Ontario to ban smoking in cars with children under 16 present

Molinaro

Illuminator
Joined
Dec 7, 2005
Messages
4,781
LINK

The Ontario Government has decided to introduce legistlation this spring to ban smoking in a car if children under the age of 16 are present. The offence will carry a fine, likely of up to $200.

The province of Nova Scotia already has such a ban.

Sounds like a good idea to me. And since it's being banned as a measure to protect children's health -- smoking around a child is child abuse isn't it? Shouldn't they also ban smoking in your home if children are present?
 
smoking around a child is child abuse isn't it? Shouldn't they also ban smoking in your home if children are present?
You mean you consider it to be child abuse? It is not child abuse in my country. But smoking in public places is illegal for reasons that could be extended to private homes. However I think that would not get public support and the enforcement methods required would be too violating of civil liberty (invasive of privacy).

Smoking in your home is illegal in the UK if it is used for a public purpose, such as a place of employment, or if you are a child-minder etc.

Not sure if that's also tru if you hire a cleaner--although almost all home cleaning staff are informally employed
 
I think it's an excellent idea. Other things they should ban:
  • Putting junk food in your kid's lunch box;
  • Having junk food in the refrigerator;
  • TV shows that feature:
    • Sex
    • Violence
    • Disrespect for parents
    • Dishonesty
    • Greed
    • Bad language
    • Drug use/alcohol use
  • Knives (if they're dangerous in the supervised atmosphere of a school, aren't they dangerous at home, too?);
  • Fatty desserts;
  • Small objects (choking hazard!);
  • Plastic bags (suffocating hazard!)
  • Cats (scratching child's eyes hazard!)
I know, I know, the no-smoking-in-the-car-with-the-kid is all in the progressive interests of protecting our children.
 
I think it's an excellent idea.

I agree with BPSCG on this one. I want to see laws that govern the installation of toilet paper rolls so that they always spool off from the front. Really, you just can't ever have too much government control...
 
Last edited:
I agree with BPSCG on this one. I what to see laws that govern the installation of toilet paper rolls so that they always spools off from the front. Really, you just can't have too much government control...
Do you know what externalities are?
 
Sounds like a good idea to me.

I wonder if the charge would stick if the defendant was in a convertable with the top down. I think that it would be fun to see something like that go to court...
 
Those laws should have been put in place years ago. There's nothing as disturbing as seeing a parent with the window cracked open just enough to to do nothing while telling the kids to shut up.
 
I've been in cars where people smoked my entire childhood, and I have no problems with my lungs today. This is getting ridiculous.

Maybe they should focus on more important things?
 
Last edited:
I think it's an excellent idea. Other things they should ban:
  • Putting junk food in your kid's lunch box;
  • Having junk food in the refrigerator;
  • TV shows that feature:
    • Sex
    • Violence
    • Disrespect for parents
    • Dishonesty
    • Greed
    • Bad language
    • Drug use/alcohol use
  • Knives (if they're dangerous in the supervised atmosphere of a school, aren't they dangerous at home, too?);
  • Fatty desserts;
  • Small objects (choking hazard!);
  • Plastic bags (suffocating hazard!)
  • Cats (scratching child's eyes hazard!)
The Saudi Arabia of the excessively careful. ;)
 
Last edited:
I've been in cars where people smoked my entire childhood, and I have no problems with my lungs today.

You are right, of course. The fact that you have no problem with your lungs proves that smoke is harmless.


Cigarettes are the only legally sold product which, if used as intended, cause harm.

Maybe they should focus on more important things? Maybe yes, maybe no.
You could equally argue that punching someone in the face should not be illegal because there are worse things that can be done.
 
You are right, of course. The fact that you have no problem with your lungs proves that smoke is harmless.

Good point, that was kind of fallacious of me.

Cigarettes are the only legally sold product which, if used as intended, cause harm.

Maybe they should focus on more important things? Maybe yes, maybe no.
You could equally argue that punching someone in the face should not be illegal because there are worse things that can be done.
I just think this whole cracking down on smokers thing is a little overstated. How exaclty are they going to implement this new legislation? Are they going to arrest people for smoking now?
 
Last edited:
There are good arguments to be made both pro and con about laws like this. What's odd is that the con side always chooses to make inherently absurd arguments ("my parents smoked and it never did me any harm"--as if there aren't countless studies out there showing that exposure to second hand smoke during childhood is strongly associated with increased risk of a whole range of negative effects; you might as well argue "my parents exceeded the speed limit whenever they drove me anywhere and I'm fine, so therefore speed limits are pointless" or "my parents shot apples off my head with a hunting bow every weekend when I was growing up and I was never killed, therefore every parent should be allowed to do that").

If you want to argue that a law like this is an unwarranted intrusion into individual rights, go ahead--that's a philosophical position that can't be "wrong" per se; we all have to decide where we draw the line on such questions. But trying to pretend that you aren't at the same time advocating for people's right to choose to raise their child's risk of a range of serious diseases (from asthma to heart disease to lung cancer) is just intellectual dishonesty.

Just say "individual freedom, in my value system, trumps a child's increased risk of serious illness." If you can't say that, then you don't actually have a principled stand, you just want to stick your head in the ground. (Or, rather, you just want to light up another cancer-stick).
 
Last edited:
I've been in cars where people smoked my entire childhood, and I have no problems with my lungs today. This is getting ridiculous.

Maybe they should focus on more important things?

I don't believe it has ever been suggested that being around second hand smoke has a 100% chance of causing illness.

What has been said, is that there is a measurable increase in your likelyhood of developing a variety of ailments.

Anecdotes of 1 person's experience are of course as meaningless here as in most situations.
 
How exaclty are they going to implement this new legislation? Are they going to arrest people for smoking now?

This new legislation would be implemented like any other legislation.
If what you are doing is illegal you risk arrest.
 
This new legislation would be implemented like any other legislation.
If what you are doing is illegal you risk arrest.

Don't you find that a little ridiculous?

I don't know, the image this creates in my head is absurd, maybe it's just me.

ETA: btw, I'm not a smoker, never was. :)
 
Last edited:
Don't you find that a little ridiculous?

I don't know, the image this creates in my head is absurd, maybe it's just me.

Is the image of people being arrested for using cocaine also absurd? Or allowing their children to use it?
I find the two things comparable.
 
I'm sorry, but that is ridiculous.
Why is that ridiculous? In both cases the state has decided that a certain substance's health risks are such that they choose to regulate its use. Now, you might happen to agree that cocaine poses a sufficient health risk and disagree (in the face, one would have to say, of a very great deal of evidence) that tobacco does pose that risk--but that's not the question at issue--the question was whether this was a law that could be enforced without patent absurdity. Given that we have plenty of laws governing controlled substances it's hard to see why adding one more such substance to the list poses any extraordinary challenges.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom