoln-douglas rules as i often have very little confidence in those that are on my team. anytime you want to engage in a debate of this type, i'm willing.




as to the question of why it took me so long to respond... i don't spend my life here, or anywhere else on the net.
 
Well, for a start refusing to debate the issues demeans us. And secondly, and with due respect to the OP, I have considerable doubts as to whether the CT brigade would sign up to a regime wich ensured fairness and openness.

i agree and it seems the same can be said of the jref brigade as well.
 
Hmm...a suggestion.

While I agree that giving a broad overview of different theories is a good tact for a first episode, there isn't really any call for debate with such a focus - any debate that occurs is going to automatically branch out into the technical aspects that would be best covered in debate on another show. For example, the WTC7 collapse, the crash at the Pentagon, etc...

Perhaps a broad overview of different theories could be offered as an introduction to the show, and the first debate topic could be something different, perhaps more specific?

Also, when you give an overview of different theories, how many different theories would be mentioned? And which ones?

perhaps the better method would be pick a theory to be discussed, and devote an entire piece on it. the theories i'd want to investigate are official, lihop, mihop, lihop as it pertains to official, mihop as it pertains to official, space rays, no planers...

on second thought maybe the theories in and of themselves shouldn't be debated, only specific aspects of theories. overall discussion of each lends itself to becoming mired in the crap, and frankly there wouldn't be enough time ever to discuss any of them in length...perhaps sticking to merely defining them for the purpose of any person listening or involved understands the definition of the terms being used.
 
And your thoughts regarding my suggested PLI/precognition format?

i havent come to an opinion on that one actually. it seems like a decent idea, though i am more afraid of it being difficult from a production aspect. i also think it takes away from it being a radio program. i do think its a good format for a written sort of piece though. perhaps even being useful for the inclusion of 'experts' who cant take an active participation
 
Last edited:
i havent come to an opinion on that one actually. it seems like a decent idea, though i am more afraid of it being difficult from a production aspect. i also think it takes away from it being a radio program. i do think its a good format for a written sort of piece though. perhaps even being useful for the inclusion of 'experts' who cant take an active participation

You have two problems that the proposed format addresses well:

1. There will be "facts" that perhaps make great soundbites but which are no such thing. A simple example is the suggestion that steel doesn't fail in even a "normal" fire scenario. The use of precognitions pre-debate limits the attractiveness of such options to the protagonists and also allows the opposition to address them at an early stage, thus ensuring fairness.

2. Neither side trusts each other, and is wary of an ambush. This format is essentially a "cards on the table" pre-debate, setting the boundaries for the discussion and allowing the moderators to focus on what both parties identify as the core (no pun intended) issues.

I should add that each team also lists its core reference documents beforehand, rather like disclosure of evidence in court, in order that it's a level playing field.

I can't take any credit for developing it - this is how we run public inquiries (yes, that's how we spell it) in the UK, and it's a system that's been getting fine tuned for 50 years.
 
Let me give you an example of how this would work, based on an issue which (if I read it correctly) you and I agree on over at LC.

There is strong photographic and eyewitness evidence of fireball damage around and apparently emminating from liftshafts at ground floor/lobby level. This is corroborated by eyewitness testimony of the blasts themselves, injuries, and the smell of aviation fuel.

If a team wishes to found upon this, the other side have a chance to gather evidence and present the opposing case as part of their written, pre-debate rebuttal. It may be that they dispute that the fireballs existed, in which case they are wasting everyone's time, or alternatively it may be that they dispute the source of the fireballs (say, explosives) in which case they will have to offer evidence to support that hypothesis and also explain issues such as the odour of jet fuel.

By the time you get to the debate, each team is able to focus on the critical points (one assumes the CTers would stick with the continuous lift shafts issue) rather than waste a pile of time arguing about issues which they might, in fact, actually agree on.

A similar example is the aircraft impacts. Now as far as I can see, the CT lobby now largely agree that real planes hit WTC1 and 2. There is therefore no practical purpose in this even apeparing in the debate, either to support the CT lobby or as a means of discrediting its wildest fringes. Instead the debate might focus on the damage caused by those impacts and whether it was sufficient to cause collapse.

A word of caution. The one disadvantage of this system for the participants is that it highlights wooly thinking. So, for example, if a set of structural calculations are produced but the other team cannot produce a detailed rebuttal then it it reflects extremely poorly on their case. The mods have no choice but to put up their hands and say "sorry, but that just doesn't cut it.....can you substantiate your rebuttal or not?"
 
water bender:

I don't have a great deal to add to what Architect has said - it seems to me that what he is proposing would be the best (and fairest) way to run things.

As to your worries that it would be difficult from a production point of view - why? To me it seems that doing things in this way would allow for a more focused discussion of important issues. Keep in mind that the papers that are written would not be read in the actual debate (as I understand it), they are simply there as a means of allowing both sides to fact check and so on before the actual debate, and to better focus on the most contentious and important issues.

The papers could then also be available as 'extra' material on the show's website.

Also, I feel that rather than discussing "LIHOP", "MIHOP", etc, the discussion should focus more on things such as "Collapse of WTC7", "The UA93 Crash", and so on. This allows for more detailed and focused debates.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom