Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
As I said, that's been discussed on this page. Including an explanation of why your characterization is unreasonable.
I have a number of people involved in this thread on ignore. I suspect it is one of them that discussed it. I understand that putting someone on ignore places me at a disadvantage and that doing so is not conducive to a discussion and it is not fair to ask you to advance someone else's argument. So I'll accept that an argument has been advanced that addresses the point and leave it at that.

Point happily conceded. On the other hand, other authorities on law enforcement and the use of force have been consulted in this thread as well. So I'm comfortable with continuing to say that this report is not "especially authoritative".
While I take issues with the "especially authoritative" point I will agree that there is a point to be made about conflicting authority.

I'm not sure what you're trying to say here.
Folks who have defended the police have acted as if it is plain and obvious that the police acted in the only possible way they could have and no counter arguments are reasonable. There has been much browbeating of those who have taken a counter position (I'll admit that the animosity and recriminations have been on both sides and I unfortunately contributed). It would be nice to get some acknowledgement at least that the rather demonstrative claims are not without rebuttal. I put people on ignore and eventually left the thread because I found that a discussion with many was simply not possible. Again, I admit that I was, at least in part, responsible for some of that animosity.

The way I see it, nobody is going to just leave it at that. As long as people are invested in making something of this incident--either holding it up as an example of occutardery, or as an example of police brutality--there will not be the slightest interest, in simply agreeing that reasonable people can reach different conclusions, and moving on from there.

But I think your inclination towards rapprochement is admirable. I think if you extended an olive branch along the lines you sketched above, it might be well-received.
Thanks. I appreciate your tone and willingness to discuss this with me. I will say up front that I do not know for a fact that the report is not biased. I don't know that should there be a civil action that Lt Pike would or would not be cleared. I'm happy to take the report with some degree of skepticism. So, I'll concede your original point that the report does not constitute conclusive evidence of failure of the police to act appropriately.

Thanks.
 
Actually, it did:
Oh, good, so it's not a complete failure.

Of course, given that the students in question were actively and physically resisting less forceful attempts at removal-the cops did gently tug on their arms-the pepper spray use was well within just about any use of force standard in the continental US. Heck, back last winter, I found several police manuals throughout the US and one in Australia (land of the drop bear) that said as much. In this very thread, IIRC.
 
263894eceaaa41ff11.jpg
 
So is the Tea Party, and yet they had a significant impact on electoral results, just a few short months after emerging as a movement.

Yeah, so significant that Mitt Romney is now the front runner for the Republicans... go figure! :rolleyes:
 
Very little, other than costing cities and the 99% millions.

Oh, you were talking about the Tea Party? Hanged if I know.
 
Which is weird, because when you point out America is the world's 1%, you get no response.
 
Very little, other than costing cities and the 99% millions.

Oh, you were talking about the Tea Party? Hanged if I know.

Support for the Tea Party I guess.

Gee, the Hannity forum is looking so much like a ray of light every day!
 
I thought they were protesting NATO now for...sitting in their big NATO buildings. Being all NATOwy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom