Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sorry. Try this.
I don't find a google search for articles written by people who made the link OWS points out corprate corruption persuasive. Why do you?

I honestly have no idea what the disconnect here is?

  • OWS makes a lot of noise about corporate corruption.
  • The news media talks about OWS and corporate corruption.
  • More news stories means more awareness about OWS and corporate corruption.
What's there not to get?
The link. When and where did 'OWS make noise about corporate corruption' that you found persuasive?

Don't get me wrong; I too am unhappy about corporate corruption, but even more unhappy with politicians per se. And no I don't see a republican congress and presidency a cure-all.

The JPMorgan crap hitting the fan is more of the same and it worries me. The fact that Obama seems to think Jamie Dimon is a financial guru also worries me.
 
I don't find a google search for articles written by people who made the link OWS points out corprate corruption persuasive. Why do you?
31,000,000 hits. A.) Are you honestly telling me you have never heard of OWS and corporate corruption in the news. B.) You don' think 31,000,000 hits ISN'T awareness? Dude, come one?


The link. When and where did 'OWS make noise about corporate corruption' that you found persuasive?
I honestly, seriously, have no idea what your complaint is. Sorry. "Persuasive"? 31,000,000 hits.

To answer your question. I found the following media sources persuasive with their stories about OWS and corporate corruption:

Time Magazine
News Week
The New York Times
The Young Turks.
Keith Olberman.
Matt Taibbi (Rolling Stone).

If you need more I can give you more.

Don't get me wrong; I too am unhappy about corporate corruption, but even more unhappy with politicians per se. And no I don't see a republican congress and presidency a cure-all.

The JPMorgan crap hitting the fan is more of the same and it worries me. The fact that Obama seems to think Jamie Dimon is a financial guru also worries me.
We can agree on that.
 
I'm pretty sure we all knew about "corporate corruption" long before the Occutards came along.

Do the names WorldCom, Enron, Adelphia or Tyco mean nothing to you?
 
...and that's exactly what I saaaaaid... :rolleyes:
I know, you are not a person who supports free speech. You want free speech only for points of view that you share.

Do you know what kinds of countries share your view?
 
After that, nothing more was heard of the Tea Party. Sorry, but as far as I can tell, nothing substantial was accomplished. Unfortunately, I believe that the original Tea Party had some laudable goals. But it seems like they were quickly co-opted by the GOP, who convinced them that all they needed to do to fix things was vote Republican. There are similar elements in OWS, trying to convince us that voting for Obama will solve all of our problems, but that doesn't seem to be going over too well.

The point was about methods, and the relative success. There are now a couple of congressmen who will certainly be willing to listen to the people who did work to get them elected. That's not a huge step, but it's a step.
I'll agree with you that the Tea Party should not have let themselves get co-opted by the Republican party.

What concrete goals has OWS accomplished? For that matter, what concrete goals have they set?
 
The point was about methods, and the relative success. There are now a couple of congressmen who will certainly be willing to listen to the people who did work to get them elected. That's not a huge step, but it's a step.
I'll agree with you that the Tea Party should not have let themselves get co-opted by the Republican party.

What concrete goals has OWS accomplished? For that matter, what concrete goals have they set?
Fair questions but I'm not sure what the answers tell us. Had you asked that question of the Civil rights activists, for years at a time, I'd have to say they had accomplished nothing concrete. They certainly had cross purpose goals and disagreed on how to accomplish those goals.
 
Fair questions but I'm not sure what the answers tell us. Had you asked that question of the Civil rights activists, for years at a time, I'd have to say they had accomplished nothing concrete. They certainly had cross purpose goals and disagreed on how to accomplish those goals.
Yet more of the "OWS is just like the 60's protests" arguments. Failed the first time it was used. Still fails.
 
A lot of talk, about people who "signify nothing".

But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright Brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.
-attr. Carl Sagan

Dude!

PFFT!

I'm not even answering this ridiculous question!

Are you going to at least explain why it's ridiculous?
 
But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright Brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.
-attr. Carl Sagan



Are you going to at least explain why it's ridiculous?

They were right about Columbus.
 
But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright Brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.
-attr. Carl Sagan



Are you going to at least explain why it's ridiculous?

Umm because WildCat is attempting to manipulate my own words. And doing a very poor job, mind you.
 
Umm because WildCat is attempting to manipulate my own words. And doing a very poor job, mind you.
I'm not so sure he is.

[Citizens United] is a right wing supported organization with an agenda.
This would seem to indicatethat you are against CU.

omg, we have to take away their free speech rights before they convince someone to vote for a tea party candidate!!!1!1!!
WC believes that CU actually supports free speech rights, as he has asserted repeatedly.

...and that's exactly what I saaaaaid... :rolleyes:

I know, you are not a person who supports free speech. You want free speech only for points of view that you share.

Do you know what kinds of countries share your view?

Do you know what sarcasm is?

So you actually support the Citizens United decision?

Dude!

PFFT!

I'm not even answering this ridiculous question!
You implied you were being sarcastic. Yet when WC asked you, point blank, if you were being sarcastic when you were disparaging of CU, you refused to answer.

I don't see how asking someone if they meant X is twisting their words. However, you did not take the opportunity to correct WC, you refused to respond, period. This is not a "have you stopped beating your wife?" question. It was an open ended question on your support or dislike of CU, with plenty of room for you to discuss the matter in detail. Yet you refuse to clarify. This isn't a real world debate where people can shout over each other. You have all the time you like to explain his alleged perfidy.

There's a reason constant sardonicism doesn't work in real life as a debating technique; sooner or later you're going to have to back something up, or you end up saying something you regret, and you have to start backpedalling or run away. That's why I simply don't use it very often.

Of course, you could've just said "I do not support CU, and I was being sarcastic only when I said [statement]."
 
Last edited:
'Occupy Global Day of Action #Occupymay' (video)

""""Saturday 12 May, police from virtually every borough in London - in addition to members of the Territorial Support Group - violently removed supporters of Occupy London who were simply sitting on the steps of the Royal Exchange. The arrests came after a day of "Meet the 1%" activities around the city timed to coincide with an international day of action marked in over 380 cities worldwide.

A Section 14 should only be put in place when there is a serious risk of imminent public disorder, damage to property or serious disruption to the life of the community. Occupy London's peaceful gathering near the Bank of England showed no potential for any of these outcomes, which would go against the principles of Occupy anyway. We are about engaging with the public in meaningful and creative ways. In any case, there is very little in the way of real community in that area; particularly on a Saturday when everything is closed.

Melanie Strickland, a supporter of Occupy London said: "What occurred on the steps of the Royal Exchange was a shocking act of political policing. We were told that the senior officer had imposed restrictions on our assembly and that we were liable to arrest, but no officer could tell us how that section applied to us. From 6.40pm teams of police started snatching peaceful activists from the crowd, one by one. The police were aggressive, employing disproportionate and unlawful force. Women and men were assaulted as they sat linking arms on the steps in solidarity. Police attacked activists using techniques designed to inflict maximum pain without leaving marks."

On 15 May it will be one year since the start of the indignados movement, and the fight against bailouts, corruption, repeating economic crises, and financial crimes continues. People are still occupying and protesting to bring about a better world.
""""
 
This would seem to indicate that you are against CU.
It sounds like there's some confusion over CU the court case and CU the organization.

There's a reason constant sardonicism doesn't work in real life as a debating technique; sooner or later you're going to have to back something up, or you end up saying something you regret, and you have to start backpedalling or run away. That's why I simply don't use it very often.
Haha, seriously, have you been reading this thread?!?
WildCat, Central Scrutinizer, applecorped...
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom