New Ad Upsets Nazis

And now the Scots consider joining us! :)
Skotland vil hellere være en del af Skandinavien

IIRC Estonia has lobbied to be considered one of the Nordic countries since the 90s with little results in popular perception so I don't think Nordic countries are something one can just join. Though they might eventually as one of the reasons why there is such a concept as 'Nordic countries' is because Finland so closely aligned itself with Scandinavia after gaining independence that although it wasn't Scandinavian it warranted lumping them all together.
 
You know, just for the halibut I'm going to point out that Vikings weren't a society. Their society were the Norse. Vikings were the sailors and warriors of the Norse. It's like calling kinda like calling all Americans "Marines."
*sigh* You are technically correct, which as we all know is the best kind of correct.
 
IIRC Estonia has lobbied to be considered one of the Nordic countries since the 90s with little results in popular perception so I don't think Nordic countries are something one can just join. Though they might eventually as one of the reasons why there is such a concept as 'Nordic countries' is because Finland so closely aligned itself with Scandinavia after gaining independence that although it wasn't Scandinavian it warranted lumping them all together.


The reservations of the Nordic countries to this idea are probably due to their fear of Russia. It was a little different back in the day when they intended to provoke the Soviet Union. Finland was always careful about stepping lightly in order to avoid angering the powerful neighbor.

The Swedish ambassador to Estonia, Mr. Anders Ljunggren, has claimed in 2015 that Estonia would have been considered a Nordic country by the other Nordic countries, "had the history been different...The differences between Estonia and Sweden have become less year by year, owing to the fact that the two countries have gotten to know each other more each year".

Criticism[edit]
The Tuglas foundation has claimed that the Nordic definition that Estonia is moving towards does not exist anymore, being a relic of past times.
Per Högselius wrote an opinion piece about the topic in 2003, looking at the idea as fringe, but concluding that "in time the Estonians might be able to persuade us".

Historic contacts with the Nordic Council[edit]
The Nordic Council had historically been a strong supporter of Estonian independence from the Soviet Union. The Nordic Council of Ministers' Office in Estonia was opened in spring 1991.
Nordic identity in Estonia: Modern political narrative (Wikipedia)


The Scots will probably have to step lightly, too. :)
 
Last edited:
The reservations of the Nordic countries to this idea are probably due to their fear of Russia. It was a little different back in the day when they intended to provoke the Soviet Union. Finland was always careful about stepping lightly in order to avoid angering the powerful neighbor.

I don't think being "Nordic" is meaningful in that sense, ie that becoming or being perceived as Nordic would be a kin to joining NATO or something. Nordics are countries that are close enough to eachother and Finland qualifies because Finland was an integral part of Sweden for 600 years and as part of the Russian Empire was allowed to retain the old laws and broad autonomy to follow political developments in Scandinavia. Estonia was more Germanic in character as no matter who was the overlord in the Baltics the rulers there were always primarily the Baltic German aristocracy who held the locals in serfdom.
 
Well, Estonia was Danish from 1219 to 1346, Swedish from 1561 to 1710 when it was occupied by Russia. And it became a part of the USSR towards the end of WW2. But that as well as the Germanic serfdom was a long time ago.
Portraying itself as a Nordic country is a way of stressing its independence from Russia without appearing to be an intolerably aggressive threat to the big neighbor.

Yes, the Baltic German aristocracy swore fealty alternatively to Denmark, Sweden and Russia, who had the upper hand in the region, in exchange for protection of their priviliges and status. I'd say Estonia and the other Baltics affirming their independence is more connected to their NATO membership, while Estonia wanting to be seen as Nordic has more to do with image. But of course it's not something that's set in stone and there's no hard definition of 'Nordic' so that the most important part of being Nordic is that you're perceived to be as such.
 
Well, Estonia was Danish from 1219 to 1346, Swedish from 1561 to 1710 when it was occupied by Russia. And it became a part of the USSR towards the end of WW2. But that as well as the Germanic serfdom was a long time ago.
Portraying itself as a Nordic country is a way of stressing its independence from Russia without appearing to be an intolerably aggressive threat to the big neighbor.

It would be inaccurate to describe it as being Swedish. A more accurate description is that it was ruled by Sweden, or more specifically ruled by the Swedish monarch. Although ethnic Swedes settled in what would become Estonia, the area kept its existing laws, customs and was largely autonomous.

Compare this to Finland, also historically called Österland (Eastern Land), which was treated as any other part of the Swedish kingdom.
 
It would be inaccurate to describe it as being Swedish. A more accurate description is that it was ruled by Sweden, or more specifically ruled by the Swedish monarch. Although ethnic Swedes settled in what would become Estonia, the area kept its existing laws, customs and was largely autonomous.

Compare this to Finland, also historically called Österland (Eastern Land), which was treated as any other part of the Swedish kingdom.

It's important to remember that these relationships were feudal, and to not transplant our modern nationalist ideas of statehood onto the past.
 
It just occurred to me: Considering Covid-19, now is probably not the best time to remind Scandinavians (or anybody else) of all the things that they may bring back home from abroad ...
I can't imagine stocks in travel agencies, airliners or cruise ships going up or recovering any time soon.
 
Well, the Swedish Chef sounds Norwegian to the Swedish, and he may have been based on an American chef....

https://slate.com/culture/2012/08/s...nk-of-him-they-think-he-sounds-norwegian.html

Furthermore, in the German dubbed version of The Muppets, he's a Dane!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_Chef#International


Yes, he is! :)



Just read a good opinion piece on this in Swedish media. It made an excellent point that I think is applicable here as well.

In the frenzy that follows this fake culture war battle, where people rush to dig trenches in a completely made up battle, instigated by fascists, the real story is forgotten: SAS is in a business that is bad for the environment. They have also recently announced plans to form a low-price daughter company in Ireland with crew and staff taken from Eastern Europe in order to pay them lower wages, thus pushing down wages for existing employees in the mother company. Nobody is outraged over this except for the current employees. Instead, we're busy fighting off the latest fascist attack on freedom of expression.


A similar point was made in this article (in Danish): Med SAS-reklamen ramte ‘woke capitalism’ også Danmark (Solidaritet, Feb. 17, 2020)
 
Finland, not wanting to be outdone in the most woke advertising competition, releases an enrty that will blow your socks off. :)



Trigger warning/content note: White people and the most annoying earworm ever. Click at your own risk.



“Stop, don't touch me there. This is my no-no square,”



Just wait until those fascists get hold of this.
You are obviously not objecting merely to the execution so what is your objection to trying to reach out to youngsters to help prevent child sex abuse?
 
That doesn't seem to be answering the question I asked - and does that mean you are also against the idea of trying to prevent child sex abuse?

It answered the question just fine. If you are unable to understand it I can't help you any further. This conversation is over.
 
It answered the question just fine. If you are unable to understand it I can't help you any further. This conversation is over.
How does it answer the question I asked? Half measure is usually a comment about something but there wasn't a something that it could be applied to?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom