Naked Short-Selling, Anyone?

I'm edging on the side of "woo."

Just take a look at a historical chart of Bear Stearns' stock price. Back in July 2007, it was up near $150. By December it was around $100. By January 2008, it was around $70.

In fact, by February 26, it had stabilized a bit, and was trading at $86.48.

But **** started going down then. As of March 10, the day before the "killer" trade in the article, the stock had dropped to $62.30.

It dropped over $24 in just 2 weeks.

Does it really sound like that crazy a bet as Taibbi claims? Does it really sound crazy that someone would bet that the slide would continue?
 
I'm edging on the side of "woo."

Just take a look at a historical chart of Bear Stearns' stock price. Back in July 2007, it was up near $150. By December it was around $100. By January 2008, it was around $70.

In fact, by February 26, it had stabilized a bit, and was trading at $86.48.

But **** started going down then. As of March 10, the day before the "killer" trade in the article, the stock had dropped to $62.30.

It dropped over $24 in just 2 weeks.

Does it really sound like that crazy a bet as Taibbi claims? Does it really sound crazy that someone would bet that the slide would continue?

But the bet wasn't just that the slide would continue; it was an enormous bet that the stock would lose half its value in 9 days or less (according to the article anyway):
The mystery figure spent $1.7 million on a series of options, gambling that shares in the venerable investment bank Bear Stearns would lose more than half their value in nine days or less. It was madness — "like buying 1.7 million lottery tickets," according to one financial analyst.
 
But the bet wasn't just that the slide would continue; it was an enormous bet that the stock would lose half its value in 9 days or less (according to the article anyway):

But that's just my point.

The stock just lost 28% of it's value over the previous 9 trading days.

Does it REALLY seem like a stretch to think that it was collapsing, and would lose half it's value in another 9 trading days?

Think about it. Over $24 per share lost in about 9 trading days. If it had done that, when the stock was at $86.48, what's to say that it wouldn't happen again when the stock was at $62?
 
Not the biggest stretch ever, but 1.7 million is a sizable gamble. What if it only went down another 28% in 9 days? Or 49%? Or what if it went back up? If it was an easy call, did many other people make similar big bets like this one? Also, according to the article Senator Dodd found it quite suspicious.

eta: WP article on naked short selling:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naked_short_selling
 
Last edited:
Not the biggest stretch ever, but 1.7 million is a sizable gamble. What if it only went down another 28% in 9 days? Or 49%? Or what if it went back up?

That's why it was a gamble.

If it was an easy call, did many other people make similar big bets like this one? Also, according to the article Senator Dodd found it quite suspicious.

I never said it was an easy call. I'm just saying that, in the context of the stock price, it doesn't seem that big a stretch to imagine someone betting the slide would continue.
 
From the RS article:
[SIZE=+1]B[/SIZE]ear Stearns wasn't the kind of company that had a problem with naked short-selling. Before March 11th, 2008, there had never been a period in which significant quantities of Bear stock had been sold and then not delivered, and the company had never shown up on the Reg SHO list. But beginning on March 12th — the day after the Fed meeting that failed to include Bear, and the mysterious purchase of the options betting on the firm's imminent collapse — the number of counterfeit shares in Bear skyrocketed.
The best way to grasp what happened is to look at the data: On Tuesday, March 11th, there were 201,768 shares of Bear that had failed to deliver. The very next day, the number of phantom shares leaped to 1.2 million. By the close of trading that Friday, the number passed 2 million — and when the market reopened the following Monday, it soared to 13.7 million. In less than a week, the number of counterfeit shares in Bear had jumped nearly seventyfold.
The giant numbers of undelivered shares over the course of that week amounted to one of the most blatant cases of stock manipulation in Wall Street history. "There is not a doubt in my mind, not a single doubt" that naked short-selling helped destroy Bear, says Sen. Ted Kaufman, a Democrat from Delaware who has introduced legislation to curb such financial fraud. Asked to rate how obvious a case of naked short-selling Bear is, on a scale of one to 10, former SEC counsel Brent Baker doesn't hesitate. "Easily a 10," he says.
 
I'm about halfway through...so far it seems reasonable. What parts seem dubious to you?

I don't know enough about finance to have a clear opinion, but I'm particularly wondering about the insinuation that other large investment banks might have been deliberately engaging in illegal activity on such a scale, perhaps with a wink and a nod from high placed government officials and the Fed.
 
I don't know enough about finance to have a clear opinion, but I'm particularly wondering about the insinuation that other large investment banks might have been deliberately engaging in illegal activity on such a scale, perhaps with a wink and a nod from high placed government officials and the Fed.

And no whistleblower emerged from the wreckage? Citigroup was cutting THOUSANDS of jobs in the aftermath. None of them were disgruntled enough to go public with this illegal conduct?
 
Not the biggest stretch ever, but 1.7 million is a sizable gamble.

$1.7 million is a sizable gamble by whose standards?

For a company like Eton Park Capital (about $10 billion in assets), $1.7 million is chump change. There are financial companies out there with literally trillions in assets (BNP Paribas, for example).
 
I thought Taibbi was stating or implying that the banks were up to no good, but what they were doing was not necessarily illegal; but maybe I'm misremembering. Anyhow, like Prometheus I'm no finance expert, but it does seem to me that the banks behaved recklessly and got away with a lot due to their influence with Bernanke and Geithner. I think small time investors and homeowners may have made bad decisions that helped create the financial meltdown as well, but they didn't get to have meetings like this one:

Then, on March 11th — around the same time that mystery Nostradamus was betting $1.7 million that Bear was about to collapse — a curious thing happened that attracted virtually no notice on Wall Street. On that day, a meeting was held at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York that was brokered by Fed chief Ben Bernanke and then-New York Fed president Timothy Geithner. The luncheon included virtually everyone who was anyone on Wall Street — except for Bear Stearns.

Bear, in fact, was the only major investment bank not represented at the meeting, whose list of participants reads like a Barzini-Tattaglia meeting of the Five Families. In attendance were Jamie Dimon from JPMorgan Chase, Lloyd Blankfein from Goldman Sachs, James Gorman from Morgan Stanley, Richard Fuld from Lehman Brothers and John Thain, the big-spending office redecorator still heading the not-yet-fully-destroyed Merrill Lynch. Also present were old Clinton hand Robert Rubin, who represented Citigroup; Stephen Schwarzman of the Blackstone Group; and several hedge-fund chiefs, including Kenneth Griffin of Citadel Investment Group.

The meeting was never announced publicly. In fact, it was discovered only by accident, when a reporter from Bloomberg filed a request under the Freedom of Information Act and came across a mention of it in Bernanke's schedule. Rolling Stone has since contacted every major attendee, and all declined to comment on what was discussed at the meeting. "The ground rules of the lunch were of confidentiality," says a spokesman for Morgan Stanley. "Blackstone has no comment," says a spokesman for Schwarzman. Rubin declined a request for an interview, Fuld's people didn't return calls, and Goldman refused to talk about the closed-door session. The New York Fed said the meeting, which had been scheduled weeks earlier, was simply business as usual: "Such informal, small group sessions can provide a valuable means to learn about market functioning from people with firsthand knowledge."

So what did happen at that meeting? There's no evidence that Bernanke and Geithner called the confidential session to discuss Bear's troubles, let alone how to carve up the bank's spoils. It's possible that one of them made an impolitic comment about Bear during a meeting held for other reasons, inadvertently fueling a run on the bank. What's impossible to believe is the ******** version that Geithner and Bernanke later told Congress. The month after Bear's collapse, both men testified before the Senate that they only learned how dire the firm's liquidity problems were on Thursday, March 13th — despite the fact that rumors of Bear's troubles had begun as early as that Monday and both men had met in person with every key player on Wall Street that Tuesday. This is a little like saying you spent the afternoon of September 12th, 2001, in the Oval Office, but didn't hear about the Twin Towers falling until September 14th.
 
$1.7 million is a sizable gamble by whose standards?

For a company like Eton Park Capital (about $10 billion in assets), $1.7 million is chump change. There are financial companies out there with literally trillions in assets (BNP Paribas, for example).

I meant, it's sizable considering what the bet was--that the stock would have to plunge to 50% or more of its value in 9 days or less. The chairman of the Senate Banking Committee apparently thought this transaction was suspicious.
 
Again, though, the point is that the gamble didn't START the free-fall.

The point is that the gamble happened DURING the free fall.

That's what I'm trying to say. The volume of shares traded had already jumped by March 10, and was in fact rising by the end of the previous week.

The timings don't seem to match up with his arguments. Like I said, the price had already fallen $24 in 9 trading days. If that doesn't set off alarm bells that a company is in trouble, what does?
 
And no whistleblower emerged from the wreckage? Citigroup was cutting THOUSANDS of jobs in the aftermath. None of them were disgruntled enough to go public with this illegal conduct?

The article makes it sound like a foregone conclusion that illegal activity took place--just that no one seems to know who was doing it--and that the big banks seem to have at least been complicit in some way.

How many people would actually need to be in on a scheme like this, though? If it really is a sizable bunch of people that would need to know, then the lack of any whistleblowers emerging yet would make me skeptical too.
 
Again, though, the point is that the gamble didn't START the free-fall.

The point is that the gamble happened DURING the free fall.

That's what I'm trying to say. The volume of shares traded had already jumped by March 10, and was in fact rising by the end of the previous week.

The timings don't seem to match up with his arguments. Like I said, the price had already fallen $24 in 9 trading days. If that doesn't set off alarm bells that a company is in trouble, what does?

I agree 100% that it was quite clear that the company was in trouble. I don't think that Taibbi is claiming that this transaction "started the free fall," is he?
 
Again, though, the point is that the gamble didn't START the free-fall.

The point is that the gamble happened DURING the free fall.

That's what I'm trying to say. The volume of shares traded had already jumped by March 10, and was in fact rising by the end of the previous week.

The timings don't seem to match up with his arguments. Like I said, the price had already fallen $24 in 9 trading days. If that doesn't set off alarm bells that a company is in trouble, what does?

It would be interesting to know the full context of the option, too. Was this a single investment, or did the investor also, for example, spend another $15M buying other less-aggressive options on the same stock? If so, it wouldn't look nearly so suspicious. I have no idea if it's true, of course.
 
I agree 100% that it was quite clear that the company was in trouble. I don't think that Taibbi is claiming that this transaction "started the free fall," is he?

That seems to be the insinuation.

He takes a similar argument with Lehman. Like with Bear, though, the timings don't seem to add up, and he doesn't go into quite as much detail about the transactions.

Like Bear, though, by the time these kinds of trades show up, it's already quite clear that the company is in serious trouble.

I'm with dasmiller, too. I think I'd like to see what other options were bought. If it was part of a bell curve-esque strategy with the options, we could better tell. Whoever did it could have bet $1.7m that they'd drop by half, but bet $10m that they'd drop a similar amount from the previous two weeks, etc.

Context is most definitely needed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom