Multiple police shot in Dallas protest

When I run into people that try to convince me that everyone should have an AR-15, I like to point out that it is overkill for making holes in paper and states like mine that believe in sportsmanship don't allow them to be used for big game hunting. Almost always the response is that people need them in Texas to deal with feral hogs.

So did the open carry guy packing an AR-15 in Dallas intend to shoot pigs?
 
Well... Some stats i read say it's very roughly 50/50 between white and black people. However, it didn't say anything about the circumstances.

Do you have any sources the circumstances under which blacks vs. whites were shot by police?

I mean, you know, it could also be that when white people get shot by police, they are doing something really nasty because whites are more nasty in general, while blacks get shot for trivial, non-nasty stuff, because they are more well behaved in general. Of course it could also be the other way around. Or it could be that they both are equal. But given the frequency in which black people are shot/killed/beaten by police for basically no reason at all, vs. the far less reports about the same happening to whites, one could easily think it is because of the first.

Without knowing who got shot for what, the raw numbers are basically meaningless.

Greetings,

Chris

The stats are normalized to a per encounter basis. A white person that has an encounter with a cop has the same likelihood of being shot as a black person that has one. This does not factor in the particular circumstances of the encounters, but blacks overall have more encounters with police. The stories that get picked up by the media and resonate with people are just a small and biased fraction of total police shootings. If whites were nastier in general, they should be shot more often. It's quite a mentally acrobatic maneuver to propose that anti-black racism from police leads them to kill blacks at a rate that perfectly balances out white peoples' inherent extra nastiness. The burden of proof is on those claiming racism as the stats we have do not support that claim.

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/18/upshot/police-killings-of-blacks-what-the-data-says.html?_r=0
 
Last edited:
Generally well said. Except those 99%. I too think it's overly optimistic ..

The percentage of police officers who are far from perfect is probably much higher than 1%.

On the other hand, the percentage of police officers whose behavior is so bad as to justify shooting other police officers in protest is probably much lower than 1%.

So, in the context of this shooting, I think 99% is probably a good number, rhetorically.
 
you need to travel more, see how the world actually works.very little of it agrees at all with your world view.

The belief that the world of today is far more violent than some golden era in the past is common. Therefore going back to the rules of these ancient times will bring back peace and tranquility. When you examine the evidence, it becomes clear that the past was far worse than our modern world.

Our friend needs to watch Seven Pinker's Ted Talk: The Surprising Decline in Violence.
 
When I run into people that try to convince me that everyone should have an AR-15, I like to point out that it is overkill for making holes in paper and states like mine that believe in sportsmanship don't allow them to be used for big game hunting. Almost always the response is that people need them in Texas to deal with feral hogs.
So did the open carry guy packing an AR-15 in Dallas intend to shoot pigs?

For the record, that is absolute, utter ********.
Humans hunted rhinos, elephants and crocodiles to near extinction without the help of AR-15s.
 
The percentage of police officers who are far from perfect is probably much higher than 1%.

On the other hand, the percentage of police officers whose behavior is so bad as to justify shooting other police officers in protest is probably much lower than 1%.
So, in the context of this shooting, I think 99% is probably a good number, rhetorically.

Neither of us have numbers to back these assertions, but I disagree with the highlighted portion. I have seen -- with my own eyes in living color -- behavior that would approach (if perhaps not meet) such a level at least three times.

I think I just got an idea for a poll.
 
When I run into people that try to convince me that everyone should have an AR-15, I like to point out that it is overkill for making holes in paper and states like mine that believe in sportsmanship don't allow them to be used for big game hunting. Almost always the response is that people need them in Texas to deal with feral hogs.

So did the open carry guy packing an AR-15 in Dallas intend to shoot pigs?

How often do you bump into these people?
 
When I run into people that try to convince me that everyone should have an AR-15, I like to point out that it is overkill for making holes in paper and states like mine that believe in sportsmanship don't allow them to be used for big game hunting. Almost always the response is that people need them in Texas to deal with feral hogs.

So did the open carry guy packing an AR-15 in Dallas intend to shoot pigs?

My father in law always used a .44 magnum.
 
Are we going to talk about how the police used a bomb to kill the suspect while he was contained indoors?
 
Are we going to talk about how the police used a bomb to kill the suspect while he was contained indoors?

I did wonder where the DPD got hold of a friggin' bomb. I mean, I'm not sorry the skidmark is dead, but picking his diseased brain would have been useful, methinks.
 
Neither of us have numbers to back these assertions, but I disagree with the highlighted portion. I have seen -- with my own eyes in living color -- behavior that would approach (if perhaps not meet) such a level at least three times.

I think I just got an idea for a poll.

Wait, your justifying shooting cops????
 
-C&P from CnN:

Rawlings stressed that other people may have been involved in planning the attack. He said there was confusion about the number of shooters at first because there were about 20 protesters dressed in camouflage and carrying rifles, and they scattered when the shooting started.
Dallas police Chief David Brown spoke at a prayer rally on Friday and said: "Through our investigation of some of the suspects, it's revealed to us that this was a well-planned, well-thought-out, evil tragedy by these suspects."

So it looks like a plan for more shooters, or at least a diversion. Many felony murder counts to come?
 
Are we going to talk about how the police used a bomb to kill the suspect while he was contained indoors?

Nope. We're supposed to ignore that out of respect for the fallen.

I did wonder where the DPD got hold of a friggin' bomb. I mean, I'm not sorry the skidmark is dead, but picking his diseased brain would have been useful, methinks.

I went over that here.

He was not contained, had broken off negotiations and was still shooting at them. He claimed to have set other bombs around the area. There may have been wounded who could not be evacuated until the firing stopped. They had not yet established whether or not there were other shooters. In other words, the police were pressed for time. This was the safest way to deal with him in a timely manner.

Police departments have little robots and use explosives to blow up suspicious packages - it is safer than sending in a person to disarm a bomb. It would be very easy to craft some of those explosives into a small bomb. This is apparently somewhat routine way of dealing with IEDs in Afghanistan and Iraq. Lots of cops are vets - some of them had probably done this before.

Is killing him with a bomb somehow worse than shooting him?
 
Last edited:
For the record, that is absolute, utter ********.
Humans hunted rhinos, elephants and crocodiles to near extinction without the help of AR-15s.

Needing to use an AR-15 to hunt feral hogs is a standard gun lobby talking point.

My state does not allow hunting big game with a rifle that holds more than six rounds total. A big game rifle is also required to have a caliber of at least 6mm.

The AR-15 fails both of these requirements.
 
Is killing him with a bomb somehow worse than shooting him?

That's the wrong question. The protest was about excessive use of force by the police. Bombs represent another step up the ladder. In this context, "gets results" isn't enough.
 
That's the wrong question. The protest was about excessive use of force by the police. Bombs represent another step up the ladder. In this context, "gets results" isn't enough.

Good thing I didn't list "Gets results" as one of the reasons they used a bomb.

It was safer than trying to get another cop in position to shoot him - that would be risky, given that he had already shot 12 cops who were presumably trying to shoot him. He seemed to be pretty skilled.

The bomb was fast, they didn't know if they had time to spare or not.

The reason for the protests was no longer a concern by that point. They had multiple injuries and fatalities, the gunman was still active and dangerous, they thought there might be other gunmen out there.

Would you want to be the commander that gets more police officers killed by the man who had already shot 12 of your officers, when you had a low risk way of dealing with the problem?
 
Needing to use an AR-15 to hunt feral hogs is a standard gun lobby talking point.

My state does not allow hunting big game with a rifle that holds more than six rounds total. A big game rifle is also required to have a caliber of at least 6mm.

The AR-15 fails both of these requirements.

The only descriptor I've read is the lowly SKS. 7.62 x 39mm, mostly Chinese imports. Cheap. I only paid $89 for mine 20 years ago. No magazine, built in ammo feed must be fed from the top. But could be had w/ detachable magazine and scope.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom