Online Neurodivergence Ecosystems

Hmm...

I have a couple of things to add to this discourse.

Firstly, as part of the Masters program, we had to attend a single lecture on 'abnormal psychology' (because the wrong people can really damage organisations).

The lecturer warned the whole class, that it was likely that many, if not all of us, would be thinking: "OMG, that's me!" as the various conditions were identified and described.

She explained that this was entirely normal, and something that all psychology students experience...

Secondly, some conditions definitely are affected by the way we manage them, for example, I stopped going to fibromyalgia support groups, because my symptoms were always much worse after associating with other people who were suffering more than me.

BTW. Just a final note.

"On the spectrum" doesn't mean that there is a sliding scale from 'normal' to 'autistic'.

There are many small characteristics that we probably all have to some degree, but are much harder to manage for someone with Autism or Asperger's.

In my case, I'm on the spectrum, because of elements of OCD, social anxiety, difficulty in interpreting peoples' hidden agendas, etc. but I'm neither Autistic or Aspie. :D

Just generally much happier when I don't need to deal with people face to face.

(Far from being detrimental to me, my personality disorders seemed to have enabled me to have a highly technical career.)
 
I've seen people go 'that's a thing? that explains a lot' about common features of disorders in both thoughtful and thoughtless ways, and occasionally about things that aren't even a thing but rather just a video someone made while laboring under a misapprehension.

ADHD and executive dysfunction 'life hacks' often help me with **** I've been struggling with for years. I think a lot of people are sort of 'soft self diagnosing' on a basis like that, in a 'the shoe fits and the shoe inserts help me walk more comfortably' kind of way.

Of course many of these are general hacks that help whether or not you have Condition. But most people don't resort to taking the doors off their kitchen cabinets because they finally accept that otherwise they will continue to accidentally live as though the insides of the cabinets don't exist. On the one hand there probably is some way to train yourself to use normal cabinets normally; on the other hand now I am actually using my cabinets. Stuff like that. Is it actually ADHD? Shrug? I might casually describe always having 4 cold cups of tea as ADD behaviour, nonetheless. Much the same way one might call any old arthropod a bug.

If youngsters start out with self diagnosis and struggle enough to go get checked out, imo, that's fine. If they don't struggle, they can wear it if it suits them.

Communities that encourage eating disorders or wallowing in harmful self hatred are a different kind of problem, and have been around for decades. Dealing with them is thorny.

The really weird ones are out there too. Kids arguing about being able to jump realities, the (now old!) 'kin' stuff, some modern takes on the indigo child stuff. You never know whether they're just really invested in some deep layers of roleplay or if they're exploring unusual ways to deal with their emotional relationships or if they are bug **** nuts.
 
Last edited:
I want to thank everyone posting so far for their overwhelmingly insightful comments.



Fascinating group!

I should perhaps explain that r/fakedisordercringe is a subreddit dedicated to pointing and laughing at (and condemning) people who pretend to have psychological disorders, and often appear to be extremely active in online neurodivergence ecosystems. Trending on that sub right now are posts about Pluralpedia, which is one such ONE.
 
...

Of course many of these are general hacks that help whether or not you have Condition. But most people don't resort to taking the doors off their kitchen cabinets because they finally accept that otherwise they will continue to accidentally live as though the insides of the cabinets don't exist. On the one hand there probably is some way to train yourself to use normal cabinets normally; on the other hand now I am actually using my cabinets. Stuff like that.

...

I met an older guy with dementia who still lives at home, alone.

A 'life hack' for him, is printed lists on the cupboard doors that explain the contents of the cupboards.

He said that this helped in two ways:

1. Saves him having to look in every cupboard every time he wants things; and,
2. Makes it much easier to put away the groceries/dishes/washing etc.

I think I identify with that guy. I'd probably want to stay 'home' as long as possible, and can see myself doing similar things.

(NB. I already have some labels on some of my drawers (inside of drawers) but that is because my ex bought a label maker and went full 'Batman' around the house.)

I'm not sure that I have the heart to remove all of the labels, but the visible ones are all gone.
 
One possibility that's often overlooked in discussions of social media and its effects, particularly on children, is the possibility that social media use may be the symptom rather than the cause of some of these problems. For instance, an association between social media use and suicidal ideation in young women is explainable by social media use causing increases in depression, but it's also explainable if depressed, lonely kids who don't have access to other forms of socializing turn to social media. The problem (in that case) would be the lack of access to those social experiences that kids crave, and the social media use would be a symptom of that problem.

Free play (free from adult supervision) and other forms of socializing, again without adult supervision, is down in children, and that does seem to me to be at least contributing to the problems that are often blamed on social media. This doesn't mean that there's no room for social media use to exacerbate these problems, but this does seem like at least a potential part of the problem that's often overlooked.

This is analogous to seeing an association between homelessness and alcoholism. Does the alcoholism lead to the homelessness or do people who are homeless turn to alcohol as an escape? My guess is that there's some of both, but it would be a mistake to ignore the latter factor. And the same sort of thing is, I suspect, true of social media.
 
One possibility that's often overlooked in discussions of social media and its effects, particularly on children, is the possibility that social media use may be the symptom rather than the cause of some of these problems. For instance, an association between social media use and suicidal ideation in young women is explainable by social media use causing increases in depression, but it's also explainable if depressed, lonely kids who don't have access to other forms of socializing turn to social media. The problem (in that case) would be the lack of access to those social experiences that kids crave, and the social media use would be a symptom of that problem.

Free play (free from adult supervision) and other forms of socializing, again without adult supervision, is down in children, and that does seem to me to be at least contributing to the problems that are often blamed on social media. This doesn't mean that there's no room for social media use to exacerbate these problems, but this does seem like at least a potential part of the problem that's often overlooked.

This is analogous to seeing an association between homelessness and alcoholism. Does the alcoholism lead to the homelessness or do people who are homeless turn to alcohol as an escape? My guess is that there's some of both, but it would be a mistake to ignore the latter factor. And the same sort of thing is, I suspect, true of social media.

While I agree with the above, may I suggest that you may have left out part of it?

There is an engineering term, positive feedback, which means that something reinforces something, pushing it further from the desired, stable state.

I believe that the reinforcement offered by social media, may exaggerate existing problems, making them worse.

These feedback loops can be seen in many aspects of human behaviour, for example:

Person feels lonely and unattractive leading to excess eating of 'comfort foods'. Weight gain makes the person feel more lonely and unattractive leading to more excess eating.

My example of meeting people struggling with pain management, causing my own pain management issues to worsen.

Depression leading to alcohol consumption, leading to more depression.

It seems to me that people, generally, are vulnerable to that kind of loop, and the worst of social media makes things worse.

(Initial cause or not)
 
While I agree with the above, may I suggest that you may have left out part of it?

There is an engineering term, positive feedback, which means that something reinforces something, pushing it further from the desired, stable state.

I believe that the reinforcement offered by social media, may exaggerate existing problems, making them worse.

These feedback loops can be seen in many aspects of human behaviour, for example:

Person feels lonely and unattractive leading to excess eating of 'comfort foods'. Weight gain makes the person feel more lonely and unattractive leading to more excess eating.

My example of meeting people struggling with pain management, causing my own pain management issues to worsen.

Depression leading to alcohol consumption, leading to more depression.

It seems to me that people, generally, are vulnerable to that kind of loop, and the worst of social media makes things worse.

(Initial cause or not)

Yeah, this is a very good point! The analogy the weight management is also very clear.

I also think that social media can have both positive and negative effects here. For instance, I have a WeChat group with my family members that we use to keep in touch. My relationship with my brother has grown a lot stronger over the last couple of years since we started exchanging voice messages on WeChat. I'll often send him 10 minutes or so of voice messages, and he'll reply a day or two later with 10 minutes of his own. Because we live on opposite sides of the planet, we used to talk on the phone maybe once/year, but now we have these sorts of exchanges around once a week. Similar WeChat groups with friends also keep me in touch with them, and chatting there often leads to us getting together in "real life", which also seems positive.

Contrast that with just scrolling on instagram or twitter, or WeChat's 朋友圈. Those things seem much less pro-social and more likely to be a part of the negative feedback loop you're talking about. But there's something going on where both sides of the coin are happening in the same apps (my friends also have a much more active chat group on instagram, I just haven't been able to get on it since my VPN stopped working).
 
I came across a free app in the App Store for people with DID to "manage their alters" or "let their alters know who is fronting".

At first I thought this was a terrible scam that would lead to worse proliferation of DID self-diagnosis.

But the app only has 37 reviews and has not been reviewed or updated in a year.

I think people with "DID" are already too confused to try and cope with organising their thoughts this way, and if they did manage it, they might soon think more clearly and maybe discard their belief in having DID.

The app is also intended for sharing their experiences, so, while it could bolster MPI, it seems to be pretty unsuccessful.
 
Neurodivergent is cool now.

That said, I have listened to people speaking about the symptoms that led them to get an actual diagnosis, and I've been surprised at how often I say "yeah, I do that too".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom