North American Union? NAFTA Superhighways? Amero?

Now again I ask are plans for the NAU really just a CT or is it just ok with everyone as long as they dress it up nice as "good for the consumer"?


So, to paraphrase, you’re asking: Is the idea of a North American Union really a conspiracy theory, or are you fine with the idea of a North American Union?

That, however, is a false dichotomy.
 
So, to paraphrase, you’re asking: Is the idea of a North American Union really a conspiracy theory, or are you fine with the idea of a North American Union?

That, however, is a false dichotomy.

And quite a beautiful example of one, if I may say so. Bravo, Zen!
 
last i heard the trans-texas corridor was on hold.

And what is the problem with the mexican trucks? Are you and corsi just concerned about driving safety and the environment? Being a libertarian of sorts, I'm generally all in favor of getting rid of regulations.
 
last i heard the trans-texas corridor was on hold.

And what is the problem with the mexican trucks? Are you and corsi just concerned about driving safety and the environment? Being a libertarian of sorts, I'm generally all in favor of getting rid of regulations.
So we shouldn't inspect any trucks for safty or emissions, or contents?

Do you have a job? How much does it pay an hour? Do you think Mexican truck drivers will start getting paid more or American truck drivers less or not at all?
 
I'm posting the links because the OP was suggesting Corsi was pushing a CT. Is it a CT? Or is it just ok with everyone? One of the links I posted was a Corsi article from a year ago suggesting that the US would open it's borders to Mexican trucks and they wouldn't be under the same regulations, inspections, or pay as American trucks and drivers. I also posted a link to reuters where it reports this very plan was pushed through late yesterday while everyone is talking about the latest and greatest from UBL.

Now again I ask are plans for the NAU really just a CT or is it just ok with everyone as long as they dress it up nice as "good for the consumer"?



But is it "This very plan"? Your link to the Reuters article doesn't seem to work:




Is this the same, or similar article?

http://www.reuters.com/article/latestCrisis/idUSN06403579

Let's look at some of what you quoted from the Corsi article that you allege predicted "this very plan", shall we?

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=50803


"As a result of the ruling, thirty thousand or more Mexican trucks – which are generally older, more polluting, and less safe than their U.S. counterparts – will be allowed to conduct long haul trucking operations to locations across the United States.


From my linked article:

The administration plans to gradually allow Mexican trucking firms greater access to U.S. highways, topping out at 100 firms and about 500 trucks at the conclusion of the pilot


So, only off by two orders of magnitude on the number of Mexican trucks.



"With all the obstacles that still need to be overcome, our government must heed the OIG's warnings from the January 2005 audit," Galen Munroe, a spokesperson for the Teamsters Union told WND in an email. "The motor carriers in Mexico need to adhere to the same regulations and standards that our companies and drivers are subject to. Unfortunately, this seems to be a near impossible task with Mexico's current infrastructure."



So the big concern is that Mexican trucks might not be held to the same standard as US trucks, right? Well:

John Hill, administrator of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, told reporters in a conference call that Mexican trucking companies, drivers and vehicles must abide by the same standards as U.S. companies, including truck inspections, licensing and drug and alcohol testing. In some cases the criteria will be stricter, Hill said.


So, they won't be held to the same standard, they'll be held to a stricter standard. Not quite a hit, is it?

So out of two major allegations you quoted, both are in fact, wrong. So "how wrong he was a year ago"? Quite wrong, it seems.
 
So we shouldn't inspect any trucks for safty or emissions, or contents?

Do you have a job? How much does it pay an hour? Do you think Mexican truck drivers will start getting paid more or American truck drivers less or not at all?

I'm not paid hourly. And as I said, as a libertarian of sorts, I am against protectionism.
 
I've seen two kind of takes here. NAU wouldn't be so bad or it's just a CT.



How about the "The changes you are so worried about are really not all that major, and certainly won't lead to the entire reconstruction of the governmental structure of North America, because there's no one who really wants that, they just want cheaper and easier trucking"?
 
I've seen two kind of takes here. NAU wouldn't be so bad or it's just a CT.


Well OK, but the question which opinions you’ve seen so far has no bearing on the fact that you presented DavidJames with an illegitimately reduced set of options.
 
I don't believe them to be the only options it's just all I've read here so far.

Then your reading comprehension is seriously deficient, as usual. Thus far you haven't provided a shred of anything even resembling evidence that the claims made about the putative NAU, e.g. that it will "dissolve the United States of America into the North American Union" are true. Absent such evidence, these claims are properly classified as yet another paranoid conspiracy theory.

Sidetrack discussions of more plausible aspects of increased US-Mexico-Canada cooperation, such as a de facto customs union, don't constitute support for the mythical superstate that has the wingnuts' panties in such a knot.

Stop hiding behind false dichotomies and strawmen like your remarks about Mexican truckers and provide some evidence in support of these larger claims, if you can. If you can't, kindly sod off.
 
But is it "This very plan"? Your link to the Reuters article doesn't seem to work:

It's the same plan as understood a year ago which was I'm sure was considered by some just a CT at the time. You're cherry picking on one side of the article and on debated topics. I read what Hill claims but what has been implemented to facilitate all of this?

From the same article...

House of Representatives Transportation Committee chairman, Rep. James Oberstar of Minnesota, and the panel's subcommittee chairman on highway safety matters, Rep. Peter DeFazio of Oregon, contended earlier in the day the administration had not met congressional safety mandates for the program and was moving ahead hastily. House legislation passed in July would cut funding for the pilot. The Senate has not acted similarly.

"This pilot program should be taken extremely seriously, and treated for what it is: a sea change in surface transportation policy. Yet (the Transportation Department) has expressed little regard for the serious calls of Congress to fully test, evaluate, and understand the impacts of granting Mexico-domiciled motor carriers access to our roads," Oberstar said.
 
How about the "The changes you are so worried about are really not all that major, and certainly won't lead to the entire reconstruction of the governmental structure of North America, because there's no one who really wants that, they just want cheaper and easier trucking"?
Yes and we all know the only things that get passed are what the people want and nothing else right?
 
Then your reading comprehension is seriously deficient, as usual. Thus far you haven't provided a shred of anything even resembling evidence that the claims made about the putative NAU, e.g. that it will "dissolve the United States of America into the North American Union" are true. Absent such evidence, these claims are properly classified as yet another paranoid conspiracy theory.

Sidetrack discussions of more plausible aspects of increased US-Mexico-Canada cooperation, such as a de facto customs union, don't constitute support for the mythical superstate that has the wingnuts' panties in such a knot.

Stop hiding behind false dichotomies and strawmen like your remarks about Mexican truckers and provide some evidence in support of these larger claims, if you can. If you can't, kindly sod off.
kindly sod off?

Where are you from the EU?
 
How about the "The changes you are so worried about are really not all that major, and certainly won't lead to the entire reconstruction of the governmental structure of North America, because there's no one who really wants that, they just want cheaper and easier trucking"?
Who's they?
 
It's the same plan as understood a year ago which was I'm sure was considered by some just a CT at the time. You're cherry picking on one side of the article and on debated topics. I read what Hill claims but what has been implemented to facilitate all of this?


"It's the same plan as understood a year ago"? How so? Did reading comprehension change in the last year? The two major factual assertions made in the article a year ago have been shown to be entirely different from the current plan. Can you quote anything from that article that would refute this, or are you just going to post your own revisionist interpretations?




From the same article...

House of Representatives Transportation Committee chairman, Rep. James Oberstar of Minnesota, and the panel's subcommittee chairman on highway safety matters, Rep. Peter DeFazio of Oregon, contended earlier in the day the administration had not met congressional safety mandates for the program and was moving ahead hastily. House legislation passed in July would cut funding for the pilot. The Senate has not acted similarly.

"This pilot program should be taken extremely seriously, and treated for what it is: a sea change in surface transportation policy. Yet (the Transportation Department) has expressed little regard for the serious calls of Congress to fully test, evaluate, and understand the impacts of granting Mexico-domiciled motor carriers access to our roads," Oberstar said.


And let's not forget this part:


Transportation officials did not act until the agency's inspector general, Calvin Scovel, had completed a safety review of the pilot program, as required by lawmakers. While the administration felt comfortable with Scovel's findings, Oberstar said the report was inconclusive.

But Hill said regulators "fulfilled every congressional requirement" on the books and turned up nothing adverse in its safety analysis of the program. "We are in compliance."


Gee, partisan political mudslinging surrounding a topic with large vested US interests.....That never happens! :rolleyes: Unless you can point to some factual elements that indicate that the current plan is anything more or less that what Hill describes, you've got no case.
 
Yes and we all know the only things that get passed are what the people want and nothing else right?

Who's they?



What, you couldn't edit?


Ultimately what gets passed is what someone wants. I make no suggestions as to who "they" are, as I really can't say for sure. Probably An Evil Mexican Trucking Baron Who Desires To Rape Our (Meaning Your, As I'm Canadian) Pristine American Highways With His Shoddy Trucks, Who Happens To Have Video Of An Important Senator. Or "AMTBWDTRO(MY,AIC)PAHWHST,WHTHVOAIS", as his mistress calls him.


ETA: P.S. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2942136#post2942136
 
What, you couldn't edit?


Ultimately what gets passed is what someone wants. I make no suggestions as to who "they" are, as I really can't say for sure. Probably An Evil Mexican Trucking Baron Who Desires To Rape Our (Meaning Your, As I'm Canadian) Pristine American Highways With His Shoddy Trucks, Who Happens To Have Video Of An Important Senator. Or "AMTBWDTRO(MY,AIC)PAHWHST,WHTHVOAIS", as his mistress calls him.


ETA: P.S. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2942136#post2942136
And no one wants the NAU?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom