Obamacare lies exposed for what they are ...

This is probably not an option for such drugs given the terms and conditions of many private health insurance schemes. Certainly the ones I've been involved in assessing wouldn't have paid for such drugs because (to simplify it) they haven't been "approved" by the NHS. Also many private health insurances in the UK have caps on the cost of pharmaceuticals.

ETA: See http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/...xtra-cancer-cover-the-right-prescription.html


That's a very interesting article. I was wondering specifically about NHS top-up policies. Of course the cost should be small, as the chance of needing to claim on such a policy is small for any individual (US posters please note - this is because very few people ever find themselves on the wrong side of an NHS availability decision).

However, the WPA policy looks like a bad deal. Encouraging people to pay in until they're 65 then cutting off cover is bad. Excluding people with a history of cancer in the family is bad. In my view a higher premium with cover continuing throughout life would be a lot more attractive, and why not give people who are currently well but who have a family history of cancer the opportunity to participate, again for a higher premium?

I've sometimes wondered about renewing my BUPA coverage (which I had with my previous job), but as with most people I suppose, my experiences with the NHS (and that includes how I see friends and relatives being treated) makes me very dubious about the benefits of shelling out money for coverage I have little chance of ever needing.

Rolfe.
 
Tonight I saw a GOP wanker pretending that in Britain the government comes between us and our doctors, and I started shouting at the TV about what a rectal sphincter he was.

How can they tell such stupid lies?

They tell such stupid lies because they believe it advances their anti-Obama argument. This isn't really about American health care at all, it's just about slamming Obama.
 
And yet, they're labelling the current healthcare initiative "ObamaCare".

Just supposing this works. And surely it has every chance of shaking down with something significantly better than the present system. Obama's name may be linked to it forever more.

Rolfe.
 
Just supposing this works. And surely it has every chance of shaking down with something significantly better than the present system. Obama's name may be linked to it forever more.
This is also supposing that conservatives would concede if it were working or was significantly better than the present system.

I'd be willing to bet that any improvements would be attributed to something, anything, other than Obama's plans.
 
I think we should just prohibit registered Republicans from getting ANY healthcare under the new system, since they don't want it.

Seriously, the amount of hate they are spewing about this is likely to cause another one of them to take up a gun and go shoot up NIH or something. They would rather 1000 poor (and non-white) people die of preventable causes than they have to pay one more dime in taxes. I wonder what their Jesus would say about that?
 
This is also supposing that conservatives would concede if it were working or was significantly better than the present system.

I'd be willing to bet that any improvements would be attributed to something, anything, other than Obama's plans.


By them, undoubtedly. However, they don't get to decide what the general public thinks about it five years down the road.

You know, I have no idea what sort of a politician Bevan was. Good, bad or indifferent. But he's practically canonised here for setting up the NHS.

Rolfe.
 
Tonight I saw a GOP wanker pretending that in Britain the government comes between us and our doctors, and I started shouting at the TV about what a rectal sphincter he was.

How can they tell such stupid lies?

It's like creationists. If they know what they are talking about, then they are contemptible liars. If they have no idea what they're talking about, how do they have the effrontery to talk about it?

Because they really believe the lies. It seems to be very much about ideological purity than any practical metric.

I see that very often in the people I work with they are absuletly convinced that people wait months for vital treatments in other countries.
 
I think we should just prohibit registered Republicans from getting ANY healthcare under the new system, since they don't want it.

Seriously, the amount of hate they are spewing about this is likely to cause another one of them to take up a gun and go shoot up NIH or something. They would rather 1000 poor (and non-white) people die of preventable causes than they have to pay one more dime in taxes. I wonder what their Jesus would say about that?


And the fact that the probable outcome will be that the increase in tax to fund a universal healthcare system is more than offset by the reduction in insurance premiums, won't rate a mention.

I suppose for very wealthy individuals, an increase in percentage income tax rate might result in a larger outgoing than a single person's risk-based health insurance premium though. So maybe the very rich will pay a bit more, while the ordinary Joe will come out better off.

You know what? I don't care. In fact I'd see it as a good thing. I suppose that makes me an evil commie.

Rolfe.
 
What's worse, the government coming between you and your doctor, or a private, for-profit corporation coming between you and your doctor?

How many of you have had to change doctors because of insurance issues?

When has the government, in a single payer sytem, ever come between the doctor and the patient?

As someone who has spent 40 years in a single payer (gov't) system, I've never seen it or heard of it being done.
 
Like this?

[qimg]http://www.thecorrectcall.com/wp-content/cbo-versus-obama-debt.jpg[/qimg]


Hmmm, that chart has projections going ten years into the future. The very first thing that comes to mind for me is this: What is the track record for accuracy of the CBO and White House when it comes to making budgetary projections ten years into the future? Unless either or both have some measure of accuracy when it comes to making such long-term predictions, then the predictions are essentially meaningless. Ten years is a long time, and a lot can change between then and now.
 
When has the government, in a single payer sytem, ever come between the doctor and the patient?

As someone who has spent 40 years in a single payer (gov't) system, I've never seen it or heard of it being done.


I can only imagine that this piece of nonsense springs from genuine experience of insurance companies and HMOs coming between the doctor and the patient. And then on the assumption that the government is always worse than the private sector at any possible task, we conclude that the government would do the same thing only worse.

I've noticed time and time again that US posters arguing against universal healthcare frequently assert that it will inevitably be terrible because of some problem or other which is already present in the US system. They seem to project their own current problems onto universal systems, and then use these projections as a reason for staying with their current system. Even though it already has these problems, in spades, and the universal systems often don't!

This seems to be just another example of the genre.

Rolfe.
 
He's right, balrog. It's only $10,000 A YEAR over the 10 years. Not that $10,000 per person isn't an awful lot to spend on health insurance. But even that amount couldn't buy the health insurance that Obama promised each of us ... the same that members of Congress get. :D

FYI: The company I work for (fairly small and without the clout to do much about negotiating terms) currently pays the health insurance company somewhere between $700 and $750 per month per insured person. The company and the employee each pay a percentage of this amount. $8400 to $9000 per person per year, and rapidly increasing each year. With deductables, co-pays, 80/20 splits and the like, it appears that many are already paying $10,000 per year for health insurance.
 
He's right, balrog. It's only $10,000 A YEAR over the 10 years. Not that $10,000 per person isn't an awful lot to spend on health insurance. But even that amount couldn't buy the health insurance that Obama promised each of us ... the same that members of Congress get. :D
Ah, so you agree that the ONLY EFFECT of the proposed measures will be to insure 10 million new people.

This smells like another lie to me.

Cue furious backpeddling.
 
Last edited:
They would rather 1000 poor (and non-white) people die of preventable causes than they have to pay one more dime in taxes. I wonder what their Jesus would say about that?

Don't you know Ben? You must be very religious to walk around quoting what Jesus would say. :D

BTW: Since you are so versed in the sayings of Jesus, perhaps you could also tell us what he said about THEFT? ;)

And finally, you might also like to know that conservatives are far more charitable (with their own money) than liberals. This has been proven over and over. :D
 
They tell such stupid lies because they believe it advances their anti-Obama argument. This isn't really about American health care at all, it's just about slamming Obama.

Not entirely true. There are companies that stand to lose a lot of money if the US goes over to nationalised healthcare. They can afford a lot of PR.
 
The very first thing that comes to mind for me is this: What is the track record for accuracy of the CBO and White House when it comes to making budgetary projections ten years into the future? Unless either or both have some measure of accuracy when it comes to making such long-term predictions, then the predictions are essentially meaningless. Ten years is a long time, and a lot can change between then and now.

The fact that they both indicate similar deficits (and other entities have also made predictions that were comparable) gives them some credibility. And whether you like it or not, we still have to base our decisions about the future on "something" and CBO predictions are about the best we have. By the way, I think they've tended to underestimate future deficits. And these are probably no exception.

http://www.thenewamerican.com/usnews/election/913 "Even CBO Deficit Projections Optimistic"

http://www.ombwatch.org/node/2248 "CBO’s Reduced Deficit Projections Mislead"

http://www.cbpp.org/cms/index.cfm?fa=view&id=1530 "DEFICIT PICTURE GRIMMER THAN NEW CBO PROJECTIONS SUGGEST"

So I'm sorry, but sticking your head in the ground and ignoring a problem is no solution. :D
 
Ah, so you agree that the ONLY EFFECT of the proposed measures will be to insure 10 million new people.

And what other effect do you foresee? Besides, I thought the promise was that some 45 million uninsured would get health insurance as good as Obama gets. :D
 
There are companies that stand to lose a lot of money if the US goes over to nationalised healthcare.

And, of course, that will be good for those taxpaying companies and their taxpaying employees. Right? :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom