Obamacare lies exposed for what they are ...

And, of course, that will be good for those taxpaying companies and their taxpaying employees. Right? :D

Generaly it's not considered worthwhile keeping companies on simply for their tax revinue when their cost to the wider ecomomy is much higher.
 
Gwhen their cost to the wider ecomomy is much higher.

That hasn't been established as fact yet. What we do know is that you can't point to a single government enterprise that has been run in a cost effective and efficient manner. Government run activities ... especially when it comes to social programs ... are notoriously wasteful. Based on that record, I'd hazard that the odds of government managed health care reducing the cost of health care in America at about ZERO. But some people will never learn from history. They are doomed to repeat the same mistakes over and over. :D
 
That hasn't been established as fact yet. What we do know is that you can't point to a single government enterprise that has been run in a cost effective and efficient manner.

Ordinance survey. Air traffic control made good money before they sold off a bunch of it to the private sector.

Government run activities ... especially when it comes to social programs ... are notoriously wasteful.

Compared to the overspend in say the average private sector canal project not so much.
 
Don't you know Ben? You must be very religious to walk around quoting what Jesus would say. :D

BTW: Since you are so versed in the sayings of Jesus, perhaps you could also tell us what he said about THEFT? ;)
us_dollar_back.gif


"Whose is the image and the superscription?"

And finally, you might also like to know that conservatives are far more charitable (with their own money) than liberals. This has been proven over and over. :D
Since one-third of "charitable" donations are to religious institutions, this discrepancy might be accounted for by the fact that no liberal is dumb enough to attempt to bribe God by buying a televangelist a private jet.
 
The long and short of it is that health care costs as much as it does because there has to be a profit for someone as it is structured now. Because care givers, doctors and hospitals must occcassionally absorb huge costs from indigent patients, in order to make a profit, they must shove some of those costs onto patients who can pay for them.

Covering everyone would ensure, at least, that no one pays directly for the indigents.

As for the McCain plan to just give everyone a voucher for private coverage, we have to remember that this is still a lot less than a full year's coverage.

Most families, especially during an ecconomic down-turn are simply not going to be able to afford coverage even with the vouchers.

Health insurance was, at one time, by law, a not-for-profit business, and it worked fairly well. That nobody made a profit from it is irrelevant. There is no inherent right to profit from someone else's dispair.

Taking care of each other is a basic trait of humanity. There is no reason not to make the system a part of the commons. It will bring down the cost of each service provided.

The entrepreneur, in an industrialized nation, needs a healthy work force. Diverting some of the income tax revenues to providing a humane health care system is just a reasonable way of providing that resource.
 
Hillarycare led directly to the disastrous democrat election defeat of 1994. Ultimately, the democrats in DC will put self first with a view to the 2010 election. Obamacare is DOA.
 
Hillarycare led directly to the disastrous democrat election defeat of 1994. Ultimately, the democrats in DC will put self first with a view to the 2010 election. Obamacare is DOA.

This is because the Democrats won't do single payer. They keep trying to cut a deal that will make both the American people and the insurance companies happy. Although I consider Obama to be a good deal smarter than Hillary, I don't think he can pull it off, either. And with our economy as bad as it is, right now, it's suicidal to even try.

What the Democrats need to do is quit bowing and scraping to their corporate paymasters and put their weight behind John Conyer's HR 676. I don't think the American people will accept anything less.
 
This is because the Democrats won't do single payer. They keep trying to cut a deal that will make both the American people and the insurance companies happy. Although I consider Obama to be a good deal smarter than Hillary, I don't think he can pull it off, either. And with our economy as bad as it is, right now, it's suicidal to even try.

What the Democrats need to do is quit bowing and scraping to their corporate paymasters and put their weight behind John Conyer's HR 676. I don't think the American people will accept anything less.

Hmm, I'm going to be an idealist. It's the right time, it's the right place. I like it.
 
He's right, balrog. It's only $10,000 A YEAR over the 10 years. Not that $10,000 per person isn't an awful lot to spend on health insurance. But even that amount couldn't buy the health insurance that Obama promised each of us ... the same that members of Congress get. :D


True, and I did mean to state that at the time. ;)


But, still, ... that's 10,000 per person covered, not $10,000 per family. That's $50,000 per year for a family of 5 with no breadwinner and no prospects. All paid from the dollars of productive US taxpayers. :yikes:


So, the Obama administration forcibly takes over the delivery of medical services to the poor and makes it even MORE expensive than MedicAid. Color me surprised! :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Yeah, the current mess is an atrocity. Don't even bring single payer to the table. Start negotiating from the middle. Dems asuming that the GOP is going to be working with them despite public assurances from the GOP that they hate the Democratic party and oppose everything that they stand for. And here comes Tom "folds like a cheap suit" Daschle with his brilliant idea of taking the public option off the table as it is a "sticking point".

Of course it is a sticking point! It's the only thing left on the table that actually matters!

All this health savings accounts/co-ops/increased competition stuff is just handwaving b***s***. At the core of this debate is the question of whether the government is going to step in a become a healthcare provider or funder for average Americans or not.

Health savings accounts are not going to slow down the rising cost of health care or make it easier for poor people to obtain healthcare. And you could accomplish the same task much easier by making health care tax deductable.

Co-ops? Already have them. Costs are still going up.

Increased competition? We have hundreds of competing insurance companies with thousands of different products and costs keep going up. That's not working either.

I support public healthcare if only because it is the only thing we haven't tried yet.
 
The fact that they both indicate similar deficits (and other entities have also made predictions that were comparable) gives them some credibility.


No, it doesn't. The only thing that gives predictions going some ten years into the future any credibility is a track record of prior ten-year projections turning out to be accurate. If there's no track record for accuracy in the long-term projections, then the projections are meaningless, and the numbers might as well have been chosen at random.

The only exception I can see to this is if one wishes to argue that the dire nature of a given long-term projection pushes the government to take action thus changing the future outlook. In that case, there's no way to know if the long-term projection was truly accurate since that history never played out.
 
Last edited:
Jeez, you'd think they'd wait until there was actually a proposal.

In fact, the analysis quoted in the OP is based on a plan before it had coverage expanding programs added to it. It is meaningless, and not Obamacare.
 
What the Democrats need to do is quit bowing and scraping to their corporate paymasters and put their weight behind John Conyer's HR 676. I don't think the American people will accept anything less.


I just read that and it looks very similar to the NHS. The main difference that I noted was that it covered dental and eye care, while the NHS requires a co-pay for these and service provision is limited, and that it also covered chiropractic, which is a bit contentious to say the least.

I presume the proposal is too sensible and too radical to have the proverbial snowball's chance in hell?

Rolfe.
 
That hasn't been established as fact yet. What we do know is that you can't point to a single government enterprise that has been run in a cost effective and efficient manner. Government run activities ... especially when it comes to social programs ... are notoriously wasteful. Based on that record, I'd hazard that the odds of government managed health care reducing the cost of health care in America at about ZERO. But some people will never learn from history. They are doomed to repeat the same mistakes over and over. :D

Red Herring.

The government will not be providing health care.
The only thing the goverment will be doing is to pay the bill when it's presented by the doctor.

There just isn't a significant amount of room for waste.
 
Red Herring.

The government will not be providing health care.
The only thing the goverment will be doing is to pay the bill when it's presented by the doctor.

There just isn't a significant amount of room for waste.


Bwaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahahahaha!

Just like there isn't any room for fraud in Medicare and Medicaid and the VA Hospital System and the Indian Health Care System. :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Oh, wait, Obama says he can squeeze $400 BILLION in waste, fraud and abuse just from Medicare!

Excuse while I get out the popcorn! :rolleyes:
 
Originally Posted by BeAChooser
That hasn't been established as fact yet. What we do know is that you can't point to a single government enterprise that has been run in a cost effective and efficient manner.

Ordinance survey. Air traffic control

ROTFLOL! Desperation time. Ok, I admit that you might have found two that were run in a cost effective and efficient manner. Although a 9 month strike by air traffic controllers after the union demanded a $10,000 across the board raise, a 32-hour workweek, and a better retirement package, and the government refused, doesn't sound very efficient or cost effective. As for Ordinance survey ... clue me in. :D
 
Originally Posted by BeAChooser
The fact that they both indicate similar deficits (and other entities have also made predictions that were comparable) gives them some credibility.

No, it doesn't. The only thing that gives predictions going some ten years into the future any credibility is a track record of prior ten-year projections turning out to be accurate. If there's no track record for accuracy in the long-term projections, then the projections are meaningless, and the numbers might as well have been chosen at random.

Just curious. Are you an advocate of global warming? ;)
 
The government will not be providing health care.
The only thing the goverment will be doing is to pay the bill when it's presented by the doctor.

Incorrect. The government will not be paying the bill. You and I will be paying it. Or at least I will be. :)

There just isn't a significant amount of room for waste.

This one deserves a ROTFLOL! (I dole those out sparingly these days.)
 
And once again: how come all the other developed countries make it work for about 1/2 the cost of the US system, whilst providing at least comparable standards of clinical care?
 
From my point of view, it's not really politically possible to go single payer on the spot. Having a 'public option' is a great idea because it leaves all doors open: if the public option works well, you can gradually move towards single payer. And for folks who are worried that it may not work: well, nothing much to be afraid of, if it doesn't work it will not be used much and can be phased out at a later date.


Here's what I think they ought to do, strategically:
1) Have a vote on a reasonable health reform bill. Eg, one that includes a non-gutted 'public option'.
2) If that fails, openly admit that congress failed.
3) Aggressively campaign against the 'nay' voters, regardless of their party association.
4) Try again in 2010. Some more 'yea' voters may have been elected, and some 'nay' voters who were not up for reelection may change their mind.

Yes, having this reform fail in 2009 would be a major blow to the Obama administration. But not as big a blow as passing a meaningless bill and pretending that it was a success.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom