Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

You know, this is starting to smell more and more. Are you saying that you would reveal your identity for a bet? (I think the Seals have some rules about that.) Yet you complain that Obama is compromising security?

I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt, but I smell BS.

You think he may have fooled Joey Donuts?
 
Gives their location.

Others have pointed out that this is highly unlikely. The only way that could be true is if ST6 hung out there for an extended period of time after they had been identified and, even if they had, anyone looking for revenge would have know where those directly responsible were, whether or not they new the team designation.

You're reasoning on this is just completely bizarre.
 
I would think you'd be mad about SEALs talking to the press. Wouldn't that be a risk to security?
Well NavySEAL has still not addressed the movie Act of Valor.
He id ST-6.
Okay, dumb on his part but ST-6 was already known to exist. How has that adversely affected their security? Examples please.

If that was dumb of Obama, what do you think of this?
Or are you just full of it?

Daredelvis
 
How many SEAL Teams are there?

Why are you ducking my questions?

Did you or did you not mean to suggest that SEALs and members of DEVGRU in particular would be reluctant to go on a mission to get OBL because they're afraid of getting shot?

ETA Remember, you said

Yet to meet the SEAL who wanted to get into a gun fight.
In fact, there isn't a single member of DEVGRU that wouldn't have jumped at the chance to get into a gun fight as part of a mission to get OBL, right? That's the gun fight we're talking about, isn't it? Not a gun fight that happened due to road rage in traffic or some such, right?
 
Last edited:
It is an election year.

The movie "Act of Valor" has nothing to do with any election. It was, in fact, the very thing you denied SEALs wanted to do: be a means of drawing attention to the unit in order to try and increase recruiting efforts.

https://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/19/...m-with-active-duty-members-of-navy-seals.html

Rear Adm. Denny Moynihan, of the Navy Office of Information in Washington, explained that every four years the Defense Department “looks at itself and says, ‘What is it that you need to be moving forward, and where do you think you are?’ ” He added, “For the Navy and the SEAL community it was, ‘Hey, you need 500 more SEALs’ and that launched a series of initiatives to try to attract more people. This film was one of those initiatives.”
 
Gives their location.

False. By the time the announcement was made, they were no longer at the compound in Pakistan. (In fact, announcement was delayed to wait for DNA confirmation so they could be 100% sure it was OBL.)

At any rate, do you think giving their location puts them at more risk than the mission itself did? Do you think there are any members who would have been reluctant to go on the mission because they might be identified in this way?

FWIW, you were responding to a question about the OP which discussed an Obama campaign ad. You're pretty much trying to bring the kitchen sink into this.

And what's the deal with using incomplete sentences now?
 
Home base.
Fail. If the home base is already known, saying the words makes no difference. If the home base is unknown, but the team isn't at it, then saying the words makes no difference. In other words, saying "Seal Team Six" is in no way endangering the team.

If you are a seal or ex-seal, I'm reconsidering what I said about them being "elite".
 
Last edited:
Fail. If the home base is already known, saying the words makes no difference. If the home base is unknown, but the team isn't at it, then saying the words makes no difference. In other words, saying "Seal Team Six" is in no way endangering the team.

If you are a seal or ex-seal, I'm reconsidering what I said about them being "elite".

Please feel free to do just that. Will you make it public?
 
The only way that could be true is if ST6 hung out there for an extended period of time after they had been identified

They were long gone by the time of the announcement.


They were on the ground at the compound something under 40 minutes total. OBL was killed within about 15 minutes, then they had to secure bystanders, gather documents and computer hardware, lug the body out, destroy the downed helicopter and beat feet.

Obama got news that OBL was killed at 3:50 pm ET. He was given fairly sure (someone on the radio said 99.9% certain) confirmation that it was OBL at 7:01 pm. He really wanted to wait for 100% confirmation, but was worried about the story being leaked (it is the age of Twitter), so made the announcement some time after that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom