Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
The new Batman movie has a few themes relating to Occupy, though the film's script was written and they started filming before OWS was born. naturally, the movement's defenders are saying that the idea of
violent revolution, overthrowing the democratically appointed law-enforcement authority, and corrupt kangaroo courts
are completely unlike the ethos of OWS. Ironically, people in this thread and forum actively defended the alleged right of OWS to defy and threaten the police in the UC Davis incident.

Elements of the film were inspired by the French Revolution, and others have made the OWS/FR comparison, including Occupiers themselves.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eik_gjDyLmI


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qlPY9AfQFqI

"Ultimately the bourgeoisie will not go without violent means"

From the comments;
"Nothing will happen if non-violent forces do not have negotiating power stemming from the threat of a militant force like the Black Panthers here in the US or Bhagat Singh in India. The white-washing of history has been imposed by the United States in order to manage any threats to the State's rule by making them harmless and taking out their teeth. Any change that will happen under non-violence will be no change at all, there needs to be a militant force, or else nothing will be accomplished."​

Yes, because everyone remembers the Black Panthers, not MLK.

"The French Revolution may have ended the reign of Louis XVI, but it paved the way for the dictator Napoleon Bonaparte to rule France with an even more dangerous hand? That's not exactly the smartest way to go about fixing our issues."

", You are wrong- I wish you weren't though. There will be no change without blood being spilled. Like in Ghandi's time. In order to change anything the people must control the military! Because that is what is standing in your way. The 1% control the military, and thus nothing will change. Look to Egypt for proof. You can either give your blood or take blood another's. Ghandi preferred one but did not disprove of the other"

"He is brave enough to speak the inevitable truth in public.... Sadly, no true revolution is bloodless; the price of freedom and liberty against oppression is usually the blood of many, many innocent people. Unless the government listens to the protestors (because they have gained such numbers showing support for the cause) and enacts effectual change there will ultimately be violence. This is proven time and time again throughout history."

"The lack of violence and non-violent tactics used as put us into the position we are in today. Pacifism is a political tactic to oppress the people."​

The funny thing is that there is plenty of violence involved with OWS. It's just that it's mostly against other Occupiers.

"The French Revolution WAS bourgeois. It was led by lawyers and politicians, once in power they slaughtered and impoverished tens of thousands of ordinary poor workers and peasants in addition to a few thousand aristocrats. The only people who benefited from the French Revolution were power hungry politicians who were far more authoritarian than even the king had been."
​

And so on.
 
Last edited:
And in other news:

EASTON, Pa. (CBS) – An Occupy Easton protester faces an attempted bank robbery charge following an arrest at an organized event at a bank – during which the “Occupier” was holding a sign that reportedly read “You’re being robbed.”

According to The Express-Times, Dave Gorczynski allegedly held cardboard signs outside a Wells Fargo Branch that read, “You’re being robbed,” while the other said, “Give a man a gun, he can rob a bank. Give a man a bank, and he can rob a country.”

http://philadelphia.cbslocal.com/20...bbery-during-organized-event-in-pennsylvania/

Of all the dumb things the authorities could have done...
 
Gorczynski allegedly did the same thing a short time later inside a Bank of America, prompting an employee to activate the panic alarm – reports The Express Times.

Don't joke about bombs at the airport and don't go into banks telling them they're being robbed. Society is not for the stupid.
 
A good overview of our current financial arrangements:

"Why We're Screwed":



I see two scenarios playing out. In the first, we allow Wall Street to carry on its merry way, as the foreclosure crisis continues and Wall Street steals all homes, packaging them into bundles to be sold for pennies on the dollar to hedge funds. All wealth will be redistributed to the top 1% who will become modern day feudal lords with the other 99% living at their pleasure on huge feudal estates.

You can imagine for yourselves just what you’re going to have to do to pleasure the lords.

This will take years, maybe even a decade or more, but it is the long march Wall Street has formulated for us. To be sure, “formulated” should not be misinterpreted as intention. No one sat down and planned the creation of Western European feudalism when Rome collapsed. To be sure, the modern day feudal lords on Wall Street certainly conspire—to rig LIBOR and muni bond markets, for example—and each one individually wants to take as much as possible from customers and creditors and stockholders. But they are not planning and conspiring for the restoration of feudalism. Still, that is the default scenario—the outcome that will emerge in the absence of action.

In the second, the 99% occupy, shut down, and obliterate Wall Street. Honestly, I have no idea how that can happen. I am waiting for suggestions.
 
JihadJane said:
A good overview of our current financial arrangements:

"Why We're Screwed":



In the second, the 99% occupy, shut down, and obliterate Wall Street. Honestly, I have no idea how that can happen. I am waiting for suggestions.
"Why we would be screwed if Occupy could ever accomplish their goals, but won't be screwed because, well... case in point."

How does the above defend Occupy's identity as anything other than clueless, ineffectual tossers?

"I have no idea how that can happen. I am waiting for suggestions." Seriously?

Here's a suggestion: The Bolsheviks accomplished everything you ever dreamed of, and more, between February and October 1917. You could probably do a lot worse than research their methodology and try to replicate it here.

I mean, you'd fail miserably, and get a lot of people needlessly slaughtered, but that's the paradigm you need to embrace, if you're actually serious about seeing "the 99% occupy, shut down, and obliterate Wall Street".
 
"Why we would be screwed if Occupy could ever accomplish their goals, but won't be screwed because, well... case in point."

How does the above defend Occupy's identity as anything other than clueless, ineffectual tossers?

Yeah, whatever.

"I have no idea how that can happen. I am waiting for suggestions." Seriously?

Do you have any suggestions as to how we can stop the ever-growing financial fraud and looting?

Here's a suggestion: The Bolsheviks accomplished everything you ever dreamed of, and more, between February and October 1917. You could probably do a lot worse than research their methodology and try to replicate it here.

I mean, you'd fail miserably, and get a lot of people needlessly slaughtered, but that's the paradigm you need to embrace, if you're actually serious about seeing "the 99% occupy, shut down, and obliterate Wall Street".

Yeah, whatever. Got any more straw?
 
Last edited:
Yeah, whatever.
Well, OWS defending it's identity is the topic of the thread, so I thought I'd at least ask.


Do you have any suggestions as to how we can stop the ever-growing financial fraud and looting?
Begging the question. And not my problem. If OWS wants to defend its identity, they need to start doing their own work, not asking me to do it for them.

Yeah, whatever. Got any more straw?
Got any more defense of the OWS identity?
 
Well, OWS defending it's identity is the topic of the thread, so I thought I'd at least ask.

Yes, it's the topic, but it's not a command or an excuse to say "tossers" in public.

Begging the question. And not my problem. If OWS wants to defend its identity, they need to start doing their own work, not asking me to do it for them.

Financial fraud and looting is your problem.

Got any more defense of the OWS identity?

In case your memory needs refreshing, here's the OP. You will see that it is somewhat more nuanced than "Got any more defense of the OWS identity?":

Be careful of special interest groups hijacking the message. That's what happened to the Tea Party leading them to be co-opted into the Fox News GOP. Even if people show up who you agree with on some political issue, ask yourselves if that issue is actually related to what the protest is about. There will be, and probably already are, many factions who want nothing more than to turn the entire movement into a DNC fundraiser. Suddenly it will be about collective bargaining for teachers or something else that doesn't involve a corporation at all, let alone Wall Street. The partisans on both sides will try and expand their trenches such that your movement falls into them. Keep an eye out, don't be the next Tea Party.
 
Yes, it's the topic, but it's not a command or an excuse to say "tossers" in public.
What is this I don't even

Financial fraud and looting is your problem.
Yeah, not so much as OWS seems to think. And "occupy, shut down, and obliterate Wall Street" is definitely not my problem. That's a problem some hapless Occupier invented, and is now wandering around helplessly unable to solve.

In case your memory needs refreshing, here's the OP. You will see that it is somewhat more nuanced than "Got any more defense of the OWS identity?":

Sadly, the OP had high hopes for the legitimacy of the OWS movement, and a completely wrong conception of where the biggest threats to the OWS identity would come from. But he was right about one thing: OWS does (did?) need to defend their identity--from themselves.
 
What is this I don't even

Yeah, not so much as OWS seems to think. And "occupy, shut down, and obliterate Wall Street" is definitely not my problem. That's a problem some hapless Occupier invented, and is now wandering around helplessly unable to solve.

I have little patience for infantile, schoolyard bully banter.

Wall Street corruption is much worse than you seem to think. I suggest you read the rest of the article I linked to, which provides a good summary of the havoc that an out-of-control financial sector is wreaking.


Sadly, the OP had high hopes for the legitimacy of the OWS movement, and a completely wrong conception of where the biggest threats to the OWS identity would come from. But he was right about one thing: OWS does (did?) need to defend their identity--from themselves.

This comment looks like concern trolling. Besides the opportunity it gives you to indulge in some meaningless, macho point-scoring games, why do you care about the legitimacy of OWS?
 
Last edited:
At this point, shouldn't this thread be moved to History? OWS doesn't exist anymore.

No, it should be moved to Humor because I can't stop laughing about how stupid, moronic, and useless the few addicted (dude, I need weed or hate capitalism...I kinda forget until I get that next check from my parents) folks left behind are.
 
I'd completely forgotten about the Occutards untill this thread was resurrected.

From what I can remember, they said and did a lot of stupid things and accomplished nothing despite a sympathetic press and generous offers from local governments to give them office space for free. They couldn't even form a coherent sentence.

What a bunch of twits.
 
OWS was not doomed to failure outright; counterintuitively, it took a bit of effort to collapse the way they did.
 
OWS was not doomed to failure outright....

Actually it was. Remember, there were no leaders. No one spoke for OWS, everyone did.

What if a (American) football team had no leader (normally the quarterback)? Every player was free to run whatever play they wished. You'd have 22 guys running in all different directions on the field. This is (or, more accurately, was) OWS. A bunch of clowns running in different directions, all with their own playbook.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom