Obama Overselling Bin Laden Raid?

How many SEAL Teams are there?

How about not answering questions with questions? If you have a valid point than make it.

Seeing as how ST-6 doesn't exist anymore and the new name remains classified I don't see what the problem is.
 
How about not answering questions with questions? If you have a valid point than make it.

Seeing as how ST-6 doesn't exist anymore and the new name remains classified I don't see what the problem is.


No big secret its called "DevGru"
 
He id ST-6.

Hate to tell you, but there has been a Wikipedia page on ST6 since 2004. I don't see how general knowledge of the team's existence is exactly top secret knowledge nor, apparently, how it has negatively impacted the team's performance since bin Laden's death. Wikipedia list two other operations since.

I really don't understand what the beef is here.
 
SEAL Team 6 hasn't been secret since at least 1992 when the Navy officer who created it talked about it (openly and in detail) in his autobiography.
 
He id ST-6.

First, proof of that?

Second, proof that it matters? It was pretty obvious to me who did this the moment I heard it. Not a Rangers type operation. Not a regular Marine operation, either. (though both would have absolutely tried if tasked with it) It was clear to me that it was SEALs. If I had not guessed, the wreckage of the stealth helicopter in the press would have told me. Nobody who is involved with defense or who pays attention to military matters would have reached a different conclusion.

ETA: Didn't consider Delta at the time, don't know why.
 
Last edited:
So nobody (other than those with top security clearance) knows who is on what Seal Team. Nobody but TSC folks knows where any specific Seal Team is working. So really, saying "Seal Team 6" is doing nothing more than ascribing a place-holder name in order to thank the anonymous members.

How exactly does saying "Seal Team 6" threaten their security?
 
So nobody (other than those with top security clearance) knows who is on what Seal Team. Nobody but TSC folks knows where any specific Seal Team is working. So really, saying "Seal Team 6" is doing nothing more than ascribing a place-holder name in order to thank the anonymous members.

How exactly does saying "Seal Team 6" threaten their security?

Gives their location.
 
So nobody (other than those with top security clearance) knows who is on what Seal Team. Nobody but TSC folks knows where any specific Seal Team is working. So really, saying "Seal Team 6" is doing nothing more than ascribing a place-holder name in order to thank the anonymous members.

How exactly does saying "Seal Team 6" threaten their security?

It doesn't. Their security was only threatened by the raid itself. And I think enough of them to believe that was A-OK with them.
 
Criticism is allowed, refusing to obey an order is not.

Got a few bucks laying around? Why not bet that I am not what I say?
You know, this is starting to smell more and more. Are you saying that you would reveal your identity for a bet? (I think the Seals have some rules about that.) Yet you complain that Obama is compromising security?

I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt, but I smell BS.
 
You know, this is starting to smell more and more. Are you saying that you would reveal your identity for a bet? (I think the Seals have some rules about that.) Yet you complain that Obama is compromising security?

I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt, but I smell BS.

He is a retired SEAL so I don't think his identity would be a big deal. The bar down the street from me is owned by a retired SEAL and neither he nor his friends make any effort to conceal their past. The bar is called "Trident" FFS!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom