Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Will the Democrats win because of all the wonderful things they've accomplished regarding whatever it is that Occupy is so butthurt about?

Yes. And they'll win because voters understand that more could have been done, if not for the obstructionism of the GOP.
 
Perhaps I'm missing something.

Is that nothing?
Nothing in terms of the law or official policy that prevented the use of pepper spray. That it was needed because the police were surrounded is questionable. That they used the big instead of the small can has been identified as inappropriate. That pepper spray was appropriate for the control of the active resisters has already be quoted.
 
Surely it can't have escaped your notice that you and Neally are using the same report to reach opposing conclusions.
Surely it can't have escaped your notice that I'm posting conclusions from the paper. In short, I'm not reaching conclusions. Just quoting the report.

That's something for you and Neally to work out amongst yourselves.
The report speaks for itself.
 
If you say so.
No. NOT if I say so.

The Decision to Use Pepper Spray Was Not Supported by Objective Evidence and Was Not Authorized by Policy
I didn't make that up. It's copied and pasted from the report. Now look, you don't have to respond but the conclusions stated in the report are a fact and not a matter of opinion. If someone wants to argue the conclusions are wrong that's one thing. Claiming that the report doesn't state what it clearly states is lying.

Indeed it does.
  • Do you deny that the sentence quoted above is from the report?
  • Do you deny that the sentence states that the use of pepper spray was not authorized by policy?
Again, you need not respond to me. But if you are going to pretend that the report doesn't state what it clearly states then I'm going to correct that inaccuracy. Put me on ignore if you don't like it.
 
Last edited:
No. NOT if I say so.

I didn't make that up. It's copied and pasted from the report. Now look, you don't have to respond but the conclusions stated in the report are a fact and not a matter of opinion. If someone wants to argue the conclusions are wrong that's one thing. Claiming that the report doesn't state what it clearly states is lying.


  • Do you deny that the sentence quoted above is from the report?
  • Do you deny that the sentence states that the use of pepper spray was not authorized by policy?
Again, you need not respond to me. But if you are going to pretend that the report doesn't state what it clearly states then I'm going to correct that inaccuracy. Put me on ignore if you don't like it.

Oops. What a terrible misunderstanding! Let me explain: When I said, "if you say so", it wasn't to express agreement that you were quoting from the report (which of course you were). It was to express agreement that quoting from the report was the only thing you were doing (which of course it was).

Anyway, I'll leave you to it.
 
Oops. What a terrible misunderstanding! Let me explain: When I said, "if you say so", it wasn't to express agreement that you were quoting from the report (which of course you were). It was to express agreement that quoting from the report was the only thing you were doing (which of course it was).

Anyway, I'll leave you to it.
Sorry for the miscommunication. In the future you might want to simply use the word "okay". I think you would find that it goes a long way to avoid conveying the wrong message.

Thanks.
 
I love how the report blames the officers for "not arranging for transportation". Because it's their fault the students prevented them from walking their prisoners out of there. It's the same logic that says if a woman wears a skimpy dress, she's just asking for sexual assault and harassment. Yes, the officers totally "escalated" the situation by standing there and letting the other students protest. The funny thing is that I've heard the exact same argument from people defending the students.

Section 2 said:
A total of six dispersal orders were given over the next several minutes.
Section 2C said:
First, and foremost, the apparent reason for the officer and arrestees remaining on the
Quad after the tents were down was because there had been no arrangements made to
transport the arrestees from the Quad. The lack of timely decision-making by Lts. Pike
and to respond to this unplanned situation caused an escalation of an already
volatile situation.

On balance, there is little factual basis supporting Lt. Pike’s belief that he was trapped by
the protesters or that his officers were prevented from leaving the Quad. Further, there is
little evidence that any protesters attempted to use violence against the police. The Kroll
report did note that felt a protester was attempting to “attack” another officer
and they had a brief altercation.
Officer Q
Of course, this ignores the argument that the officers were prevented from leaving with their prisoners. The crowd specifically wanted the cops to leave, but not their suspects. It also says the crowd was not a threat because they didn't physically attack and ignores the students' threats. Again, same argument I've seen people make defending the students. They even use a wordier version of "Pike didn't act threatened."

At the time the
operation was mounted (and continuing until the present) it was not clear what
legal authority existed for the campus police to remove the tents and arrest those
who opposed them.
Of course, it "not clear" because the Campus Counsel raised the question.

“Their assumption was [that] we should anticipate that if we are engaged in nonviolent
protests the police are still going to use violence against us. Because from the students’
perspective, the presence of police on campus is intrinsically violent. Their belief, before
the pepper spray incident, and their statement beforehand, had been that we want police
off campus because police are military, and they are violent, and look what they do at Berkeley, look what they do at UCLA. We don’t want this here. This is not what we
envision in a University campus.”
160
This is rather hypocritical, considering that they threatened the police with violence.

I like the Sea-Lawyer nonsense about "oh, we're not using these tents for overnight camping".

This report is a joke. It tries to do everything it can to tar the cops and UCD, ignores any responsibility on the part of the students, and actively or accidentally misrepresents the situation in several key aspects, such as referring to the students' chants as simply "let them go!".

I honestly wonder what people would be saying if the crowd had rioted and taken back the prisoners by force, leading to serious injury on the part of protestors and officers. What if a cop had gotten brain-damaged or killed? What if a protestor had?

No, wait, I know that last one; they would be saying the cops did it, even if video surfaced showing a protestor was responsible, which they would declare faked or ignore entirely.
 
Last edited:
I love how the report blames the officers for "not arranging for transportation". Because it's their fault the students prevented them from walking their prisoners out of there. It's the same logic that says if a woman wears a skimpy dress, she's just asking for sexual assault and harassment. Yes, the officers totally "escalated" the situation by standing there and letting the other students protest. The funny thing is that I've heard the exact same argument from people defending the students.




Of course, this ignores the argument that the officers were prevented from leaving with their prisoners. The crowd specifically wanted the cops to leave, but not their suspects. It also says the crowd was not a threat because they didn't physically attack and ignores the students' threats. Again, same argument I've seen people make defending the students. They even use a wordier version of "Pike didn't act threatened."

Of course, it "not clear" because the Campus Counsel raised the question.

This is rather hypocritical, considering that they threatened the police with violence.

I like the Sea-Lawyer nonsense about "oh, we're not using these tents for overnight camping".

This report is a joke. It tries to do everything it can to tar the cops and UCD, ignores any responsibility on the part of the students, and actively or accidentally misrepresents the situation in several key aspects, such as referring to the students' chants as simply "let them go!".

I honestly wonder what people would be saying if the crowd had rioted and taken back the prisoners by force, leading to serious injury on the part of protestors and officers. What if a cop had gotten brain-damaged or killed? What if a protestor had?

No, wait, I know that last one; they would be saying the cops did it, even if video surfaced showing a protestor was responsible, which they would declare faked or ignore entirely.

Well, I'm disapointed. Looks like the report won't be all things to all people after all.

However, I think a reasonable case can be made for rejecting the report's conclusions. If the report reaches its conclusions based on the same evidence already available, then people who have reached their own conclusions based on the same evidence will have no justification changing their minds.

It would be different, of course, if the report included new evidence not previously available, that might change the conclusion. It would also be different if those who agreed with the report's conclusions were able to mount a successful (non-fallacious) appeal to the authority of the report's authors. That doesn't look likely.

In any case, those who have reached a different conclusion than the report, have already appealed to expert authority to support their conclusion. Unless the authority of the report's authors can be shown to trump the authority of the subject-matter experts previously cited in this thread, I think that 000063 is perfectly justified in retaining their existing conclusion in the face of the report: There is no new evidence presented, and the report's authors are not especially authoritative.

I suppose one might say that the report is actually "no things to nobody".
 
However, I think a reasonable case can be made for rejecting the report's conclusions. If the report reaches its conclusions based on the same evidence already available, then people who have reached their own conclusions based on the same evidence will have no justification changing their minds.
My main interest was finding out if there was any law or regulations protocol that indicated that spraying the protestors was illegal or improper, which of course would have justified disciplinary action against the cop that did it. With the exception of using the wrong size can of pepper spray, there was not.
 
It would be different, of course, if the report included new evidence not previously available, that might change the conclusion.
There is a lot in the report that I didn't know. And much that I've not seen discussed. That's not to say that it hasn't been discussed so I apologize if it has. Let me take one instance, according to Kroll, the third party risk management firm who was hired to conduct an investigation, they note that one officer escorted two different protestors under arrest past the seated group to a squad car.

Reynoso Report said:
On balance, there is little factual basis supporting Lt. Pike’s belief that he was trapped by the protesters or that his officers were prevented from leaving the Quad. Further, there is little evidence that any protesters attempted to use violence against the police.
I've not seen the arguments that explain why it was not possible to evacuate those arrested while at the same time it was possible.

theprestige said:
...and the report's authors are not especially authoritative.
I don't think that is correct.

Reynoso Report said:
To assist the Task Force with fact finding and the identification of best practices in policing, the University engaged Kroll, Inc., an internationally known risk management firm.
It would seem there is some basis to claim authority. Had the task force relied solely on their own authority I would find that complaint more compelling.

theprestige said:
In any case, those who have reached a different conclusion than the report, have already appealed to expert authority to support their conclusion.
I would be willing to acknowledge the point if the folks on the other side of the fence would agree that there is a reasonable basis to believe the police acted inappropriately.
 
Last edited:
My main interest was finding out if there was any law or regulations protocol that indicated that spraying the protestors was illegal or improper, which of course would have justified disciplinary action against the cop that did it. With the exception of using the wrong size can of pepper spray, there was not.
I don't think it even addresses the use of force standards. It just makes it binary. "Katehi told them not to use force. They used force. Therefore they were wrong."

It does everything it can to imply, however, that Pike was a dangerous maverick, possibly in a department full of mavericks, maybe headed by a maverick.

I also like how they seem to have difficulty contacting the students in question. Despite all their apparent dilligence, they couldn't find the interviews on Youtube where they admit they deliberately obstructed police? And repeatedly gloss over the threats? And claim the police "provoked" the attack? They are either biased, or incompetent, or both.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it even addresses the use of force standards.
Actually, it did:

Most police departments across the United States use a training device commonly referred to as a “use of force continuum” as a means of training their officers on when and what type of force to use. Most of these continuums—there is no standard national continuum—allow the use of pepper spray when confronted with “active resistance. Thus, the use of pepper spray against seated protesters linking arms may be technically permissible.
 
There is a lot in the report that I didn't know. And much that I've not seen discussed. That's not to say that it hasn't been discussed so I apologize if it has. Let me take one instance, according to Kroll, the third party risk management firm who was hired to conduct an investigation, they note that one officer escorted two different protestors under arrest past the seated group to a squad car.
Yeah, that's been discussed on this page.

I've not seen the arguments that explain why it was not possible to evacuate those arrested while at the same time it was possible.
Probably because "not possible to evacuate those arrested while at the same time it was possible" is not a reasonable characterization.

As I said, that's been discussed on this page. Including an explanation of why your characterization is unreasonable.

I don't think that is correct.
Fair enough.

It would seem there is some basis to claim authority. Had the task force relied solely on their own authority I would find that complaint more compelling.
Point happily conceded. On the other hand, other authorities on law enforcement and the use of force have been consulted in this thread as well. So I'm comfortable with continuing to say that this report is not "especially authoritative".

I would be willing to acknowledge the point if the folks on the other side of the fence would agree that there is a reasonable basis to believe the police acted inappropriately.
I'm not sure what you're trying to say here.

If you're saying, "I've read the report and considered the evidence, and the report's conclusions seem reasonable to me", that's fine with me.

If you're saying "Other people, considering the evidence and reading the report, could reasonably disagree with its conclusions", that's fine with me too.

Whether either of those things is fine with anybody else is something you'll have to take up with them.

The way I see it, nobody is going to just leave it at that. As long as people are invested in making something of this incident--either holding it up as an example of occutardery, or as an example of police brutality--there will not be the slightest interest, in simply agreeing that reasonable people can reach different conclusions, and moving on from there.

But I think your inclination towards rapprochement is admirable. I think if you extended an olive branch along the lines you sketched above, it might be well-received.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom