Perseverence porn

I bet that you can find premature ejaculation porn without having to persevere for very long.
 
Perseverance porn, Inspiration porn, all the lot of it is just an attempt to distract ourselves from the fact that there are serious problems with our culture. The powers that be have learned how to use that to preserve a system that is responsible for creating or exacerbating the problem; a system which they directly benefit from.

It's nothing more than a way to avoid having to acknowledge harsh realities, and the need to take action against a system that is predicated on oppressing a great number of its members for the benefit of a tiny elite few. It's just another form of exploitation turned to entertainment.

Every rags-to-riches or community-rallies-to-help story demands the question "Why was this situation allowed to exist in the first place?"; but very few people bother to ask that question, and even fewer propose any workable solution to it or put in the effort to change it.
 
Perseverance porn, Inspiration porn, all the lot of it is just an attempt to distract ourselves from the fact that there are serious problems with our culture. The powers that be have learned how to use that to preserve a system that is responsible for creating or exacerbating the problem; a system which they directly benefit from.

It's nothing more than a way to avoid having to acknowledge harsh realities, and the need to take action against a system that is predicated on oppressing a great number of its members for the benefit of a tiny elite few. It's just another form of exploitation turned to entertainment.

Every rags-to-riches or community-rallies-to-help story demands the question "Why was this situation allowed to exist in the first place?"; but very few people bother to ask that question, and even fewer propose any workable solution to it or put in the effort to change it.

Are you new? This is how civilizations have always behaved, right back to the beginning. Religion. Epic poems. Bread and circuses. Salvation in the afterlife. Those in power have always taken advantage of distracting the masses with wish fulfillment nonsense. At least reading crap online is less physically challenging than building a ziggurut, so the moderns are coming out ahead on it.
 
Are you new? This is how civilizations have always behaved, right back to the beginning. Religion. Epic poems. Bread and circuses. Salvation in the afterlife. Those in power have always taken advantage of distracting the masses with wish fulfillment nonsense. At least reading crap online is less physically challenging than building a ziggurut, so the moderns are coming out ahead on it.


Oh well, since it's always been that way, then there's clearly no point in doing anything about it. Nice to see that you've solved the problem of social inequality, racial oppression, sexual discrimination and assault, etc. etc. etc. Just sit back, relax, consume, don't think, don't act. I can rest easy now knowing that the status quo is the one true god.
 
Oh well, since it's always been that way, then there's clearly no point in doing anything about it. Nice to see that you've solved the problem of social inequality, racial oppression, sexual discrimination and assault, etc. etc. etc. Just sit back, relax, consume, don't think, don't act. I can rest easy now knowing that the status quo is the one true god.

Yeah, that's so what I said.

Feel free to fix civilization and/or human nature. Can you get it done by Saturday? I've got a garage sale and I think a utopian society of enlightened sages would pay top dollar for my dad's old garden tools.
 
Yeah, that's so what I said.


Given your next paragraph, yeah it certainly seems to be.

Feel free to fix civilization and/or human nature. Can you get it done by Saturday? I've got a garage sale and I think a utopian society of enlightened sages would pay top dollar for my dad's old garden tools.


So, since we can't change everything, we shouldn't change anything? I guess everyone should just shut the hell up about how messed up the world is because no one can change anything. And we sure as hell shouldn't talk about how screwed up it is unless we have an easy and infalliable plan to fix everything by teatime. Whatever was I thinking. Are you one of those people slagging off, say, Greta Thunburg or David Hogg? After all, they clearly have no plan to fix the world on the timeline you're demanding, so what the hell are they blithering on about?
 
Are you new? This is how civilizations have always behaved, right back to the beginning. Religion. Epic poems. Bread and circuses. Salvation in the afterlife. Those in power have always taken advantage of distracting the masses with wish fulfillment nonsense. At least reading crap online is less physically challenging than building a ziggurut, so the moderns are coming out ahead on it.
I hope this civilization might be adjusting to new experiences, fingers crossed.

Just because every previous civilization behaved as you said, does not mean that every future civilization will behave as you said.

After all, every previous civilization never got to the level of this one, we are at the frontier of civilizations, we can lead the way.
 
Last edited:
Given your next paragraph, yeah it certainly seems to be.

So, since we can't change everything, we shouldn't change anything?

If I had to guess what TM meant....

One can simultaneously admire the bravery of the firefighters while regretting that there was a fire at all. You don't have to make a single judgment of what the best possible situation would have been, and then issue letter grades to all the participants based on how close they came to the ideal.
 
They are filler stories.

Either filling blanks space in news papers or fluffy news items on the TV.

They save them up, as they can be shown in a few days time.

It is for slow news days when nothing much happens.

We get hit with the US ones on the main TV news at weekends all the time as not much happens at the weekend in NZ and they need to put something in.

Normally the same bloke reporter with a soppy voice all the time (can't remember who it is).

"Stray cat makes sick kid his pal. Kid looks better"

That sort of thing.

The examples in the OP are particularly patronising, but same thing.
 
Last edited:
I guess I see these things differently.

The little girl selling lemonade is uplifting in that a child is confronted with a problem and does what she can to help, even if the result is insignificant to the scope of the problem. That's admirable. But the story also highlights the problem: medical care expenses make treatments unavailable for the non-wealthy/uninsured. This is made obvious just by telling the story of the little girl and why she's out there. There's kind of an implication that she shouldn't have to be out there selling lemonade. I don't think anyone sees that story and says: "Well, healthcare solved!"

The bravery of firefighters fighting fires started by arson is something to celebrate. But telling the story also highlights the fact that arson is a problem and, like the little girl, the firefighters should not have needed to be there fighting that particular fire. No one watches the story and says: "Arson is not a problem!"

We shouldn't need St. Jude's or Home Depot employees or robotics classes to provide mobility for disabled children. But until the larger problem is solved, it is a good thing that people do what they can to address the smaller individual problems. You can celebrate when people in the community do so without ignoring why the help is needed in the first place.

We are all confronted with problems at some point we shouldn't have to face. Reporting positively on those who do what they can to solve the short term immediate problem does not "distract" from the larger problem. It highlights it, just in a more subtle way.
 
I guess I see these things differently.

The little girl selling lemonade is uplifting in that a child is confronted with a problem and does what she can to help, even if the result is insignificant to the scope of the problem. That's admirable. But the story also highlights the problem: medical care expenses make treatments unavailable for the non-wealthy/uninsured. This is made obvious just by telling the story of the little girl and why she's out there. There's kind of an implication that she shouldn't have to be out there selling lemonade. I don't think anyone sees that story and says: "Well, healthcare solved!"
.

No one says exactly "healthcare solved", but relying on individuals to find their own stopgap solutions rather than letting legislation tackle big problems where markets fail is the name of the game.

Sure they know healthcare costs are an issue, but the GOP's general position is that the solution is to get government out of the way and let individuals solve their own problems, like the lemonade stand etc. While they can't be so bold to say that lemonade stands will solve healthcare, there is an implicit idea that the solution to healthcare lies in individual elbow grease and sacrifice along the same lines as these feel good stories.

In another world (and for other issues) I think I could enjoy stories of how individuals triumph over their difficult problems. But in the US, we live in the world where there is a very powerful push that these kinds of individual acts are the virtuous alternative to legislation.
 
Puppy Pays for Own Cancer Treatment by Walking Five Hours in Snow to Minimum Wage Job

Some More News (Dec. 4, 2019):
The Dystopian Reality Of All Those "Inspirational" Stories:
 
I understand the basic concern in the article, but don't these stories also help calling attention to exactly those shortcomings in society?

Hans
 
I'm not sure they do. It's all in the framing.

The framing is almost never, "It's scandalous that a woman is being denied a kidney transplant because of lack of money, and heartbreaking that her child is trying to raise the money by selling lemonade when nobody can make $400,000 from a lemonade stand. The mother is going to die."

The framing is "Look at this wonderful kid, she's raised $1,000 from a lemonade stand to help her sick mother, isn't that heartwarming!"
 
The video touched on a crucial point. The man with type 1 diabetes who couldn't afford his insulin set up a go-fund-me page, and came up only $50 short. He died. The presenter pointed out that if the page had got more clicks, if there were more people who realised that only $50 would save this man's life, he would have got it. But that didn't happen.

People are generous, people are charitable, people want to help. But there are many appeals out there and nobody is triaging them to make sure the really critical ones get seen and it's a toss-up whether something goes viral and rakes in plenty or is overlooked and fails. What can be done about that?

Well, one thing that can potentially be done about that is taxation, and a properly-administered benefits system. Two huge advantages. It prevents freeloading by the rich miser who doesn't contribute anything, leaving the burden of charity to others - essentially it spreads the charitable load equitably according to means rather than inequitably according to generosity - and it (in an ideal world) identifies where the critical need is and gets the money there. The diabetic gets his insulin before the little girl gets her Christmas present, I'm afraid.

And now we're going to have a pile-on by people who insist that this is theft and it should be entirely up to them who they want to give money to and if they want to let the diabetic guy die that's their right. Carry on.
 
I'm not sure they do. It's all in the framing.

The framing is almost never, "It's scandalous that a woman is being denied a kidney transplant because of lack of money, and heartbreaking that her child is trying to raise the money by selling lemonade when nobody can make $400,000 from a lemonade stand. The mother is going to die."

The framing is "Look at this wonderful kid, she's raised $1,000 from a lemonade stand to help her sick mother, isn't that heartwarming!"

I understand that, but there must still be people thinking: Why is that sort of thing necessary?

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom