SYLVESTER1592
Critical Thinker
- Joined
- May 7, 2007
- Messages
- 307
First...as a big appreciator of Jon Stewart, I do know that this is being "recorded," and my question to this list, do you know that because in the near future when homeopathy will have achieved great acceptance, we will look back at your responses as evidence of the fact that dinosaurs yell and scream the loudest before their fall. Timber.
A couple more notes about the "acute diarrhea" experiments. Why, oh, why do people still ignore the entire body of statistics from these experiments? The p value was in the substantial range...beyond significant! P=0.008. Take off your blinders.
As for why there was no significant difference at day 5 is that acute diarrhea resolves on its own in most cases...but THIS trial showed that children given homeopathic treatment (and ORT) got over it substantially faster than those just given ORT. End of story. Saying anything else is simply not supported for the data.
I think this is what skepticism is, thinking critcally. When you look at all the comments and criticisms and also see that the author was not able to replicate the results... Well, you can only come to the conclusion that this is not evidence of homeopathy working. A p-value alone doesn't say everything. You have to look at how it has attained and what contributed to it. That's where there are still a lot of problems.
Doing research is not about satisfying the needs of conventional medicine, although many homeopaths seem to think so, but it's about the advancement of medical practice. That is why it is looked at with this kind of scrutiny. The patients rely on us to provide the best treatment available; that's the aim. We look for objective measurements to achieve an objective judgement and try to control as many influencing factors as possible to make a reliable distinction between treatments that work and those that don't. Why? Because both doctors and patients need to be sure that they get the best possible chance of succes. Looking backwards patients may say that something worked or that it hasn't. Homeopathy gets to choose their patients, they pick the ones that will have ailments that will be resolved by themselves in most cases and send the patients that have a serious disease to the conventional medical practitioners (in the best case scenario). The result is that conventional medicine will need to help all the patients that did not receive their real treatment in a timely fashion and sometimes patients don't get their real treatments at all, because the homeopath thinks he can treat serious diseases. The evidence for homeopathy is still anecdotal as far as I know. The studies published have serious flaws in them and are often contradicted later on. The contradiction or rectification is something proponents of homeopathy discard or selectively don't remember. As long as at one time it was said to work, it will stand as a testimony to homeopathy as far as they care, anything else doesn't matter. I think those are the real blindfolds and I don't think we are the ones wearing them.
When there would be a proven mechanism of the effects of homeopathic solutions it would be building on previous knowledge and still require thorough investigation. Any conventional drug would receive the same kind of criticism, maybe even more... Mainly because the quality of the research lets scientists do that. It also leads to a better acceptance of conventional medicine, because it hold up under scrutiny, because it can be reproduced, it is researched for effectiveness and toxicity in well-designed, well-executed, well-analyzed experiments. It offers something to build on...
So what do you think of my criticism of the article? I think it's fair to say it doesn't hold up. Remember that a badly designed, badly executed, badly analyzed experiment can always render a significant difference if you want it too, but it doesn't advance knowledge and doesn't contribute to the advancement of science. When the goal is to treat patients, I think we should maintain a high quality of research for a definite conclusion. And remain skeptical...
What if it was your child. You know a little more now... What would you do?
SYL
Last edited:

If you take me up on this offer, remember that a test should be a simple as possible, and as complex as necesary. Please don't just add complexity in order to cloud the issue.