Opinion: turn the US into a fascist state ASAP

Turn the US into a dictatorship if the following conditions are true?

  • Yes

    Votes: 4 9.5%
  • You are insane.

    Votes: 34 81.0%
  • Planet X thinks yo - see above

    Votes: 4 9.5%

  • Total voters
    42
The US has survived low quality presidents before and it will continue to do so. The quality is not getting worse, it's never really been that high to begin with. We've had a lot more mediocre or worse presidents than good or great ones.

For one thing if one believes that the presidents that have been impeached or come closest to being impeached (regardless of individual opinion about the merit of impeachment) are Johnson, Nixon, Clinton, and Bush/Cheney then that would mean that 75% of the most impeachable presidents occurred in a time frame that is only the most recent 11% of American history.

Another objective measure is the rate at which candidates are closely related to previous presidents. You can not call it a coincidence that the first time in US history that a president's son claims the presidency occurs in the exact same small time time period that the leading opposition candidate is the first candidate in history that is the wife of a former president. The odds of immediate family members of recent previous presidents claiming the presidency twice in this time period can be objectively measured and compared to the odds of the rate of impeachment in this time period.

Thirdly, decreasing quality of presidents and elections can be objectively measured by the factors which cause them to be elected, which are all more meticulously documented than they ever have been. Do you dispute that the factors that cause the available selection of candidates and the factors that then cause Americans to vote for a candidate is worse now than it ever has been? The most common reason cited why people support Obama is 'personal charisma' while the most common reason cited for Thompson is what's been described as his 'commanding presence' as viewable in his tv show appearances, the two most stupid and dangerous reasons possible. It would not have been possible for these qualities to even be very assessable to the public in the past, before tv.

Those are three fairly undisputable ways it can be measured that the American system of government is producing worse leaders and policies than ever before.
 
Last edited:
For one thing if one believes that the presidents that have been impeached or come closest to being impeached (regardless of individual opinion about the merit of impeachment) are Johnson, Nixon, Clinton, and Bush/Cheney then that would mean that 75% of the most impeachable presidents occurred in a time frame that is only the most recent 11% of American history.
Nope. All it means is that 75% of the impeachment attempts occurred within the last 11% of American history. Assuming your numbers are correct, of course.

Another objective measure is the rate at which candidates are closely related to previous presidents. You can not call it a coincidence that the first time in US history that a president's son claims the presidency occurs in the exact same small time time period that the leading opposition candidate is the first candidate in history that is the wife of a former president. The odds of immediate family members of recent previous presidents claiming the presidency twice in this time period can be objectively measured and compared to the odds of the rate of impeachment in this time period.
It's not just the first time in American history that the wife of a former president becomes a leading candidate, it's also the first time in American history a woman is likely to win the presidency! What are the odds of that? Add on top of that, for the first time in American history a black candidate is a serious contender for the job as well. Imagine that, both first woman and first black! Multiply it all and you get absolutely impossible odds! I think I've just proven god's existence!

Numerology is teh fun, I tell ya.

Thirdly, decreasing quality of presidents and elections can be objectively measured by the factors which cause them to be elected, which are all more meticulously documented than they ever have been.
The weighing of these factors is hardly going to be objective.

It would not have been possible for these qualities to even be very assessable to the public in the past, before tv.
Mass media has indeed changed the rules of the game. I don't know if it's possible to objectively quantify the factors that led to a president's election in the past and now, though.

Those are three fairly undisputable ways it can be measured that the American system of government is producing worse leaders and policies than ever before.
You have not demonstrated anything like that.

Besides, I find your whole logic rather silly:
  1. Recent presidents didn't quite adhere to your standards
  2. You propose to switch to a system of government that will make sure the president adheres to nobody's standards
  3. WTF?
 
I hope you don't mind, LA but I'm going to start a new thread on this topic. I'll give you the credit. They way the question is worded is confusing. It sounds like you are asking if we should turn the US into a fascist state rather than are these the preliminary conditions. I would guess that was the limitation of the character limit in wording the question? I've run into that before.

Anyway, I'm taking back my answer and reversing my opinion about your sanity. All because I heard author, Naomi Wolf, talk about her book, "The End of America: Letter of Warning To A Young Patriot", which outlines 10 steps which in history preceded the development of fascists states.

So, I'll start the thread and edit in a link here.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=3050719#post3050719
 
Last edited:
Nothing like USA=fascist! spam, eh, skeptigirl? Kind of like the sheep chorus in Animal Farm; hoping bto win by simply repeating oneself a million times, no matter how inanely.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom