North American Union? NAFTA Superhighways? Amero?

And no one wants the NAU?



I'm sure you could find someone who does. If you leave off the paranoid fears about lost civil rights, it's not really that bad an idea. It's just almost certainly never going to happen.

We can't even get Americans to use Metric, and adopt a $1 coin. Do you really think they'll sit still for a complete overhaul of the political structure of North America?
 
It is my understanding that Canadian trucks can enter the USA with goods destined for US locations and pick up goods destined for Canadian locations BUT they cannot pick up goods in the USA and deliver them to another US location. Would I be correct in that?

I would then assume that the same applies to Mexican trucks.

So, just how does this take a job away from an American trucker?
If Mexican and Canadian trucks must meet or exceed safety and enviro standards where's the problem?

It seems that the opponents to this would simply want all goods to travel via American trucks. That would require that all goods be brought to the borders and then transfered to another truck. Yeah, I cannot envision that making goods travel slower or more expensively!:boggled:

What is the situation for goods traveling from the USA to Mexico? Can these truckers cross free to deliver their loads to mexican locations?
 
"It's the same plan as understood a year ago"? How so? Did reading comprehension change in the last year? The two major factual assertions made in the article a year ago have been shown to be entirely different from the current plan. Can you quote anything from that article that would refute this, or are you just going to post your own revisionist interpretations?







And let's not forget this part:





Gee, partisan political mudslinging surrounding a topic with large vested US interests.....That never happens! :rolleyes: Unless you can point to some factual elements that indicate that the current plan is anything more or less that what Hill describes, you've got no case.
Gee, partisan political mudslinging surrounding a topic with large vested Corporate interests.....That never happens! :rolleyes: Unless you can point to some factual elements that indicate that the current plan is anything more or less that what the Teamsters the Public Citizen and Rep. James Oberstar of Minnesota, and the panel's subcommittee chairman on highway safety matters, Rep. Peter DeFazio of Oregon describe, you've got no case.
 
It seems that the opponents to this would simply want all goods to travel via American trucks. That would require that all goods be brought to the borders and then transfered to another truck. Yeah, I cannot envision that making goods travel slower or more expensively!:boggled:

What is the situation for goods traveling from the USA to Mexico? Can these truckers cross free to deliver their loads to mexican locations?


That's pretty much what happens now:


Currently, Mexican trucks must transfer their goods at areas just inside U.S. border crossings.



Of course, if you're worried about job losses, there's this brief line:

U.S. trucking firms, until now, have not been allowed to operate in Mexico.


...which seems to imply that this plan will also allow US trucks to now enter Mexico. It's not clear, though, so if anyone has any idea on that, please post it.

So, where's the paranoid fears that US companies will take over the Mexican Trucking Industry? If Mexican trucks are the pieces of crap they're alleged to be, this shouldn't be that hard!
 
I want the NAU. Apparently none of you live by the border, where trucks wait needlessly for hours on end, spewing fumes into the envirnoment, because there could be a terrorist on board? If they want in, they'll find their way. The border between Canada and the US is an imaginary line. Do you honestly believe they will wait at Customs for clearance? I can see Belle Isle as we speak. 2 minutes on a jetski and I can be in an American marina undetected and sipping Stroh's. Making the border between our countries accesible is important. Free flow of good and materials is key. We need to take a page from the EU and move on. Welcome to the New World Disorder.
 
Gee, partisan political mudslinging surrounding a topic with large vested Corporate interests.....That never happens! :rolleyes: Unless you can point to some factual elements that indicate that the current plan is anything more or less that what the Teamsters the Public Citizen and Rep. James Oberstar of Minnesota, and the panel's subcommittee chairman on highway safety matters, Rep. Peter DeFazio of Oregon describe, you've got no case.




Oh, burn! I'm so scared!


:rolleyes:


Did you forget that this was a discussion of whether or not it's the same plan as discussed a year ago? I've posted the factual elements that show this simply isn't so. If you choose to ignore that, well, hey, knock yourself out. I'm going to go play with my cat.
 
That's pretty much what happens now:






Of course, if you're worried about job losses, there's this brief line:




...which seems to imply that this plan will also allow US trucks to now enter Mexico. It's not clear, though, so if anyone has any idea on that, please post it.

So, where's the paranoid fears that US companies will take over the Mexican Trucking Industry? If Mexican trucks are the pieces of crap they're alleged to be, this shouldn't be that hard!

Pretty much what I was getting at. The agreement would have to be reciprocal and allow US trucks into Mexico.

I fail to see a great downside at allowing goods to move freely and less expensively between the countries. Once again this is not going to allow truckers from, for eg. the USA, to make pick-ups in Mexico for delivery within Mexico so national carriers are protected.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom