And just about every woman I know says the exact same thing "I don't get along well with girls, girls are catty, I have more guy friends than girls".
Which is probably another thread itself, but I think it speaks well to the present topic. I think some girls expect to have guy friends and expect them to not have feelings for them.
I think this confuses guys, especially younger guys, in this high risk age group. They bide their time as friends hoping that eventually things will change and the girls will develop feeling for them.
Things don't progress as far as a relationship goes but a trust builds. Then frustration.
Then along comes alcohol and with it opportunity and happy accidents. Or maybe not. Maybe it isn't an accident at all,maybe it's something much worse.
In the last several threads on the topic of rape and sexual assault I was somewhat surprised, but not entirely shocked at the number of women victimized at some point in their lives. In all the discussions however nobody has really accounted for all those assaults, reported and unreported.
I think the above scenario is a very good example of how an unreported rape happens. A girl is victimized by a friend or acquaintance that she trusts enough to to be alone and intoxicated with.
So you guys can tell anecdote after anecdote about how you have guy friends you "hang around" with and nothing happens, but you're just making it harder to explain the number of assaults we know occur.
Do you see how this simply doesn't add up? Morrigan tried to explain it away as "tiny" but we know for a fact that isn't the case. It can't be.
Unless you come up with a viable explanation, I'm still inclined to believe a majority of these assaults occur because older men encourage younger girls to do things they wouldn't otherwise do, young girls are foolishly going home with or taking home a guy they think is a friend, and drinking so much they're easily coerced into the above or worse yet pass out.
Say what you want about me, I think it amounts to neglect for parents not to start instilling this information in young girls starting around the age of 14 so by the age of 18 it's something they can carry on for themselves into their mid twenties.
There's nothing in this that precludes a girl from having guy friends or even being alone with a guy. It's just information that keeps them from forgetting that being alone with a guy shouldn't be taken lightly. Especially if you've been drinking.
Feel free to actually show how this is misguided or how exactly it "blames the victim".
Well I can say that in my case, where I was almost raped by a friend, I was not drunk. And it was someone I had known for years, not someone who was a recently met friend.
When it comes to other women I have spoken with when they have been assaulted by a friend or acquaintance, in all but a couple cases, the girl being drunk was not the issue. She was not drunk, and this still happened to her.
I really don't know what the statistics are in this, that is, if women are overall more likely to be raped by a friend IF she is drunk. But let's say that in a majority of cases- or at least, a significant minority, women raped by friends were NOT drinking at the time...would you then further advise that women should not be friends with men?
Now I think that getting drunk to the point you are blacking out or completely unable to discern what is going on is a bad idea for EVERYONE, male, female, young, old, etc. I went to a big drinking school (though I was never a big drinker, as I get sick from alcohol very easily). I know plenty of people who got into really bad situations after drinking heavily, and most of those were not women who were raped. Most people I know who have gotten into major trouble when alcohol being involved got into these troubles with a person of the SAME SEX, and these troubles were not sexual in nature. Well actually, overwhelmingly the biggest trouble I have seen people get into due to alcohol was trouble they got THEMSELVES into that had nothing to do with another person (i.e. hey, I think showing of my awesome balancing skills and walking on the railing of this 4 story balcony is a great idea right now!)
I do think your advice goes too far, or at least, is too specific. If your blanket advice is simply, "Don't get so drunk that you can't take care of yourself" than I agree, but I do NOT feel this should be coached in terms of directing it to women who are alone with male friends because they might rape you. That just fosters a feeling of paranoia, IMO.
I just don't believe that male friends are inherently dangerous than female friends. In my life I've been betrayed by 3 people I thought were my friends. I have always had more male than female friends, yet two of these betrayels were by women and in both cases, the emotional hurt they caused me far surpassed that of the friend who tried to rape me, and I do believe that would remain true even if I had been successfully raped.
Also, from the way you phrase it, it sounds like you are teaching your daughter to actively not trust any male friend because they are a potential rapist, and I just feel that could really mess with her psychologically. Obviously if you won't be alone with someone in a vulnerable state, that means you do not trust them.
Now obviously it may turn out that someone you thought was your friend wasn't, as I have experienced myself. But why single out guys? Despite being a minority of my friends, I have personally found women to be more dangerous friends than men.
Also, I know FAR more guys who got physically assaulted by another man when alcohol was involved than I know women who got sexually assaulted by a man when alcohol was involved. So I don't see why you think your daughter needs this lesson more than a man would.