Mystery illness in US consulate due to non-ionizing radiation?

Do we have to wait until we have a produced a generation of children with mental defects to say non-ionizing radiation is a health risk?


No, we’ve already got plenty of people who are prepared to make unsupported statements.
 
I have not idea what he is willing to do, but you keep ignoring this part where he emphasizes that he thinks that he can't handle it unlike somebody in full health: "My immune system is fighting a battle against inflammation from a bat fungus. Cancer is just being kept at bay.)"

But since the damage is probably imaginary anyway, it doesn't really matter.
Not ignored anything relevant to the point I was making.
 
See? That’s how dangerous these towers are, even if they aren’t switched on!


It's due to the Quantum Tunneling Effect. (You have to invoke the word "quantum" because it is magical and means anything can happen and all those silly scientists aren't smart enough to understand it.)

The massive concentration of electromagnetic energy has caused it to tunnel back in time and cause damage even before it exists.

Pretty dangerous stuff!!!
 
I have not idea what he is willing to do, but you keep ignoring this part where he emphasizes that he thinks that he can't handle it unlike somebody in full health: "My immune system is fighting a battle against inflammation from a bat fungus. Cancer is just being kept at bay.)"

But since the damage is probably imaginary anyway, it doesn't really matter.

Hence the phrase "batcrap crazy"...
 
Disclaimer: This post is not meant to be nasty. Just the truth as I see it.


Before I reply to individual posts, let me say that I seem to be up against a group of TOTALLY BIASED individuals who are pre-judging based on their stereotypical view that "once branded a woo, always a woo".

Some of you are just here to get your jollies by sarcastic dumping on another poster (me). That is part of forums I guess.

But some you are so aligned with what the "authorities" tell you you are incapable are independent thought and judgment.

I have had two "anecdotes" about people experiencing ill-effects from overuse of their cell-phone. But they do not count do they? Unless they are part of an scientific survey that give their stories some credence.

Like the bad olive oil in Spain which was never proven by testing because they could not get hold of a sample (it was all consumed), but the 300 affected were given credibility because of consistency.

Am going to learn anything technical here?
 
I have had two "anecdotes" about people experiencing ill-effects from overuse of their cell-phone. But they do not count do they? Unless they are part of an scientific survey that give their stories some credence.


No, because they cannot establish causality. The reported ill effects could be the result of the placebo effect, or they could simply be coincidence. When this sort of thing is controlled for, the apparent effects disappear. See, for example, the review of controlled provocation trials linked to on the previous page.

Am going to learn anything technical here?


If you read the responses you’ve been given, yes.
 
Last edited:
But some of you so aligned with what the "authorities" tell you you are incapable are independent thought and judgment.
By "the authorities" you apparently mean carefully controlled and unbiased testing by people who actually know what they're doing. Their conclusions may not be 100% reliable (nothing ever is, which is why we have occasional mistakes like the thalidomide tragedy) but they are a lot more reliable than those of credulous ignoramuses who have nothing to go on but their subjective experiences.

I have had two "anecdotes" about people experiencing ill-effects from overuse of their cell-phone. But they do not count do they? Unless they are part of an scientific survey that give their stories some credence.
Correct.

This is not complicated, PartSkeptic. People have convinced themselves of all sorts of things which turned out not to be true, from the belief that doing a rain dance makes it rain to that blood letting and homeopathy are effective medical treatments, by relying on their subjective experiences rather than gathering objective evidence.

The scientific method is not perfect, but findings obtained using it are a damn sight more reliable than those obtained any other way.
 
This needs clarification. During use, thyratrons can produce x-rays if the voltage is high. They do not, however, become radioactive, in the sense that they do not give off ionizing radiation while the device is unpowered.

Yes, some of the internal parts become radioactive.

I'm not sure exactly how, but I have worked with the devices and we were strongly warned not to touch the parts if one was broken.

ETA: According to this http://www.radartutorial.eu/08.transmitters/Thyratron.en.html the hazard is in the X-ray emission. I will look for confirmation of the claim for residual radioactivity.

ETA ETA; Ah, here: https://books.google.dk/books?id=Os...nepage&q=Thyratron tube radioactivity&f=false

It is not clear whether radioactive materials were used in manufacture, or whether they become radioactive during use.

Anyhow, the point is that all this does not apply to cell-phone towers.


Hans
 
Last edited:
This sentence from your link:
Do not remove radioactive tubes from carton until ready to use them.

seems to imply that they are already radiactive when installed, not made radioactive by use.
 
Disclaimer: This post is not meant to be nasty. Just the truth as I see it.


Before I reply to individual posts, let me say that I seem to be up against a group of TOTALLY BIASED individuals who are pre-judging based on their stereotypical view that "once branded a woo, always a woo".

Some of you are just here to get your jollies by sarcastic dumping on another poster (me). That is part of forums I guess.

But some you are so aligned with what the "authorities" tell you you are incapable are independent thought and judgment.

I have had two "anecdotes" about people experiencing ill-effects from overuse of their cell-phone. But they do not count do they? Unless they are part of an scientific survey that give their stories some credence.

Like the bad olive oil in Spain which was never proven by testing because they could not get hold of a sample (it was all consumed), but the 300 affected were given credibility because of consistency.

Am going to learn anything technical here?
Well, you could learn technical things here, but you seem uninterested in doing so.

I could easily explain why it is that cell phone masts do not cook you like a microwave oven, for example. However, I am aware that you would simply consult the cards for verification so why should I bother?
 
It's worth noticing that the belief in dangerous electromagnetic waves may actually kill!

"There were 13 fatalities, including the perpetrator. The shooter and 11 of the victims were killed at the scene, while a twelfth victim, 61-year-old Vishnu Pandit, died at George Washington University Hospital. All the victims killed were civilian employees or contractors. Eight others were injured, three of them from gunfire."

Mental health issues
After the Navy Yard shooting, the media speculated that Alexis had appeared to be suffering from mental illness. The media reported that Alexis had filed a police report in Rhode Island on August 2, 2013, in which he claimed to be the victim of harassment and that he was hearing voices in his head. According to an FBI official after the shooting, Alexis was under the "belief that he was being controlled or influenced by extremely low frequency electromagnetic waves". A message later obtained by federal authorities from Alexis' personal computing devices said, "Ultra low frequency attack is what I've been subject to for the last 3 months. And to be perfectly honest, that is what has driven me to this."
Washington Navy Yard shooting: Mental health issues (Wikipedia)


Unfortunately, the FBI doesn't seem to have learned much from the case of Aaron Alexis!
 
Explain the Scientific American article that showed brain alpha waves changed with cell phone use.

No "damage" but "changes".

You guys seem to say "It will not kill you - and what is wrong with being turned into a zombie?"
 
"... being turned into a zombie."


You mean like this?

The arousal effects the researchers measured are equivalent to about half a cup of coffee, and many other factors in a person's surroundings will affect a night's sleep as much or more than cell phone transmissions.
The Scientific American article


That is a far cry from The Walking Dead, isn't it?




Let me recommend an experiment that you can do yourself with your allegedly electro-sensitive friends:
Place a cellphone in a small cardboard box with the power on or off. The box shouldn't interfere much with the electromagnetic fields generated by the cell phone. Your friends should now be able to determine if an electromagnetic field is generated by the cell phone or not.
Do it 20 times and make sure that the test is double-blinded.
 
Last edited:
ETA ETA; Ah, here: https://books.google.dk/books?id=Os...nepage&q=Thyratron tube radioactivity&f=false

It is not clear whether radioactive materials were used in manufacture, or whether they become radioactive during use.

I'm positive that it was radioactive material used in the manufacture, not activated during use. In order to make something become radioactive, you need to change the makeup of the nucleus. That generally means bombarding it with other nucleons (usually neutrons, but alpha particles can also work). You can't really do it with x-rays or electrons.

Anyhow, the point is that all this does not apply to cell-phone towers.

Absolutely correct.
 
Microwave exposure of sufficient energy to heat up tissue is damaging, potentially lethal.

However, many of the older cases of RADAR operators getting radiation damages were not due to the RADAR beam as such. Instead, in older RADAR sets a certain type of valve, a thyratron, was used, and parts of those became radioactive with use. Handling those components caused the damage.

Modern RADAR sets use a semiconductor called a thyristor instead, which eliminates that danger. The high-energy microwave output still poses a hazard, of course.

Hans

Close proximity to live radar or radio antenna can cause injury.
Before working aloft on naval ships the radars and Radio transmitters are stopped. Anyone working aloft has to be handed circuit links (or 'keys' as they are called) that cut the connection from the transmitter to the antenna.
These have to be placed in the hand of the man going up who hangs them on a placard by the mast or superstructure. This placard has a warning that there is a man working aloft and systems are dead.
'RF Burns' are not a rare thing even among enthusiastic radio Hams who like to repair and build their own gear.
An Air Warning radar or main radio is pushing out a huge amount of power.
Note that ships crews working on deck are within 25m of the antenna and don't suffer any ill effects.

As for Thyristors, they can still cause damage if you are within close, unshielded proximity and they have enough power going through them.


It's all to do with proximity and power.
 
Explain the Scientific American article that showed brain alpha waves changed with cell phone use.

No "damage" but "changes".

Radiation from cell towers enhances brain activity and makes people smarter? Fantastic!

What? I have the same justification for assuming that such changes are beneficial as you have for assuming that they are harmful, i.e. none whatever.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom