Mystery illness in US consulate due to non-ionizing radiation?

Before I reply to individual posts, let me say that I seem to be up against a group of TOTALLY BIASED individuals who are pre-judging based on their stereotypical view that "once branded a woo, always a woo".

No. But once nonsense, always nonsense. Sorry.

Some of you are just here to get your jollies by sarcastic dumping on another poster (me). That is part of forums I guess.

But some you are so aligned with what the "authorities" tell you you are incapable are independent thought and judgment.

Look, several of us us are engineers, even scientists. We actually try to sort the wheat from the chaff, and are basically qualified to do so.

I have had two "anecdotes" about people experiencing ill-effects from overuse of their cell-phone. But they do not count do they? Unless they are part of an scientific survey that give their stories some credence.

No, anecdotes are always doubtful. Problem is, people may have experienced what they say, but nobody can know the actual reason. It is easy to point at cellphones, but really: Who is NOT using cellphones?

Am going to learn anything technical here?

If you really wanna listen, you are going to learn a LOT of technical stuff here. But be prepared to discover that it does not all support your ideas.

Hans
 
Disclaimer: This post is not meant to be nasty. Just the truth as I see it.


Before I reply to individual posts, let me say that I seem to be up against a group of TOTALLY BIASED individuals who are pre-judging based on their stereotypical view that "once branded a woo, always a woo".

Some of you are just here to get your jollies by sarcastic dumping on another poster (me). That is part of forums I guess.

But some you are so aligned with what the "authorities" tell you you are incapable are independent thought and judgment.

I have had two "anecdotes" about people experiencing ill-effects from overuse of their cell-phone. But they do not count do they? Unless they are part of an scientific survey that give their stories some credence.

Like the bad olive oil in Spain which was never proven by testing because they could not get hold of a sample (it was all consumed), but the 300 affected were given credibility because of consistency.
Am going to learn anything technical here?


This may not be the best comparison.

I'm pretty sure there is no shortage of samples of cell phones.
 
Radiation from cell towers enhances brain activity and makes people smarter? Fantastic!

What? I have the same justification for assuming that such changes are beneficial as you have for assuming that they are harmful, i.e. none whatever.
Sound like the premise for yet another Fantastic Four reboot.

Doctor Doom harnesses the power of vibranium to supercharge the world's cellular network and then take over the world.

But Reed Richards has prior art - and superpowers derived from a vibranium-cellphone lab accident. Doom has powers, too, but the Fantastic Foir's secret ingredient is accidental cosmic rays, and so the heroes prevail. But Doctor Doom will return, in Fantastic Four 2: The Return of Doctor Doom.
 
No. The use of cellular technology is not new or unique to these locations. The symptoms observed here are new and unique to these locations. Whatever it is, it isn't cellular technology.
(snip)

When asked if you are certain you say you are!

Wow. The experts do not know but you know for sure it is not cell EM.

You must work for a cell-phone company, or have lots of stock.
 
Close proximity to live radar or radio antenna can cause injury.
Before working aloft on naval ships the radars and Radio transmitters are stopped. Anyone working aloft has to be handed circuit links (or 'keys' as they are called) that cut the connection from the transmitter to the antenna.
These have to be placed in the hand of the man going up who hangs them on a placard by the mast or superstructure. This placard has a warning that there is a man working aloft and systems are dead.
'RF Burns' are not a rare thing even among enthusiastic radio Hams who like to repair and build their own gear.
An Air Warning radar or main radio is pushing out a huge amount of power.
Note that ships crews working on deck are within 25m of the antenna and don't suffer any ill effects.

As for Thyristors, they can still cause damage if you are within close, unshielded proximity and they have enough power going through them.


It's all to do with proximity and power.

These towers all have warnings about turning off before working on/in them.

What about exposure time? Is that not a factor?

Did the radium that killed people who took it for health reasons take a long time to have an effect?
 
Radiation from cell towers enhances brain activity and makes people smarter? Fantastic!

What? I have the same justification for assuming that such changes are beneficial as you have for assuming that they are harmful, i.e. none whatever.


Where did it say smarter? Your bias makes you a conclusion jumper.

It says it disturbs sleep. That is not smarter.:covereyes
 
No. But once nonsense, always nonsense. Sorry.



Look, several of us us are engineers, even scientists. We actually try to sort the wheat from the chaff, and are basically qualified to do so.



No, anecdotes are always doubtful. Problem is, people may have experienced what they say, but nobody can know the actual reason. It is easy to point at cellphones, but really: Who is NOT using cellphones?



If you really wanna listen, you are going to learn a LOT of technical stuff here. But be prepared to discover that it does not all support your ideas.

Hans


I am waiting but yet have to read some words of wisdom. Having done my research, I am aware of just about everything said here.

As for cell phone use, I limit mine to as little as possible. About 7 calls a week and about 10 SMSs. I will not use the hands free set but instead use the landline phone.

Are cell phones great? Absolutely. Is nuclear power great? Absolutely but not in my back yard.
 
Last edited:
PartSkeptic once again has us playing that favorite game of fringe idea promoters, called "Hey Skeptics, Prove I'm Wrong", which falls under the heading of "Let's Poke the Skeptics With a Stick".

PS, you know the drill - you need to provide good scientific evidence if you want to make a scientific case for your idea. Your claim, your burden to proof. You offer us anecdotes in lieu of good evidence and then complain when we don't accept it. I seem to recall we've played this same game with you before.

ETA: You do know you're posting in the science subform, right?
 
Last edited:
When asked if you are certain you say you are!

Wow. The experts do not know but you know for sure it is not cell EM.

You must work for a cell-phone company, or have lots of stock.

The experts do know that the symptoms experienced by our diplomats in Cuba and China are not due to cell phones. If cell phones have negative effects, they are at a level below that experienced by these diplomats. None of your sources have claimed or suggested otherwise.
 
These towers all have warnings about turning off before working on/in them.

So don't work on them without turning them off.

What about exposure time? Is that not a factor?

Depends. I can stick my hand in liquid nitrogen for a short time without damage, but if I leave it in long enough I might have to amputate my hand. But I can stick my hand in 50 degree F water for an indefinite period of time without damage.
 
Well, you could learn technical things here, but you seem uninterested in doing so.

I could easily explain why it is that cell phone masts do not cook you like a microwave oven, for example. However, I am aware that you would simply consult the cards for verification so why should I bother?

TBF, I find the EM nomenclature unnecessarily hyperbolic (and confusing).


Legend:
γ = Gamma rays

HX = Hard X-rays
SX = Soft X-Rays

EUV = Extreme-ultraviolet
NUV = Near-ultraviolet

Visible light (colored bands)

NIR = Near-infrared
MIR = Mid-infrared
FIR = Far-infrared

EHF = Extremely high frequency (microwaves)
SHF = Super-high frequency (microwaves)

UHF = Ultrahigh frequency (radio waves)
VHF = Very high frequency (radio)
HF = High frequency (radio)
MF = Medium frequency (radio)
LF = Low frequency (radio)
VLF = Very low frequency (radio)
VF = Voice frequency
ULF = Ultra-low frequency (radio)
SLF = Super-low frequency (radio)
ELF = Extremely low frequency(radio)

I would have preferred something that compares every Frequency to Gamma Rays - with GR being (Totally Badass Ninja Frequency!*) and what is today called ELF being (Total Suckfest Frequency!).

* Or perhaps Totally Awesome Badass Frequency with VL being just (Awesome Frequency because we can, like, totally see it, dude!)


Oops, forgot something for Part Skeptic!

Oh, dear ...


https://petapixel.com/2018/06/07/a-radioactive-lens/
 
Last edited:
TBF, I find the EM nomenclature unnecessarily hyperbolic (and confusing).




I would have preferred something that compares every Frequency to Gamma Rays - with GR being (Totally Badass Ninja Frequency!*) and what is today called ELF being (Total Suckfest Frequency!).

* Or perhaps Totally Awesome Badass Frequency with VL being just (Awesome Frequency because we can, like, totally see it, dude!)

<snip>


Yet another useful XKCD strip.
 
An interesting unit of radiation exposure is the banana equivalent
http://www.ppe.gla.ac.uk/~protopop/teaching/NPP/P2-NPP.pdf
For those interested the fatal dose of bananas is 100,000,000 (from radiation poisoning).
Just where you live makes a difference. Some houses in the UK (Cornwall) can be unsaleable because of radon accumulation leaking from the granite Living at altitude increases your radiation exposure to cosmic rays essentially pretty similar to x or gamma rays. Up north we can see the cosmic rays sweeping in most (winter) nights.
 
Where did it say smarter? Your bias makes you a conclusion jumper.

It says it disturbs sleep. That is not smarter.:covereyes

You have a fantastic ability to completely and utterly miss the point, time after time.
 
So don't work on them without turning them off.



Depends. I can stick my hand in liquid nitrogen for a short time without damage, but if I leave it in long enough I might have to amputate my hand. But I can stick my hand in 50 degree F water for an indefinite period of time without damage.

What? You mean to say all those moisturiser ads were *lying*?

Conclusion: moisturiser prevents damage from non-ionising radiation if you don't stick your hand in liquid nitrogen for too long. Or something. You wanted logic? Wrong thread.... :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom