NY Times Declares WOD a failure. But misses the obvious ...

You completely missed the important points, BAC. Almost all the noticeable declines occurred when there were liberals in power. Eisenhower was paying down the WWII debt and taxing the bejabbers out of the rich. Kennedy dropped the rates for everybody and then closed the loopholes on the rich.

As long as the high-earners were paying their frieght, poverty declined or stayed low and level.

Along comes Reagan and screws everyone on the recieving end of government programs so that he could give his owners a tax break and Ooop! Here we go again.

The War on Poverty did not fail. The Republicans defected to the enemy.
 
Well it certainly seems to me like you did suggest that - the article "misses the point", by not mentioning the alleged failure of the WOP.

Don't misquote me. I said the New York Times doesn't see the obvious because in all it's years it's failed to publish any articles noting the failure of the WOP for exactly the same reasons as this one about the failure of the WOD. I never once suggested that my complaint is that this article didn't mention the failure of the WOP. I'm after bigger game than just this one article. :D

I'd say you're "missing the point" by diverting attention from the actual issues of the article into your pet issue which is connected only tangentially to the point of the article.

No, I made it quite clear in the OP that my purpose in quoting the NY Times article was to expose liberal bias in the NY Times. They've had plenty of time and opportunity to write an expose on the WOP and complain that it has failed for the same reasons as they are now complaining that the WOD has failed. I can't recall them doing so. Can you point me to a NY Times article that says the WOP is a failure for the same reasons it says the WOD is a failure? If not, perhaps my charge is valid. :D

That being said, I stand by my characterization that your OP is a stretch.

And I stand by my characterization that you are ... apparently desperate ... to change the topic off the one I clearly wanted to discuss. :D
 
ok well we obviously won't progress much further. I would suggest that the reason they don't write an article along the lines of your wishes with regards to the WOP is that they likely aren't working with the same set of facts you are.

It could likely be argued that the War on Poverty does not rise to the same level of failure as the WOD (if at all), and myself and others here would agree.

This could be because we're all liberally biased - or maybe cause you're conservatively biased..;)

Or maybe cause we're all operating with different perceptions of the facts, and heck, different facts.
 
Except you forget that the percentage of Americans living in poverty was dropping dramatically before the WOP even began.

It was, wasn't it? But then if Eisenhower was here today you'd call him a socialist.

LBJ's Great Society may not have ushered in a utopia but it made one heck of a difference to a lot of people and to US society.

Two things changed with the advent of the Reagan-Thatcher social paradigm. Long-term GDP growth in Anglo-America fell from ~2.3% to ~1.8%, and that growth was less equally distributed - with much more going to the already rich. We're living with the results.

By the way, when it comes to poverty rates you have to take account of migration. It's a complicated issue. For instance, the fall in Black poverty in the 40's and 50's was mostly a matter of migration from the dirt-poor South to the industrial North. The South remained as relatively poor until LBJ (a good ol' boy) made a difference.

Murphy's First Law : Nothing is as simple as it seems.
 
I would suggest that the reason they don't write an article along the lines of your wishes with regards to the WOP is that they likely aren't working with the same set of facts you are.

Oh. Do they have different statistics on the decline in poverty rates than the ones I cited? By all means, point me to them. :D

It could likely be argued that the War on Poverty does not rise to the same level of failure as the WOD

And what would be the basis of that claim? That they didn't spend as much trying to fight the WOP as the WOD? Wrong. They spent ten times as much. :D
 
ok well we obviously won't progress much further. I would suggest that the reason they don't write an article along the lines of your wishes with regards to the WOP is that they likely aren't working with the same set of facts you are.

The facts remain the same; what you do with them differs. A lot depends on the tools you have to work with.

It could likely be argued that the War on Poverty does not rise to the same level of failure as the WOD (if at all), and myself and others here would agree.

Victory was declared in the War on Poverty. Nobody would try that in the War on Drugs. There's no end in sight.

Or maybe cause we're all operating with different perceptions of the facts, and heck, different facts.

Perceptions are free (but often limited) but facts are sacred!
 
Victory was declared in the War on Poverty. Nobody would try that in the War on Drugs. There's no end in sight.

Mission accomplished eh?

Seems to me like all three "wars", terrorism, poverty, drugs are limitless.
 
The WOD, which I prefer to call Drug Prohibition, is indeed a miserable failure...

As is BAC's attempt to double dip and make this thread really about a "failed" WOP. :rolleyes:
 
Oh. Do they have different statistics on the decline in poverty rates than the ones I cited? By all means, point me to them. :D

Well, allow me an aside here. I used to participate in the Tom Delay blog comments section. It was part of a broader attempt to understand those who thought differently than me. I delved into Pat Buchanan, diverse movement conservative screeds, even Pat Robertson. From there to more intellectualy solid ground with Burke, William F Buckley, Hayek and so on.

From there, I moved on to the extreme of the right-wing which led me to conspiracy theories of all sorts - which coincided with seeing friends on "the left" fall for woo that shared many of the same contours as the kind of things you'd read on the American Free Press or from the John Birch society. Maybe its more fun reading the "crazies" I dunno.

But what I took away from all this was the realization that the people I was debating with really did live in a completely different universe than me: with different histories, different lines of thought - like parallel lines that never meet.

This is certainly true when comparing a more moderate person like me with people on either extreme - but I also think it explains even lesser leaps across the spectrum.

Yes, there are other statistics. Its not as if the ones you post are invalid, but maybe the interpretation of them. In your posts, the mentioning of "victicrats" and a "culture of dependency" indicate a certain evaluation of the outcomes of anti-poverty legislation, an evaluation that sits squarely in the American conservative tradition of modern times. This tradition has a different way of looking at a lot of things: the same events, like say the Great Depression, Vietnam, the 2000 election even, are interpreted very differently by conservatives and by liberals (and with plenty of variations within and without those labels). There's competing histories at work.

So other schools of thought may introduce other contextual factors not considered here: statistics on say, the greater numbers educated and earning more money because of government assistance, the numbers of hungry children going down, etc etc. They would also likely not emphasize the "culture of dependency" or consider that the most important thing with which to evaluate the success of the War on Poverty.

Some may even accept that there are unwanted and negative side effects, such as the encouragement of some dependency, yet still think the other benefits more than make up for that.

So think of the truthers. We're not that out to lunch you and I, but maybe we live in different worlds all the same.

And what would be the basis of that claim? That they didn't spend as much trying to fight the WOP as the WOD? Wrong. They spent ten times as much. :D

I'd have to research more on these costs. What spillover costs do each program have that aren't counted?

I'm of the mind that sociologically speaking, the War on Drugs is more destructive than the War on Poverty could ever be. This could be because of my liberal Canukistani bias however, predisposed to consider social safety nets to be positive things in general, and from much research into prohibition, which to be honest I've spent a lot more time studying than social safety nets.
 
Last edited:
Are you sure? I think we should debate that claim since I don't agree. For instance:

We haven't had another 9/11 (or anything even close to it) in the US in nearly 8 years. Good job, Bush/Cheney.
I have this rock to sell to you. It keeps tigers away. I swear, you will never encounter a tiger around your house for as long as you live.
 
But then if Eisenhower was here today you'd call him a socialist.

Why would I do that? If you're going to post red herrings and strawmen, at least try to flesh them out so they sound at least a little credible.

LBJ's Great Society may not have ushered in a utopia but it made one heck of a difference to a lot of people and to US society.

But it was sold as ushering in utopia. And perhaps it has only helped bankrupt the US. Ten trillion dollars gone, and what do we have to show for it that wouldn't have happened anyway if we'd just left those 10 trillion in taxpayer hands where they could have grown the economy? Actually in that case, the poverty rate would probably be half what it is today. :D

By the way, when it comes to poverty rates you have to take account of migration. It's a complicated issue. For instance, the fall in Black poverty in the 40's and 50's was mostly a matter of migration from the dirt-poor South to the industrial North. The South remained as relatively poor until LBJ (a good ol' boy) made a difference.

I acknowledge the fact that in a free market economy like ours, people can vote with their feet to better themselves? That surely was important to falling poverty rates in the 40's and 50's for blacks. But it was important throughout the 60's too, even after the WOP began. During that time, black migration continued. So poverty rates continued to drop with the reductions highest, as one would expect, in those portions of the black population most able to relocate.

And I contest your claim that LBJ's programs helped many blacks (and their children) in the south out of poverty. Do you know that four of the five poorest states are still in the south and black poverty rates are still very high? The spending programs didn't really help despite the fact that from 1970 on, WOP spending grew exponentially. If anything of a government nature has actually helped, it was the Civil Rights act forcing employers to end discrimination in hiring. As a result, blacks began to get jobs that had been dominated by whites, rather than just the menial positions they held before. To give you example, in South Carolina less than 5 percent of textile mill workers were black in 1964, but by 1976, nearly one in three were black. That, not LBJ's massive welfare programs, is what changed lives. The reality is that LBJ's programs only made many blacks dependent on government aid. And it looks like Obama is only going to make them even more dependent. Stuck on Stupid.

And one last point, speaking of migration, the poverty rate recently certainly hasn't been helped by the fact that liberals are so keen to let poor illegal aliens into the country and give them government benefits (and the vote) ... in the hope they will vote democrat. :D
 
Yes, there are other statistics.

Then by all means post them. Because pontification is not a substitute for verifiable facts.

I'm of the mind that sociologically speaking, the War on Drugs is more destructive than the War on Poverty could ever be.

I'm of a mind to think you are wrong, if for no other reason then the percent of the population that's affected by each war and how they are affected. The WOD could never bankrupt this country. The WOP may already have done so.

By the way, just so you know, I've been an opponent of the War On Drugs for decades.
 
I have this rock to sell to you. It keeps tigers away. I swear, you will never encounter a tiger around your house for as long as you live.

Do you really believe that had Bush and Cheney done nothing after 9/11, no other serious terrorist attacks would have occurred in the US in the last 8 years? You really think the WOT is as absurd as worrying about tigers around our houses in the US? :rolleyes:
 
Do you really believe that had Bush and Cheney done nothing after 9/11, no other serious terrorist attacks would have occurred in the US in the last 8 years? You really think the WOT is as absurd as worrying about tigers around our houses in the US? :rolleyes:

Well the Bear Patrol IS working. I haven't seen a bear since it started.

I'll buy that rock!
 
Winners in the WOD (besides drug dealers):

Police (at all levels of govt) powers
Police numbers
Prosecutors and judges employed in WOD
Police/Prosecutor asset seizure (theft) schemes
Prison-industrial complex
 
If I remember my Star Trek right, Boloboffin's avatar is glorifying illogical behavior?
 
The irony is that the New York Times doesn't see that the same can be said for LBJ and the democrat's "War On Poverty".

Wow, the NYT IS stupid. I mean both "War on Drugs" and "War on Poverty" have the word "war" in them! The irony!

Why didn't they cover the "War on Terror", the "War on Science", or the "War on Guns" in the same article?
 
or the War on Christmas!

war-on-christmas.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom