New Ad Upsets Nazis

No, the Magyars are the Hungarians. It’s the Hungarian word for the Hungarians.

That's as may be but its not as simple as that

"Magyar" is also the generic term for a group of Finno-Ugric humans who originated in the Urals and migrated westwards to settle in what is now Hungary about 1,200 years ago, but that does not mean that ALL Magyars ended up in Hungary. Their Y-DNA haplogroups are also found among Austrians and the Slovak peoples.

http://www.khazaria.com/genetics/hungarians.html
 
You know what's bugging me ?

Let me tell you what's bugging me

All this Scandinavian "pride" in their Viking heritage.

The Vikings were the first peoples to get on ships, sail to distant lands, sack their religious institutions and steal their scared items for profit. Then they colonized the place(s) This behavior emboldened other European nations to do the same thing centuries later.

IIRC, the Vikings actually tried to colonize the Americas but failed ( luckily ) giving the indigenous Americans a few more centuries of peaceful, blissful white people free living.
 
It gets complicated.
Finland is geographically part of Scandanavia, but the Finns, ethnically, are totally different from the other Scandinavian nations. Language..except for a few borrowed words,is totally different from Norweigian, Swedish, Danish, etc.
And they have the world's prettiest Prime Minister.....

Wrong. Scandinavia is a geographical term to deal with that peninsula that cuts off. Ethnically, Finns are pretty much homogenous to the Swedes at least in the west. However, 50% of Finnish males carry the N1 gene which is thought to come from the East. Very little in common with the Russians, who are Slavic, as is their language. The Scandinavian languages are Germanic like English and Dutch. Finnish is a Uralic language, so named as it is thought to originate from near the Ural mountains. However, it is a common mistake to assume language equals ethnicity. You can be born in a stable but it doesn't make you a horse.
 
That was deliberate. I was also going to choose the Finnish swastika as well, but thought it would be too obvious.

The Finnish swastika which was in use in the Finnish Air Force long before Hitler came along was simply an adopted rune by Count Von Rosen (_sp?) who happened to have seen it on a Swedish grave monument and adopted it as his family legend. The Air Force was originally private which is how his swastika got to be on the underside of the wings. The Finnish swastika was still in use until the mid-1940's. I guess they had to stop using it so as not to upset the Russians. Obituary/death announcements during that era appeared under the Finnish swastika rather than the Christian cross. My uncles, who were killed in the Continuation War have the swastika on their gravestones, in the war heroes part of the cemetery, as does the War Memorial found in every church yard.
 
Geographically, the Scandinavian peninsula consists of Norway, Sweden and a small part of Finland. Denmark is not a geographical part of Scandinavia.
Culturally, you could say that the Nordic Baltic Eight (Wikipedia) are a kind of sister nations. Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania were Danish for a couple of centuries in the Middle Ages, before they became Swedish and then Russian.
Iceland (Wikipedia) was liberated from the Danish hegemony in WW2. :)

Latvians and Lithuanians are considered Slavic.
 
Wrong. Scandinavia is a geographical term to deal with that peninsula that cuts off. Ethnically, Finns are pretty much homogenous to the Swedes at least in the west. However, 50% of Finnish males carry the N1 gene which is thought to come from the East. Very little in common with the Russians, who are Slavic, as is their language. The Scandinavian languages are Germanic like English and Dutch. Finnish is a Uralic language, so named as it is thought to originate from near the Ural mountains. However, it is a common mistake to assume language equals ethnicity. You can be born in a stable but it doesn't make you a horse.

No, dudbalb not necessarily wrong.

https://lamoureurope.com/scandinavian-europe/

"Scandinavia is a region in Northern Europe, with strong historical, cultural, and linguistic ties. The term Scandinavia in local usage covers the three kingdoms of Denmark, Norway, and Sweden. The majority national languages of these three belong to the Scandinavian dialect continuum, and are mutually intelligible North Germanic languages. In English usage, Scandinavia also sometimes refers more narrowly to the Scandinavian Peninsula, or more broadly so as to include Finland, the Faroe Islands, and Iceland."​

So both of your positions can be correct depending on where you were educated; it is NOT wrong to state that Finland is part of Scandinavia.
 
About 8000 years ago. There is now zero similarity apart from both being inflected.

Wrong, it was not that long ago, more like 1,200-2,000 years. The early Magyars arrived in the land of Hungary from the east in the 9th century

Magyars, Estonians and Finns are all descended from the same Finno-Ugric branch of the Uralic family.
 
Err, wrong again

"Genes reveal traces of common recent demographic history for most of the Uralic-speaking populations"

https://genomebiology.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s13059-018-1522-1

Note the word, 'trace'. Fact is, over the centuries, Hungary has been invaded by various groups and tribes; plus it has adopted numerous loan words from Turkish and its surrounding mid-European neighbours that it bears zero resemblance to Finnish or Estonian, other than being inflected.

As I said language does not equate to ethnicity anyway. It'd be like my saying 'Americans are of British descent as they speak English', when of course, as you know the biggest group by far are the Germans, with 40% of American having that descent. So much for language telling you anything much.

In fact of the ancient Finno-Ugric group of languages, linguists have found only four words that have a common root in all. They are: Fish, swim, water, and living.

So, 'The living fish swims in the water' would be the only sentence that would be remotely similar to that group of language speakers.
 
Last edited:
No, Finland is not a part of Scandinavia. Finland is a Nordic country, which is a broader notion.

Scandinavia is limited to Denmark, Sweden and Norway. The Nordic countries are those, plus the countries that have been heavily influenced and controlled by the Scandinavian ones. Finland was an integral part of Sweden for centuries, so it qualifies as a Nordic country.

In fact, in the medieval ages, Turku-Åbo, the then Finnish capital, was the second most important town in Sweden. Vyborg (near St Petersburg) was also important.

Actually, it qualifies as Nordic as having the second most northerly capital in the world, after Rejkvik in Iceland. Its northerliness is not anything that has been conveyed to it by its Swedish neighbours.
 
Last edited:
Note the word, 'trace'.

I did note it - a "trace" is an amount greater than zero. You said, and I quote "Finns share zero DNA with Hungarians". That statement was wrong, you just admitted it!

You will find that genome distribution is a lot more complex than you think, and making belligerent, blanket statements about things is not only ill-advised, but such statements will almost certainly turn out to be wrong.
 
Last edited:
I did note it - a "trace" is an amount greater than zero. You said, and I quote "Finns share zero DNA with Hungarians". That statement was wrong, you just admitted it!

You will find that genome distribution is a lot more complex than you think, and making belligerent, blanket statements about things is not only ill-advised, but such statements will almost certainly turn out to be wrong.

Sorry if I was a bit impatient but it is a common misconception that language = ethnicity. Just because Hungarian and Finnish once broke off from a language group believed to have originated near the Urals it honestly doesn't mean they are related ethnically. Hungary is pretty far south in Europe and thus culturally is different simply due to different climate, different history, different migrations, different wars and invaders.

Finns do not feel any kinship with Hungarians or vice versa other than being joint Europeans and sharing a common language group.
 
A little like the black Scandinavian in the ad with the Viking ancestors! :)


genetically, Finns have more in common with, for example, the Dutch or Russians living in the area of Murom, to the east of Moscow, than with their linguistic relations, the Hungarians; more generally, genetic closeness clearly follows geographic distance more closely than linguistic distance.
Finns, genes and languages (Languages of the World, April 8, 2010)


The article contains other examples.

Swedish is one of the two official languages of Finland: Swedish Language in Finland
Swedish-speaking Finns are often much easier to understand for other Scandinavians than actual Swedes because their consonants tend to be pronounced much more clearly than (some) Swedes do. For this reason they usually make excellent travel guides when Scandinavians of different nationalities travel together.
When digital voice recognition became a thing, Finnish turned out to be particularly well-suited for this purpose because of the distinct consonants.
 
Last edited:
SAS’ suspicions appear to be correct. While the backlash likely has multiple points of origin, the ad campaign has particularly incensed 4chan’s Pol message board, the politics-focused portion of the website that’s a known hub for fringe alt-righters and white nationalists. The commercial directly contradicts bigoted notions of white, European, and Nordic supremacy, which are core beliefs of the internet far-right. In response, Pol users have launched a coordinated campaign targeting the airline and the ad agency that made the video.
As is often the case on the Pol board, the rage is unequivocally racist. While 4chan is small compared to some other social media platforms, the site still brings in 27 million monthly users, according to its own metrics. And compared to other 4chan eruptions, the scope of the anti-SAS campaign is massive. Pol users have created more than a dozen independent threads to gripe about the ad, and many are highly active.
4Chan Trolls Target Scandinavian Airlines With Racist Harassment Campaign (Mother Jones, Feb. 13, 2020)


Any comments, Ziggurat and theprestige?!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom