Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, so we're posting things relevant to the context of this thread, now?

Okay.

You first.

Below, Matt Taibbi addresses Occupy National Gathering (#NATGAT) and explains the illegal LIBOR fixing by the banksters and talks about Occupy's stance vis-à-vis the world financial system's unprecedented (in scale) corruption and criminality:



You second.
 
Below, Matt Taibbi addresses Occupy National Gathering (#NATGAT) and explains the illegal LIBOR fixing by the banksters and talks about Occupy's stance vis-à-vis the world financial system's unprecedented (in scale) corruption and criminality:



You second.

The Occutard at 1:45 has finally found something he is good at.
 

They are evolving. They have figured out how to use a loudspeaker, instead of having the crowd holler everything the main speechtard says.

Now, they need to invent a pole to hang it on so Spicoli doesn't have to hold it in the air for the whole speech so the backrowtards can hear.

Jesus, if this country is so friggin' terrible, how come these douchebags haven't died of cholera or starvation or government death squads or something?
 
Below, Matt Taibbi addresses Occupy National Gathering (#NATGAT) and explains the illegal LIBOR fixing by the banksters and talks about Occupy's stance vis-à-vis the world financial system's unprecedented (in scale) corruption and criminality:



You second.


What assurances do we have that Matt Taibbi or the NATGAT actually represent the Occupy Movement or its stance vis-à-vis the world financial system?
 
What assurances do we have that Matt Taibbi or the NATGAT actually represent the Occupy Movement or its stance vis-à-vis the world financial system?

None. Very strange question. I'd be interested know what assumptions lie behind it about the nature of the "Occupy Movement". At first sight, it looks like a remarkable level of ignorance, as if you are meeting an alien from another planet for the very first time!

Perhaps watching the video might help.
 
None. Very strange question. I'd be interested know what assumptions lie behind it about the nature of the "Occupy Movement". At first sight, it looks like a remarkable level of ignorance, as if you are meeting an alien from another planet for the very first time!

Perhaps watching the video might help.

The topic of the thread is OWS defending its identity (and, latterly, OWS's ongoing failure in that regard).

If you're posting Taibbi's address to NATGAT in the context of this thread, does that mean you intend it to be a defense of OWS's identity? Does it mean that you understand OWS to be identified with Taibbi's stance vis-à-vis the world financial system (the stance he imputes to OWS)?

If I watch the video, and then say, "I disagree with OWS, because of their occutarded stance vis-à-vis the world financial system", will I be rewarded with another four score and seven pages (or more!) about how that's not really the stance of OWS, and Taibbi doesn't really speak for OWS, and NATGAT addresses don't really identify the OWS movement?

If what Taibbi is saying is what OWS really stands for, then fine. We can probably start a thread to discuss it. But first, I'd like to know, if we start that thread, that there is some consensus that Taibbi is in fact a true Scotsman, and NATGAT is in fact the true Scotland.

If not, then we're right back at page one of this thread: OWS needs to defend its identity, and sucks pretty hard at doing so.
 
The amusing part about that is that the Seattle Times has primarily supported right leaning candidates and issues, and has been generally defined as a more conservative paper in the region.

Just because something has the name "Seattle" in it does not automatically mean that it is liberal. There are a lot of areas in Washington that are strongly conservative, and that has an effect on the news in the cities.

Not to mention that liberal papers tend not to print stories like this.

What assurances do we have that Matt Taibbi or the NATGAT actually represent the Occupy Movement or its stance vis-à-vis the world financial system?
Well, they said so, and they sound convincing, and they haven't really done anything embarrassing yet*. Isn't that how it works?

*"In the event of your capture, Occupy will disavow all knowledge of your existence, as long as they can't spin it to make The System look like the bad guys. This placard will self-destruct in -"
 
Last edited:
The topic of the thread is OWS defending its identity (and, latterly, OWS's ongoing failure in that regard).

If you're posting Taibbi's address to NATGAT in the context of this thread, does that mean you intend it to be a defense of OWS's identity? Does it mean that you understand OWS to be identified with Taibbi's stance vis-à-vis the world financial system (the stance he imputes to OWS)?

If I watch the video, and then say, "I disagree with OWS, because of their occutarded stance vis-à-vis the world financial system", will I be rewarded with another four score and seven pages (or more!) about how that's not really the stance of OWS, and Taibbi doesn't really speak for OWS, and NATGAT addresses don't really identify the OWS movement?

No, I'd reward you by asking why you needed to spice your question up with childish, offensive, disablist abuse.

Tabbi isn't claiming to speak for anyone. He addressing a bunch of people who have gathered under the tag #NATGAT and sharing his analysis of the jaw-dropping corruption and criminality of the finance industry and asking what, if anything, we can do about it. Does that interest you?

It is clear from what he says in the video that he regards Occupy as a long-term conversation aimed at putting the the heart back into society by directly participating in political processes.

If what Taibbi is saying is what OWS really stands for, then fine. We can probably start a thread to discuss it. But first, I'd like to know, if we start that thread, that there is some consensus that Taibbi is in fact a true Scotsman, and NATGAT is in fact the true Scotland.

Watch the video and get back to us.

If not, then we're right back at page one of this thread: OWS needs to defend its identity, and sucks pretty hard at doing so.

Would it be easier for you if they all wore uniforms and identical hats and bowed before a great, charismatic leader?
 
Last edited:
The constant barrage of "occutard" after I get an infraction for using the word "occutardtard".

That's what's WOW.
That's because you referred to other posters with that name, while we make fun of occutards who don't post here.

It's a fine line.
 
Yes, someone once mentioned that they couldn't discuss someone because they had an account here. Not that they were posting in the specific thread, but that they merely had an account.

No, I'd reward you by asking why you needed to spice your question up with childish, offensive, disablist abuse.
....
Does that interest you?
...

Watch the video and get back to us.


Would it be easier for you if they all wore uniforms and identical hats and bowed before a great, charismatic leader?

What is it with you and personalizing the debate?

I like how you backpedal from specifically claiming that this guy was talking about Occupy's stance and the financial system to a group of people who claim to be Occupiers to just talking about the financial system and Occupy, as soon as someone asked you what your criteria for a "True Occupier" was and whether he really was one. You're trying to put the video in some sort of superposition where it both is and isn't representative of OWS. It really is amazing to me.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom