Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
You implied you were being sarcastic. Yet when WC asked you, point blank, if you were being sarcastic when you were disparaging of CU, you refused to answer.

I don't see how asking someone if they meant X is twisting their words. However, you did not take the opportunity to correct WC, you refused to respond, period. This is not a "have you stopped beating your wife?" question. It was an open ended question on your support or dislike of CU, with plenty of room for you to discuss the matter in detail. Yet you refuse to clarify. This isn't a real world debate where people can shout over each other. You have all the time you like to explain his alleged perfidy.

There's a reason constant sardonicism doesn't work in real life as a debating technique; sooner or later you're going to have to back something up, or you end up saying something you regret, and you have to start backpedalling or run away. That's why I simply don't use it very often.

Of course, you could've just said "I do not support CU, and I was being sarcastic only when I said [statement]."

Ummmmm... Lulz!

63, did you miss the :rolleyes: ???

Did you? Possibly? Maybe? All encompassingly?

Well it just so happens I put :rolleyes: there because I was being sarcastic.

"...that's exactly what I said..." is where I was being sarcastic - In other words, IT'S NOT EXACTLY WHAT I SAID!

Figure it out yet?
 
University of California police this morning arrested protesters from the "Occupy the Farm" movement, ending a standoff that had stretched out for weeks. The protesters began clearing the land on April 22, demanding that it be used for sustainable agriculture.


http://content.usatoday.com/communi...protesters-at-uc-berkeley-site/1#.T7FQNsUaf4E

So the Occutards want to take over other people's property to open one of their stupid "local, organic, natural farms"? It's been suggested by O'tard sympathizers in this thread that one of their main goals is to raise awareness of "corporate coruption" (whatever that is). I suppose this stunt somehow furthers that goal. Way to stay laser focused on the mission, Occutards!
 
Ummmmm... Lulz!

63, did you miss the :rolleyes: ???

Did you? Possibly? Maybe? All encompassingly?

Well it just so happens I put :rolleyes: there because I was being sarcastic.

"...that's exactly what I said..." is where I was being sarcastic - In other words, IT'S NOT EXACTLY WHAT I SAID!

Figure it out yet?

So you do not support CU? Thanks for clearing that up.
 
It sounds like there's some confusion over CU the court case and CU the organization.


Haha, seriously, have you been reading this thread?!?
WildCat, Central Scrutinizer, applecorped...

Yes, they are often sardonic, and they often back their claims up, use things we all know, or provide claims that we can find backup for in about ten seconds of Googling. DC, however, seems to rely almost exclusively on a mockery, sarcasm, and tu quoque.

The Tea party, with all of its faults, got people elected. ...
Nowhere near as irresponsible as OWS. Bill O'Reilly hasn't yet raped anyone, killed anyone, set fire to anything, been charged with terrorism for trying to blow up a bridge in Ohio, etc etc.
I'm pretty sure we all knew about "corporate corruption" long before the Occutards came along.

Do the names WorldCom, Enron, Adelphia or Tyco mean nothing to you?
 
Last edited:
No, seriously Jane, I'm ignoring your posts. I can see them, and I'm choosing to just keep scrolling. I'm not even reading them. You contribute less substantial content than DC, and I've never, ever seen you admit when you were wrong. I might as well argue with a tree.
Incidentally, the 1% actually own 40% of wealth in the US, the top 5% own 20%. If you combine the top 20 they own 80%. Of course they pay more taxes. The 80% that are left are dividing 20% of the wealth of the US. So yes, many of them will be a low-income or poverty bracket which is not taxed.

To continue to give tax cuts to the people who own 80% of the wealth is not fiscally sound.

I would like to see some backup for those numbers. No, wait, there's no way the top 1% can own less than the top 5%.

If the claim is that the 1% pay less taxes, and they actually pay more taxes, then the claim is false. One of OWS's biggest points is flat wrong.

Still nothing about how your statements about the government's concerns were...poorly phrased, let's call it?
 
Last edited:
Because there's a difference between reading and ignoring parts of people's posts while addressing others, and ignoring the person entirely.

I'm guessing, here, I don't know what you posted.
 
No, seriously Jane, I'm ignoring your posts. I can see them, and I'm choosing to just keep scrolling. I'm not even reading them. You contribute less substantial content than DC...

If that's how you feel.

Seems you're just another conservative who wants to pick a fight with me.

Tell me, where have you or WildCat or haze or applecorped said anything substantial?

I keep seeing the "occutard" word being used again and again. Now the conversation he's reached a new low where you just want to attack me and tell me how "unsubstantial" I am! You guys really need to get a life! Seriously! We're only having a discussion on a measly internet forum... RELAX!!
 
If that's how you feel.

Seems you're just another conservative who wants to pick a fight with me.
I'm a guy on a forum discussing what I see as flaws in the debating/discussion habits of another. But feel free to attack my imagined motivations while ignoring what I'm actually saying.

Tell me, where have you or WildCat or haze or applecorped said anything substantial?
Post #5282 for me. I don't think Haze has posted recently.

OWS cheerleader Roseanne Barr says she should be executed, along with everyone else worth more than $100 million.

Does OWS even exist as an entity? Or was it just a clever branding of the disparate groups that rally around the "anti-capitalist" cause but agree on little and are often hostile to each other.

That would be an irrelevant question. Since this thread is not about the Tea Party, as much as it serves as a useful distraction for OWS supporters on the defensive.

You may have a point. It came into existence as a number of groups of individuals who shared concerns about the power of the federal government and the level of taxation.

However, "sole entity" or not, it did have an easily identifiable twofold goal: to reduce the power of the federal government and reduce taxes. You'd probably find some who would argue that this is the same thing. The groups individually organizing under that "tea party" brand went to some trouble to keep their protests legal.

OWS, on the other hand, seems like an umbrella brand for folks who have made a hobby of protest.

Much of what we've seen from the signs, chanting, and written stuff from OWS has been about greed, redistribution of wealth, and anti capitalist ideas. That you want to say what the movement is really about is a fallacy by assertion.

Kind of my point. They're more concerned with Saying Something than saying anything.

Here are the people you're defending, Jane. Note that this is Union Square, not Montreal. From March.





I have seen children with more maturity than this lot. This is turning even people who support OWS against them. Not even "No True Occupier", straight-up "shut up guys you're making us look bad".

http://gothamist.com/2012/03/23/video_occupy_wall_street_protesters_1.php
http://gothamist.com/2012/03/23/video_occupy_wall_street_protesters_1.php#comment-474516643
Note how Jarek says its wrong to judge OWS by the actions of a few protestors, yet has no problem judging all the police by those who he feels oppress OWS.

So one second OWS' 1st Amendment rights are being violated, the next what they do doesn't matter so the cops shouldn't be offended.

http://gothamist.com/2012/03/23/video_occupy_wall_street_protesters_1.php#comment-474475522
Oh, look, anti-semitism.




http://www.ethecofem.com/an-occupiers-thoughts-on-leadership-and-authority/
Given that a leader is, by definition, an authority figure from which people take direction, I'd say yes.

I always love it when people try to rewrite the dictionary. The funny thing is the definition of "authority" they quote has this as the third definition.

a: power to influence or command thought, opinion, or behaviorb:
a: persons in command;

And, of course, they don't quote the Webster definition of "leader".

: something that leads
2. a person who leads
b (2) : a person who has commanding authority or influence

Yep, those are the usual tactics, assuming that someone reading this thread is going to see the word occutard and go out and discriminate against the developmentally disabled, after all, three teenagers in the UK did.

By the same token the black bloc is racist after all what are we supposed to think ? A group dressing up in black, calling themselves black, we may just come to the conclusion that black people are all violent clowns.

We see protesters taunting cops, we see videos of protesters getting pepper sprayed and we naturally come to the conclusion that the protesters were asking for it. We become "authoritarian"

We all pay the price for these political extremists actions. Because protesters like to go on destructive rampages, the residents of Chicago are getting permanent surveillance cameras and beach.park closures. Because some moron with a bomb in his shoe tried to blow up a plane, we get to take off our shoes before boarding and because someone doing direct action got on a plane with a bomb in his underwear, we have to go through those porno scanners.

Political extremists,hiding behind their bandannas and masks are no friends to the general population. Not only do they hold us in contempt because we're not them with their oh so superior moral enlightenment that they can twist and manipulate to allow themselves the very same attitudes towards segments of society that they are critical of us for holding. Eg. comparing cops to animals because they "have more power" and hating conservatives for bring conservatives.

We can look at the Kelly Thomas video and see a clear cut case of murder however after the Trayvon Martin incident we're wondering whether there might be a race angle to the assault. Not racist, of course, because as the radical left keeps telling us, Latinos are POC and POC can't be racist because they're not the dominant group in society. The second cop charged in that murder ? Turns out he only had one eye, he was disabled.

I gather you don't think self policing is a serious idea so we can ask...Civil disobedience, how's that working out for occupy ? What happened to all their support ? The support they had in the first week of the occupation ? Where's Hollywood, Rosie O'Donnell ? You remember her, the one who said that anyone with more than a hundred million in the bank should be executed ?

Turns out she's only got eighty million herself, so yea, I can totally relate to her concerns.

So do actions, and you seem to simply ignore and hand wave away the juvenile and destructive actions of the Occutards, and instead make an issue of the use of slang.

Do I need to in order to plainly see that OWS actions are destructive, naive, and juvenile?

Agreed however if occupy isn't going to even acknowledge that they are being manipulated into buying and using the latest consumer goods then this argument is moot wrt the power corporations have over society. We're victims of the corporations, remember ?



No, occupy is claiming to speak for everyone, the 99%, they should listen to us and our criticisms yet they don't. Any Joe on the street could have foretold that the occupy, the tents tactic was doomed to failure right from the start, that they'd be over run with homeless people and get themselves shut down.

Occupy told us they were going to rebuild society from the ground up, they didn't listen when we told them we didn't want our society rebuilt on some sort of anarchist model.

Occupy ignored us when we said they needed to defend their identity after they, predictably, attracted every cause in the book, from twoofers to chemtrailers to immigrant rights groups and appeared to be taking over the protest industry with their brand.

Simply because they didn't listen to the people they were claiming to represent, they lost everything and are now vainly attempting to rebuild something that's doomed, once again to failure.



They're completely revalent, it's what takes an idea from the fringes to the mainstream. If occupy tells us we're being manipulated the least they can do is prove that they themselves haven't been manipulated.



It doesn't really, there could be all sorts of factors at play here maybe Europeans are more educated about advertising and debt or maybe they don't have the same bankruptcy protection laws, you know the good law:) that we have here in the US and Canada.



This is politics, this is an emotional issue, it's all about caring.



Cheers, thanks for the clarification.



No, it's not the sole solution, I just want occupy to address it, something they simply refuse to do. All they can do is respond with "that's stupid" or some such asshattery,it's a problem when your movement has no identity, it can be about anything and everything at any time

Then what is the purpose of OWS? We've been told that they are raising awareness of how unfair the world is, yet you say we've already identified the failures.

When is OWS going to get a candidate on the ballot?

So let me get this straight. The various community city ordinances around the country decided via democratic means, restricting park hours and camping, each dependent on their respective communities, is a horrible oppression which you and other OWSers suffer tremendously, is an unacceptable restriction on peacefully assembly and first amendment rights that time and place restrictions are draconian in your opinion but 60 days prior to an election is a reasonable time and place restriction on speech? Two weeks seems more reasonable to me.

And directly before that, he said "Same thing I say about the Republicans who kill doctors and blow up abortion clinics, I hope they go to prison." He made the comparison again in #4988. Or did you not know most of the people opposed to OWS in this thread are conservative?

OWS members do something good, all of OWS takes credit, even when it's outside of what's generally regarded as their goals. OWS is dealt with by police, help, help, it's all of OWS who's being oppressed. OWS members do something bad, and it's the fault of only the people who did the bad things, who don't represent OWS and never really did.
Looks pretty substantial.


I keep seeing the "occutard" word being used again and again.
And I and others have said we don't approve of such language. I went out of my way to state such, whereupon Jane tried to snidely assert that I was lying. Yet no one who supports OWS seems to call out Jane for comparing cops to pigs. And finding them wanting.

Now the conversation he's reached a new low where you just want to attack me and tell me how "unsubstantial" I am! You guys really need to get a life! Seriously! We're only having a discussion on a measly internet forum... RELAX!!
I was talking to Jane, explaining why I'm not reading her posts. I have never had a productive discussion with her, ever. I don't mean productive for my side, I mean productive, period, anywhere on JREF.

You, at least in the US politics forum, seem to argue mostly in one-liners and/or sardonicism.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for making the point I was only alluding to.

ping RandFan.
I'm pretty sure that people knew about racism and segregation prior to the civil rights activists.

Come on. Raising awareness is about a lot more than just informing people that there is a problem. It's letting them know that the problems are systemic and to let them know that their leaders are not working to solve the problems. In fact, the banks and corporations are working hard right now to get rid of the flaccid regulation that was put in place after the banking scandal. People ought to know that? People ought to know that banks can pretty much do the things they did before that got us into this mess?

So, we need a hell of a lot more awareness raising.
 
Yes we do. Damn shame OWS so far isn't providing it, other than crap like the pepper-spray fiasco.

If the cops would have just waded in with billy clubs to the dangling donut bunch they would have had something else.

Yet, no link yet between OWS and an actual attempt to point out corrupt corporate activities.
 
Come on. Raising awareness is about a lot more than just informing people that there is a problem. It's letting them know that the problems are systemic and to let them know that their leaders are not working to solve the problems. In fact, the banks and corporations are working hard right now to get rid of the flaccid regulation that was put in place after the banking scandal. People ought to know that? People ought to know that banks can pretty much do the things they did before that got us into this mess?

People do know that. At least people who choose to keep themselves informed. And people who are smart enough to know that camping out and beating on drums isn't going to solve anything. Nor will eliminating debt (an Occutard favorite).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom