Opinion: turn the US into a fascist state ASAP

Turn the US into a dictatorship if the following conditions are true?

  • Yes

    Votes: 4 9.5%
  • You are insane.

    Votes: 34 81.0%
  • Planet X thinks yo - see above

    Votes: 4 9.5%

  • Total voters
    42
Joined
Aug 4, 2006
Messages
926
If one believes that:

1. America's democratic process is deteriorating,

2. the US is slowly turning authoritarian,

3. the quality of presidential candidates is getting worse, producing presidents who are increasingly extreme, damaging, and less and less law abiding,

4. that there is no foreseeable event or trend which will cause major change to the election process and will save America's democracy

5. and at a certain point sometime in the not too distant future the country will be stuck with a permanent leader who will be more evil and damaging than the current leaders are


then would the best way to maintain the country's system of government, ability of it's leadership, and potential to change, be to halt the democratic process making a dictator out of whoever's in charge?

That leadership would then either attempt to slowly restore the health of the democratic process or would be fought against in a revolution by rebels who wanted to restore a functioning democracy. In the latter scenario it would be easier to fight against a less evil dictatorship so it would be better if that conflict happened sooner rather than later.

The same reason why it would've been a good thing if Hindenburg turned Germany into a dictatorship before the 1930s and the same reason why it's a good thing Musharraf keeps Pakistan from getting more extreme under an Islamist form of government is increasingly applicable to the US too if the momentum of current politics isn't reversed.

The point of contention I allow is that there's uncertainty about #4, but if the probability of #4 being true is over 60% then my opinion would be not to rely and act on it.
 
Last edited:
You have to look at long-term trends.

#1 is not really true compared to pre-1860, or before women's suffrage, or before the Civil Rights movement. I contend that most major trends are in fact moving in the right direction in the long run. It's just slow and there are occasional setbacks.
 
America's democratic process is deteriorating...
I think if you look around you'll find other democratic nations are having similar issues.

the US is slowly turning authoritarian...
I think an exact definition of what you mean by authoritarian might be helpful here. I can see some variance in how people might interpret that term.

the quality of presidential candidates is getting worse, producing presidents who are increasingly extreme, damaging, and less and less law abiding[...
This presumes that it was better in the past. Was it? Also, again, I think you'll find there are other countries also struggling with the quality of their candidates.

that there is no foreseeable event or trend which will cause major change to the election process and will save America's democracy...
I'll have to let those much more educated than I on the politics of America's past chime in. My understanding is that American politics in earlier years was often every bit as partisan and nasty as is claimed to be these days.

and at a certain point sometime in the not too distant future the country will be stuck with a permanent leader who will be more evil and damaging than the current leaders are...
I think the United States is about the last country on Earth where that would happen.
 
The Origins of the American Military Coup of 2012

Some people think it will be a charsmatic general who the people turn to when things go bad. This paper was written about the time that Colin Powell's popularity was at its peak.

From the introduction:

The letter that follows takes us on a darkly imagined excursion into the future. A military coup has taken place in the United States--the year is 2012--and General Thomas E. T. Brutus, Commander-in-Chief of the Unified Armed Forces of the United States, now occupies the White House as permanent Military Plenipotentiary. His position has been ratified by a national referendum, though scattered disorders still prevail and arrests for acts of sedition are underway.

A senior retired officer of the Unified Armed Forces, known here simply as Prisoner 222305759, is one of those arrested, having been convicted by court-martial for opposing the coup. Prior to his execution, he is able to smuggle out of prison a letter to an old War College classmate discussing the "Origins of the American Military Coup of 2012." In it, he argues that the coup was the outgrowth of trends visible as far back as 1992. These trends were the massive diversion of military forces to civilian uses, the monolithic unification of the armed forces, and the insularity of the military community. His letter survives and is here presented verbatim.

It goes without saying (I hope) that the coup scenario above is purely a literary device intended to dramatize my concern over certain contemporary developments affecting the armed forces, and is emphatically not a prediction. -- The Author


DR
 
5. and at a certain point sometime in the not too distant future the country will be stuck with a permanent leader

As this amounts to the definition of dictatorship, your poll is meaningless. The only possible answer would be "yes".

The same reason why it would've been a good thing if Hindenburg turned Germany into a dictatorship before the 1930s and the same reason why it's a good thing Musharraf keeps Pakistan from getting more extreme under an Islamist form of government is increasingly applicable to the US too if the momentum of current politics isn't reversed.

Er, Hindenburg did turn Germany into a dictatorship. He signed the Ermächtigungsgesetz (Enabling Act of 1933WP). And no, I don't think Musharraf's dictatorship is a good thing in the long run, just because it keeps the Islamist extremists at bay now.
 
I'll have to let those much more educated than I on the politics of America's past chime in. My understanding is that American politics in earlier years was often every bit as partisan and nasty as is claimed to be these days

Politics today in the US is nastier then usual,but not nastier then it has been several times in the past.
Or More corrupt. Boss Tweed would make the most corrupt ,dirtiest politican today seem like an bumbling amateur.
Of the OP's original points the one about the lack of quality Presidental candidates is IMHO the most valid,and that is not a constitutional issue. It has to do with the political process has become so trying that a lot of qualified people don't want anything to do with it.
ANd the whole idea of the "benevolent tyrant" is hopelessly flawed. "Power Corrupts" is one of the great rules of history.
And the same goes for a varient,the Rule Of A Small Elite.
 
As this amounts to the definition of dictatorship, your poll is meaningless. The only possible answer would be "yes".



Er, Hindenburg did turn Germany into a dictatorship. He signed the Ermächtigungsgesetz (Enabling Act of 1933WP). And no, I don't think Musharraf's dictatorship is a good thing in the long run, just because it keeps the Islamist extremists at bay now.

But what I meant was that it would have been a good thing if Hindenburg made himself dictator (barring bizarre time travel accidents) or restored the monarchy, halting Germany's deteriorating democratic process which was steadily handing everything over to lawless mad men. My conclusion is that something like that is happening in America. Giuliani is far more dangerous than Bush because he shares much of Bush's idealogy but is much smarter, ambitious, and less sane.

Also, that article says that Hindenburg signed into law the act that the Reichstag voted for with the needed 2/3 majority.

Incidentally Hindenburg certainly didn't want Hitler to become Chancellor much less dictator:

In October 1931, Hindenburg and Hitler had their first meeting. The Hindenburg-Hitler meeting was a disaster as both men took an immediate and immense dislike to one another. In private, Hindenburg disparagingly referred to Hitler as "that Austrian corporal", "the Bohemian corporal" and sometimes just simply as "the corporal". Hitler in turn, often described Hindenburg as "that old fool" and "the old reactionary". Right up until January 1933, Hindenburg often stated that he would never appoint Hitler as Chancellor under any circumstances. On 26 January 1933, Hindenburg told a group of his friends: "Gentlemen, I hope you will not hold me capable of appointing this Austrian corporal to be Reich Chancellor".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_von_Hindenburg
 
But what I meant was that it would have been a good thing if Hindenburg made himself dictator (barring bizarre time travel accidents) or restored the monarchy, halting Germany's deteriorating democratic process which was steadily handing everything over to lawless mad men.
At his age, Hindenburg was way too weak to make himself dictator. Remember that he died the year after Hitler became chancellor. And even if it had been possible, I don't think it'd have helped much. Another coup or revolution would have been the likely outcome. As always, the problem with a dictatorship is that it's only good as long as you get to choose the dictator.

My conclusion is that something like that is happening in America. Giuliani is far more dangerous than Bush because he shares much of Bush's idealogy but is much smarter, ambitious, and less sane.
If you think so. If I were American I might even consider to vote for the guy.

Also, that article says that Hindenburg signed into law the act that the Reichstag voted for with the needed 2/3 majority.
Yes, he signed it into law, even though it was his duty to make sure that no unconstitutional laws were passed. And the Reichstag vote was a farce. All communist deputies and more than twenty socialists had already been rounded up or were in hiding. The rules were changed so that absent deputies were considered present.

Incidentally Hindenburg certainly didn't want Hitler to become Chancellor much less dictator:
Yes, Hindenburg disliked Hitler, not least because of Hitler's lack of pedigree. In the end he gave in to the pressure of Papen and his son. Again, this exemplifies the weakness of Hindenburg in his final years.
 
Hindenburg was ALWAYS only a stuffed shirt and a name for others to use as a symbol.

Even the Battle of Tannenberg, the event that made him first famous, shows that; he was only chosen as CO because of his petty-aristocratic connections, and one of the German central-command higher officers used to say to visitors looking at the battlefield afterwards,
"This is where General Hindenburg slept before the battle.
This is where General Hindenburg slept after the battle.




And this is where General Hindenburg slept during the battle."
 
Last edited:
(SNIP)... would the best way to maintain the country's system of government, ability of it's leadership, and potential to change, be to halt the democratic process making a dictator out of whoever's in charge?

Sounds like Viet Nam War era philosophy -- destroy the village in order to save it. And look where that way of thinking got us.
 
then would the best way to maintain the country's system of government, ability of it's leadership, and potential to change, be to halt the democratic process making a dictator out of whoever's in charge?

Wouldn't halting the democratic process pretty much mean you've stopped maintaining the country's system of government?

That leadership would then either attempt to slowly restore the health of the democratic process or would be fought against in a revolution by rebels who wanted to restore a functioning democracy. In the latter scenario it would be easier to fight against a less evil dictatorship so it would be better if that conflict happened sooner rather than later.

The point of contention I allow is that there's uncertainty about #4, but if the probability of #4 being true is over 60% then my opinion would be not to rely and act on it.

If I'm reading the first part correctly, the benefit of this is that it might be easier to rebel against a nicer dictator rather than against a worse one down the road, but since you've given me up to a 40% chance that there could be an event or trend to save America's democracy, wouldn't it be even easier to work for such a thing and save the day now when the system pretty much allows you to?

Where I find myself now there has been a trend towards military regimes establishing themselves based on this premise of restoring healthy democracies once corruption and broken systems have been fixed. Here, Thailand, Pakistan, there's a good question of whether this will come to pass or not. (I won't put my guesses down for any of these states, it's still a very open issue for all). I will say that it's easier to work for change and keep a government healthy if you don't have to try doing it under the barrel of a gun.
 
Originally Posted by latent aaaack
and at a certain point sometime in the not too distant future the country will be stuck with a permanent leader who will be more evil and damaging than the current leaders are..."

I think the United States is about the last country on Earth where that would happen.

I'm talking about a time span of at least one decade away. I'm expressing a strong suspicion not a belief but history has repetitively seen truth become stranger than fiction. Already within the last several decades of the twentieth century much of America's societal values were turned on their head. You really can't imagine the country's political values being turned on it's head in a similar time frame even when it can be seen to have already begun? I hope it's a false start too but that seems like a position of faith.

http://archive.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2003/11/20/185048.shtml

[FONT=arial,helvetica]Gen. Franks Doubts Constitution Will Survive WMD Attack[/FONT]

....In the magazine’s December edition, the former commander of the military’s Central Command warned that if terrorists succeeded in using a weapon of mass destruction (WMD) against the U.S. or one of our allies, it would likely have catastrophic consequences for our cherished republican form of government.
Discussing the hypothetical dangers posed to the U.S. in the wake of Sept. 11, Franks said that “the worst thing that could happen” is if terrorists acquire and then use a biological, chemical or nuclear weapon that inflicts heavy casualties. If that happens, Franks said, “... the Western world, the free world, loses what it cherishes most, and that is freedom and liberty we’ve seen for a couple of hundred years in this grand experiment that we call democracy....”
 
Last edited:
I really thought I spelled 'fascist' correctly until I re-read it just now.

Wouldn't halting the democratic process pretty much mean you've stopped maintaining the country's system of government?





If I'm reading the first part correctly, the benefit of this is that it might be easier to rebel against a nicer dictator rather than against a worse one down the road, but since you've given me up to a 40% chance that there could be an event or trend to save America's democracy, wouldn't it be even easier to work for such a thing and save the day now when the system pretty much allows you to?

Where I find myself now there has been a trend towards military regimes establishing themselves based on this premise of restoring healthy democracies once corruption and broken systems have been fixed. Here, Thailand, Pakistan, there's a good question of whether this will come to pass or not. (I won't put my guesses down for any of these states, it's still a very open issue for all). I will say that it's easier to work for change and keep a government healthy if you don't have to try doing it under the barrel of a gun.

Hi, welcome to the board.

In a scenario where US democracy is de-evolving and producing increasingly dangerous leaders, stopping the democratic process would stop the leadership from getting any worse. I believe that would also give democracy the best chance of coming back too, since these dictatorial leaders and their system of government would be less evil than future more extreme leaders and their system of government. It would be the difference between trying to instill democracy into a pre WW1 style German monarchy over time versus in Nazi controlled Germany. Or the difference in difficulty between trying to instill democracy in Musharraf's Pakistan versus trying to do so in the Taliban style government which would result from giving Pakistan full voting rights now.

I agree that it would be ideal to fix what's causing democracy to de-evolve now but that would take radical action and radical action is always taken only after its learned the hard way that it's needed and America (and arguably other countries) haven't learned the hard way yet, only through relatively small debacles like Iraq and Katrina. The current president is the sperm of the last president before the former one and the leading opposition candidate is the wife of the former president, the leading Republican candidates are all more extreme and more different/unrepresentative/bat-dropping insane than most Americans than the current president is and yet most Americans still think elections mean they're choosing who gets put in power and that they don't need to resist as the basis of their freedom is taken away.

It would be hard enough convincing Americans that what's right in front of their eyes is an incendiary danger to them, convincing them to agree and vote on a radical solution in advance of the danger seems nearly impossible. But turning the US into a dictatorship within the next few years also is nearly impossible, but since it's going to happen anyway and the population is already being primed for and warmed to it, it's less impossible. As long as information and education, specifically world history, isn't outlawed then democracy will grow back. Germany would still most likely be a democracy now if Hindenburg had restored the monarchy and dissolved the Reichstag before they could vote Hitler into power. Even if Hindenburg or a newly appointed monarch had executed thousands of dissidents in the process it would still have prevented WW2.
 
Last edited:
Even if Hindenburg or a newly appointed monarch had executed thousands of dissidents in the process it would still have prevented WW2.

Horse apples.

WW II was already underway, in 1937, between Japan and China, and Stalin's ambitions were not going to be influenced by whatever Hindenberg did.

DR
 
3. the quality of presidential candidates is getting worse, producing presidents who are increasingly extreme, damaging, and less and less law abiding,

The US has survived low quality presidents before and it will continue to do so. The quality is not getting worse, it's never really been that high to begin with. We've had a lot more mediocre or worse presidents than good or great ones.
 
...since these dictatorial leaders and their system of government would be less evil than future more extreme leaders and their system of government...

So you're saying that a pre-emptive strike against possible future extremist leaders and the installation of a dictatorship is a better alternative that trying to address it through the current system?

You have very little faith in the American people. While the history of America is replete with swings from one extreme to the other, America has always pulled back from the edge.

And this illusion that current presidents have been more extreme than in the past is just that, an illusion. Lincoln suspended habeas corpus, Roosevelt interred hundreds of thousands of American citizens just because of their ancestry.

ETA: Please give me one example where a dictatorship has been less evil than the current situation in America?
 
So you're saying that a pre-emptive strike against possible future extremist leaders and the installation of a dictatorship is a better alternative that trying to address it through the current system?

You have very little faith in the American people. While the history of America is replete with swings from one extreme to the other, America has always pulled back from the edge.

And this illusion that current presidents have been more extreme than in the past is just that, an illusion. Lincoln suspended habeas corpus, Roosevelt interred hundreds of thousands of American citizens just because of their ancestry.

ETA: Please give me one example where a dictatorship has been less evil than the current situation in America?
Before any of the usual suspects respond, I'll toss out Cuba under Castro as the obvious choice of Utopian, non American, idyllic island life. (With cigars like that, how can one complain about one's lot in life, I ask? :cool: )

Ah, the popcorn is just about ready, this ought to be fun.

DR
 
I'm talking about a time span of at least one decade away.
Doesn't matter if it's ten years or a hundred, the U.S. is still about the last country on Earth that would turn into a dictatorship.

Already within the last several decades of the twentieth century much of America's societal values were turned on their head.
Now this is an interesting statement. What exactly do you mean by "societal values"? How have they been turned on their head? Care to expand upon this point of yours?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom