Online Neurodivergence Ecosystems

Orphia Nay

Penguilicious Spodmaster
Tagger
Joined
May 2, 2005
Messages
54,615
Location
Australia
"For Teen Girls, Rare Psychiatric Disorders Spread Like Viruses on Social Media

Researchers argue that a massive sudden spread of unusual psychiatric problems follows the pattern of “psychosomatic social contagion.”"

https://www.madinamerica.com/2023/1...isorders-spread-like-viruses-on-social-media/

TikTok’s “sick-role subculture” leads to children taking on the characteristics of rare psychiatric diagnoses, according to an article in Comprehensive Psychiatry. Kids—especially teenage girls—are presenting with self-described Tourette’s, eating disorders, autism, and dissociative identity disorder (DID)—but suddenly, and in a way that doesn’t match how these diagnoses have previously been identified.

“There has been a recognition of vast online ‘neurodivergence’ ecosystem in which classical mental illness symptoms and diagnoses are viewed less as mental health concerns that require professional attention, but rather as consumer identities or character traits that make individuals sharper and more interesting than others around them,” the researchers write.

I've come across DID groups online that reaffirm the poster's (self- or otherwise) diagnosis. I've also seen three people self-diagnose ADHD, though they have had some contact with psychologists, just not official final diagnoses.

Has anyone else noticed a trend towards self-diagnosis and a drift contrary to the stigma formerly associated with mental illness?
 
Tens now a days are morelikely to diagnose themselves, and several family members with 'something'. And the larger communities and school systems are likely to have suicide awarenesss days and mental awareness months...multiple. So this idea of some mental crisis is around them much much MUCH more than any of us had as kids.

It is also more normalized... so that a fear of bees or perhaps a sensitivity to others' chewing noises is a mental illness with a name they can find on their iphone. Everyone is mentally ill if you look enough!

Also, tiktok is braintrash.

my limited source?: I have a 15 year old in high school, in California.
 
Tens now a days are morelikely to diagnose themselves, and several family members with 'something'. And the larger communities and school systems are likely to have suicide awarenesss days and mental awareness months...multiple. So this idea of some mental crisis is around them much much MUCH more than any of us had as kids.

It is also more normalized... so that a fear of bees or perhaps a sensitivity to others' chewing noises is a mental illness with a name they can find on their iphone. Everyone is mentally ill if you look enough!

Also, tiktok is braintrash.

my limited source?: I have a 15 year old in high school, in California.

"Everyone is mentally ill if you look enough!"

I follow some meme groups, and many popular memes these days feature some sort of mental illness symptom and a common occurrence most of us can sympathise with. I can see how teens and even adults can start thinking they have certain diagnoses.
 
"Everyone is mentally ill if you look enough!"

I follow some meme groups, and many popular memes these days feature some sort of mental illness symptom and a common occurrence most of us can sympathise with. I can see how teens and even adults can start thinking they have certain diagnoses.

I think that is partly because we've long ignored how prevalent mental illness is. So is it that people are misdiagnosing themselves and each other or simply now recognising the symptoms of mental illness?

I know I still have a problem with accepting people being "on the spectrum*" who live a pretty "normal" life, I would describe them as "shy" or "socially anxious". But I suspect that is me at fault and my conditioning when younger the "not to cry", to keep a stiff upper lip, never show a weakness, suck it up to use an Americanism and so on. I suspect this is a generational thing in many ways, first of all the first generation to grow-up constantly online and constantly sharing their lives on-line in a way that is completely alien to me and a generation that has been told it is OK to talk about feelings and to "admit" to mental illness and mental illness symptoms.

Then we have to add in the issue of, to use a quick and dirty phrase, "social contagion".

What I do know is that it is bloody complicated.




*note I am not denying autism exists, I know some severely autistic people - one of my neighbours across the road has a son I've known for 20 years, now in his early 30s totally unable to cope with life and deal with everyday situations now living in assisted accommodation. It can be a totally disabling condition. I was using this as an example of how an old git like myself is not always the best person to make these judgements of youngsters because of my own "generational" bias.
 
I would venture to say, conditions like cognitive dissonance are just as much a mental illness as ADD.

Not at all. Cognitive dissonance is a state of attempting to make mutually incompatible beliefs fit. Everyone can have it from time to time particularly when not wanting to confront an unwelcome conclusion. But ADHD is a disorder which someone will have regardless of how much they try to think straight. They may be able to manage the symptoms through certain strategies but that doesn’t mean they can get rid of it entirely.
 
I would venture to say, conditions like cognitive dissonance are just as much a mental illness as ADD.

Cognitive dissonance is the state of perceiving incongruent beliefs or behaviours. In itself it doesn't automatically have positive or negative consequences (other than the unpleasant emotional arousal produced) and is not an 'illness'. It could have negative consequences if somebody adopts an irrational belief or behaviour to reduce dissonance (like uncritically adopting a belief to fit in with a social or political group).

ADD isn't really an illness either - it's a neurodevelopmental condition (present from childhood, even if not diagnosed till later). It is classified as a disorder because it can cause functional impairment or distress, but it involves long-term neurodevelopmental characteristics rather than a state that is aberrant for that person.

The main feature distinguishing the socially contagious conditions is their rapid onset, links to social influence, and prevalence amongst female adolescents.
 

Read the first two descriptive papers. They do show there should be concern about "social contagion".

My meagre opinion is there is more than enough information for us to be very restrictive with kids access to the internet especially regarding social media companies, we need to keep remembering that they are profit making companies using kids as both consumers and the consumed. And there is a need for us to exert control on how social media interacts with children. This whole algorithmic push to up "engagement" is a pernicious evil that infiltrates all the major players (apart from the ISF of course).

In the UK there has been a lot of discussion about our "Online Safety Bill", and it has come in for plenty of (deserved) ridicule, but at its heart there is a truth and that is we need to legislate for online safety, protecting people especially children is a necessary evil that the state has to enforce, we now know we can't leave it up to the mysterious all-knowing "market".
 
Last edited:
Addiction.

To say that social media is just as addictive as alcohol, drugs etc. is absurd. That's the same kind of hyperbole that people said about video games that was totally debunked, for example, in Markey and Ferguson's "Moral Combat. Why the War on Violent Video Games is Wrong."
 
To say that social media is just as addictive as alcohol, drugs etc. is absurd. That's the same kind of hyperbole that people said about video games that was totally debunked, for example, in Markey and Ferguson's "Moral Combat. Why the War on Violent Video Games is Wrong."

As you say there isn't the evidence in the case of video games however in this case the evidence is building that the "engagement" model social media companies use to make money is harmful to children. It may not be addictive - and I don't think it is - that does not mean it isn't (or can be) harmful.
 
The internet/social media is just as addictive as alcohol, tobacco and drugs. Why not restrict minor access and make it a crime to provide access to minors?

To say that social media is just as addictive as alcohol, drugs etc. is absurd. That's the same kind of hyperbole that people said about video games that was totally debunked, for example, in Markey and Ferguson's "Moral Combat. Why the War on Violent Video Games is Wrong."

As you say there isn't the evidence in the case of video games however in this case the evidence is building that the "engagement" model social media companies use to make money is harmful to children. It may not be addictive - and I don't think it is - that does not mean it isn't (or can be) harmful.

It's as easy as Googling "Social Media Addiction "...

I don’t know if addiction is the main problem with all of the things mentioned. It is the attendant harms that come with the addiction. People can be addicted to coffee without it being as harmful as addiction to cigarettes. The ostensible problems with video game addiction, if it was addictive, was not the addiction itself but the purported claims of making people violent. Similarly, the problems with internet or social media addiction is that it makes people depressed or anxious or radicalized by cults, etc… or, according to the OP, people on on social media self-diagnose because they put undue trust in their ability to filter through the nonsense on TikTok and pull out the diamonds of objective truth.

No idea how much of the claims in the case of social media is actually true, but it is best to focus on those issues rather than the mere addiction.
 
One thing that's interesting to me about these "online neurodivergent ecosystems" is that they seem to not actually be neurodivergent? Getting caught up in a fad isn't neurodivergent, it's neurotypical. Joining a cult to feel like you belong is neurotypical. Pretending to be something you're not, for acceptance or inclusion is neurotypical. This situation is interesting because playing at being neurodivergent is the cult/fad that's pulling in the normies.

Though, periodic browsing of r/fakedisordercringe does lead me to suspect that a lot of these "neurodivergency cosplayers" do have, or will give themselves, a real psychological disorder - just not the one(s) they're cosplaying.

What concerns me the most is that these kids aren't getting healthy socialization, or real help when they need it.

What concerns me second-most is when they bring their contagion to school, and spread it that way - or when their teachers have already caught it and are spreading it. Restrict internet access for minors, sure. But maybe also we should take a good look at the kind of social environment we're required by law to send our children into, five days a week.
 
Aren't sexual deviations and oh so modern transgenderism part of it ? It's clear number of transgender children is way above expected levels among Hollywood actresses .. but that's more an issue of the parents. It is likely similar phenomenon.
Also known for ages with fresh medicine students. Them thinking they have all those diseases they learn about, not transgenderism.
 
What concerns me second-most is when they bring their contagion to school, and spread it that way - or when their teachers have already caught it and are spreading it. Restrict internet access for minors, sure. But maybe also we should take a good look at the kind of social environment we're required by law to send our children into, five days a week.

Maybe kids could study online to prevent them being exposed to bad ideas in the classroom?
 
Aren't sexual deviations and oh so modern transgenderism part of it ? It's clear number of transgender children is way above expected levels among Hollywood actresses .. but that's more an issue of the parents. It is likely similar phenomenon.
Also known for ages with fresh medicine students. Them thinking they have all those diseases they learn about, not transgenderism.

The proposed mechanism here is hypochondria? Like the character in Three Men in a Boat who reads the Medical Encyclopedia and decides he has every ailment described in it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom