Perseverence porn

The video touched on a crucial point. The man with type 1 diabetes who couldn't afford his insulin set up a go-fund-me page, and came up only $50 short. He died. The presenter pointed out that if the page had got more clicks, if there were more people who realised that only $50 would save this man's life, he would have got it. But that didn't happen.

Well, that can't be true. Insulin is a life-long treatment. 50 bucks does not make a crucial difference. That would have helped him a month longer, or so, but it would not have saved his life. (and you don't just go die from diabetes, it's a long process)

Well, one thing that can potentially be done about that is taxation, and a properly-administered benefits system. Two huge advantages. It prevents freeloading by the rich miser who doesn't contribute anything, leaving the burden of charity to others - essentially it spreads the charitable load equitably according to means rather than inequitably according to generosity - and it (in an ideal world) identifies where the critical need is and gets the money there. The diabetic gets his insulin before the little girl gets her Christmas present, I'm afraid.

Oh, I quite agree. That's what we have where I am. No diabetic will lack insulin here, but there ARE limits, obviously: Some very expensive treatments for rare diseases are not covered.

Hans
 
I understand that, but there must still be people thinking: Why is that sort of thing necessary?


Well, yes, the article that I posted in the OP and the video just posted. But it seems not to be something that strikes most viewers or readers, because that interpretation isn't pointed out.

I didn't follow up on the diabetes thing but there was a Snopes link on the video so I assume that at some level there was truth in the allegation.

A diabetic did die in England because he had no money for electricity so he couldn't run his fridge that was necessary to keep his insulin cool. It's not just America where atrocious things happen.
 
Last edited:
Obviously, if a diabetic consistently does not get insulin, the condition will eventually be fatal.

Hans
 
I don't know the exact circumstances of the go-fund-me guy, but as I said, the video had a link to Snopes in relation to the case.
 
The video touched on a crucial point. The man with type 1 diabetes who couldn't afford his insulin set up a go-fund-me page, and came up only $50 short. He died. The presenter pointed out that if the page had got more clicks, if there were more people who realised that only $50 would save this man's life, he would have got it. But that didn't happen.

People are generous, people are charitable, people want to help. But there are many appeals out there and nobody is triaging them to make sure the really critical ones get seen and it's a toss-up whether something goes viral and rakes in plenty or is overlooked and fails. What can be done about that?

Well, one thing that can potentially be done about that is taxation, and a properly-administered benefits system. Two huge advantages. It prevents freeloading by the rich miser who doesn't contribute anything, leaving the burden of charity to others - essentially it spreads the charitable load equitably according to means rather than inequitably according to generosity - and it (in an ideal world) identifies where the critical need is and gets the money there. The diabetic gets his insulin before the little girl gets her Christmas present, I'm afraid.

And now we're going to have a pile-on by people who insist that this is theft and it should be entirely up to them who they want to give money to and if they want to let the diabetic guy die that's their right. Carry on.
And that, my friend, is rather strange. In effect, such an attitude is actually anti-christian. Only help one's neighbour if one happens to be in the mood? maybe?? So long as it has no impact on my comfortable life?

Is that really the message of jebus? I think not.
 
Yes by all means keep the news negative at every cost, feel good stories have no place in this "if it bleeds it leads" Society. Actually, that's not the kind of world I want to live in. I want to hear positive stories once in awhile.

News papers and TV? Ok Boomer.
 
The video touched on a crucial point. The man with type 1 diabetes who couldn't afford his insulin set up a go-fund-me page, and came up only $50 short. He died. The presenter pointed out that if the page had got more clicks, if there were more people who realised that only $50 would save this man's life, he would have got it. But that didn't happen.

People are generous, people are charitable, people want to help. But there are many appeals out there and nobody is triaging them to make sure the really critical ones get seen and it's a toss-up whether something goes viral and rakes in plenty or is overlooked and fails. What can be done about that?

Well, one thing that can potentially be done about that is taxation, and a properly-administered benefits system. Two huge advantages. It prevents freeloading by the rich miser who doesn't contribute anything, leaving the burden of charity to others - essentially it spreads the charitable load equitably according to means rather than inequitably according to generosity - and it (in an ideal world) identifies where the critical need is and gets the money there. The diabetic gets his insulin before the little girl gets her Christmas present, I'm afraid.

And now we're going to have a pile-on by people who insist that this is theft and it should be entirely up to them who they want to give money to and if they want to let the diabetic guy die that's their right. Carry on.

IIRC, he was an obese T2. And insulin is available in many places OTC. I've bought it for $24 at Walmart pharmacy. That would be $100/month. Unless his Rx was for a pen, then it cost literally 10 times as much. A Doc did that to me one month. Needles can be re-used for the same patient, if you are not concerned about giving yourself a germ from yourself if you stick yourself when you re-cap. And they only cost 25 cents. I use mine for a week or so. He died because he was stupid, not because he was poor.

He was making $35K. Working in a restaurant, his meals were free/cheap. How expensive is rent in St. Paul? What was he doing with his money?
 
Last edited:
The video says he was T1. Not the same case?

The article I read didn't say. But there was a follow on article about a different case, that did mention the individual being T1.

But the waters get muddied by "Insulin dependent T2", like me. True T1, which is an auto-imune disease, prevents insulin out put at all. T2 is "insulin resistance", and needs gobs of insulin to overcome the resistance by keeping the receptors flooded. T1 might only need 30 units/day, one $25 vial would last a month. T2 might need 200 units per day, $150/ month.

Those prices are for a quick acting, short lived type(Humalog in one brand, Novalog in the other) . 2 shots per day, at breakfast and dinner. Plus there is a slower, longer type, Humalin/Novalin. Twice per day also, morning and evening, but the two types can be mixed together for a total of 2 shots per day. And 70/30 pre-mixes are available too. The newer extra long lasting kind, in a pen, (Insulin for dummies) might cost umm 10 times as much. Lantus is one of those. But it does not lead to any better sugar control, does add to Big Pharma's bottom line.
 
I understand that, but there must still be people thinking: Why is that sort of thing necessary?


There are, but IME very, very few of them; and those who do are generally shouted down for being "Negative Nancys", cynics, killjoys, and generally accused of being misanthropic or "politicizing a personal tragedy".

Reporting of these sorts of stories is framed to prevent those sorts of questions from being asked, to distract from the wider failures of society and its broken social structures by "hitting the feels". To get people so caught up in pity and the vicarious experience of overcoming adversity, that they fail to ask why a company needs to run sad sack contests and food drives to support their employees, instead of just paying them a living wage out of the billions-of-dollars-per-year profits that they're making so these contests and food drives are unnecessary.
 
IIRC, he was an obese T2. And insulin is available in many places OTC. I've bought it for $24 at Walmart pharmacy. That would be $100/month. Unless his Rx was for a pen, then it cost literally 10 times as much. A Doc did that to me one month. Needles can be re-used for the same patient, if you are not concerned about giving yourself a germ from yourself if you stick yourself when you re-cap. And they only cost 25 cents. I use mine for a week or so. He died because he was stupid, not because he was poor. He was making $35K. Working in a restaurant, his meals were free/cheap. How expensive is rent in St. Paul? What was he doing with his money?

That escalated quickly based on your own speculation. In any event, you seem to be talking about this person who died from lack of insulin, not this one.
 
I understand the basic concern in the article, but don't these stories also help calling attention to exactly those shortcomings in society?

Hans


Yeah, but they also show these problems being solved and paint them as positives.

What they don't show is numerous other cases of a similar nature that ended badly because they didn't catch publicity or the person concerned was ugly or undesirable or there was nobody who knew about it who could spend x weeks fundraising without losing their job and their home.

For every 'aren't people generous, isn't it marvelous' there are many more cases where the person just died or suffered.
 
And Guide Dogs for the Blind have more money than God while geriatric mental healthcare charities barely get a bean.
 
And Guide Dogs for the Blind have more money than God while geriatric mental healthcare charities barely get a bean.

Guide dogs are cute. Old people with failing mental health are not.


Not that I'm telling you anything you don't already know.
 
I'm not sure they do. It's all in the framing.

The framing is almost never, "It's scandalous that a woman is being denied a kidney transplant because of lack of money, and heartbreaking that her child is trying to raise the money by selling lemonade when nobody can make $400,000 from a lemonade stand. The mother is going to die."

The framing is "Look at this wonderful kid, she's raised $1,000 from a lemonade stand to help her sick mother, isn't that heartwarming!"

That's why it made me think of this article I saw a while back. Victim derogation/blaming is well established in research on just world beliefs and system justification. There probably needs to be more research on victim enhancement to establish whether it it is replicable. The argument is that those who want to preserve a belief that people get what they deserve tend to engage in victim blaming when they can manage to find a trait in the victim that can appear to be causally related to the outcome. When this can't happen (as in the case of a child with a dying parent) victim enhancement is an alternative that serves the same function.
 
And Guide Dogs for the Blind have more money than God while geriatric mental healthcare charities barely get a bean.
Top 10 charities in the UK by fundraising

The top 10 charities by fundraising income (2010/11 ranking in brackets)
1 Cancer Research UK (1)*£446.5m raised out of a total income of £634.9m
2 British Heart Foundation (2)*£263.8m, £288.2m
3 Macmillan Cancer Support (6)*£214.1m, £218.4m
4 Oxfam (3)*£192.8m, £401.4m
5 Sightsavers (10)*£184.7m, £199.7m
6*RNLI*(4)*£170.9m, £190.1m
7*British Red Cross*(7)*£139.1m, £261.8m
8*Salvation Army*(9)*£130m, £196.3m
9*Save the Children*(13)*£125.3m, £370.3m
10 NSPCC (5)*£115.3m, £125.9m
 
That escalated quickly based on your own speculation. In any event, you seem to be talking about this person who died from lack of insulin, not this one.

Speculation or expertise? Have you ever bought your own insulin? I was buying my own for 15 years before I got health insurance. On income of less than $15k (1990 dollars). And paying for my own groceries.

The culprit in these two diabetic deaths is being sheeple and stupidly going along with doctor's orders. Doc gives you an Rx for an expensive 'pen', because he thinks you are too stoopid to use a syringe and vial. And you don't think to ask about a cheaper alternative. Because you are too stoopid to educate yourself. But they can spend their time on Facebook, and making Gofundmes. Instead of googleing <diabetes treatment>. I could buy enough insulin to kill a horse for the money they spent on their internet bills.

Unless you can prove which insulin they were on, YOU are the speculator.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom