NY Times Declares WOD a failure. But misses the obvious ...

BeAChooser

Banned
Joined
Jun 20, 2007
Messages
11,716
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/14/opinion/14kristof.html?_r=1

This year marks the 40th anniversary of President Richard Nixon’s start of the war on drugs, and it now appears that drugs have won.
“We’ve spent a trillion dollars prosecuting the war on drugs,” Norm Stamper, a former police chief of Seattle, told me. “What do we have to show for it? Drugs are more readily available, at lower prices and higher levels of potency. It’s a dismal failure.”

The irony is that the New York Times doesn't see that the same can be said for LBJ and the democrat's "War On Poverty". It too is over 40 years old. And over TEN trillion dollars has been spent fighting it. TEN TRILLION. And what do we have to show for it? We have just as many poor people as we did when it first began. And the racial divide (that it was supposed to also fight) is as wide as ever. In short "it's a dismal failure." But what do democrats want to do? Spend even more on it. And even export it to the rest of the world. In fact, Obama is calling for the US to spend a trillion dollars in third world countries fighting poverty. Are any of you foolish enough to think that will work? :D
 
Just as many poor people today as in LBJ's day equals a dramatic drop in the percentage of Americans living in poverty between then and now.
 
The irony is that the New York Times doesn't see that the same can be said for LBJ and the democrat's "War On Poverty".

There's a good reason they don't see that.

It's not true.

We have just as many poor people as we did when it first began.

Well, that's true, but only because the population has increased substantially. As a percentage, the number of people in poverty has dropped dramatically, as can be seen from this graph (Wikipedia).

Poverty_by_Age.png


It's the little details that make the story even more compelling. Notice how well poverty had been reduced by about 1980, when Reagan decided that he wanted to fight on the other side.

So what we really see is that the "War on Poverty" has been a tremendous success when not hampered by fifth columnists such as yourself -- people who insist on fighting for poverty instead of against it.

Once again, reality intervenes in one of BAC's arguments -- to his detriment.
 
Three Anti Obama threads started in less then ten minutes.
I call this::spam1

I notice you didn't attempt to challenge the validity of any of the content in those three OPs. So I guess I can call your post ... desperation. :D
 
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/14/opinion/14kristof.html?_r=1



The irony is that the New York Times doesn't see that the same can be said for LBJ and the democrat's "War On Poverty". It too is over 40 years old. And over TEN trillion dollars has been spent fighting it. TEN TRILLION. And what do we have to show for it? We have just as many poor people as we did when it first began. And the racial divide (that it was supposed to also fight) is as wide as ever. In short "it's a dismal failure." But what do democrats want to do? Spend even more on it. And even export it to the rest of the world. In fact, Obama is calling for the US to spend a trillion dollars in third world countries fighting poverty. Are any of you foolish enough to think that will work? :D

A shame that what could have been an interesting discussion relevant to the topic of the NYT article is diverted into a pet peeve of a Reagan Revolutionary.

I refuse to play along.

NYT - good job for calling a spade a spade. CNN is having a week-long series on legalizing pot.

Are these cracks in the media dam noteworthy do you think?

Seems to me the idea of a new approach to the drug war is not as heretical as it was even a decade ago.
 
Just as many poor people today as in LBJ's day equals a dramatic drop in the percentage of Americans living in poverty between then and now.

Except you forget that the percentage of Americans living in poverty was dropping dramatically before the WOP even began. In fact, a good case can be made that the only real effect of the WOP has been to build a minimum percentage poor into the system because soon after the WOP began, the decrease in percent poverty rates leveled off. It has remained basically the same ever since. Here:

http://www.friesian.com/stats.htm

The "capitalism alone" phase of poverty reduction can be seen operating from 1950 to 1966. In that period the poverty rate (column H) fell from 30% to 15%. Even poverty in the non-white population (column I) fell from almost 60% in 1960 to 40% by 1966. ... snip ... What attends the striking increase in anti-poverty activity is the actual slowing and halting of the fall in the poverty rate. The percentage of the population below the poverty line bottoms out in 1973 at 11.1% and then stagnates or increases from then on. By 1981, only the first year of the Reagan Presidency, the poverty rate is already back up to 14%, where it hadn't been since 1967. At the same time, the percentage of families on AFDC had skyrocketed, from the disturbing 2% of 1963 to what must be the even more disturbing, or shocking, 6.5% of 1980. Programs intended to reduce "dependency" had instead more than tripled it. ... snip ... It is also noteworthy that the general availability of abortion, often presented as necessary for the alleviation of poverty, in fact coincided, after the Roe v. Wade decision, with the period when poverty ceased to decline and began to increase again.

Here's the poverty rate data the above mentions (from the same link) where H is the total poverty rate and I is the rate for non-whites:

Year H (total, %)
1950 30.2
1951 28.0
1952 27.9
1953 26.2
1954 27.9
1955 24.5
1956 22.9
1957 22.8
1958 23.1
1959 22.4
1960 22.2
1961 21.9
1962 21.0
1963 19.5
1964 19.0
1965 17.3
1966 15.7
1967 14.2
1968 12.8
1969 12.1
1970 12.6
1971 12.5
1972 11.9
1973 11.1
1974 11.6
1975 12.3
1976 11.8
1977 11.6
1978 11.4
1979 11.6
1980 13.0
and
Year I (non-white, %)
1959 58.2
1960 56.4
1961 56.8
1962 56.1
1963 51.1
1964 49.8
1965 47.1
1966 40.8
1967 38.2
1968 32.8
1969 30.9
1970 31.6
1971 31.3
1972 32.4
1973 29.3
1974 30.5
1975 29.8
1976 29.5
1977 29.0
1978 29.4
1979 28.9
1980 29.9

Remember, the WOP was announced by LBJ in 1964. So any reduction in the poverty rate before that cannot be due to the WOP. And it's even questionable whether the reduction in the rate the first few years after that date can be ascribed to the WOP because it took years to ramp up and establish the programs that are part of the WOP. So are you sure you really understand this issue? Are you sure that the reduction in poverty rates since 1964 are due to the WOP ... or are they just the natural result of the capitalism expansion and improvements in racial attitudes that were going on at the time (and even before that time)? Are you sure that in fact the WOP hasn't actually slowed that improvement in the poverty rate from what it might have been ... by draining off resources into non-productive channels and thus hurting economic growth ... and by making people dependent on government (and thus killing initiative)?

Go ahead ... explain to us what caused the poverty rate for non-whites to drop from 58% in 1959 to 50% in 1964 ... before the War on Poverty got started? Explain what caused the drop in the total poverty rate from 30% in 1950 to 19% in 1964? It certainly wasn't the War on Poverty, was it, because that hadn't even started yet. Can you offer any explanation for why the total poverty rate dropped almost 10% (from 27.9% to 19%) in the ten years prior to the start of the WOP (more than it did in the 10 years after the start of the WOP)? If you can't explain that with a cause that wasn't still in effect once the WOP began, how can you begin to rationally claim that the decrease in the poverty rate during the WOP is the result of the $10 trillion dollars during it (so far)? Perhaps all that spending did just the opposite. Perhaps if we'd spent that $10 trillion on economic growth and providing even more REAL job opportunity, the poverty rate would be even lower today. Perhaps if we'd not taught millions of people to be victims (Larry Elder calls them victicrats), the poverty rate would have dropped even faster than it has since 1964.

And I'll leave you with this (hope you read it all) but here's a quote:

http://www.capmag.com/article.asp?ID=3864

The poverty rate among black families fell from 87 percent in 1940 to 47 percent in 1960, during an era of virtually no major civil rights legislation or anti-poverty programs. It dropped another 17 percentage points during the decade of the 1960s and one percentage point during the 1970s, but this continuation of the previous trend was neither unprecedented nor something to be arbitrarily attributed to the programs like the War on Poverty.
 
A shame that what could have been an interesting discussion relevant to the topic of the NYT article is diverted into a pet peeve of a Reagan Revolutionary

You apparently failed to understand the point of the OP. This thread isn't about drug policy but whether the NY Times is biased in it's views since quite obviously they've ignored the facts that clearly point to the WOP being an even greater failure than our drug policy. So if you don't want to play along, then I suggest you start your own thread on legalizing drugs and have at it. :D
 
You apparently failed to understand the point of the OP. This thread isn't about drug policy but whether the NY Times is biased in it's views since quite obviously they've ignored the facts that clearly point to the WOP being an even greater failure than our drug policy. So if you don't want to play along, then I suggest you start your own thread on legalizing drugs and have at it. :D

Well, I mean, couldn't they also be "missing the point" since the War on Terrorism has been a failure since its launch, and since they're talking about failures of policy, shouldn't they be talking about that one too?

To me, it really felt very artificial and a big stretch to even connect the "War on Poverty" with the "War on Drugs" in this way.

If the NYT should discuss the War on Poverty, shouldn't they start their own article about it instead of having to address it in an unrelated article on drug policy?
 
Except you forget that the percentage of Americans living in poverty was dropping dramatically before the WOP even began. In fact, a good case can be made that the only real effect of the WOP has been to build a minimum percentage poor into the system because soon after the WOP began, the decrease in percent poverty rates leveled off. It has remained basically the same ever since. Here:

http://www.friesian.com/stats.htm



Here's the poverty rate data the above mentions (from the same link) where H is the total poverty rate and I is the rate for non-whites:

Year H (total, %)
1950 30.2
1951 28.0
1952 27.9
1953 26.2
1954 27.9
1955 24.5
1956 22.9
1957 22.8
1958 23.1
1959 22.4
1960 22.2
1961 21.9
1962 21.0
1963 19.5
1964 19.0
1965 17.3
1966 15.7
1967 14.2
1968 12.8
1969 12.1
1970 12.6
1971 12.5
1972 11.9
1973 11.1
1974 11.6
1975 12.3
1976 11.8
1977 11.6
1978 11.4
1979 11.6
1980 13.0
and
Year I (non-white, %)
1959 58.2
1960 56.4
1961 56.8
1962 56.1
1963 51.1
1964 49.8
1965 47.1
1966 40.8
1967 38.2
1968 32.8
1969 30.9
1970 31.6
1971 31.3
1972 32.4
1973 29.3
1974 30.5
1975 29.8
1976 29.5
1977 29.0
1978 29.4
1979 28.9
1980 29.9

Remember, the WOP was announced by LBJ in 1964. So any reduction in the poverty rate before that cannot be due to the WOP. And it's even questionable whether the reduction in the rate the first few years after that date can be ascribed to the WOP because it took years to ramp up and establish the programs that are part of the WOP. So are you sure you really understand this issue? Are you sure that the reduction in poverty rates since 1964 are due to the WOP ... or are they just the natural result of the capitalism expansion and improvements in racial attitudes that were going on at the time (and even before that time)? Are you sure that in fact the WOP hasn't actually slowed that improvement in the poverty rate from what it might have been ... by draining off resources into non-productive channels and thus hurting economic growth ... and by making people dependent on government (and thus killing initiative)?

Go ahead ... explain to us what caused the poverty rate for non-whites to drop from 58% in 1959 to 50% in 1964 ... before the War on Poverty got started? Explain what caused the drop in the total poverty rate from 30% in 1950 to 19% in 1964? It certainly wasn't the War on Poverty, was it, because that hadn't even started yet. Can you offer any explanation for why the total poverty rate dropped almost 10% (from 27.9% to 19%) in the ten years prior to the start of the WOP (more than it did in the 10 years after the start of the WOP)? If you can't explain that with a cause that wasn't still in effect once the WOP began, how can you begin to rationally claim that the decrease in the poverty rate during the WOP is the result of the $10 trillion dollars during it (so far)? Perhaps all that spending did just the opposite. Perhaps if we'd spent that $10 trillion on economic growth and providing even more REAL job opportunity, the poverty rate would be even lower today. Perhaps if we'd not taught millions of people to be victims (Larry Elder calls them victicrats), the poverty rate would have dropped even faster than it has since 1964.

And I'll leave you with this (hope you read it all) but here's a quote:

http://www.capmag.com/article.asp?ID=3864

Correlation/Causation Fallacies for everyone!
 
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/14/opinion/14kristof.html?_r=1



The irony is that the New York Times doesn't see that the same can be said for LBJ and the democrat's "War On Poverty". It too is over 40 years old. And over TEN trillion dollars has been spent fighting it. TEN TRILLION. And what do we have to show for it? We have just as many poor people as we did when it first began. And the racial divide (that it was supposed to also fight) is as wide as ever. In short "it's a dismal failure." But what do democrats want to do? Spend even more on it. And even export it to the rest of the world. In fact, Obama is calling for the US to spend a trillion dollars in third world countries fighting poverty. Are any of you foolish enough to think that will work? :D
You remember how we proved this nonsense was idiotic the first time you puked it out?

It hasn't got any less idiotic since then. What with the facts staying the same.
 
boloboffin,
You have the best avatar ever.

I must thank Paulhoff for introducing us. It just sums up the sheer banality life hurls our way and the indispensable human ability to suck it up and make it through a spectacularly idiotic moment together.

Which brings me back to this thread...
 
since the War on Terrorism has been a failure since its launch

Are you sure? I think we should debate that claim since I don't agree. For instance:

We haven't had another 9/11 (or anything even close to it) in the US in nearly 8 years. Good job, Bush/Cheney.

al-Qaeda appears to have lost in Iraq, with Iraq well on the way to being a successful, prosperous democracy, despite the fact that al-Qaeda focused the bulk of it's attention on destabilizing the country. Iraq's terrorist supporting government is no more. Good job, Bush/Cheney.

The Taliban has been driven from power in Afghanistan and is now under pressure to even call Pakistan a safe haven. And recently, there have been signs the organization is having financial problems. Even Obama seems to be continuing that effort. Must have been working.

Support of terror by Kadafi came to an end with Kadafi giving up his aspirations of possessing WMD after watching Saddam get pulled, looking like a street bum, from a hole in the ground. Good job, Bush/Cheney.

North Korea is being increasingly isolated by the world community at large. Although notice that it got a lot more unruly as soon as Obama took over the White House. ;)

We're witnessing mass demonstrations against the dictatorship in Iran. You are watching that, aren't you?

Terrorist organizations even seem to be losing support in Palestine. Despite the encouragement they got from Obama.

, and since they're talking about failures of policy, shouldn't they be talking about that one too?

You don't think the NY Times has been trying to paint the WOT as a failure? Where have you been the last half a dozen years. :D

To me, it really felt very artificial and a big stretch to even connect the "War on Poverty" with the "War on Drugs" in this way.

Well I don't agree. The NY Times claims the WOD is a failure because it hasn't ended the drug problem after spending a trillion dollars. It complains that drug use is as high as ever.

I say the WOP is a failure because it hasn't ended poverty after spending ten trillion dollars. And like some claim regarding the WOD, I say the policy in the WOP has only made the problem worse ... has frozen a certain amount of poverty, dependency and racism into the system.

Whereas in the WOT, the trillion or so spent against terrorism has indeed made a significant impact on the threat of terrorism. Like I said, no 9/11's in nearly 8 years.

If the NYT should discuss the War on Poverty, shouldn't they start their own article about it instead of having to address it in an unrelated article on drug policy?

I never suggested they had to discuss the WOP in their WOD article (although, come to think of it, there probably is a fair amount of drug use that is a consequence of the poverty that the WOP has frozen into the system). :D
 
Correlation/Causation Fallacies for everyone!

So TB, what did cause the poverty rate to drop as much or more in the 10 years prior to the WOP than since the WOP began 45 years ago? Or do you have your head in the ground like all the rest of the liberals around here? :D
 
You remember how we proved this nonsense was idiotic the first time you puked it out?

By all means, DA, link us to the thread where you did that? Is the reason you didn't link it because when I pointed out the above facts concerning the drop in the poverty rate prior to the WOP beginning, all of you of RAN? :D
 
Well I don't agree. The NY Times claims the WOD is a failure because it hasn't ended the drug problem after spending a trillion dollars. It complains that drug use is as high as ever.

I say the WOP is a failure because it hasn't ended poverty after spending ten trillion dollars. And like some claim regarding the WOD, I say the policy in the WOP has only made the problem worse ... has frozen a certain amount of poverty, dependency and racism into the system.

Whereas in the WOT, the trillion or so spent against terrorism has indeed made a significant impact on the threat of terrorism. Like I said, no 9/11's in nearly 8 years.

I never suggested they had to discuss the WOP in their WOD article (although, come to think of it, there probably is a fair amount of drug use that is a consequence of the poverty that the WOP has frozen into the system). :D


Well it certainly seems to me like you did suggest that - the article "misses the point", by not mentioning the alleged failure of the WOP.

You basically took an article on the WOD, and shoehorned the WOP into that issue, claiming the NYT made a mistake by not also mentioning that failure of policy.

Couldn't there be more than one failed policy? Why would discussing one failed policy require the mentioning of another failure of policy with a different history and context in order to not "miss the point"?

I'd say you're "missing the point" by diverting attention from the actual issues of the article into your pet issue which is connected only tangentially to the point of the article.

And yes, you're talking to an arts major who took a lot of electives in sociology when I wasn't taking economics/politics classes and there are indeed a myriad of ways in which drug policy meets issues of class (ie, poverty).

That being said, I stand by my characterization that your OP is a stretch.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom