Naked Short-Selling, Anyone?

How many people would actually need to be in on a scheme like this, though? If it really is a sizable bunch of people that would need to know, then the lack of any whistleblowers emerging yet would make me skeptical too.

Depends on what kind of a "scheme" you're talking about. If you're talking about a single rogue trader who has signature authority for 2 million dollars in investments, it could be a single person (and God knows there are/were enough of those types of people floating around, especially in hedge funds and stuff). But in that case, it wouldn't be a massive conspiracy involving the Treasury department, the Fed, and the major Wall Street Banks....

If we're talking about a massive conspiracy, then by definition it would involve hundreds or thousands of people.

Something worth pointing out is that naked short selling was not illegal in March, 2008. More accurately, it was illegal but not enforced -- and riddled with industry loopholes; any broker/dealer could engage in naked short selling entirely within the law. Any of the major players could easily have set something up through a tame broker without violating the law. So why the elaborate conspiracy to perform something completely legal? (I'm reminded of an old Monty Python skit here.)

Boss: (unfolding big map across table; talking carefully) Right ... this is the plan then. At 10:45 .. · you, Reg:, collect me and Ken in the van, and take us round to the British Jewellery Centre in the High Street. We will arrive outside the British Jewellery Centre at 10:50a of m. I shall then get out of the car, you Reg, take it and park it back here in Denver Street, right? At 10:51, I shall enter the British Jewellery Centre, where you, Vic, disguised as a customer, will meet me and hand me £5.18.3d. At 10:52, I shall approach the counter and purchase a watch costing £5.18.3d. I shall then give the watch to you, Vic. You'll go straight to Norman's Garage in East Street. You lads continue back up here at 10:56 and we rendezvous in the back room at the Cow and Sickle, at 11:15. All right, any questions?

Larry: We don't seem to be doing anything illegal.

Boss: What do you mean?

Larry: Well ... we're paying for the watch.

Boss: (patiently) Yes...

Larry: (hesitating) Well... why are we paying for the watch?

Boss: (heavily) They wouldn't give it to us if we didn't pay for it, would they... eh?
 
That seems to be the insinuation.

I don't think that's what Taibbi's getting at--that the 1.7 million dollar short "started the free fall."

If we're talking about a massive conspiracy, then by definition it would involve hundreds or thousands of people.
I don't think Taibbi has stated or implied that there was a massive conspiracy.

So why the elaborate conspiracy to perform something completely legal?
Did you read the entire article? Again, I don't think he's claiming that there was an elaborate conspiracy to allow naked short selling.

Maybe I'm missing something--feel free to quote Taibbi if you think he is making these points.

eta:

Like Bear, though, by the time these kinds of trades show up, it's already quite clear that the company is in serious trouble.

Has Taibbi said otherwise?
 
Last edited:
Did Taibbi accuse Citigroup of breaking the law?

Directly? Probably not. If nothing else, that would be libelous and Citigroup could sue.

But he implied it fairly strongly.

Look at the title: "Wall Street's Naked Swindle : A scheme to flood the market with counterfeit stocks helped kill Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers — and the feds have yet to bust the culprits"



Or a little later on,

That this was a brazen case of insider manipulation was so obvious that even Sen. Chris Dodd, chairman of the pillow-soft-touch Senate Banking Committee, couldn't help but remark on it

While naked short selling isn't illegal, "insider manipulation" is. So, yes, Taibbi is accusing someone of breaking the law.

And a little later:

To the rest of the world, the brazenness of the theft — coupled with the conspicuousness of the government's inaction — clearly demonstrates that the American capital markets are a crime in progress.

... but the only problem is that the one act he can actually identify, the possible naked short-selling, was not illegal. (Laws changed in September 2008 in response to this.)


I don't think Taibbi has stated or implied that there was a massive conspiracy.

What's this, then?

Then, on March 11th — around the same time that mystery Nostradamus was betting $1.7 million that Bear was about to collapse — a curious thing happened that attracted virtually no notice on Wall Street. On that day, a meeting was held at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York that was brokered by Fed chief Ben Bernanke and then-New York Fed president Timothy Geithner. The luncheon included virtually everyone who was anyone on Wall Street — except for Bear Stearns.

Bear, in fact, was the only major investment bank not represented at the meeting, whose list of participants reads like a Barzini-Tattaglia meeting of the Five Families. In attendance were Jamie Dimon from JPMorgan Chase, Lloyd Blankfein from Goldman Sachs, James Gorman from Morgan Stanley, Richard Fuld from Lehman Brothers and John Thain, the big-spending office redecorator still heading the not-yet-fully-destroyed Merrill Lynch. Also present were old Clinton hand Robert Rubin, who represented Citigroup; Stephen Schwarzman of the Blackstone Group; and several hedge-fund chiefs, including Kenneth Griffin of Citadel Investment Group.

[...]

Given the Fed's cloak of confidentiality, we simply don't know what happened at the meeting. But what we do know is that from the moment it ended, the run on Bear was on, and every major player on Wall Street with ties to Bear started pulling IV tubes out of the patient's arm. [...] All of these tactics were elements that had often been seen in a kind of scam known as a "bear raid" that small-scale stock manipulators had been using against smaller companies for years. But the most damning thing the attack on Bear had in common with these earlier manipulations was the employment of a type of counterfeiting scheme called naked short-selling. From the moment the confidential meeting at the Fed ended on March 11th, Bear became the target of this ostensibly illegal practice — and the companies widely rumored to be behind the assault were in that room.

So, yes, he's directly suggesting a massive conspiracy (and even putting a date and location on the where the conspiracy happened).
 
Last edited:
But the bet wasn't just that the slide would continue; it was an enormous bet that the stock would lose half its value in 9 days or less (according to the article anyway):

Why did it need to have its price drop by half? Why wouldn't 10% have been enough for a nice profit?
 
Why did it need to have its price drop by half? Why wouldn't 10% have been enough for a nice profit?

Not clear. From the article, what was bought were options, and I assume they were deep out of the money puts (q.v.) And from the article, I assume they were March 30 puts, bought in mid March, which gave them slightly less than two weeks before they expired worthless.

If I buy a put at $25 on a stock trading at $50, then the option will expire worthless if the stock drops to $26. The right to sell at $25 is worth zero when the stock itself can be sold at a better price on them market. So the only way I could make money off that option is via the greater fool theory -- selling it to some other dumb cluck who thinks that the stock will drop further. And I'm more likely to find such a fool if the stock has dropped to $30 than if it has dropped to $40, and more likely at $40 than at $50.

So the options will get slightly more valuable with a slight price drop.

But only for a short time.

Option pricing is complex. While the exercise price is one factor, the length of time the options have to run is also a factor, and it basically means that options tend to get less valuable over time (you lose money buying and holding options), because the stock has less time to make huge moves.

So a moderate drop (10%) would have made the options marginally more valuable, but at the same time they were getting substantially less valuable through the mere passage of time. Which effect would have dominated at any one time,.... I dunno.
 
Okay, to expand on what DrKitten said, so we can actually understand why we are arguing whether it was deliberate or not:

Looked at in one light, options are merely insurance.

Consider your house insurance. You insure your house for $350K. It is basically the option to sell your house to the insurance company for $350 (if it burns to the ground). Your opportunity to do that is time limited - say, 1 month if you pay your premium lately.

So what you have done here is laid off your risk to a counter party. In return, you give them cash flow every month. From the counter party point of view, they have taken on your risk, but they sufficient cash flows every month to pay off the odd claim or two.

Now, instead of being able to 'sell' your house to the insurance company if it burns to the ground, just imagine your policy allowed you to sell that house for any reason for $350K. Suddenly you could make or lose money based on whether or not the housing market is going up or down. Your house value drops to $320K, and you force the insurance company to buy it at $350K. As you might imagine, the price of that insurance premium will vary every day depending on the current market. Call on Tuesday and they quote you $100/month; call on weds and the quote went up to $120 because the market went down a bit.

Finally, imagine that there is a free market on this insurance. I buy insurance at $100/month on tuesday, it goes up to $120, and I sell the policy to you for $120. In which case *I* am no longer insured if my house burns down, but oddly, you would get the $350K if it did.

And that's all options are. Trading risk for cash flows, where a payment gives you the right to buy or sell, or force the counterparty to buy or sell at a a fixed price for a limited period of time. It would make no sense for me to sell my house insurance to you, which is why there is not a trading market in house insurance, but as we will see it can make perfect sense for stocks.

Okay, so let's say you own $500MM of Coca Cola. You don't want to lose massive amounts of money. So, you buy insurance (options). Every month you buy a new option (pay your insurance premium). The person selling it to you takes on the risk that Coca Cola will have a major downfall, but they get your cash flows. At the end of the month (actually, the third week of the month) if Coca Cola didn't have a disaster, that insurance (option) expires worthless. You are probably happy about that, just like you are happy each month to pay your house insurance and yet not have the house burn down. Likewise, the option writer (home insurer) is happy because they are getting cash flows.

As we reach the end of the contract, if Coke hasn't had a disaster, the contract is worth very little. But so long as there is time left, it's worth something. So, I may decide a day or so out that I want to recoup a bit of my money, and sell that contract to you.

Now, the final twist. Mortgage companies force us to insure for the cost of the house (they want their money no matter what, after all). With stocks, no one is forcing that. You can insure 1/2 of what you own, which will cost less than if you insured all of it. You can insure for it falling 1% (which will cost you a lot of money), or insure for it falling only 80% or more (which will cost you pennies).

And, you can insure something you don't own. Which is pretty cool - you can get paid for a stock falling, even though you don't own the stock. In this case you are quite leveraged, and pretty much just speculating about the stock going up or down. I can't insure my neighbors house, so I get paid if it burns down, but I can do that with stocks. The option writer (insurer) doesn't care - their profit/loss ratio is the same, and they want more cash flow streams, so they will write whatever contract you want, so long as the price is right.

For me, as the buyer, it can make sense too. For example, say I am saving money for college. I can't afford to risk that money in the market. OTOH, I think it will probably go up over the next two years. Instead of putting the money in the market, I put it in a savings bond, and then take a small percentage of it and buy an options contract betting that the market will go up. I don't own the stocks, but I've insured myself anyway. Worst case, if the stock doesn't go up, all I've lost is the premium. If the market does go up, I make money just as if I invested my entire college fund, minus the premium cost. Pretty sweet deal.

Or, if I am a gambler, I could put all of my college funds in options. If the market goes up, I make massive amounts of money (if that is not clear, remember an 'option' on your $350K house may just cost $100. If you spent $350K on insurance, that might represent a $50MM house - you could make tens or hundreds of millions of dollars on the deal). On the other hand, if it went down say 10% I could lose my entire investment. In this case you are massively leveraged, and speculating, rather than intelligently investing. A 10% swing in the stock market could cause you to (say) double your money, or lose it all, depending if the swing is up or down, and whether you bet the direction would be up or down.

So, it would make sense, if you had a huge exposure to a wall street firm, to buy some options to insure yourself against catastrophe. If you own enough of it, $1.7MM really isn't all that much insurance. If you have $1B tied up in the company, and you are hearing rumors that it is about to go tits up, why not throw a couple of million at the problem? At worst you lost $2M; at best you not only save yourself from losing $1B, but you actually make money on the deal (that 'make money' is where the house insurance analogy breaks down - you don't make money if your house burns down). If your house is not currently insured, and wild fires are raging just 1 mile up the canyon, you'd probably pay just about any price for a month's worth of insurance. If you have a $10MM house, you might pay $500K for a 1 month policy.

On the other hand, if you didn't own the company, then you are purely gambling that it will fail. Why risk $2MM in that case? Well, maybe you are a high roller. Or, maybe, as the article argues, you planned to manipulate the stock price via short selling to destroy the company.

Now, in the case of this option purchase, I don't think they were priced as if there was 'a fire raging 1 mile up the canyon', so a $1.7MM bet is pretty large - it represent a lot of stock. So the suspicion starts leaning toward manipulation and/or speculation, rather than insurance. If you out of the blue insured your $350K house for $50MM for a 2 week period, and a week later it burns down, questions would be raised to say the least. On the other hand, if there is a fire in your canyon, and you insure your $350K house for up to a $150K loss to wildfires, that would be reasonable and not worth questioning.
 
Last edited:
Now, in the case of this option purchase, I don't think they were priced as if there was 'a fire raging 1 mile up the canyon', so a $1.7MM bet is pretty large - it represent a lot of stock. So the suspicion starts leaning toward manipulation and/or speculation, rather than insurance. If you out of the blue insured your $350K house for $50MM for a 2 week period, and a week later it burns down, questions would be raised to say the least. On the other hand, if there is a fire in your canyon, and you insure your $350K house for up to a $150K loss to wildfires, that would be reasonable and not worth questioning.

As I pointed out, the stock had fallen over $24 in about 9 trading days, from $86.48 to $62.30.

To use your metaphor, the firewall had been breached, and the houses at the end of the street were already in flames.
 
Now, in the case of this option purchase, I don't think they were priced as if there was 'a fire raging 1 mile up the canyon', so a $1.7MM bet is pretty large - it represent a lot of stock. So the suspicion starts leaning toward manipulation and/or speculation, rather than insurance.

Good explanation.

But you're starting to conflate two different things here. Manipulation is, of course, evil and illegal and all sorts of other mean and nasty things.

Speculation, on the other hand, is exactly what hedge funds are supposed to do. There are actually option funds out there that spend all their time doing that kind of speculation.

So it's a little disconcerting to see you lump the two together. Frankly, if someone (legitimately) read the tea leaves and spotted the potential for a zillion dollar profit in the middle of the sky falling, that's good. I want that person on my team.

The question isn't insurance vs. speculation. The question is speculation vs. manipulation.

And, in fact, if the purchase in question was in fact a deep out of the money put, then there wasn't even any naked short selling involved. So the whole connection between "smart option trader" and "evil illegal market manipulator" is a conspiracy theory.
 
As I pointed out, the stock had fallen over $24 in about 9 trading days, from $86.48 to $62.30.

To use your metaphor, the firewall had been breached, and the houses at the end of the street were already in flames.

Well, that's one of the questions.

It's obvious, to you, with hindsight, that the firewall had been breached.

Was it obvious to the market? What was the price on the deep out of the money puts on Bear Stearns at the time? If you could pick them up for pennies, then you may have a hindsight advantage over the traders at the time. Or you may have a hindsight advantage over all the traders but one.

Or the trader may actually have been a manipulator as well. But that's looking less and less likely the deeper I dig.
 
Well, that's one of the questions.

It's obvious, to you, with hindsight, that the firewall had been breached.

Was it obvious to the market? What was the price on the deep out of the money puts on Bear Stearns at the time? If you could pick them up for pennies, then you may have a hindsight advantage over the traders at the time. Or you may have a hindsight advantage over all the traders but one.

Or the trader may actually have been a manipulator as well. But that's looking less and less likely the deeper I dig.

I don't know. I don't know if it was obvious. I don't know if someone guessed.

To me, it seems like pure speculation, based on the factors known.

You've got a very large drop in share price in a very small period. You've got volume of trading skyrocketing by the end of the slide (on March 10, it was something like 4x the volume of trades as in previous days). It's a company that just a few months prior had been trading near $150, and was a company deep in the whole sub-prime crisis.

I'm not saying it was obvious. I'm just saying it's not a large leap to think that someone out there took a bet that the sky was indeed falling. Whether it was a guess or anything else, I don't think we'll know, other than it was speculative.

Maybe it could have been manipulative, but I've not read anything overly convincing that it was.
 
Good explanation.

But you're starting to conflate two different things here. Manipulation is, of course, evil and illegal and all sorts of other mean and nasty things.

Speculation, on the other hand, is exactly what hedge funds are supposed to do. There are actually option funds out there that spend all their time doing that kind of speculation.

So it's a little disconcerting to see you lump the two together. Frankly, if someone (legitimately) read the tea leaves and spotted the potential for a zillion dollar profit in the middle of the sky falling, that's good. I want that person on my team.

The question isn't insurance vs. speculation. The question is speculation vs. manipulation.

And, in fact, if the purchase in question was in fact a deep out of the money put, then there wasn't even any naked short selling involved. So the whole connection between "smart option trader" and "evil illegal market manipulator" is a conspiracy theory.
I don't see conflation. As I said, the suspicion leans towards "manipulation and/or speculation". Suspicion shouldn't be assumed to have a pejorative connotation in that sentence. Consider "every time roger walked in on his wife on the phone, she quickly changed the subject. He began to suspect that either she was having an affiar, or planning a big blow out birthday party for him". The former would be bad, the latter good.

But this really gets to the heart of what is being argued about. CDOs, in and of themselves, are reasonable. If you have huge exposure to a bank, why not insure yourself against a collapse of the bank? And if you have billions of dollars with no good place to invest them, why not write CDO contracts, get some cash flows, against the unlikely event of a failure? win-win. Given that, why not create a free market in CDOs? Prices become fairer and more competitive, a smart person can excel, etc (all your points above).

But then you get the perverse situation where somebody can buy so much 'insurance' that they stand to make billions if a company fails evn though they have no exposure to the company's failure to begin with, and they have enough leverage in the market to make the failure happen. It's hard (for some people) to turn their backs on billions.

So the question becomes, how should these be regulated? A free market is good, but when you can lay on these kinds of bets, it pretty much guarantees that somebody is going to decide that crime pays.

(I know you get that point, but I get it too).

And, in fact, if the purchase in question was in fact a deep out of the money put, then there wasn't even any naked short selling involved. So the whole connection between "smart option trader" and "evil illegal market manipulator" is a conspiracy theory
Absolutely.
 
Last edited:
@ Roger & drkitten: Thank you very much. Your posts have been quite helpful! :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom