Ontario to ban smoking in cars with children under 16 present

A few other media outlets' reports on the story:

CBC News
CTV News
The Toronto Star
The Globe & Mail

In terms of punishment for the offence, here is what The Toronto Star reports (and the other linked reports mention much the same thing):

The legislation is expected to provide for maximum fines of $200, and to include a public education campaign.
In other words, no arrests for the offence itself, you get a ticket.
 
Suppose a person lights a cigarette in Quebec province and then drives into Ontario while it is still burning. With kids in the car, of course. That was a legally lit cigarette under Quebec law, is it grandfathered under Ontario law until that border-crossing cigarette is extinguished?
 
Well if the idea is to protect kids at all costs then why are they letting the kids into cars at all. People get into accidents driving around in their cars all the time. If a parent is driving along with their kids in their car and they get sideswiped by a drunk driver then we need to punish both the drunk driver and the parent in the car the drunk driver hit. The drunk driver is punished for driving drunk and the parent is punished for endangering their kids by having them in a car that might get hit by a drunk driver.

Kids still need to be conveyed from one location to another however so we need to establish a system to do this. For example here is how the kids will get to school:

The kids wake up in the morning in a hermetically sealed room (to keep out any possible contaminants and germs) wash up with water from a special water supply for kids only (this water supply is more rigorously inspected and regulated) and are given food provided by the government (to ensure that the kids' food is safe and nutritious) by their parents who must wear hazmat suits (because adults may themselves have germs) and can only speak to their children using government approved words in government approved phrases. After this is done the kids proceed down a sealed corridor to an airlock that is constantly slightly over pressurized. A special hermetically sealed bus pulls up and extends a sealed tube that connects to the airlock allowing the kids access to the bus without being exposed to the dangers of outside air. The bus then takes them to their airtight, completely underground, school on a special highway reserved only for buses with kids on board. Of course all school sports would be banned because a kid may hurt themselves playing sports and as this smoking ban shows we need to make anything that may in anyway potentially ever bring any harm to any child be completely illegal..... for the good of the kids.
 
Last edited:
I hear that some Canadians let their kids go down steep hills in sleds! How crazy is that! Those parents ougt to have their kids taken away until they're re-educated.
 
Well if the idea is to protect kids at all costs then why are they letting the kids into cars at all. People get into accidents driving around in their cars all the time. If a parent is driving along with their kids in their car and they get sideswiped by a drunk driver then we need to punish both the drunk driver and the parent in the car the drunk driver hit. The drunk driver is punished for driving drunk and the parent is punished for endangering their kids by having them in a car that might get hit by a drunk driver.

Kids still need to be conveyed from one location to another however so we need to establish a system to do this. For example here is how the kids will get to school:

The kids wake up in the morning in a hermetically sealed room (to keep out any possible contaminants and germs) wash up with water from a special water supply for kids only (this water supply is more rigorously inspected and regulated) and are given food provided by the government (to insure that kids' food is safe and nutritious) by their parents who must wear hazmat suits (because adults may themselves have germs) and can only speak to their children using government approved words in government approved phrases. After this is done the kids proceed down a sealed corridor to an airlock that is constantly slightly over pressurized. A special hermetically sealed bus pulls up and extends a sealed tube that connects to the airlock allowing the kids access to the bus without being exposed to the dangers of outside air. The bus then takes them to their airtight, completely underground, school on a special highway reserved only for buses with kids on board. Of course all school sports would be banned because a kid may hurt themselves playing sports and as this smoking ban shows we need to make anything that may in anyway potentially ever bring any harm to any child be completely illegal..... for the good of the kids.

Um, careful: when you pile up THAT many strawmen you'd better make sure you don't smoke--you'll likely set the whole internet on fire.

How is the decision to protect children from ONE well-documented health risk the same as saying that we need to protect children from ALL POSSIBLE risks?

Like I said in my first post: why is it that the people opposed to these regulations rely strictly on patently absurd arguments? If you think that personal liberty trumps X-degree of increased risk to a child's health, why aren't you willing to just say that? As I say, it's not a claim that can be proven wrong.

For example, I think marijuana should be legal, even though I think it can be proven that in general it is healthier not to smoke marijuana than to smoke it (and I don't smoke it--FYI). I think people should have the liberty to make that choice, despite the fact that it might harm them. I think children should be allowed to ride skateboards, even though it is patently obvious that they're safer if they don't ride them. I think the liberty to engage in fun-but-risky behavior in that case outweighs the evident non-zero risk of serious injury or death. I don't think that a smoker's liberty outweighs someone else's right to a smoke-free environment, so I support this law. I don't think a smoker should smoke inside a house where there are children, either, but I would oppose making a law to that effect because it would be unenforceable, and unenforceable laws are never a good idea.

So...those are some of my opinions. If enough people agree with me about where these lines should be drawn we'll tend to elect representatives who vote along these lines in passing legislation. If enough of us agree throughout the country, measures like these will become the law of the land. That's democracy at work.

Why this would be likely to result in laws that try to enforce a "0 risk at all occasions" policy is pretty hard to understand.
 
Some other Canadian parents also let their kids - I kid you not - travel at high speeds over slippery ice with sharp metal blades attached to their feet, while swinging sticks!

Won't someone think of the children!
 
Last edited:
Some other Canadian parents also let their kids - I kid you not - travel at high speeds over slippery ice with sharp metal blades attached to their feet, while swinging sticks!

Won't someone think of the children!

Show us the potential benefits for a child of being in a car with a smoker and you might have a point, rather than a tired and self-evidently absurd slippery-slope fallacy.

No parent is unaware that letting a child play ice-hockey involves a risk to the child's health. They also think that it provides an opportunity for the child to have fun, to develop useful social and physical skills, to exercise and develop their bodies, and to become more confident. They weigh the risks against the benefits, and decide that the benefits outweigh the risks.

Now, again: what were those benefits of being in a small enclosed space with a demonstrated carcinogen again?

By the way: it's illegal for children in the US or Canada to go car-surfing. Is that absurd nanny-statism that will lead to the banning of tobogganing, or a reasonable weighing of risks and benefits? How do you make the distinction?
 
Show us the potential benefits for a child of being in a car with a smoker and you might have a point, rather than a tired and self-evidently absurd slippery-slope fallacy.
How many Canadian children have suffered injuries from second-hand smoke exposure in cars?
 
Second hand smoke is bad for children (and adults)
Among the recognised health risks: glue ear, asthma, bronchial harm.
 
So...those are some of my opinions. If enough people agree with me about where these lines should be drawn we'll tend to elect representatives who vote along these lines in passing legislation. If enough of us agree throughout the country, measures like these will become the law of the land. That's democracy at work.


Wow! You're not Merikan, are you?

That was a breath of fresh air after having been reading some of the stuff the Merikans think about government in general and their own government in particular.

Sigh.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Second hand smoke is bad for children (and adults)
Among the recognised health risks: glue ear, asthma, bronchial harm.
A hockey skate across your neck is bad for adults and children. A hockey stick across your shin is bad for adults and children. A puck hitting a face at 100 km/hr is bad for children.

How many children are sick in Canada from secondhand smoke exposure in cars?

Or is this all about making yourselves feel good at the expense of a minority (smokers), while ignoring real, quantifiable risks that are popular?

Why not make kids play floor hockey (no running allowed!) with light plastic sticks and foam balls instead of pucks?
 
Wow! You're not Merikan, are you?

That was a breath of fresh air after having been reading some of the stuff the Merikans think about government in general and their own government in particular.

Sigh.

Rolfe.
Why do you insist on using derogatory names for [Americans? Should I feel free to simply refer to the British here as Limeys from now on?
 
Last edited:
A hockey skate across your neck is bad for adults and children. A hockey stick across your shin is bad for adults and children. A puck hitting a face at 100 km/hr is bad for children.

How many children are sick in Canada from secondhand smoke exposure in cars?

Or is this all about making yourselves feel good at the expense of a minority (smokers), while ignoring real, quantifiable risks that are popular?

Why not make kids play floor hockey (no running allowed!) with light plastic sticks and foam balls instead of pucks?

Cigarettes, when used as intended, are harmful.
Hockey gear, when used as intended, is not harmful.
It is silly to suggest that cigarettes do not bear real quantifiable risks. The risks have been thoroughly identified and well documented for years.
Your argument is specious.
Refer to Yoink's earlier post: I can't put it better than that.
 
Um, careful: when you pile up THAT many strawmen you'd better make sure you don't smoke--you'll likely set the whole internet on fire.
:rolleyes:

How is the decision to protect children from ONE well-documented health risk the same as saying that we need to protect children from ALL POSSIBLE risks?

How does this in anyway protect any child from any, supposedly, well documented health risk? The child will still be subject to second hand smoke at home making the brief periods of time they are in the car, and not subjected to second hand smoke, rather pointless. So the only way this can work is in conjunction with an outright ban on smoking around kids period, and once you've established a legal precedent to do that then any interest group can have the umbrella of such an allowance be extended to ban whatever supposed health risk they care about. We already have lots of groups talking, seriously talking, about having it be a crime to have parents serve their children "unhealthy" food. Only thing is that a lot of what they characterize as "unhealthy" foods are what my own parents served to me growing up and I didn't end up obese with high cholesterol and high blood pressure.

However this overlooks something.....what if the kids smoke? How absurd is it that it would be illegal for an adult to smoke in the very same car that the kids is them self smoking in? Don't say that doesn't happen because I've known many people who started smoking when they were 9-11 years old. Sometimes the parents didn't approve and the kid just did it behind their backs until they were 18. Some of the parents recognized the futility in telling the kids to stop and accommodated them on it. Intriguingly the only ones who quit before they were adults were the ones that didn't have to do it sneakily.

But, let's not kid ourselves. No one that had anything to do with this law really cared about any kids. This is just part of a larger campaign to get smoking banned altogether. The steps towards this are done like this with seemingly reasonable explanations backing them up that fall apart upon examination. That the individuals continue to support these measures even after they are shown to help no one from anything demonstrates what their real motivations are.

Now I'm not a smoker, never have been, but I have real problems with the erosions of personal liberties based on faulty logic and ulterior motives. You want a squeaky clean life of no smoking, vegan diets and bike riding then fine but don't force it on other people and don't force them to force it on their kids.
 
Cigarettes, when used as intended, are harmful.
Hockey gear, when used as intended, is not harmful.
Playing hockey, as intended, will lead to injuries. Over 4,000 children every year in Canada suffer hockey injuries severe enough to send them to the emergency room.

It is silly to suggest that cigarettes do not bear real quantifiable risks. The risks have been thoroughly identified and well documented for years.
Fine, then show me the quantified risks from secondhand smoke in cars to Canada's children. I'd really like to see the data that shows this law will cut down significantly on secondhand smoke exposure to children.

What will be next - a ban in children's bedrooms?
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:
How does this in anyway protect any child from any, supposedly, well documented health risk?

Are you seriously asking how a ban on adults smoking in cars with children will protect children from inhaling second hand smoke in cars? Seriously?

The child will still be subject to second hand smoke at home making the brief periods of time they are in the car, and not subjected to second hand smoke, rather pointless.

Again, are you seriously suggesting that the risks associated with exposure to second hand smoke are invariant with respect to the AMOUNT of exposure? Seriously?

And are you seriously suggesting that exposure to carcinogens in cigarette smoke is invariant with respect to the volume of the room in which the smoke is being released? (Hint--cars are very small rooms compared to the rooms in almost all houses in Canada.)

So the only way this can work is in conjunction with an outright ban on smoking around kids period, and once you've established a legal precedent to do that then any interest group can have the umbrella of such an allowance be extended to ban whatever supposed health risk they care about. We already have lots of groups talking, seriously talking, about having it be a crime to have parents serve their children "unhealthy" food. Only thing is that a lot of what they characterize as "unhealthy" foods are what my own parents served to me growing up and I didn't end up obese with high cholesterol and high blood pressure.
Sigh. And the ranting about slippery slopes resumes. Look, when someone actually moves to ban smoking in private dwellings or to outlaw fatty foods, then make your arguments against those measures. In the meantime, try not to get so worked up when someone institutes a measure that does nobody any harm and will do some people some good.

However this overlooks something.....what if the kids smoke? How absurd is it that it would be illegal for an adult to smoke in the very same car that the kids is them self smoking in? Don't say that doesn't happen because I've known many people who started smoking when they were 9-11 years old.
O.K., you just said goodbye to planet sanity here. It's already illegal for children to smoke (do you see that as another evil step on the slippery slope towards total cigarette prohibition?) So if the children are smoking in a car with an adult the adult is already in trouble. This law won't change anything.

Sometimes the parents didn't approve and the kid just did it behind their backs until they were 18. Some of the parents recognized the futility in telling the kids to stop and accommodated them on it. Intriguingly the only ones who quit before they were adults were the ones that didn't have to do it sneakily.
You're saying--and again, I have to ask if you can possibly be serious--that children who smoke with the approval of their parents are MORE likely to give up smoking than children who smoke despite parental disapproval. I'm sure you have a great pile of studies to back up that astonishingly improbable claim (hint: the plural of anecdote is not data).

But, let's not kid ourselves.
Why stop now?

No one that had anything to do with this law really cared about any kids.
No, of course not. That's just impossible! No doubt they're set on world domination. Maybe they want to plant radio transmitters in everybody's goldfish? Let's see if I'm right...

This is just part of a larger campaign to get smoking banned altogether. The steps towards this are done like this with seemingly reasonable explanations backing them up that fall apart upon examination.
Yeah, you tell 'em. Now that you've shown that the risks of second-hand smoke are invariant with respect to the amount of exposure the whole idea behind the law falls apart like a wet paper bag. You do have studies that support that claim, right? [crickets]

That the individuals continue to support these measures even after they are shown to help no one from anything demonstrates what their real motivations are.

It IS something to do with goldfish and radio transmitters, isn't it?

Now I'm not a smoker, never have been, but I have real problems with the erosions of personal liberties based on faulty logic and ulterior motives. You want a squeaky clean life of no smoking, vegan diets and bike riding then fine but don't force it on other people and don't force them to force it on their kids.
Now see, if you'd only pointed out the passages in the bill that forced vegan diets and bike riding on people then your post wouldn't have come across like paranoid nonsense. What's that you say? The bill only outlaws parents smoking in cars with their children present. But...that sounds like a perfectly reasonable limitation on personal rights to me. Surely there must have been SOMETHING in there about vegan diets and goldfish transmitters??
 
I wonder if they will ban using cell phones while driving a car with children under 16 as passengers?
 
Last edited:
Playing hockey, as intended, will lead to injuries. Over 4,000 children every year in Canada suffer hockey injuries severe enough to send them to the emergency room.

And you continue to ignore the point about the assessment of BENEFITS from this activity that, in most people's view, outweigh the RISKS. Again, the risks of childhood exposure to second hand smoke have been demonstrated over and over again. Not even cigarette companies pretend that this is not the case. If you can show me that there are benefits to putting a child in a car with a smoker then your comparison to hockey has a point. Given that you can't, you're just trying to score a cheap rhetorical point that you know has no bearing whatsoever on the point.

Fine, then show me the quantified risks from secondhand smoke in cars to Canada's children. I'd really like to see the data that shows this law will cut down significantly on secondhand smoke exposure to children.

The risk obviously varies with the degree of exposure. A car--because it is a small, enclosed space--obviously provides orders of magnitude more exposure to the passive smoker per cigarette smoked than an ordinary room (plus, a child can step out of a room where an adult is smoking, but cannot step out of a car while it is being driven). Here is a report on a relevant study that you might find interesting and relevant.

It is equally obvious that children who are regularly driven long distances in cars will be exposed to far more smoke this way than those who rarely ride in vehicles. It may well be that children who rarely drive long distances with their smoking parents will benefit little under the terms of this law. However, it is impossible to make a law that reaches the frequent drivers but skips the infrequent, and for the infrequent drivers the burden of not being able to smoke while driving their children will obviously also be extremely light.

What will be next - a ban in children's bedrooms?
And we're back to slippery slope land--the official argument of the "got nothing" brigade.
 
And you continue to ignore the point about the assessment of BENEFITS from this activity that, in most people's view, outweigh the RISKS.
Surely there's a safer way to play hockey that doesn't have the risks, yes? I offered one up earlier...

Again, the risks of childhood exposure to second hand smoke have been demonstrated over and over again.
And what percentage of secondhand smoke exposure takes place in cars?

And I wonder about children's exposure to vehicle exhaust on a busy street, maybe children shouldn't be allowed in cars period, or within 100 feet of a street?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom